Share

Frank Talk of Obama and Race in Virginia

by: Peter Wallsten  |  The Los Angeles Times

photo
Obama supporters attend a campaign rally in Fredricksburg, Virginia, on September 27, 2008. (Photo: AFP / Getty Images)

As Obama supporters push to win the dead-even battleground state, they are talking directly about race, betting that the best way to put neighbors at ease is to open up.

    Whitewood, Virginia - The isolated towns of Virginia's Appalachian coal region are home to strong labor unions and Democratic political machines that date back generations. Yet voters here who eagerly pushed Democrats into the Senate and the governor's office are resisting Barack Obama.

    Some Americans say Obama's race and uncommon background make them uncomfortable - here those people include Democratic precinct chairmen and get-out-the-vote workers. Many Americans receive e-mails falsely calling Obama a Muslim - here a local newspaper columnist has joked in print that Obama would have the White House painted black and would put Islamic symbols on the U.S. flag.

    And so Obama's supporters, as they push to win this dead-even battleground state, are talking directly about race, betting that the best way to raise their neighbors' comfort level with the prospect of the first black president is to openly confront their feelings.

    When Cecil E. Roberts, president of the coal miners union that shapes politics in much of this mountain region, talks to voters, he tells them that their choice is to have "a black friend in the White House or a white enemy." When Charlie Cox, an Obama supporter, hears friends fretting about Obama's race, he reminds them that they pull for the nearby University of Tennessee football team, "and they're black."

    Union organizer Jerry Stallard asks fellow coal workers what's more important: improving their work conditions or holding onto their skepticism of Obama's race, culture or religion. "We're all black in the mines," he tells them.

    The presidential campaign, in the almost all-white counties of southwestern Virginia, has produced an outcome that few people expected: a frank discussion of race. Voters sometimes sound as if they are reasoning with themselves and working through their own complex views as they talk through the choice they face this November.

    "I've never been prejudiced in my life," said Sharon Fleming, 69, the wife of a retired coal miner, who spends hours at the union hall calling voters on behalf of Obama. "My niece married a black, and I don't have a problem with it. Now, I wouldn't want a mixed marriage for my daughter, but I'm voting for Obama."

    Obama beat Hillary Rodham Clinton convincingly in the Virginia Democratic primary, but his supporters have known they face a challenge in this part of the state, just as Obama has faced challenges elsewhere among white voters from rural and working-class households.

    He took 64% of the primary vote statewide but just 9% here in coal-rich Buchanan County, for instance, and 12% in neighboring Dickenson County. Though he is now the Democratic nominee, many voters are cool to him - even some of the party's own leaders and precinct captains.

    "I haven't found in my precinct one out of five that will vote for Obama," said Tommy Street, the party's vice chairman in Buchanan (pronounced buck-AN-in) County.

    Street, 78, counts himself among the doubters, citing Obama's alliance with Sen. Edward M. Kennedy (D-Mass.). He has always voted Democratic, he said, but this year plans to leave the presidential ballot blank.

    Some here blame Obama's troubles on his mixed-race background (his mother was a white Kansan, his father a black Kenyan). Others say his journey from Hawaii and Indonesia to Harvard and big-city Chicago politics makes him an oddity.

    The challenge facing Obama was on display at a recent Democratic Party dinner at Twin Valley High School in Buchanan County, deep in the mountains, about a two-hour drive from Bristol, the nearest city.

    Looking out at about 70 local Democrats as they ate turkey, ham and mashed potatoes from school cafeteria trays, Phil Puckett, a local state senator who backed Clinton in the primary, said he knew that nearly everyone present had voted for Clinton and that many were not necessarily excited about Obama. But he pleaded with them not to believe everything they were hearing about the Illinois senator, and to seize the chance to boot the GOP from the White House.

    "Don't miss this opportunity because someone says to you, 'I'm not voting for him because he's Muslim,'" said Puckett. "If there's a word of truth in my body, this guy is a Christian who believes in Jesus Christ."

