Share

Unemployment Rate Is Highest in 26 Years

by: Dean Baker  |  The Center for Economic and Policy Research

photo
(Photo: Chris(UK) / flickr)

    The benchmark revisions will show job loss was 824,000 larger than originally reported.

    The loss of 263,000 payroll jobs, coupled with a 0.1 hour decline in the average workweek, pushed the index of aggregate hours to 98.5, slightly below the 98.6 level in December of 1998. Hours worked have now declined by 8.6 percent from the pre-recession peak. In the 1981-82 recession the decline from peak to trough was 5.8 percent. The loss of jobs also pushed the unemployment rate to 9.8 percent. The unemployment rate for men hit 10.3 percent, surpassing the 10.1 percent peak in the 1981-82 recession.

    The accelerated pace of job loss was driven primarily by the government, retail, and educational services sectors. The government sector lost 53,000 jobs in September, compared with a loss of 19,000 jobs in August. Most of the job loss was again at the state and local level, which together accounted for 47,000 of the lost jobs. The private educational services sector, which had been adding jobs through the recession, lost 16,900 jobs in September. These job losses, like the state and local cutbacks, are largely the result of budget shortfalls since much of the funding for these services comes from the public sector. Retail trade lost 38,500 jobs in September after losing just 8,800 in August. The biggest difference here was in the auto sector – 7,100 jobs lost, after having added 3,500 in August to meet demand from the Cash for Clunkers program.

    The construction sector continued its rapid pace of job loss, shedding 64,000 jobs in September, mostly in non-residential construction. Manufacturing lost another 51,000 jobs. The loss of jobs, coupled with shorter workweeks, has led to a fall in the index of aggregate hours worked in manufacturing of 22.0 percent from its pre-recession peak in July of 2006. Hours worked in this sector have dropped 39.1 percent since December of 1997.

    Wage growth continues to weaken with wages rising at just a 1.7 percent nominal rate over the last quarter, almost certainly less than the rate of inflation.

Job loss


    This month, the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reported its preliminary benchmark revisions to the establishment survey data. This revision, based on unemployment insurance records, shows that employment in March of 2009 was 824,000 lower than originally reported, with private sector employment 855,000 lower. This extraordinarily large downward revision is not surprising because the imputation for new firms not included in the survey was consistently larger than the imputation from the prior year when the economy was still growing. Including this revision, the economy has lost over eight million jobs in the downturn.

    The 0.1 percentage point rise in the unemployment rate was coupled with a 0.4 percentage point drop in the employment rate, as there was a sharp decline reported in the size of the workforce. The employment to population ratio (EPOP) is now 4.6 percentage points below its pre-recession peak and 5.9 percentage points below the peak reached in 2000. Unemployment continues to disproportionately hit men, with the unemployment rate for women a relatively low 7.8 percent. However, with job losses in manufacturing slowing and job losses in the government sector rising, women will be harder hit in coming months. Black women have been especially hard hit. At 55.0 percent, the EPOP for black women in the last two months has fallen below the EPOP for white women (55.8 percent) for the first time ever.

    By education group, high school graduates took the biggest hit in September, with a 1.1 percentage point rise in their unemployment rate to 10.8 percent. However, even the 4.9 percent unemployment rate for college graduates is higher than the overall unemployment rate before the recession. All the duration measures of unemployment rose in September, with the 26.2-week mean duration setting a new record as did the 35.6 percent share of long-term unemployed.

    The data in this report indicates that a turnaround in the labor market is not imminent. Continuing losses of jobs and declines in hours, coupled with stagnant or declining real wages, means that workers' purchasing power is still falling. There are no further tax breaks scheduled to boost demand and state and local governments are cutting back and raising taxes to address budget shortfalls. The immediate future does not look good.

  

»


Dean Baker is the Co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research. CEPR's Jobs Byte is published each month upon release of the Bureau of Labor Statistics' employment report.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

So it still not as bad as it

So it still not as bad as it was under Reagan.

Worse then under Reagan,

Worse then under Reagan, depending on how old you are. Obama is well to the right of Nixon. I don't remember so many people losing their homes, in addition to their jobs, in the mid 80s.

Over the last few years,

Over the last few years, I've often thought Paul Craig Roberts CounterPunch blogs were a bit hysterical, but recently I'm coming to the conclusion there is a lot of truth in his writing. Industrial employment began disappearing in the U.S. in the late 1970s as Europe and Japan began recovering from the devastation of WWII. Substituting for these jobs was service employment, which in turn in many instances became "outsourced" to lower wage countries. Remaining industries are investments and medicine. Investments remain because the government needs this industry to sustain the dollar as the world reserve currency. Medicine remains because of demand by an aging population. To be blunt, without any intentional irony,essential to alter this circumstance is socialism. The Federal government need begin planning a rebuilding of American industry, with resource support. Recovery without this appears impossible.

