Share

Marching Backwards: The Spectacle of Fear

by: John Cory, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
(Photo Illustration: Lance Page / t r u t h o u t)

    Everything old is new again.

    It may be 2009 but the rhetoric is strictly 1950 when a man held up a sheet of paper and declared, "I have here in my hand a list of names ..."

    Glenn Beck is not original, nor was Joe McCarthy. The "red scare" of McCarthyism was merely the recycled red scare of the 1920's, when Attorney General Mitchell Palmer and his right-hand assistant, J. Edgar Hoover, conducted warrantless raids on union halls and labor organizations deemed socialists or communists for their suspected anti-American, anti-corporate beliefs.

    Each time the "red scare" gets trotted out, new laws are passed that ever so gently and ever so patriotically encroach on the integrity of freedom and individual liberties of our citizens. They bear great names like the Alien and Sedition Acts, the Espionage Act, loyalty oaths and investigations by the House Un-American Activities Committee and the Patriot Act. Each labels "the enemies of the state" and warns that our government, our very way of life, is in jeopardy of utter collapse unless we act immediately and act strongly against the influences of liberalism corrupting the very fabric of American life. The Constitution is hanging by a thread.

    And what is accomplished?

    The "Palmer raids" resulted in thousands of our fellow citizens being held without trial and hundreds deported on the flimsiest of innuendo, or worse, on the principle that they actually practiced their First Amendment rights and therefore were considered a danger to America.

    McCarthyism turned neighbor against neighbor and friendship into a weapon of false allegation and fearmongering that took away jobs of an estimated ten thousand people and sent hundreds of others to jail and ruination. For all the hype and shouting, the end result was to add "under God" to the Pledge of Allegiance so we could tell a godless communist from a god-fearing American. Was that what William F. Buckley meant when he wrote this? "McCarthyism is a movement around which men of good will and stern morality can close ranks."

    Now there is a new fuss generated by an article at NEWSMAX, advocating that the military overthrow President Obama with a bloodless coup to restore America to its true glory and power. Even that is not original. Barely past a hundred days in office, FDR was the target of a coup revealed by Gen. Smedley Butler after having been approached by "agents of Wall Street" financed by the Du Pont family, General Motors and Chase National Bank, among others, to use a veterans organization as the front for the overthrow of the New Deal and President Roosevelt.

    The spectacle of fear is not new. Whether financed by Wall Street or organized by FOX News, fear is the product being sold for the sole purpose of maintaining power and control by those who themselves fear the power of the people. And that includes today's mendacious media that see themselves as the "stars" in this political circus while collecting thirty pieces of silver for entertaining the public and betraying the people.

    Fear is the root of hate and bigotry and racism. It drives the mob to build internment camps and free speech zones and segregated facilities. It sets fire to books and thoughts and people who would challenge the darkness. It seeks to paralyze the vision seeker and the dreamer. Fear is the flame that ignites war and genocide and collateral damage. But most of all - fear is the tool of demagogues and tyrants who offer themselves up as our red white and blue champions with the promise of salvation for one easy payment of obedient servitude. Fear is never free.

    The GOP is nothing more than the recycled fearmongering of a hundred years ago. A party that would march us backward with banners flying and Hosannas shouted while people die from fear of health care reform or corporate regulation or the fresh oxygen of science and climate change.

    During the coal strikes of 1902, mine owner George Baer, when urged to make concessions to the labor unions, wrote, "the rights and interests of the laboring man will be protected and cared for - not by the labor agitators, but by the Christian men to whom God in His infinite wisdom has given the control of the property interests of the country."

    Those are familiar words with a familiar sentiment. Is 1902 the same as 2009? The GOP and Glenn Beck and talk radio would have you think so.

    Where Franklin Roosevelt took America into his confidence and told us that the only thing we had to fear was fear itself, the GOP whispers in the dark, "Be very afraid."

    Where JFK inspired us to ask what we could do for America, the GOP warns us that government must be feared.

    Where Edward R. Murrow exhorted us to not walk in fear of one another, the GOP promotes suspicion.

    Where Dr. King gave us a dream of diversity, the GOP rips us apart with fear of equal belonging.

    Everything old is new again.

    The GOP clutches fear in its tiny fists because it is all it has. It is the touchstone. It is not even original. Darkness never is.

    So, Democrats, tell me again - what exactly are you afraid of?

  

»


John Cory is a Vietnam veteran. He received the Purple Heart and Bronze Star with V device, 1969 - 1970.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

I'm afraid we'll continue to

I'm afraid we'll continue to keep our eyes shut so we won't have to look into the darkness.

