Share

Documents Say American Detainee Near Insanity

by: Pamela Hess  |  The Associated Press

photo
An American detainee was being driven nearly insane by months of punishing isolation and sensory deprivation in a US military brig. (Photo: Brennan Linsley)

    A U.S. military officer warned Pentagon officials that an American detainee was being driven nearly insane by months of punishing isolation and sensory deprivation in a U.S. military brig, according to documents obtained by The Associated Press.

    While the treatment of prisoners at detention facilities at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, and in Afghanistan and Iraq have long been the subject of human rights complaints and court scrutiny, the documents shed new light on how two American citizens and a legal U.S. resident were treated in military jails inside the United States.

    The Bush administration ordered the men to be held in military jails as "enemy combatants" for years of interrogations without criminal charges, which would not have been allowed in civilian jails.

    The men were interrogated by the CIA and Defense Intelligence Agency, repeatedly denied access to attorneys and mail from home and contact with anyone other than guards and their interrogators. They were deprived of natural light for months and for years were forbidden even minor distractions such as a soccer ball or a dictionary.

    "I will continue to do what I can to help this individual maintain his sanity, but in my opinion we're working with borrowed time," an unidentified Navy brig official wrote of prisoner Yaser Esam Hamdi in 2002. "I would like to have some form of an incentive program in place to reward him for his continued good behavior, but more so, to keep him from whacking out on me."

    Yale Law School's Lowenstein International Human Rights Clinic received the documents through a Freedom of Information Act request filed by two attorneys Jonathan Freiman and Tahlia Townsend, representing another detainee, Jose Padilla. The Lowenstein group and the American Civil Liberties Union said the papers were evidence that the Bush administration violated the 5th Amendment's protections against cruel treatment. The U.S. military was ordered to treat the American prisoners the same way prisoners at Guantanamo were treated, according to the documents.

    However, the Guantanamo jail was created by the Bush administration specifically to avoid allowing detainees any constitutional rights. Administration lawyers contended the Constitution did not apply outside the country.

    "These documents are the first clear confirmation of what we've suspected all along, that the brig was run as a prison beyond the law. There was an effort to create a Gitmo inside the United States," Jonathan Hafetz of the ACLU's National Security Project in New York said, using the slang word for the U.S. naval facility in Cuba.

    The 91 pages of e-mails and documents produced by U.S. Fleet Forces Command, which runs the military brigs in Norfolk, Va., and Charleston, S.C., detail daily decisions made about the treatment of Hamdi and Padilla, then both American citizens, and Ali Saleh Kahlah al-Marri, a legal resident. All were designated as by the White House as "illegal enemy combatants."

    The paperwork show uniformed officials at the military brigs growing increasingly uncomfortable and then alarmed that they were being directed to handle their prisoners under the rules that governed Guantanamo.

    The authors and recipients of the e-mails are censored from the documents. They appear to be going to either military or Pentagon legal counsel and policy offices.

    The documents show that some officials at the Charleston brig were deeply skeptical about the mandate that Guantanamo rules should apply in the United States, a decision made by the defense secretary's office, according to the documents.

    "You have every right to question the 'lash-up' between GTMO and Charleston - it was the first thing I ask (sic) about a year ago when I checked on board," wrote one official to another in 2006. "In a nutshell, they gave the Charleston detainee mission to (Joint Forces Command) who promptly gave it to (Fleet Forces Command) with a 'lots of luck' and nothing else."

    An officer was still raising alarms about Hamdi's mental state after 14 months of jail with no contact with lawyers, his family or even other prisoners.

    "I told him the last thing that I wanted to have happen was to send him anywhere from here as a 'basket case,' of use to no one, to include himself," the officer wrote in an e-mail to undisclosed government officials in June 2003. "I fear the rubber band is nearing its breaking point here and not totally confident I can keep his head in the game much longer."