As long as Obama and his

As long as Obama and his fellow Ivy Leaguers are to ignorant of the fact that Bill "Bubba" Clinton sold out the working classes when he gave us Nafta, and sold out our industrial base to China, the unemployed percentage will creep up higher than the 1929 depression.. Why are they so afraid to admit that the globalization brought on by G H W Bush and Clinton, is a complete failure? Fooling the people with a Stimulus will not work, although Obama's boys have saved the Banking system.

There is at the moment no

There is at the moment no countervailing force to the corporate control of government that can act on behalf of ordinary employees because corporate political behavior is incompatible with democratic processes. The corporate buzz machine has reduced democracy to mean the mere presence of an electoral process. From the corporate perspective, employees casting ballots for corporate candidates is all the freedom we're to be allowed and the Preamble of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights be damned. If we are to have a democracy as planned by the Founding Fathers, we will need to eliminate corporations.

Hmm. Popular President (I'm

Hmm. Popular President (I'm still not sure what to think of Obama...hiring Van Jones good, G20 bad, health care debate good, drones over Af/Pak bad), media oversaturation, in-effect climate change, high fructose corn syrup, Glen Beck, no jobs. So when are we going to do the green sector thing again?

Say thank you to the Bush

Say thank you to the Bush legacy

The Obama plan to get things

The Obama plan to get things turned around was tepid at best and is not working. It was a halfway plan and plans like that seldom work. I'm not sure if he's well to the right of Nixon, but Obama is certainly not as progressive as he appeared to be during his run to the White House. The demise of the cash for clunkers program is insane. Here you had a program getting people out of their gas guzzlers and in to more fuel efficient cars, all the while boosting the economy. Good thing we decided that program had run it's course. So stupid. They shoot horses, don't they?

This is about the rise in

This is about the rise in military spending over more than a decade and the rise in corruption in the alphabet agencies that used to pretend to protect us. These agencies are now pretty open about the raw power corruption, and they are joined by some non-profits that used to pretend to do good. There are blow-back currents going on, but they are at grave risk from the scare-mongering and name-calling that has become so rampant and distracting. The blow-back currents are in small, local, dispersed groups planting lawn signs for conservation measures for better care of water, energy, and food. Some wonks have watched as governments pretend to help, with glossy announcements of big, concrete, centralized-resource plans. They put these on their websites, apparently thinking only the bidders are going to look. They appear to think regular ratepayers are too dumb or distracted to look at this stuff. If such plans threaten to degrade water with boondoggles, the beer and wine industries can get alerted, which is the only way to get press against banks and other cartels wanting to own everything. It's scary, but it's also exhilarating, if you can keep the part of the movie where the little guy wins in your mind's eye as you invent new jingles and lawn signs. You might as well do something if you are unemployed.

Oh yeah, let's blame

Oh yeah, let's blame foreclosures on Obama, too... and the ants that are trying to get into my house, and my daughter's rash...

I don't know why everyone

I don't know why everyone keeps on talking about this spurious "unemployment RATE". Who caress about the rate of job loss? The important figure is: what percentage of the (available) work force is not working? That figure is between 16% and 18% of the work force. Not only does capitalism seek to alienate the worker from the surplus value of his labor, it seeks to alienate him from knowledge of his own lumpen suffering.

So, after years of respected

So, after years of respected economists and others telling the BLS to stop "birthing" jobs as if the economy is growing, they are finally starting to admit their fraud. Now we want to know the true extent of their corrupt data, and while you're at it, audit the Federal Reserve to find out how much money went from TARP to foreign banks. Oh, what about Georgia Bank not even on the FDICs "troubled" list? Maybe we can get the truth about bank balance sheets too, before Geithner pushes Sheila Bier out and Dodd extends the FASB accounting gimics?

Regardless of whether Obama

Regardless of whether Obama sold liberals/progressives a bill of goods, or we bought it on our own, it is evident that Obama is governing as a Republican. If Bush III does not take steps to subtantially diminish unemployment and underemployment, by means of a contemporary WPA or similar government program, come 2010 the New Republicans wil lose their majority to the Old Republicans, and by January, 2013, Obama will be back in Hyde Park organizing his presidential library.

The only way to fix the

The only way to fix the economy is to close down the military industrial complex and start healing ecosystems. The US government seems incapable of either and the right wing thinks both ideas are socialism. We are in big trouble, and neither the Democrats nor the Republicans have a clue.

