Share

What's So Scary About Michael Pollan? Why Corporate Agriculture Tried to Censor His University Speech

by: Martha Rosenberg  |  AlterNet

photo
Journalist and author Michael Pollan. (Photo: poptech / flickr)

Agribusiness is trying to combat Pollan's message of sustainable, healthy eating.

Even if agribusiness could shut Michael Pollan up, the outspoken author of Omnivore's Dilemma and a journalism professor at University of California, Berkeley, it still has the Los Angeles Times to contend with.

Last week, the Times blasted California Polytechnic State University in San Luis Obispo for downgrading a scheduled Pollan lecture because it received pressure from David E. Wood, a university donor who happens to be chairman of the Harris Ranch Beef Co.

"Agribusiness gets plenty of opportunities to preach its point of view at agriculture schools such as Cal Poly, where the likes of Monsanto and Cargill fund research," the Times wrote, calling the 800-acre Harris Ranch, near Coalinga, whose "smell assaults passersby long before the panorama of thousands of cattle packed atop layers of their own manure,"--"Cowschwitz." Ouch.

And agribusiness has the University of Wisconsin-Madison to deal with.

The land grant, ag-based university, in the middle of dairyland, clearly doesn't remember its roots. It gave Pollan's In Defense of Food, another anti-agbiz screed according to industry, free to all incoming freshmen as part of its common book read program where everyone reads the same book, Go Big Read, in August.

"I have not seen the students this excited about something in years," Irwin Goodman, horticulture professor and vice dean of the College of Agricultural and Life Sciences told the Associated Press as the James Beard Award-winning book was discussed in French and political science classes and included in an exhibit on the history of food.

Protesting farmers who came to hear Pollan speak at the university's 17,000-seat Kohl Center in September wearing matching green T-shirts which said "In Defense of Farming: Eat Food. Be Healthy. Thank Farmers" were clearly outnumbered. So were bumper stickers reading No Food; No Farms and Don't Criticize Farmers With Your Mouth Full in the parking lot.

Students get all their facts from writers like Pollan, the farmers, who were bussed in by Madison-based feed company Vita Plus, told the Capital Times. They have never visited a farm for first-hand knowledge of food production and don't know what they're talking about.

But efforts to open farms to the public are not always successful.

This month United Egg Producers' "Opening the Barn Doors" media tour at Morning Fresh Farms in northern Colorado, for example, only confirmed the size of today's egg farm that make humane conditions impossible (36 barns; 23,000 birds each, 23 million dozen eggs a year) and raised further questions about environmental blight by showing the press wearing white HazMat suits to enter the barns. (See: You want us to eat WHAT?)

Last month the American Egg Board rolled out a kid-focused "The Good Egg" campaign which includes sponsorship of Sesame Street, a Cookie Monster product placement and a feel good virtual tour to soften public opinion about egg farms. But nowhere does the campaign address the daily grinding up of newborn males even as they hatch at the hatcheries which supply egg farms to provide the industry with only females--a practice that United Egg Producers confirms is routine. Does the Cookie Monster know about that?

Nor can all that crowding and all those chemicals be good for you, Pollan has written and many studies suggest.

But agribusiness is also combating last year's American Institute for Cancer Research and World Cancer Research Fund study that found the link between processed meats and colon cancer so strong, the organizations advised consumers to change their eating habits.

Trent Loos, an outspoken columnist with the agbiz weekly, Feedstuffs, says nitrosamines, found in processed or cured meat and widely believed carcinogenic, may actually be good for you, preventing and treating "cardiovascular and other diseases associated with nitric oxide insufficiency in the diet."

"Nitric oxide is an important signaling molecule in the human body to regulate numerous physiological functions including blood flow to tissues and organs," write Loos of research conducted by Dr. Nathan Bryan at the Brown Foundation Institute of Molecular Medicine at the University of Texas, Houston. "The regular intake of nitrite-containing food appears to ensure that blood and tissue levels of nitrite and nitric oxide pools in the body are maintained at adequate levels."

Some of the ag press has even picked up the theory--but don't expect a Pollan book called In Defense of Nitrites anytime soon.

--------

Martha Rosenberg is a columnist and cartoonist who frequently writes about the impact of the pharmaceutical, food and gun industries on public health. A former medical copywriter, her work has appeared in the Boston Globe, San Francisco Chronicle, Los Angeles Times and Chicago Tribune, as well as on the BBC and in the original National Lampoon.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Eggs are good for you!! I

Eggs are good for you!! I eat two a day. One of the best things you can do for yourself and your family is to buy eggs from a local producer with free-range chickens, fed naturally--or build your own chicken coop and produce your own eggs.

Suppression of speech by big

Suppression of speech by big actors is daunting, on all levels. It is also troubling that recruiters will be dangling money and contracts in front of these students as they get closer to graduation. In an on-line forum some time ago with Amory Lovins and Paul Hawken, someone asked if environmentalists go back. One young woman said yes, they do. That's where the money is to pay off student loans. If the Gates Foundation continues to shower money on ag buddies and if Obama continues to appoint big-ag promoters to power in D.C., we have a way to go before we are safe from abominations in our food, water, and air. The increasing use of healing ways from traditions with thousands of years of experience is one area of hope.

