Share

Chronicle of Despair, A Promise of Change

by: John Nichols  |  The Nation

photo
Senator Obama speaks in Sunrise, Florida, on Wednesday. In a 30-minute television program aired Wednesday evening, Obama described the problems he sees ordinary Americans facing, and laid out his ideas for solving them. (Photo: Getty Images)

    Before he dismissed it as a "gauzy, feel-good commercial," John McCain really should have watched the thirty-minute television program that Barack Obama's campaign aired Wednesday night.

    There was nothing particularly "gauzy" about the image of an Ohio woman struggling to open medicine containers with arthritic hands, or that of her husband heading off - at age 73 - to work at a Wal-Mart store.

    There was nothing "feel good" about lingering shot of a Ford worker, leaning against his truck and looking at the Louisville auto plant where his hours have been cut in half and his wife has been laid off.

    Barack Obama was the star of his own commercial, as is to be expected of a presidential candidate on the cusp of a national election.

    But this final national appeal to the hearts and souls of undecided voters - particularly working-class whites in the remaining battleground states of the upper Midwest and the Hispanic women in the southwest - was all about an economy that no longer works for tens of millions of Americans.

    There were no Ross Perot flip charts, no John Kerry with Bruce Springsteen flourishes.

    This was an expression of empathy, a report from Barack Obama about what he has learned after spending the better part of two years with a hurting populace.

    The commercial, which aired on multiple networks at a cost of $4 million to the Democrat's campaign, was poignant and direct. And it did hold out a measure of the "hope" that has been the essential message of the senator's once-audacious and now-presumptive candidacy.

    "America the time for change has come," Obama told a live audience in Kissimmee, Florida, in the final stages of the broadcast. "In six days we can choose an economy that rewards work and creates jobs and fuels prosperity starting with the middle class."

    But at a deeper level, Obama presented a chronicle of despair:

    Sick people are having a hard time paying for medicine.

    Old people are working to make ends meet.

    Teachers are taking second jobs to pay for food.

    Third-generation factory workers are watching the American dreams that they once took for granted turn into nightmares of dislocation and declining prospects.

    Obama appeared through much of the commercial as a sort of narrator. There was documentary-style footage shot by Davis Guggenheim, the director of former vice president Al Gore's global warming documentary An Inconvenient Truth. And there were snippets of Obama accepting the Democratic nomination and debating McCain.

    But, except for the theater of the live finish from Florida, this was not Obama the inspirational orator.

    Rather, the Obama who came into the homes of tens of millions of Americans less than a week before election day was a calm, reassuring, dare-we-say presidential figure speaking from a room that looked vaguely like the Oval Office.

    He was self-deprecating - "I will not be a perfect president."

    He was self-referencing - "I know what its like to see a loved one suffer, not just because they are sick, but because of a broken health care system."

    But he was, most of all, a candidate who wanted the people who are about to decide his political fate to know that he understands that there is really just one issue in the waning days of the 2008 campaign: an economy that is now officially in crisis but that long ago stopped working for millions of working Americans.

    This was a commercial, to be sure.

    But it was, as well, a statement. And Barack Obama's determination to make it the closing message of this long campaign will go a long way toward reassuring uncertain voters about the president he intends to be.

    Most commercials aren't worth the thirty seconds it takes to watch them.

    Obama's commercial is a thirty minute slice of an American story that was crying out to be told... and that Barack Obama heard.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

If there are still people

If there are still people who saw the presentation and remain unmoved by what Obama presented then God help them. I thought the piece was the perfect summation of what I've been trying to tell people all year long. I was too young to vote for Jack and Bobby Kennedy but I will do the next and equally best thing and that is vote for Barack Obama on Election Day. This Kentuckian will be very proud to send Barack Obama to the Oval Office!

McCain is out of touch (like

McCain is out of touch (like most Republican Elites who legislate for the riches Americans)with the American People and the problems we face. If you do not understand a problem you are unable to fix it.

15 Billion a year for green

15 Billion a year for green energy when you just supported 700B for the great 08 swindle?

So it seems that Barack

So it seems that Barack Obama understands the task at hand. The $164,000 question is: what is he going to do about it? The remotely sensed answers coming in on the airwaves thus far are: not much. Beyond his rhetoric is a man all too willing to kowtow to the forces who are largely responsible for the mess the USA is in: corporate attorneys, corporate financial institutions, the extreme right wing Israeli lobby (AIPAC), the military industrial complex, the WTO and WMF, and Big Coal. But somehow he's going to cut taxes for 80% of Americans, reduce healthcare costs, and put Americans back to work. YEAH RIGHT. And he's going to save the polar bears too. But a vote for a third party candidate such as Ralph Nader or Ron Paul is not a wasted vote, or a spoiler vote, but a vote for real change. Ask Howard Zinn.

I could not disagree more!