    The frustrated officer wrote that he had "to have the ability to exercise some discretion when I believe it best for the health and welfare of those assigned to my facility ... Know ... we are to remain consistent with the procedures that were/are in place at Camp X-Ray" a reference to the Guantanamo jail. He pointed out that imposing those conditions in the brig had a far harsher effect on his prisoners because they had no contact with any other detainees, which was allowed at Guantanamo.

    Scores of pages of once-secret legal opinions regarding detainee rights and treatment have been released under the Freedom of Information Act. At least two apparently crucial memos about enemy combatant treatment inside the U.S. have yet to be made public.

    Hamdi was captured in Afghanistan in 2001, shipped to Guantanamo and then moved to the U.S. after his citizenship was discovered. He was held and interrogated for three years without charges. The Supreme Court in 2004 rejected the government's attempt to hold him indefinitely without charge. He was released to Saudi Arabia on the condition he give up his U.S. citizenship.

    Al-Marri, a citizen of Qatar, was a legal resident studying for a master's degree in Illinois when he was arrested in December 2001 by the FBI as a material witness to the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. He was charged with credit card fraud in 2002. A month before his trial in 2003, President Bush declared him an enemy combatant and al-Marri was transferred to the consolidated naval brig in Charleston. There he was held in isolation for 16 months, denied shoes and socks for two years, and was not allowed any contact with his family for five years. He remains in the military brig but is appealing his detention to the Supreme Court.

    Padilla was arrested in 2002 under suspicion he was collaborating with al-Qaida to build a radioactive or "dirty" bomb. He was held as an enemy combatant for more than three years. He was held totally incommunicado for 21 months. His mother was only allowed to see Padilla after she agreed not to alert the media to the visit, according to the documents.

    The government dropped the dirty bomb charges and Padilla's case was moved to civilian court where in 2007 he was convicted of supporting terrorism in Kosovo, Bosnia and Chechnya.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

GOOD ARTICLE ON THE "ENEMY

GOOD ARTICLE ON THE "ENEMY COMBATANT"

"why!" say paranoid HomeLand

"why!" say paranoid HomeLand Security dependent ReichWingers, "he's not DEAD!! there was no ORGAN FAILURE!! he can live in a cardboard box somewhere in an alley!!... " you'll note that ReichWingers don't consider mental integrity, free will or coherent thought to be indicative of ORGAN failure... but the lack of a ReichWing 'world view' is indicative of insanity... I guess they consider he was insane before they picked him up... & that torture was in his own interest as a therapy... "Violence can only be concealed by a Lie, & the Lie can only be maintained by Violence." ... "Any man who has once proclaimed violence as his method is inevitably forced to take the lie as his principle" – Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn "Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities." - Voltaire

This is outrageous! The

This is outrageous! The whole world is watching.

I am appalled by the

I am appalled by the inhumanity or some of our U.S. government leaders to ANY human, citizen or otherwise! Words cannot express the evilness of such actions.

How can anyone forgive John

How can anyone forgive John McBush for condoning such unAmerican activities? How can anyone consider voting for that lying hypocrite? He wants sympathy for his time in Hanoi, during which he collaborated with the enemy by making statememnts, and got special treatment because of his parentage, and now he runs at the mouth about his patriotism. Patriotism presupposes preserving, protecting and defending the Constitution and moral values of the country.

The one fact that drives me

The one fact that drives me toward Obama the most is the fact there is a slim chance that Bush, cheney and all involved in the Iraq going to war lies, 9-11 and this direct violations of our constitution with wire tapping can be pursued legally to the fullest punished by law. That is very unlikely under McLiar , regardless of what he says. He will deny all 9-11 reinvestigations and pursuit of bin laden....And Russia wont put up with McCain pursuing oil, last night in the debates the old goat mentioned that pathway to oil was in Russia's territory , or atleast surrounding countries... We are in a war for oil....our evil of our prey

I am outraged. These

I am outraged. These illegal immoral atrocities must be stopped. The criminals who illegally seized the American government must be arrested. Who will stand up for justice? Where are the Americans who would fight for democracy?

