Share

Report: Bush Exceeded Power by Withholding Cheney Comments

by: Jeff Bliss  |  Bloomberg

photo
A new Congressional report has concluded that George W. Bush "overstepped his authority" when he refused to turn over comments made by Dick Cheney in an interview with the FBI. (Photo: Win McNamee / Getty Images)

    President George W. Bush overstepped his authority by withholding an FBI interview of Vice President Dick Cheney from a congressional panel probing the leak of a CIA agent's identity, a draft bipartisan House report said.

    The interview may shed light on who disclosed former CIA agent Valerie Plame's identity, the draft report said. The report was circulated by House Oversight and Government Reform Committee Chairman Henry Waxman, a California Democrat, and Virginia Representative Tom Davis, the panel's senior Republican.

    The president's decision to withhold the interview transcript from the committee in July "was legally unprecedented and an inappropriate use of executive privilege," the report said.

    The committee is investigating what role Cheney may have had in the leak of Plame's work in 2003. Her husband, former ambassador Joseph Wilson, had questioned evidence used to justify the U.S. invasion of Iraq.

    Attorney General Michael Mukasey had told the committee that Bush's refusal to release the Cheney interview was within the president's authority, under executive privilege, to keep his discussions with advisers private.

    White House spokesman Tony Fratto today objected to the report and another one circulated by Waxman that said the administration wrongly asserted executive privilege regarding a separate panel investigation of climate change and Clean Air Act policies.

    Fratto said the committee received "upwards of a million pages of documents" from the administration and that today's reports were partisan and unhelpful.

    "Campaign Attack"

    "We're focused on more important business than another campaign attack from Representative Waxman," he said.

    In August, a federal appeals court upheld the dismissal of a lawsuit by Plame and Wilson that accused Cheney, former White House political adviser Karl Rove and former Cheney aide I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby of conspiring to reveal Plame's identity.

    Plame and Wilson accused the three men and former Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage of leaking her name to retaliate against Wilson.

    Libby was convicted by a federal jury in March 2007 of obstructing a Department of Justice probe into the leak of Plame's identity. Bush commuted Libby's sentence three months later while leaving the conviction intact. No one has been charged with illegally disclosing Plame's identity.

    The report on climate change said it was an "abuse" for administration officials to withhold 2,000 pages of documents from the committee.

    The documents concern administration decisions to prevent California and other states from seeking to reduce greenhouse gases from motor vehicles and adopt ozone standards at odds with Environmental Protection Agency scientists' recommendations.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.

  

»


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

Oh yeah? Well is anything

Oh yeah? Well is anything going to come of this bipartisan finding? I doubt it. This administration gets away with lying, cheating, swindling, and they will never be prosecuted for their crimes. What's tragic is that they have now set a precedent, and every presidential administration in the future will also have all this power.

I'd rather Obama have this

I'd rather Obama have this power than McCain.

We should have a post-Bush

We should have a post-Bush truth and reconciliation commission to make clear to the American people and the world exactly what these people did in the name of democracy and they should be held accountable for their illegal and immoral acts.

At a certain point a person

At a certain point a person that is complicit in a crime may become a conspirator depending on the degree of involvement by the individual and whether a crime was completed or not. GW, What did you know and when did you know it. We, your boss want to Know! I think, GW thought he was the "boss". He still does not understand that his job was to serve all Americans, not just the guys who gave him the most money and power, mostly Big Oil. When you turn off oil production in one major oil country the prices go up and up. That is why we attacked an unarmed people and put our sons and daughters in harms way. Who should pay for these Crimes?

Bush and Cheney belong in

Bush and Cheney belong in jail. I'll bet that both of them move out of the country after January. Bush will head to Paraguay where his family bought a huge ranch. Coincidentally, Paraguay doesn't have an extradition with the US.

Enthusiastic about Obama?

Enthusiastic about Obama? I'm not. BUT if McCain is elected there is NO HOPE that the criminals in the most criminal administration ever will be held accountable for their crimes. Pelosi MUST lose her seat over this. Dear San Francisco voters, I have done my best. I participated in the Beach Impeach action. Please help out here and kick out Pelosi!

Another cute report for the

Another cute report for the dust bin. Impeachment must be put back "on the table" for future ministrations, and BushCo must be indicted for war crimes, crimes against humanity, and crimes against the constitution. The power-grab of the neo-cons and the complicity of the dems must not be permitted to stand. If it does, our republic is toast within the decade. The treasonous laws have been passed, camps built, and military deployed for domestic law enforcement. Does anyone any longer question how the 1930s fascists got away with it? They thought they were free.

This is nothing new in the

This is nothing new in the narrow little world of George W. Bush, where the only people who matter to him are those who (probably snickering behind their hands) have continued to seek him out for a slap-on-the-back "attaboy" as he pandered the cause of Big Business above all else. The only place this little popinjay will ever look good in history is in his egotistical presidential library, where everything will be edited to make him look good. The man is a pompous, lying, incompetent, narcissistic farce--always has been, always will be.

SCREW ELECTION DAY-we can't

SCREW ELECTION DAY-we can't vote for change-WE HAVE TO BE CHANGE! I propose that "we the people" take this to the streets and designate 11/4/08 A DAY OF ACCOUNTABILITY. If everyone that reads this will step forward and organize some sort of "stand down" at the state capital/county courthouse/post office/YOUR POLLING PLACE WOULD BE A GREAT PLACE to stand together and make ourselves heard. Maybe we can stop the ability of this administration to get away with this appalling behaviour. We must join together and let out "representitives" know that if they cannot/willnot act on our behalf to hold these criminals accountable-we will hold THEM accountable for their failure to act. We saw just a glimpse of how effective this strategy could be with the resistance to the bailout. If you have had enough and want to ACT-let's get together as citizens and demonstrate our will before they open those camps ( I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT THE EXISTANCE OF THESE CAMPS HAS BECOME "COMMON KNOWLEDGE" & STILL WE DO NOTHING TO PREVENT THE INEVITABLE USE OF THEM) and our door of opportunity closes forever. For your sake, for your children's sake, for your family's sake (yes, even for GOD SAKE) STAND UP NOW!

Bush and Cheney were behind

Bush and Cheney were behind it. It's too late to impeach them but it's never too late to sue them in civil court for all sort of crimes, after they get out of the Oval Office. So I heard that some legal activist groups already have this planned.

It ain't over 'til its over.

It ain't over 'til its over. This Pres and VP are the most impeachable ever... if these two clowns aren't impeached, no future President will ever be. We must demand accountability from Congress and impeachment of these evil doers. What is the point of Constitutional law if Congress is too timid to enforce it! Demand impeachment. If nothing else, there is a greater chance this will occur under Obama than under McCain but would be a definite under Nader! Even Pelosi must be constrained by the Constitution to act against an Executive Branch that abuses its power and exceeds its Constitutional authority! and commits crimes against the country... If Pelosi fails in her Constitutional duty, she should be replaced.

Get over it, folks. The

Get over it, folks. The injustice has been perpetrated, and as soon as these guys are out of office, any interest in prosecuting them will evaporate. We've got bigger things to worry about right now anyway. Leave it and get on with building a better world!

First, let's impeach the two

First, let's impeach the two crooks and their cronies who lied, cheated, and stole our freedoms, Mr. Bush, Mr. Cheyney, Mr. Rove, and the list continues. Secondly, all the people should unite to file the biggest class action suit we have ever seen as a nation. United we stand! These people need to be brought to justice by the American people. Let justice prevail.