Share

Americans Cutting Back on Health Care to Save Money

by: David Lightman  |  McClatchy Newspapers

photo
Health care costs are a top concern facing Americans. (Photo Illustration: Jared Rodriguez / t r u t h o u t, Adapted From: ulybug / flickr)

    Washington - Many Americans have been putting off doctors' visits, forgoing medical tests and taking expired medications to save money over the past year, according to a new poll by Consumers Union.

    The survey by the nonpartisan organization found that 51 percent of Americans have "faced difficult health care choices in the past year."

    Despite overwhelming concern about how to pay for health care, however, there's still no clear public or political consensus on how to overhaul the system.

    The Senate Finance Committee is expected to take a final vote on its plan later this week or early next week, with Democrats split over whether to create a government-run alternative to private health insurance or set up a system of co-ops, nonprofit member-run insurance companies.

    A McClatchy-Ipsos survey conducted last Thursday through Monday found that while 53 percent of Americans favored a public health-insurance plan "to make sure all Americans have access to quality health care," another 42 percent thought that sufficient changes could occur without a public plan.

    "People are really split," said Rebecca Sizelove, senior research manager at Ipsos Public Affairs.

    However, they're increasingly concerned about the state of their own health care. According to the Consumers Union poll, 28 percent have lost or endured cutbacks in coverage in the past year, and the trend has been widespread across income groups. Thirty-four percent of those with household incomes of less than $50,000 annually experienced those changes, but so did 21 percent of those with household incomes above $100,000.

    The Consumers Union survey of 1,002 adults from Sept. 17 to 20 found that among the ways people have tried to cut back on health care costs:

  • 28 percent put off doctors' visits.

  • 25 percent have been unable to afford medical bills or medication.

  • 22 percent put off medical procedures.

  • 20 percent declined medical tests.

  • 20 percent skipped filling prescriptions.

  • 15 percent took expired medication.

  • 15 percent skipped scheduled dosages of prescriptions.
  •     The problems were more prevalent among households with incomes of less than $50,000, in which about two-thirds said they'd cut back on health care because of costs. Even where income topped $100,000, however, about one-third made similar decisions.

        The findings spurred Consumers Union to launch a television ad on a policy issue for the first time in its 73-year history.

        In the ad, Jim Guest, Consumers Union's president and chief executive, says: "Today, health care costs too much. Many Americans are one slip or major illness away from losing their coverage."

        How, or even whether, that concern will translate into specific legislation is another matter, though, and the McClatchy-Ipsos poll illustrates why.

        Asked their view of the most important problem the country faces today, 35 percent said the economy. Health care coverage lagged far behind, at 10 percent.

        "Though health care is dominating the news and what's going on in Congress, for most people the biggest concern is fear of losing their job and other economic issues," Sizelove said.

        To some extent, the two issues are intertwined, she added, because losing one's job often affects health care coverage, and salary and benefits cuts could affect health care decisions.

        The McClatchy-Ipsos poll found that consumers are still unsure about remedies, however. Forty percent said they favored the proposals being discussed in Congress, while 42 percent were opposed, a statistical tie.

        The latest McClatchy-Ipsos poll surveyed 1,296 people 18 and older and had a margin of error of 2.72 percentage points. For the Consumers Union poll, the margin of error is plus or minus 3.2 percentage points.

      

    »


    Comments

    This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

    Of course many Americans are

    Of course many Americans are cutting back on health care - they can barely afford to pay for essentials like food and shelter. That's the reason behind the health insurance mandate - the insurance industry is losing customers, which equates to lower profits. It's a cruel joke on the public for Congress to MANDATE payment of monthly Blue Cross premiums, leaving even fewer funds for basic essentials. Single-payer is the only affordable long term solution to the US health care problem.

    I believe a more relevant

    I believe a more relevant and beneficial poll would be one asking how many Americans have put into effect efforts to improve their health holistically and if they found information to do so easily available and comprehendible.

    Best solution is to stop

    Best solution is to stop paying premiums to the insurance companies. Let them die first before they kill us....

    If congress puts through a

    If congress puts through a mandate criminalizing everyone who doesn't buy insurance, I will boycott insurance entirely and take my chances. As it stands now our deductible is $6000 which means everything is more or less out of pocket anyway. It's already a joke, and with a 50% chance of rescission (dumping you if you get an expensive medical problem) why pay premiums? I have news for you: We're all going to die anyway. I think I'll make my peace with it if it's sooner than I expect. Just like the old days before there was such a thing as insurance. In the meantime I will check in with the holistic doc and focus on life habits and how to stay well.

    As one of the many Americans

    As one of the many Americans who have put off specialist appointments or buying prescriptions necessary to health, I can tell you right off that the main reason for doing so is not just the high cost of insurance deductibles, but the rate of inflation of life's other necessities. Food prices are skyrocketing. Energy prices are beyond absurd and taxes are rising at every level, while incomes most decidedly are not. Insurance premium rates continue to increase, too, making it more and more unaffordable. There is no relief from any of this in sight. For health care, the Baccus bill is a nightmare. The US should be configuring a national insurance program built on the Medicare or Tricare system. One's health should not be completely for profit commodity. While I'm at it, it would be hugely helpful to bring back usury laws, regulate public utilities and bring back Taft-Hartley. It would be wonderful to see America RE-INDUSTRIALIZE so that our citizens could once again produce our own shoes, shirts, carpets and car parts, grow our own food and not be dependent on imports. The current system of things is utterly insane and does nothing to improve anyone's life other than those with tons of money. It has jeopardized our currency to the point of near worthlessness and devalues the general standard of living for the majority of our citizens. One in five families have lost their homes...THEIR HOMES for God's sake. The current unemployment rate is actually closer to 20% than the assessed 10% the government counts. The entire American system of things is broken, not just health care.

    My cobra pay is 835$ per

    My cobra pay is 835$ per month for heath care. That is @ 10,000$ per year. I gross 40 -50k per year. Iknow gross 30k per year. Obamba pays 2/3's for 9 months. That helps but is not the solution. Universal health care is for a educated first world econamy like social security/medicare.

    As it is clear that our

    As it is clear that our government is not going to provide single payer health care it should at least facilitate the flow of information to let Americans know where to go in Canada and Mexico and Thailand and Costa Rica and Argentina, and Europe, to get affordable health care. I found it cheaper to travel to Germany for treatment as a US citizen than to get the same treatment performed in San Francisco and I have Blue Cross insurance. I know others who have gone to Thailand for bypass surgery, Argentina for hip replacements, and then there are the thousands of American medical refugees living in Mexico and Cost Rica where they can pay less than $300 a year of 1st class health insurance and no co-pay and no fighting with the bureaucrats at their health insurance company whose bonuses depend upon denial of coverage.