Fear is what drive people to

Fear is what drive people to madness

Fabulous piece of by a

Fabulous piece of by a talented writer who has a true gift for words. I happen to agree wholeheartedly with the sentiment, but even those who don't should appreciate the skilled execution of ideas.

Right on. Progressives have

Right on. Progressives have nothing to fear from the GOP. Their old games have become stale, transparent and thus are losing their grip of power quickly. That is why they are so rabid. They are losing control and that makes them very fearful. The culture of fear that is their legacy is being rejected on a mass scale, as more and more citizens day by day across the whole political spectrum finally recognize it as a tool of manipulation. They have nothing to offer because their vision is clouded in hate and fear. They have fallen for the illusion that they are separate. They should be pitied for their suffering but cannot be permitted to continue in their failing attempts to lead. They have lost their way in a manner that they don't even realize they are lost. We as progressives only have our own fear to get in the way of creating our beautiful vision for humanity's future and we can't afford to be fearful now. We've waited too long and suffered too much already. It's time to wake up now. Humanity and all that is the world is depending on you, on me. NOW. Won't you join us to carry the torch for real freedom and love? With that we can solve or do anything. Come with us!

I really hate to say this,

I really hate to say this, because I agree completely with the article... but the Left needs better sound bites. The reason the Reich(t) keeps winning is that they have excellent short sound bites, and they march in lockstep. The Left has excellent points, but attempts to communicate in the fashion of a college professor, lecturing away with big words and deep thoughts.... and getting the Left to work together is like herding cats. Until the Left finds a better way to communicate its messages, it is doomed to failure.

Well written from my

Well written from my perspective (65 years old, retired teacher, former banker, male, etc.). Not only on Vietnam where my friends and colleagues served (my day# never came up 1964-end), as did John Cory, but my experience as a "history teacher" for 25 years (after 13 years in the banking/"savings & loan" industry right out of college). There I tried to explain about the Weimar Republic in Germany at the end of WWI, McCarthyism at the end of WWII & USAPATRIOT (I'm sure there are links for those who slept through any of this [including one to: "Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism" = USAPATRIOT--I think it was Ron Wyden (D-OR) who said it took longer to come up with the acronym than....]). History shows me that the Democrats must look at themselves to find "what exactly are you afraid of?". The answer keeps coming back: "the competitive institutions & $..." including, now most obviously, the GOP and those Democrats unwilling/incapable of positive moral over profit decisions. What is a majority to do? From what I experience, "darkness" is "just around the corner" and if I fear the future based on the past, I find myself helpless when I must look for changes that are meaningful. I don't have any solutions just a willingness to think outside the box.

Amen!

Amen!

If it wasn't for FDR we

If it wasn't for FDR we would probably speak japanese right now. Today I feel like we lost the war and the japanese won it just because I could use some japanese public healthcare.

I was one of a very few

I was one of a very few people who were called before all three of the witch-hunt committees: McCarthy and, separately, the Internal Security Subcommittee in the Senate, and the House Un-American Activities Committee. It is generally accepted that I won all three encounters. This is best illustrated by the last words of my appearance before McCarthy. Sen. Dirksen, a member of the Committee, realizing that McCarthy was getting the worst of the exchange with me, posed a question that gave me the chance to respond in a manner that turned McCarthy to the bottle in a way that resulted in his death within a year: "You can dish it out, Senator McCarthy, but you can't take it." All reports say that forty million people were watching. They didn't know me from a hole in the wall before that day, but McCarthy's hearings were the bigges tthings happening in the country at the time. Readers interested in further detail may turn to my autobiography, SAYING NO TO POWER, Creative Arts, Berkeley, 1999.

Professor Henry Giroux's

Professor Henry Giroux's article on this Web site traces the grinding march of this movement -- the movement to promote fear so as to maintain control -- through its various manipulations to control what can be discussed, indeed, what can be thought about, among the public. It is a chilling, and itself rather frightening tale of what really amounts to literally centuries of concerted effort, grounded in religion and a lust for power. Mr. Cory is correct: it is nothing new. The trend in North America can be traced to the Reformation "theologian", Jean Calvin, whose doctrines of predestination and "The Brotherhood of the Elect" formed not only the philosophical underpinnings for usurious money-lenders and rapacious merchants to advance the cause of mercantilism in late Medieval Europe. It also was enthusiastically espoused by the Puritans, who, regrettably, have set the tone for present-day American corporatists, and served as their justification.