    Ben and Beth Bailey sat in the back and clapped politely, but they remained unpersuaded. They said they were likely to break from their tradition of voting Democratic and might well not vote at all.

    Obama "just doesn't seem like he's from America," said Beth Bailey, 25. Ben Bailey, 32, noted that Obama's middle name is Hussein, "and we know what that means."

    Beth's father, Josh Viers, is the party's Whitewood precinct chairman, responsible for working the polls and urging Democrats to vote the party line. He came around to backing Obama only recently, and reluctantly.

    "Am I racial? Am I prejudiced? No, I'm not," said Viers. Still, he is frustrated that his job is to persuade other Democrats to back a black man.

    "Somebody in Buchanan County or in the United States can look at him and say, 'He's not my color,'" said Viers. "Why put yourself in that position? We had a shot four years ago, and the people listened to lies, rumors, negative ads and got us beat. Bush got him a second term, and look what it got us."

    Viers said he will do his best to help Obama on election day. But local Democratic leaders said they could not rely on all of their precinct chairs to follow suit.

    That is why party officials are relieved that they can rely on another local organization: the United Mine Workers of America.

    The union, which initially backed John Edwards in the Democratic primary, has a strong presence here and in other coal-producing areas. It has field workers going door to door and making phone calls across Appalachia, with special emphasis on Virginia, Pennsylvania and Ohio - all of them election battlegrounds.

    Virginia, which has not chosen a Democrat for president since Lyndon Johnson in 1964, and Ohio are so close in polls this year that no one can say whether Obama or Republican John McCain is ahead. Both states are central to each campaign's national strategy.

    Often, union officials show up at coal mine bathhouses during shift changes, when dozens of workers are getting dressed, to make the case for Obama.

    The union portrays him as a friend of the coal industry, and argues that Obama is culturally in step with local workers. Union literature tells them that the Democratic nominee supports gun rights, and the literature attacks McCain for opposing legislation that would make union organizing easier.

    "Barack Obama Won't Take Away Your Gun," says one flier. "But John McCain Will Take Away Your Union."

    A new 18-minute video that the union is distributing in coal states features Roberts, the union president, talking directly about race as he addresses white workers, many them clad in jeans or denim overalls.

    "I could just ignore the fact that Barack Obama is African American," says Roberts, "but I'm not."

    Roberts challenges the notion that a believing Christian could base a voting decision on a candidate's ethnicity.

    "We go to church, sing our songs, pray, come out and talk about, 'I can't be for an African American, because of the color of his skin,'" Roberts says in the video. His voice rising, he then scolds the crowd: "Can't do that if you believe in the Bible."

    Republicans say that they also are aggressively courting coal miners and other union voters in southwest Virginia, but that race is not part of their conversation.

    Instead, said McCain spokeswoman Gail Gitcho, voters in the region are being told that Obama and his running mate, Joe Biden, are not true friends of the coal industry. That has been the theme of campaign ads that have seized on a recent Biden gaffe in Ohio, when he appeared to oppose the construction of any new coal-fired power plants.

    "We certainly don't believe that race has any part in the political discourse," Gitcho said.

    But here in Buchanan County, it is unavoidable.

    A local newspaper columnist, in a spoof of Obama's platform, wrote in one recent piece that the Democrat would hire the rapper Ludacris to paint the White House black (a reference to a pro-Obama song by Ludacris), and divert more foreign aid to Africa so "the Obama family there can skim enough to allow them to free their goats and live the American Dream." He joked that Obama would replace the 50 stars on the U.S. flag "with a star and crescent logo," an Islamic symbol, and that his policy on drugs would be to "raise taxes to pay for Obama's inner-city political base."

    The columnist, Bobby May, is also treasurer of the Buchanan County Republican Party and was listed in a July news release as the county's representative on McCain's Virginia leadership team, though he said his column reflected his views alone, and he denied it was racist.