Where in the world of our

Where in the world of our America did these men conceive of such treatment of humans? Where? Reading that, all the came to mind was ...round all these criminals up, try them and imprison them, every last one from Bush on down. What they did in the name of our country is abominable...loathsome.

We have become "The Evil

We have become "The Evil Empire," that famous label the Reagan administration loved to level at the old Soviet Union. We have accomplished every unAmerican, undemocratic, unConstitutional practice upon other nations and peoples in the world community, even torture. Iraq was Bush logic. The acts that have flowed from the source of such criminal foreign policy, implemented by criminals, should come as no surprise. They have disgraced all good Americans. This is not who we are, and yet it is who we are.

Illegal denial of a USA's

Illegal denial of a USA's citizen's rights. The article did mention that two of these tortured and "treated as less than animals" were UNITED STATES OF AMERICA CITIZENS._____________"Hamdi was captured in Afghanistan in 2001, shipped to Guantanamo and then moved to the U.S. after his citizenship was discovered. He was held and interrogated for three years without charges. The Supreme Court in 2004 rejected the government's attempt to hold him indefinitely without charge. He was released to Saudi Arabia on the condition he give up his U.S. citizenship."___________If this is how the country you love and to which you hold citizenship treats you, then I believe Hamdi chose the right path. After all, is the Saudi Government as despicable of the terrrorist organization that is the "ruling class" in the United States of America?*************I am ashamed to call myself a US citizen while these criminal acts are perpetrated upon the innocent (or those not even given the right to demostrate, "INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY;" the concept that this country's laws were founded upon.******************The USA is *NOW* the world's "ROGUE NATION" with the criminality of secret prisons, secret prisoners who "disapppeare," no legal redress, and we hold all the WMD's that could destroy the world over, and we have the technology and ability and more frightening, THE WILL, to do so and use it without evidence. The BUSH DOCTRINE HAS PAVED THE WAY TO HELL FOR THE USA IN THE GLOBAL COMMUNITY. WE ARE A ROGUE NATION with some one worse than Kim Jong Ill holding the nuclear codes._____________The definition of a terrorist has changed------>it is US.

I am thoroughly embarrassed

I am thoroughly embarrassed by this country.

The perps of these

The perps of these trangressions should be impeached. End of story. This is not the way we were taught that America functions.

Above all doctrines,

Above all doctrines, agreements. et al.... "DO NO HARM" Please release these people and hope that they ever can regain a semblance of life, treat them only as you would want yoor family treated---they are OUR FAMILY. PLEASE we beg of you.

America what have you

America what have you become? You are worse than your worst enemy. You violate human rights on a worldwide scale. You torture, you detain without charges your own citizens. You reward the criminals in high places in your society. Your elections are rigged and votes discarded. Is there any hope for your once proud country and constitution? Is there any hope for your people?

I simply do not understand

I simply do not understand why Congress do not impeach and prosecute these criminals. What have we become? The whole neo-conservative Gangsters belong in jail!!!!

This is all to prepare you

This is all to prepare you for "Brave New World". As the atrocities get worse, look at what they are really saying: We have complete control over every living soul.

It is not just the POW's the

It is not just the POW's the same inhumane treatment is going on under the secret satellite surveillance. Citizens in this country are remotely interrogated for years and not allowed any privacy at all. Take a shower and you twinkles of light from their system or their images on the wall. These are sad times for true Americans...the military has taken to harming it's own citizens, weapons testing and none have the courage they are supposed to have to stand up for those that they are supposed to protect. There are only a few good men. Unlike Columbus we have no place to explore and get away from King Bush...unlike our founding fathers who were great presidents we were saddled by questionable elections with an idiot that was able to put in place more corrupted leaders in each agency...we should have dumped them all. No wonder the military is talking about crowd control...it knows there will be an uprising over their secret programs and illegal violations of our constitution.