Good for the Univ. of

Good for the Univ. of Wisconsin! How about other colleges and universities selecting Pollan's book for their "common reading" assignment? Hey, reader, have you cut down on processed meats yet? or purchased more locally grown food from genuine family farms? Try it!

We are what we eat, and so

We are what we eat, and so are the animals we eat.

Pollan has turned my eating

Pollan has turned my eating around and I believe I am much healthier for it. The corporate food folks are clearly the enemy and it took a long time for me to catch on - it is good today's kids are learning early. For what it is worth a corporate food grower in Canada told me chicken is the most deadly followed closely by pork; beef is a little better but to be safe it is better to eat lamb and goat which so far hasn't become part of the great food machine.

It's important not to frame

It's important not to frame this as consumers vs. farmers, because it's not. Most remaining farmers I know are struggling, trying to make an honorable living and hang on to the family farm while juggling public policies not of their making. Those with factory farms on their land are managing to hang onto their land, yes, but find themselves virtual slaves to companies that control the animals, the feed and the market. How do you opt out when you have mortgages on infrastructure that cost half a million dollars on up? You can't then quit and go work at walmart to recoup that sort of investment. It's stay on the treadmill or lose the farm. A hard, hard place for farmers. Work for and support systems that promote local agriculture, and markets for local food. We need farmers who have the skills to grow food.

Oh goody! We get to be all

Oh goody! We get to be all self-righteous about avoiding cheap factory-made nitrates just like we used to be about avoiding cheap factory-made glutamates and cheap factory-made sugars. Natural sources are so much more profitable, unless, of course, ignorance turns out to have its own hidden expenses for our world.

I think there are plenty of

I think there are plenty of farmers that are misinformed also. I had a conversation with a dairyman and he didn't understand the big deal about growth hormones in the cows because they have them naturally. I tried to explain that I have hormones naturally also, but if you quadruple the amount you would have to peel me off the ceiling. I think he understood that.

Do We Get It, NOW? Poor

Do We Get It, NOW? Poor people cannot afford "good food." Therefore, BigAg hopes always for more poor people. Aha! It may not be "conspiracy," but it is most certainly a very symbiotic relationship that the largest corporate "industries" have developed. BigFinance falters, creating vast unemployment = more poor folks, millions more probably, who can't afford to buy "good food." Do we "get it" now?

There is little research and

There is little research and news reporting on one big question: Why are the cancer rates so high and getting higher? Breast cancer in particular. It seems nobody wants to find out the source of diseases. Is it because we are willing to take the risk or because you can't fight city hall? Telling people they shouldn't eat processed meats because they might get colon cancer isn't enough. They have to change the way they process meats or get rid of them altogether. Is there any common sense out there? For a long time I have been saying that mankind will become extinct because we are going to pollute ourselves to death.

Thanks to everyone working

Thanks to everyone working to expose the US food industry for what it is, including Michael Pollan. The tough part to move beyond is the many decades of conditioning we've been subject to, to accept fast food or highly processed food in an effort by the food industry to move more "product", faster by building brand recognition and loyalty by way of the family structure. Mom doesn't have time to prepare a home-cooked meal so the kids get Hamburger Helper: flavoring powder sprinkled on ground meat. Kids decide: nothing wrong with the many varieties of hamburger. As Pollan says, natural food wouldn't be profitable because you don't do anything to it except grow it. In an era of non-nutritious, overly-processed food, natural and organic food commands a premium price, not because it's nutritious, but because the dominant food industry does things an entirely different way. As with any and all corporations, the food industry does not care if food is nutritious, they only care if people are buying what they're selling, being motivated single-mindedly to satisfy their shareholders need for return on investment. Maybe also to see if they can be the biggest producer on the planet.

We definitely need to

We definitely need to support local farmers, family farms, local co-ops and try to have food grown and distributed locally. This used to be the case until after WWII, when the corporations took over most of the economy making large scale the only profitable way to go. City folk and country folk need to realize we share the same interest, the same danger

What do they do with the

What do they do with the ground up male chicks? Feed them back to the female chickens?...Mad Hen Disease?

Replacing "factory farming"

Replacing "factory farming" and industrial food processing with more modestly scaled facilities (on some set of definitions) would require major changes in how the economy is organised, and a willingness to accept lower "living standards" both here and abroad, and, probably, a lower global human population. All this may be desirable. How to get there is more problematic. Based on past experience, it will be struggle over resources, and the four horsemen of the apolcalypse, as contrasted with the outcome of a consensual international process.

We already have lower

We already have lower standards, Frank. Where have you been for the last decade? Unfortunately we're also broke, so we can't afford decent food unless we get it locally or grow our own.

Give me, as a consumer, the

Give me, as a consumer, the RIGHT to choose. Truth in labeling laws should include whether or not a product has been grown with GM seeds and/or contains ingredients that have been. If I have a right to know what kind and how much fat is in a product I buy, shouldn't I have the same right to know whether it contains GMOs? In April 2009, Germany joined France, Greece, Hungary and other EU countries opposed to GM crop cultivation by ordering a ban on Monsanto's MON 810 maize. Since 1994, 58 different GM crop varieties have begun the process to be included on the UK national seed list and so be available for commercial growing. All 58 applications have now been abandoned. Why? Largely because of a public educated by what is their mainstream media. We can do it, too!

I'm hungry, I think I'll run

I'm hungry, I think I'll run down to McDonald's