How's this for

How's this for fear-mongering: "...destructive warming that brings coastal inundation, more frequent heat waves, extinction of species and other results of a climate shift." "...a culture that is increasingly poisonous and detrimental not just to liberalism, but to the formative culture that makes an aspiring democracy possible." "As costs continue to rise, more employers will have to drop coverage, which will lead to more uninsured individuals having to buy insurance in the exchange, more government subsidies to help them afford that coverage, and less incentive to the insurance companies to curb costs." All this fear comes from recent pages of Truthout.

They have nothing to give

They have nothing to give but fear itself.

This essay is eloquent.

This essay is eloquent. Divide et impera – divide and rule – is an ancient strategy of tyrants, who reward their loyalists, and spread hate and fear of everyone else. Division power however (not the people) is a legitimate tool of democracy– think β€œtrust busting”, divestiture, separation of powers, one person- one vote. And yes, what are we afraid of?

Thank you for expressing my

Thank you for expressing my sentiments in language more eloquent than I can muster. I'm doing an analysis unit with hs seniors. Shocked by their inability to read critically -- quick fix sources like "Opposing Viewpoints" gives them all the fuel they think they need to make an informed decision. After three weeks of debating health care, one young lady told me that the illegal aliens are the root of all our problems, dropping their 'anchor babies' on American soil and depleting all of our valuable resources. Her solution? We should send them all back to Africa! This remark is disturbing on so many levels, but mainly because she is echoing an opinion generated by one of the best and brightest in our graduating class. Racism is alive and well in the provincial town where I work and all across America. Many young people take their news and their views from Beck and Limbaugh. We are in a state of emergency -- anti-intellectualism reigns supreme. Joh Cory is truly an American hero -- not only a Vietnam veteran, but still fighting to keep our country free! Long live the power of the pen -- now how to give the power of change back to the people?

If the conservatives are

If the conservatives are fear mongers, then why the security measures taken in Pittsburgh because of the liberal protests threatened to be staged there? At the tea parties, I realize that they did, though, have to hire one or two extra cops to direct traffic.

The fear is that the

The fear is that the democratic leadership is too much like the republicans. The fear is that Obama has embraced Bush's policies, so where do progressives go from here? The fear is that America has lost it's democracy to capitalism which is the religion of both parties. The people have lost their voice. Money is free speech.

Thanks for your wonderful

Thanks for your wonderful insight!

There are two types with

There are two types with which one should never try to engage in civil discourse - the fear mongers and the criminally insane. Fux News seems to employ both. But one day they will reach a critical mass of detritus and the sky will cave in on chicken little.

Accurately said. GOP logic

Accurately said. GOP logic 'fear of government' was negated by the Constitution forefathers when they wrote 'WE THE PEOPLE' making the government 'BY, FOR & OF the people' AS AN inseparable & this is what GOP-lovin'lobbyists are continually assaulting & trying to destroy. Will we let it happen??

and you don't think these

and you don't think these people could have engineered 9/11?

great article Fear Works --

great article Fear Works -- but judging by history, only for a while...

Excellent and poignant

Excellent and poignant article. These are dangerous times for everyone.

''...J. Edgar Hoover,

''...J. Edgar Hoover, conducted warrantless raids on union halls and labor organizations deemed socialists or communists for their suspected anti-American, anti-corporate beliefs.''.......................... WE Americans have failed to stave off the Corporate assault on our Country. Maybe it took longer than I thought, but ever since Ronald Reagan and the end of the Fairness Doctrine in Media and the almost complete deregulation of Media Ownership rules to the point where just a few GLOBAL CORPORATIONS own and exploit almost all Media in America.., and the Republican driven Deregulation of almost everything and anything Corporate under the foisted guise of 'LESS GOVERNMENT'' (By the People For the People) is best for all--- Our Democratic Republic of 'By the People for the People' has been transformed into WE THE AMERICAN CONSUMER FOR THE CORPORATION BY THE CORPORATION...... Corporations--- GLOBAL Corporations Run this Country from sea to rising sea..... And apparently, ''WE'' can't do anything about it except to hold elections which transfer power back and forth between our Two Corporate Sponsors.

What scares me about global

What scares me about global warming is our making the problem worse instead of solving it. Where is American Can-Do? If I had a gun in my hand and for some unfathomable reason couldn't stop from putting it to my head and pulling the trigger, I'd be very scared.

The Democrats are afraid of

The Democrats are afraid of criticism from the gop minority and from the right-wing media. The question is why?