    History suggests that a black candidate could win support here. In 1989, L. Douglas Wilder carried Buchanan and other nearby counties as he became the country's first black elected governor since Reconstruction. Many here recall that Wilder kicked off his campaign in the region and aggressively courted whites.

    Obama is expected to do well in Virginia's urban areas and the suburbs of Washington, D.C. But to win the state, strategists say, he needs to improve his performance in the southwest counties. For that to happen, volunteers such as Ruby Hale have to strike the right tone with their neighbors.

    On some nights, Hale, a retired jewelry store owner, shows up at her Pentecostal church in tiny Rowe with her Toyota truck stacked full of Obama signs and bumper stickers.

    "I'll tell them, 'You can't judge a man this way,' that he couldn't help who his father was, and he didn't name himself - that I am convinced he is a Christian."

    Then she tells the potential voter to think it over for a few days. And the conversation often begins again.

    --------

    peter.wallsten@latimes.com

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

It is highly disturbing that

It is highly disturbing that racism in the United States (the" Melting Pot"????) is still being practiced especially by the uneducated and misguided. A human being is a human being, no matter what color his/her skin and to claim that the name Hussein is referred to in negative connotations is just totally ludicrous and reveals the low IQ and education of those who believe it does. Seems at least 50% of the nation has been dumbed down on purpose - it would be equally stupid to say we have been guided to the precipice of ruin by a" Bush and a Dick." Come on folks; do I have to start being ashamed being an American living as an expatriate in a foreign country? Even here people are mad as hornets at the conduct of the administration over the past 8 years and it is a good thing that Europeans are more fiscally conservative in a lot of countries, not falling victim to the latest fad or gadget to impress their neighbors. Family and helping each other as well as a community spirit still do exist - at least in the Acores where war-mongers and Alaskan Governors picked to "balance" the ticket are being ridiculed and heads shake "I can't believe this is happening in the land of the FREE and the land of OPPORTUNITY. No more FREE, no more OPPORTUNITY - don't come here all at once, there are other like-minded places in the world who value education, health-care and infrastructure. But they DO NOT have NUKES - and no desire to acquire them either plus strict gun-laws People who in a globalized world look suspiciously at a person of color or different ethnicity - get a grip!

---"I've never been

---"I've never been prejudiced in my life," ... "My niece married a black, and I don't have a problem with it. " --- Man.. you know when someone says "I'm not a racist or prejudiced," the next thing out of their mouth is going to be ridiculously racist and prejudiced. "A black?" Seriously? Most likely the exact quote was closer to "My niece married a ni...black, and I don't have a problem with it." Racism is like alcoholism: you need to admit it before you can deal with it.

The White House SHOULD be

The White House SHOULD be painted black, but not for reasons that have anything to do with Obama. And instead of changing the design of the American flag, let's just fly it upside down...it's an international maritime symbol for a ship in distress!

It's hard to believe the

It's hard to believe the anti-Obama folk are actually Americans. Much less Christians. Would Jesus vote for a black man? Probably - he was, after all, brown.

Why don't they just tell the

Why don't they just tell the people that he is not a black!! He's just as much white as he is black. Even moreso, as he was raised by his white mother and grandmother.

I love the way some of the

I love the way some of the Virginians are dealing with the prejudice........ "We're all black in the mines,...... U of T football team, "and they're black." ".

I don't have trouble with

I don't have trouble with race - I take issue with religion. Most americans are not religious, nor do they want to be, but somehow people have been made to believe this is a religious nation, no worse, a christian one. Bull**** - there was a separation of church and state - keep your beliefs between yourself and your god. The constitution is not based on religion! I do not want a religious president - I want an intelligent thinking one who can communicate without convincing people god is on their side. Why do we have to listen to this unnecessary religious crap? I want to hear what they have to say about getting out of war now, and cleaning up historical horrors, now! not 30-50 years from now. I actually want peace. I'd like to see america apologize publicly to every nation we have 'civilized' beginning with missionaries and ending with a permanent presence of american troops - not one beautiful piece of land the world over has been allowed to live without our tyranny - and somehow religious freaks look at this behavior and say 'god blessed america'. We need to wake up, grow up, and stop shoving god down peoples unbelieving throats - its just a technique to keep you fearing your neighbors, black, red, yellow, and millions of them now mixed, yep with white. Keep the little people stupid and warring and they won't see what those in control are doing. The dumbing down of america did not happen over night. I'm white as they come, and I'm ashamed of nearly every act we've forced on the world. My ancestors killed and caused this beautiful continent to be raped from sea to shining sea. Our humanity needs to be restored, and that is not done with hate or fear.

