Truthout Original

Facebook DIGG

Wall Street Follows the Path of the Steel Industry in Pittsburgh

by: Dean Baker, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson.
(Illustration: Paul Giambarba /
t r u t h o u t)

    There is a joke circulating on the Hill these days. "What is the technical term for a Wall Street investment banker who supports free trade?" The answer, of course, is "liar."

    In spite of the $700 billion bailout package, Wall Street is going the way of the steel industry in Pittsburgh. The financial industry in the United States is hugely bloated and hopelessly uncompetitive in international markets. In this way, it shares similarities to the US steel industry in the late 70s, except Wall Street is much more poorly situated.

    While workers in the steel industry may have been somewhat more highly paid than their counterparts in Europe, Japan and South Korea, the differences were comparatively small. By contrast, nowhere else in the world do bankers get paid annual salaries in the tens or hundreds of millions of dollars. Until these salaries are pushed down closer to the pay scales in other financial markets, Wall Street will have a very difficult time competing.

    The $700 billion bailout package slows Wall Streets day of reckoning. The Wall Street gang, with its huge campaign contributions and friends in high places, such as Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson, is better positioned to get protection than steelworkers or textile workers. But, as we all know, you can't just build walls around the country.

    Perhaps, our trading partners will protest the subsidies to Wall Street, which may violate our commitments under various trade agreements, but even if they don't, the days of the Wall Street crew are numbered. Their conduct over the last 15 years has shattered their reputation both nationally and internationally.

    The fact that so much junk was passed along to international investors as top-quality debt means, in the future, foreign investors will no longer trust the assets that Wall Street firms are marketing. Similarly, the fact that so many small towns and cities were ripped off on auction rate securities and other financial instruments probably means that the investment bankers will not be welcomed in large parts of the country for many years into the future.

    While innocent people will undoubtedly be hurt as Wall Street adjusts to the modern global economy, there will be important gains to the country. In fact, the principles economists cite when extolling the benefits of "free trade" may actually apply to some extent to Wall Street.

    The resources tied up in Wall Street will find better uses in other areas. Specifically, the tens of thousands of highly educated workers who made huge salaries on Wall Street may find something more productive to do with their lives than shuffling complex derivative instruments. Some might become doctors, engineers or research scientists - areas where they could make important contributions to society.

    And, if it is not plausible for many of the people who are currently losing their job to pursue these alternative career paths, certainly it will be possible for the people who are now in college or grad school in the hopes of pursuing a high-paying Wall Street career. By eliminating the Wall Street path, other relatively high-paying jobs will look much better.

    In other words, we will be less likely to have doctors who think that they are making huge sacrifices by earning $200,000 a year. Without Wall Street as a basis of comparison, doctors' salaries would look very good even to doctors.

    The public has every right to be outraged over the bailout. It gives taxpayers dollars to some of the richest people in the country, precisely because they messed up on their jobs. That means money is flowing from schoolteachers and firefighters to the top executives at Citigroup, Goldman Sachs, and other well-connected financial behemoths.

    But, this is just a stopgap measure. In the longer term, the financial sector will contract and salaries will be brought back down to earth. Protectionist policies can buy the Wall Street crew some time, but in the longer run, the market will win out, forcing large cuts in pay and employment. At last, Wall Street will feel the sort of job loss and pressure on wages that it so eagerly sought to impose on workers in other sectors of the economy.

»


Dean Baker is the Co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research. CEPR's Jobs Byte is published each month upon release of the Bureau of Labor Statistics' employment report.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

"The fact that so much junk

"The fact that so much junk was passed along to international investors as top-quality debt means, in the future, foreign investors will no longer trust the assets that Wall Street firms are marketing." -- The implication being that all or most "foreign investors" had no idea what was going on - they were just innocent, honest, hard-working traders duped by the geniuses on Wall Street... as opposed to the complicit, enabling thieving bastards there are/were, trying to pocket as much as possible before it all came crashing down... (which is now known as The New American Way!)