I could not disagree more! This was straight out of the propaganda play book. Americans are strong people that have heart, strength and fight. He showed us as weak and helpless. What about Americans that are helping change America? What about those that are the small business owners that help create jobs? It was pandering and it made me feel sick. Those that are struggling should feel like he was talking down to them. My favorite part was: "I think everybody feels the same way, that they'd like to see an end in sight to all the worry and the chaos of everyday living, trying to make ends meet." Missouri mother of six Rebecca Johnston from the Obamamerical. The government can not take our worries away! It just can not. Those that trade liberty for security deserve neither!

This Oklahoman will be very

This Oklahoman will be very proud to send Barack Obama to the Oval Office, also. Martha A. Miller

One small detail that should

One small detail that should be noted here... the live audience at the end of the 30 minute spot was in SUNRISE, Florida, not Kissimmee. A minor detail, to be sure, but accuracy is important in journalism. Excellent article otherwise!

"Those that trade liberty

"Those that trade liberty for security deserve neither!" And that is exactly what we did when we invaded Iraq. A reason not to vote for a republican who will Follow on Bush's steps.

He still talks with the

He still talks with the VALUES of a highly evolved community organizer: 1) People have the solutions to their own problems if you give them the support and access to good information, 2) Everybody has leadership to offer and is responsible to serve in the interest of the COMMON GOOD,and 3) Our survival and prosperity will be determined by the degree to which we can BUILD COMMUNITY across all of our various identities. I always knew that I would not be voting for McCain, but I have not let myself believe that that Obama really meant all he was saying. I kept thinking that some mysterious "they" who represented military-industrial oppression of all on the planet were sending somebody to trick us again into believing in the system. I am starting to believe that something different can happen. I am starting to believe that there IS a new day. That nobody could be so cynical as to make all of this a continuation of THE BIG LIE of freedom, justice & equality for all as we continue to live on stolen land and deny it. I am starting to believe that justice and renewal IS possible. We are all related.

Well, from someone who just

Well, from someone who just 8 years ago could've cared less about politics. From someone who never even voted in elections- mainly because "they just don't matter". From someone who had his own "awakening" and for the past 8 years advocated against the Bush administration, vehemently at times to anyone who would listen. From someone who is as passionate about the state of the American dream, the state of American politics and the state of American (anything) as I am about my own personal shortcomings and financial shortfalls. To my "MPEACHW" license plate. It seems that for all my fruitless talking about the incorrigible precedings of the past 8 years that has finally come full circle and stares most Americans directly in the face. I was absolutely shocked at just how deeply that 30 minute message struck me. It was as if, finally, and for the first time, my views- my disproportionately passionate views of the terrible things that have occurred in the past 8 years, were finally explained on a national level to any American that was willing to tune in and listen. Having these strong feelings for so long finally shared by not only fellow Americans, but recognized by the current Democratic nominee and potential next President brought tears to my eyes. Factor in the devastating stories told by average Americans like myself- the elderly having to work past age 70 to pay for meds, or the teacher working several jobs to afford food for her family and I couldn't hold them back. And for once, I didn't feel silly about the tears that flowed down my cheeks as I looked to my wife to see her eyes streaming the same sentiment. My only hope is that those who were unsure of which candidate would get their vote next Tuesday, have now decided to cast their precious vote for Barack Obama. When, ultimately, in the end, your choice is for someone who has supported the poor decisions of the past 8 years - or someone new. In my most humble opinion, "someone new" is worth the the (unwarranted) risk over what we can expect from john McCain and his undying support for W's policies.

I think that now is the time

I think that now is the time to stand up and fight for the very things that we need. I do not think that Obama is the "savior of all" but he is the greater of the two. McCain has that Palin woman, who is just a big mess and do we really want Palin at the helm if there is a difficult situation? At least Biden is a back biting, racial fantic, PMS B****.

As an Australian who has

As an Australian who has worked in and visited and admired the your country over many years, I wish I could vote there . I look forward to the reemergence of the respect and admiration we used to have for your political leaders. I look forward with great hope and enthusiasm for the Obama Presidency, as do, according to the latest polls here, 80% of my countrymen!

We have had both liberty and

We have had both liberty and security traded away wholesale for the past 7 years. The Bill of Rights and international laws are ignored while there are massive tax cuts for the richest 1% of the country that are greater than for the rest of the taxpayers combined. And now $700 billion for bankers and investment speculators who took the first $70 billion to pay bonuses and executive severance packages and pay dividends while Americans continue to lose their home, their jobs, and the medical coverage. The richest 1% have seen their net worth increase by over 670 billion dollars in the past 7 years under the Bush=McCain approach to trickle down economics. Under Reagan who brought us 14% home mortgage rates, the junk bond crisis, and the savings and loan fraud and taxpayer bailout, and now with Bush we have a dollar whose purchasing power has declined by more than 30%, and widespread bank fraud with a $ Trillion dollar bailout and counting. And McCain was the man who loaded the gun with his sponsorship of the bill that killed the Glass-Segal Act and opened the banking industry to the latest round of maverick raiders. McCain's role has been downplayed in the press but he along with Phil Graham led the way to the present financial crisis and is hardly the man to now provide leadership to fix the mess he instigated. The question is whether enough voters will open their eyes to the fraud that is McCain or continue to go like sheep to the shearing shed.

That was a powerful 30 mins.