I believe that a lot of this

I believe that a lot of this covert racism in these communities is not only due to ignorance, but also due to a lot of peer pressure. Openly discussing race and race relations is the first, and best, step in overcoming this poisonous residue of America's history. Directly challenging the assumptions of racism may not convert the diehards but will make most people stop and think, and perhaps realize that they're not alone.

I on the other hand find it

I on the other hand find it highly offensive that Appalachian people are described as "uneducated and misguided." There are a lot of really well-educated and smart racists out there, in fact their racism is all the more damaging because they justify and conceal it so well. When you start picking on "mountain people" as being somewhat less than you, you risk getting caught in the same snare.

Exquisite photo of a young

Exquisite photo of a young black woman . . . captures "hope" beautifully.

The continuing pervasiveness

The continuing pervasiveness of racism in the USA is part of the pernicious and long-running campaign conducted by the PTB to polarize and splinter American society along racial, religious and other lines. This is all about dividing and conquering - the last thing the PTB wants is for the American populace to act together and in concert to thwart the aims of the megalomaniacs that pull the strings in the US. While Obama is clearly a better choice for ALL Americans, we still need to be vigilant and keep our eyes peeled for any strings that may be attached to him as well.

Ive seen little or no

Ive seen little or no difference in the amount of racism among various segments of the white community in my life. In the working classes it tends to be related to scapegoating or affirmative action. Among the educated and wealthy its often masked as an issue of "access" to education and hidden behind an unconscious cultural arrogance. In my experience the assumption among the educated and wealthy is often that actual differences in behavior and perspectives are just a result of not being exposed to the "right way." So I find the overemphasis of racism among the white poor and working classes largely untrue and self-serving However the dynamics are frequently all too clear. All things being equal...if you have the same variables and the only change is in the race of the person...you would often end up with different results.

When you walk in a garden,

When you walk in a garden, do you want to see just the red flowers? Or the yellow ones? Or the blue ones? Do you not relish in how ALL the flowers compliment each other? And how you, as the gardener, have interwoven your garden to grow all colors of flowers to bring beauty to your garden? Is it not then possible that the Creator wanted to grow in His garden ALL the colors of mankind to bring diversity, and light, and knowledge to His garden? Now one so chosen to be prejudice to what color the flower is, would be seen in today's world as being an enlightened soul who is paving the way of the future. Is it your intent to be seen as crazy? So in God's world, if you have a color preference in the people of the Earth, then you are seen, and must be seen, as a doofous who is behind the times, and as a spirit who does not wish to advance itself. Yes, we understand that you were born into prejudice, but you have not questioned this, and just gone along with the illusion. You will not allow yourself to awaken, and be who you are to God. You align with the lower realms of man, and you let yourself be brainwashed by the thugs of ignorance who came before you. Sorry, but your beloved grandmother did not have the eyes to see what you, if you choose, can readily see. It is time for you to update your files. You can continue to be a doofous and like just white flowers, or you can get with the times and grow your spirit in ways that allows for new possibilities. You get to choose - not your father or your grandmother, but YOU, get to choose, how it will be. Can you open your eyes, or will you just keep totterring behind tradition and convention and the things of the past that held you back? Open your mind for once and grow your soul beyond color. You are capable of so much more.