It took conservatives and

It took conservatives and free-marketers three decades to bring the economy to it's knees, and it's not going to turn around in a year or two. An important step now would be to reestablish the regulatory controls of corporations and financial institutions that began disappearing when Uncle Ronnie took office.

Unnecessary weapons, War and

Unnecessary weapons, War and Wall Street always get money, but when it comes to helping people there is never enough. Now, health care reform depends on meeting conservative budget demands, not on, giving everyone affordable insurance. The US Chamber of Commerce and the Manufacturing Association are among the biggest anti-worker pro outsourcing organizations. The Chamber has spent millions lobbying against unions, health care reform, environmental issues, minimum wage increases, equal pay for woman and even buying American to name a few. Where are the laws curbing outsourcing or trade agreements that save American jobs? They do not exist, thanks to organizations like the Chamber. We all know greedy misfits that would sell their grandmother, if they could make money at it, run corporations. The real problem is the corrupt politicians in office and the lack of news media regulation. Our news media, flooded with highly paid corporate backed right-wing professional agitators ginning up their gullible followers 24/7 under the guise of free speech and entertainment, with the blessing of the government. There is no room in a democracy for a right-wing propaganda hate machine. That is how the Germans lost their democracy in the 30s. Corrupt politicians like democrat Max Baucus (Senate Finance Committee Chair), bought and paid for by the insurance industry to the tune of $3+ million. His health care bill is a gift to the insurance industry at the detriment of millions of Americans. The 45 thousand Americans a year dying from lack of health care or the 47 million Americans without health insurance do not disturb these clowns. Seriously, why would anyone think these corporate lackeys (conservative democrats and republicans) would do anything to put people back to work or help them save their homes?

Born in the forties, I

Born in the forties, I enjoyed the easy life. My dad belonged to a union, only one parent need work to provide a comfortable middle class life. I was able to work my way through school on minimum wage for 20 hr.s a week and full time summers. I didn't graduate in debt. Jobs were there for the taking. One seldom needed more than one job interview, and "hey presto!" a job-and this is important, with benefits. Rents were low enough I lived in two houses on the Sound in Seattle, and on three lakes. These same locations now cost millions. My middle class family in my middle class neighborhood were, like the rest of the neighbors, able to pay off their mortgage and own their four bedroom rambler home. Schools were well funded (regrettably by local levy) and could hire and retain excellent teachers. (Three PhD.s in my high school). Art and music were part of the curriculum. After school activities were funded by the school with 0$ fees. Our debate team traveled, yea unto Canada- where we got creamed as their schools were vastly superior to our own. The dichotomy has gotten much worse. I have traveled and I say this, "We are a third world country"... by any measure. We demonstrated in the civil rights movement (my parents' value), and the Vietnam War in comparative safety. Would-be Workers of the World Unite! Protest and survive- maybe. Ignore it and it will kill you.

"The biggest difference here

"The biggest difference here was in the auto sector – 7,100 jobs lost, after having added 3,500 in August to meet demand from the Cash for Clunkers program." What better warning that there is no real macro-economic plan for recovery, just short-term subsidy, which only buys short-term "recovery." We have reached the crossroads. The issue is the distribution of wealth. Always has been, but now we can't ignore it any longer. Communal development values must be nationalized (land and resource values), and private values must be untaxed. This formula is the only just, viable and sustainable path for a developed society to continue advancing. We are already living the middle stages of the alternative which every now disappeared empire lived and died through in its day. Search "Progress and Poverty" for more info...

These stats are compelling,

These stats are compelling, but are they national or state #s? If they are state #s, which state? Thx.

The rate is an indication of

The rate is an indication of the direction we are going (to the person who said, "Who cares about the rate.") - improving or degrading. It's obvious that Obama is in over his head, and Pelosi has lost tough with reality. We can't afford any more of their help.

$156,000/hr health execs

$156,000/hr health execs funding huge lobby giveaways are one place to start looking for savings that might restore world confidence in yankee genius and US$.

There is no recovery.

There is no recovery. Recovery is fiction.

Is it too late to say, "I

Is it too late to say, "I TOLD YOU SO." I mean just look at the foundation of the United States' wealth- slavery and genocide, then severe exploitation of poor immigrants. Is it a surprise to anybody that "we the people" are in the dilapidated economical position that we are in today. But we have Obama right? The same president who is keeping us in Afghanistan after promising us to get out. Well I guess people say a lot of funny things before they get rich. Face it the whole American system has been achieving its M.O. since its inception. Its time to start seeing the truth, set your alarm clocks for NOW.