That was a powerful 30 mins. Obama is not perfect. I do not agree with his support of the bail out, domestic drilling, and clean coal does not exist. One thing is for sure, that he is light years ahead of McCain. I really hope that the GOP is unsuccessful in tampering with the voting machines next week.

I'm a small business owner

I'm a small business owner and unlike Joe the plumber and a few comments here, Barack Obama will do more for small business than most administrations before. He will provide the foundation for all American based business to thrive. Ignore the scare tactics of the right with there sound bits and miss directed views. Learn the truth about Obama's plans. Then and only then can you rise above the rhetoric and decide what's right for yourself. I felt the 30 minute spot was right on. And America needs to see more like it as well as full details of Obama's economic plan for individuals as well as business owners instead of hearing what Joe Wurzelbacher is planning to do next. Hopefully paying his back taxes...

Michael, at first I thought

Michael, at first I thought your comment was going to be more right wing rhetoric, but then I suddenly realized you are correct! However, I dare say do not underestimate Obama! Remember, he has to be middle of the road right now for the votes. He has to be the quintessential politician! You must trust him! He will not completely disappoint you! Although I love Howard Zinn, I do think its a vote thrown away to support anyone other than Barack who has a real chance at winning the Presidency! Please think deeply about your vote if you haven't already voted. PS I do believe that greedy corporate America, the WTO ( I'm not so sure about putting the WMF in the same category, but maybe you could enlighten me) and the military industrial complex have ruined and destroyed this country and the world!!

Senator McCain appearing on

Senator McCain appearing on Larry King Live repeated his criticism of The Times newspaper and Tribune Co. for not releasing a videotape of Obama at a dinner where he spoke about a Palestinian friend. The Pentagon is in possession of a tape recording Senator McCain's confession as a POW in Vietnam, why doesn't the Obama campaign call on the Pentagon to release it?

My husband and I were

My husband and I were saying these same things 4 years ago when we tried to get Bush out of office. The Americans then didn't see it, now they feel it more everyday. Yes, there are great things going on in our country as well but for the most part we have gone down hill fast. I don't think it's pandering I think it is empathy. I believe we have a man with vision and it's about time!

To Michael: There will be

To Michael: There will be time to grow support for alternative political parties and to vote for candidates like Ralph Nader and Ron Paul after the rudderless Republican party disintegrates following this election. At this point a vote for a third party candidate is a wasted vote. Right now let us work to ensure that disintegration. To Brent: Americans that are helping to change America are working in the Obama campaign today.

We are all lucky to have a

We are all lucky to have a candidate of Obama's intelligence and stature at this dark hour in our nation's history. Get out there and support him and VOTE! Regardless of your general or previous persuasions, he is the only candidate fit to be president, and he will be a darn good one too.

Well, I saw it, but I

Well, I saw it, but I enjoyed seeing it again, and will probably see it a few more times from time to time just be inspired when I need it.

"This cannot be another

"This cannot be another election where the choice is based merely on fear. In terms of painting a brighter future for America and the world, Mr Obama has produced the more compelling and detailed portrait. He has campaigned with more style, intelligence and discipline than his opponent. Whether he can fulfil his immense potential remains to be seen. But Mr Obama deserves the presidency." That was the conclusion to a very thoughtful endorsement in the print edition of The Economist that also appeared on line today at Economist.com. This from a normally right-leaning publication.

Perhaps, this provides a

Perhaps, this provides a clue to Obama's charisma at home.

A wonderful presentation!

A wonderful presentation! Obama really spoke to the problems faced by so many ordinary people. After the disastrous last eight years, we simply can not afford another four years of the same basic approach embodied by McCain. Though a New Jersey resident, I am going to bust my butt working for Obama in Philadelphia these last days of the campaign. Pennsylvania simply must go for Obama. This will almost assuredly guarantee that it will be President Barack Obama come January 2oth! Hopefully you reading this will join me in doing all that you can to work for this all important Obama victory!

THRUST: You ain't the only

THRUST: You ain't the only one. I'm 62, been a lefty cynical of normal politics all my adulthood, mostly voted for third parties unless it was a close one (which has been rare in the red state now turning blue I've lived n for 35 yr). I only overheard the first segment, but it drew me to watch the rest. Which I had difficulty doing for the tears. Maybe, just maybe, we have a chance to vote for a man--and a team--that really has some feeling for the great majority of decent people left behind by the last 30 yr of gush up-trickle down governments. Ain't done it in 36 yr, but I'll be pounding the pavement from now to the election for a frugal politician who spent $4million to show us ourselves rather than himself.

A vote for anyone other than

A vote for anyone other than Obama is a wasted vote. The way to begin moving toward change is to get an experienced change agent into the White House. Obama is an experienced change agent. he knows the slow, consistent work that needs to be done, at the grass roots, bringing the people into the process. He knows that not everything he tries will work. But he also knows that unless he tries - unless we ALL try - nothing will change. Each vote for Obama brings us closer back to America.

He is so ready; America is

He is so ready; America is so ready . . . If McCain truly means to put country first, he should concede right now.