EVERYONE on this Earth has

EVERYONE on this Earth has genetic material of a dark-shinned AFRICAN in them. No matter how "WHITE" you are, your ancestors came from there. All our ancestors came from there. And if you deny that, you deny science, and you also deny the color of the skin of the people in the Bible. AND TAKE A LOOK AT YOUR OWN NAMES. OTHER THAN NATIVE AMERICAN INDIANS, I DON'T SEE ANY NAMES THAT WOULD TELL ME THAT YOUR ANCESTORS WERE FROM AMERICA. YOUR ANCESTORS CAME FROM ELSEWHERE.

@jrp You missed the point

@jrp You missed the point of the article. The person you "dis" in your post is talking about race in a way she may never have in her life. And you just blanket suggest she really used the "N" word and that she is a blind racist. What I hear is first, she is actively supporting Obama. Next, she is recognizing honestly that she would not be comfortable with her daughter being in a mixed-race marriage and engaging with the inconsistency in her willingness to vote for an African American but not feel comfortable about her daughter marrying one. Below, her words quoted: "I've never been prejudiced in my life," said Sharon Fleming, 69, the wife of a retired coal miner, who spends hours at the union hall calling voters on behalf of Obama. "My niece married a black, and I don't have a problem with it. Now, I wouldn't want a mixed marriage for my daughter, but I'm voting for Obama." The article is about people talking. Some of it is about people telling lies. But this woman is talking her own truth. Do you want to kick here of the Democratic party? Do you want her to stop phone banking for Obama because of your assumptions about her? I think you should follow her example and look in the mirror with honesty, even though it's hard.

Some guy actually said "his

Some guy actually said "his middle name is Hussein, and we know what that means" ... ??? Someone actually said this, in public, to a reporter? Game over, folks. You cannot reason with insanity.

It was 45 years ago last

It was 45 years ago last June, John F. Kennedy stood at the Berlin Wall, saying that all free men share a common destiny, and that freedom knows no ethnic divides. "When one is enslaved, all are not free", he said, "All free men are citizens of Berlin, therefore -as a free man-, I take pride in the words, "Ich bin ein Berliner". (I am one of you, we ALL are with you) That Berlin speech proved the only way out of the cold war mess- freedom was our asset, our common goal, that they knew we had, and also wanted.. As free people, be it in Berlin or the main, we were not different. We have an uncanny chance to look beyond race in this election, setting a example to a world looking to us for leadership and brotherhood, yet, for the past 8 years finding nothing but liars and criminals from the old school. It is time we stop torturing, show respect for our Constitution, our Declaration of Independence-, "All men are Created Equal" Freedom knows no color.Indeed, the one statesman to brush the closest with freedom, to push ahead racial and ethnic equality as testing any limits of freedom, was a Black preacher from Atlanta, active at the time of a great President from Massachusetts and, together, they showed that all men have a common destiny working positively toward freedom- our one asset as Americans- not playing dirty spy games; instead pushing the bounds of freedom to newer heights, living beyond the wall, beyond ourselves- ... even living beyond Jim Crow servitude or outsourced greed. - John F. Kennedy and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.- trailblazers both killed by shortsighted racist, narrow, syndicated bushwhackers wanting to continue the dirty narrow past in which they took advantage, standing to lose if freedom prevailed, showing the eyes of the world a seemier side to Democracy. The old school vs the new. Please let's progress. Obama/Biden is our one chance. Vote.