Will it be the end of Wall

Will it be the end of Wall Street or the end of this country as we have known it? That remains to be seen. Bush & his cronies created a panic and now we all live with the consequences. He hopes to save Paulson et al. and let them get richer. In the same way, he created a war so Cheney, Haliburton, Blackwater, etc. could get rich, sending thousands of soldiers to be killed and maimed and destroying a country along with hundreds of thousands of lives. Evil on a grand scale. We are living in a dark time, but it feels like a prelude to darker times.

The problem with this theory

The problem with this theory is that people go into business when they can't hack it in other disciplines such as engineering or the sciences. I suspect these people will still be useless, no matter what path they choose.

The Wall Street CEOs knew no

The Wall Street CEOs knew no more about the nature, composition, and workings of the "toxic securities" than does a bagger at the supermarket. Yet they lay claim and defend their 500 million dollar "compensation" packages! Outrageous! Fine all of them for their frauds, fine them their net gains for the last 10 years.

Wall Street was, however,

Wall Street was, however, extremely successful in competing against Americans.

I have been questioning our

I have been questioning our monetary system since we went off the gold standard shortly after gleaning all our silver coinage from the public sector. I found it quite difficult to get information about this system and the Fed. What the Fed offers about itself is just about as quasi-truthful as the financial instruments that caused this crisis. What I've come up with is that the Fed (particularly the NY Fed) is owned by the banks which invented and unleashed the financial instruments of mass destruction and will rescue them with taxpayer money at the sole discretion of a former chairman of Goldman Sachs, who invented many of those instruments under his watch. It goes MUCH deeper than this. Talk about foxes in the henhouse. Anyone who really wants to know can google Catherine Austin Fitts, who lends deep detail to the history and practices of our financial institutions. She is a former assistant housing secretary and was manager at Dillon-Read. BTW:I worked for the Department of Labor and Industry/ Unemployment in Harrisburg in the 70s before computers. I remember row upon row of gigantic filing cabinets containing only the records of laid off steel plant workers.

It's Rescue Time for Wall

It's Rescue Time for Wall Street Thieves AKA Investment Bankers and they must be celebrating double time now that a 35 year old "one of them" has been chosen by Paulson to administer this disgusting bailout. And then their ace in the hole, the Bush Admin played the fear game going as far as threatening martial law if it was not passed.

Most of the problems and the

Most of the problems and the influence of Wall Street were a natural development after we went off the gold standard and the "financial world" became more and more detached from the "real world/economy". Because the financial mass became so large it was sucking out the live blood in the real economy (demanding a cash flow that was next to impossible to be generated by the real economy). Banking and finance is the lynchpin in any economy that's why its propensity to power is so huge. In the end economic believes taught in Universities and true believers in a new risk model where risk magically disappears when it is spread around as much as possible created a train wreck. Risk never disappears it just collects in the system and increases, so called, SYSTEMIC RISK. WRONG BELIEVES AND MORAL HAZARD INCREASE SYSTEMIC RISKS. This is the lesson that has to be learned!!!

"Some might become doctors,

"Some might become doctors, engineers or research scientists - areas where they could make important contributions to society." Thanks, Dean, we certainly wouldn't want retrained investors making unimportant contributions to society like literary critics, philosophers, artists, historians, and so on. Neither would we want them to become non-research scientists, whatever they may be. Earlier this year John McCain pronounced the culture of America is consumption. Apparently Dean Baker would heartily agree. It is why the contemporary left is so intellectually moribund, with Dean Baker leading the way.

Must agree with anonymous

Must agree with anonymous above... I wouldn't trust one of these people to be my doctor or lawyer for a heartbeat. I've worked for these guys - they may have been highly paid but they're morons. Really, really dumb people. I for one have never been enticed by the money - if anything, the somewhat higher salary is like a badge of disgrace - you couldn't come up with any good contribution to society so you found a way to legally steal money from people who do, at quite a disgusting volume. They're only getting part of what they deserve. What they deserve is prison and public humiliation... at least we can rest assured they've gotten the latter.

Please read "The Secret From

Please read "The Secret From Jekyll Island" by G. Edward Griffin. All will be revealed. And you will be disgusted.

My mistake, I meant "The

My mistake, I meant "The Creature From Jekyll Island", not the "secret". I'm reading two books at once and confused the titles.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.