When you get beyond the

When you get beyond the smoke and mirrors around race, religion, and the pseudo-populist platitudes that McCain and Obama are spouting;there is actually very little difference between them in their thoughts and practices.Both are very much in the service of a trans-national, big money,corporate elite -and both are in support of a continued Imperial Amerika, and a further shutting down of any socialization of the legitimate functions of government. Until the US of A gets proportional representation, does away with the Electoral College, removes the barriers to 'real' citizen candidates participating in the electoral process -all we get is these "manufactured" empty suits arguing about straw-man issues. Both McCain and Biden are up to their necks in the 'bail-out' scam,as are most of their colleagues in the Republican and Democratic parties. Most of their campaign coffers are full of 'dirty' money, and they are in no hurry to get off that gift horse until it drops. Whatever happened to term limits? Once these guys get used to feeding at the Public trough,there is no pulling their heads out of it. The corruption that is an intrinsic part of the rotating door between Legislature-Industry-and Bureaucracy; the Military-Industrial Complex that Eisenhower (-no starry-eyed radical) warned about has come home to roost. This hasn't happened overnight, the roots of the problem have been with us ever since the founding of the country; however until the period following the Depression, it was difficult for them to acquire the economic and political power they currently enjoy. (Thank you,FDR! ...not the Workingman's Hero that he's been painted in popular history) The culmination of their control of the US political agenda came at the end of the Second World War, when it looked like the Gravy Train was coming to the end of the line. Their response was to have the US put on a state of perpetual War. Our history from the 'Cold War' onward has been a constant succession of entanglements and atrocities. We are at the crux of the final movement of this little Passion Play we refer to as 'American Democracy'. We were lucky enough that the founding fathers were romantics (in the philosophical sense) that their words in the form of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution far outstripped their intentions or their deeds.They left a far more populist, and enlightened legacy then was their intent. I hope and believe that they put their highest aspirations to pen in the hope that future generations would fulfill them. I would like to believe that the American public can 'step up to the plate' and demand better then what we're getting, but every time I see somebody voting for McCain because they're indoctrinated to have a racist response to a black man, or an Obama supporter who speaks only in platitudes about their new-found Messiah -and refuses to look at his record, I lose hope.

Racial and religious

Racial and religious prejudice are the ugliest and most deeply ingrained aspect of American history and continue to move as slowly as a glacier. Of course bigots must be encouraged to open their minds and look at those who are different from them with attitudes that they are not used to, but unfortunately, you can't get those results by clobbering them over the head. It's an education problem, coupled with limited social exposure to those who are 'other.' The Obama people will address this problem in a way that the Republicans will not, because Republicans love keeping the majority ignorant ant prejudiced. They have no choice but to divide and conquer--they don't have the numbers. For now, we must concentrate on getting the Democrats out to vote. Obama must win, or this country is finished as a democracy.

Whenever I hear someone say

Whenever I hear someone say there is no difference between Obama and McCain, I am reminded of those who said the same about Bush and Gore. Where might we be if Gore had taken the position he rightfully won? Perhaps there would have been no 9/11 because Gore would have kept his eye on terrorism just as Clinton had. If there had been a 9/11, perhaps we would have finished the job in Afghanistan. We would never have diverted our attention to Iraq which had no WMD and also kept Iran at bay. Perhaps we'd be 8 years ahead in developing alternative fuels. Perhaps we would have had regulations that would have kept our economic ship from sinking. Perhaps America would still be a respected world leader. I would like to see the bludgeoning that is the Electoral College ended, but that is what we have for now, and the difference is a leader who can inspire us to pull together and do our best to make changes that improve our chances of survival as a nation and one who will continue most of the failed policies of the last eight years.

No question, not all the

No question, not all the angles of race that converge at the Obama campaign have received much attention. It’s increasingly popular to argue that the fuel for unrest has disappeared because the problem of racism has receded into America’s past. This idea has long held sway on the right, but, paradoxically, it’s taken Barack Obama’s candidacy to elevate this persistent right-wing myth into conventional wisdom. Obama’s candidacy is seen as an indication that racial barriers no longer exist in the United States. Indeed, the election of a black president would be an undeniable milestone in American history, forcing many white Americans to confront latent fears and distrust of black people. And many see progress in the fact that a black man can run a campaign in which race is incidental. Yet it’s taken Obama’s embrace of post-racialism, and concurrent distancing from traditional civil rights-style black leadership, to lend viability to his campaign. Some activists see him as the culmination of a trend over the last 40 years of black leaders moving away from the communities they’ve traditionally served and closer to the political and corporate power that dominates the Democratic Party. Read the full: http://www.indypendent.org/2008/10/02/illusion-post-racial-america/