Share

Lawsuit Accuses Psychologist of Ignoring Guantanamo Torture

by: William Fisher, t r u t h o u t | Report

photo
(Photo Illustration: Lance Page / t r u t h o u t; Adapted From: electron, glog and dcmaster / flickr)

The state board responsible for licensing - and disciplining - psychologists in Louisiana is "fighting awfully hard to turn a blind eye to serious allegations of abuse" brought against one of its members, who is being accused of complicity in beatings, religious and sexual humiliation, rape threats and painful body positions during his service as a senior adviser on interrogations for the US military in Guantanamo Bay and Abu Ghraib.

That is the view expressed to Truthout by Deborah Popowski, cooperating attorney with the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR), part of the legal team representing Dr. Trudy Bond, an Ohio-based psychologist, who is suing the Louisiana State Board of Examiners of Psychologists to compel it to investigate the behavior of Louisiana psychologist and retired US Army Col. Dr. Larry C. James, a former high-ranking adviser on interrogations for the US military in Guantanamo Bay and Abu Ghraib.

"We wish the Board would devote its resources to investigating unethical conduct instead. Everyone, including the people of Louisiana, would be better served," she told Truthout.

The chairperson of the Board, Dr. Jillandra Rovaris, who also chairs the complaints committee, did not respond to telephone calls or emails from Truthout, seeking comment and clarification.

Popowski says that, according to his own statements, Dr. James played an influential role in both the policy and day-to-day operations of interrogations and detention at the prison camps. She claims that publicly available information shows that "while Dr. James was at Guantanamo, abuse in interrogations was widespread, and cruel and inhuman treatment was official policy."

In February 2008, Dr. Bond filed a complaint against Dr. James before the Board, the agency that issued and now regulates his psychology license. Dr. Bond alleged that Dr. James breached professional ethics by violating psychologists' duties to do no harm, to protect confidential information and to obtain informed consent, and she called on the Board to investigate whether action should be taken against Dr. James.

Dr. Bond's lawyers contend that the Board summarily refused to investigate her complaint, claiming that the statute of limitations had run, despite what they say is conclusive information to the contrary. Dr. Bond then filed suit against the Board in Louisiana's 19th Judicial District Court, which, in July 2009, dismissed her case without looking at the merits. Now, in a brief before the First Circuit Court in Baton Rouge, Dr. Bond argues that the District Court should have reviewed the Board's "clearly wrong legal decision."

Said Dr. Bond, "The five psychologists on the Louisiana Board were given plenty of credible evidence, but they chose not to investigate the head intelligence psychologist of prison camps notorious for their use of psychological torture. I don't think Louisiana lawmakers intended to give five fellow professionals total, unchecked power to make arbitrary decisions that deeply affect the public welfare."

Dr. Bond told Truthout, "I began reading of the role of psychologists at detention sites such as Guantanamo and was horrified when the American Psychological Association, by way of the infamous PENS report in 2005, determined that the actions of the BSCT psychologists were ethical."

She added, "In his biographical statement for the PENS report, Larry James stated that he was the 'Chief Psychologist for the Joint Intelligence Group at GTMO, Cuba' starting in January 2003. When the Camp Delta Standard Operating Procedure Manual (dated February, 2003 and implemented March 27, 2003) was released in November of 2007 and included behavioral management of prisoners that violated our psychological ethics codes, that same ethics code required that I report such violations to the licensing board to be investigated. My complaint to the Louisiana Board of Psychologists was dated 2/29/08."

Allegations of abuse during Dr. James's January to May 2003 deployment include beatings, religious and sexual humiliation, rape threats and painful body positions.

Canadian citizen Omar Khadr, who is still imprisoned in Guantanamo, is one of the prisoners who has alleged brutal treatment in the spring of 2003, when he was only 16 years old.

Khadr was captured by American forces at the age of 15 following a four-hour firefight with militants in the village of Ayub Kheyl, Afghanistan. He has spent seven years in the Guantanamo Bay detention camps, charged with war crimes and providing support to terrorism after allegedly throwing a grenade that killed a US soldier.

A Canadian citizen born in Toronto, he is the youngest prisoner held in the Guantanamo Bay detention camp by the United States and has been frequently referred to as a child soldier. In April 2009, the Federal Court of Canada ruled that the Canadian Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms made it obligatory for the government to immediately demand Khadr's return. After a hearing before the Court of Appeals produced the same result, the government announced they would argue their case before the Supreme Court of Canada. The Supreme Court is expected to hear the case next month.

Dr. James was also stationed in Iraq's Abu Ghraib prison in 2004 and returned to Guantanamo in 2007. In 2008, he was named dean of the School of Professional Psychology at Wright State University in Dayton, Ohio.

The CCR says that, as chief psychologist of the Joint Intelligence Group and a senior member of the Behavioral Science Consultation Team (BSCT) at Guantanamo, Dr. James had access to the confidential medical records of people he was charged with exploiting for intelligence.

It adds that, according to former Guantanamo interrogators, BSCTs used information from patients' records to help interrogators increase the patients' psychological duress, including by exploiting their fears. The very purpose of these mental health professional teams, the interrogators said, was to help "break" the prisoners. Dr. James denies that claim, but an extensive government paper trail supports the interrogators' accounts, the organization contends.

The so-called "Biscuit Teams" have sparked controversy ever since their existence became public. The actions taken by team members have called into question the appropriate behavior for physicians, psychologists, and other health care professionals who are team members.

The take by the Center for Constitutional Rights is, "Despite their universally recognized duty to do no harm, doctors and psychologists have played a key role in the United States government's policy of torture in its overseas prisons. Some have crafted and justified torture tactics, inflicted pain, overseen abuse and enabled and covered up cruel treatment."

The group adds, "Freedom of Information Act litigation and a US Senate Armed Services Committee (SASC) inquiry into the treatment of detainees have yielded, shed light on, the specific role of military intelligence psychologists and psychiatrists at the Guantanamo Bay detention center in Cuba. The names and licensing information of several individuals who may have been involved in prisoner abuse are publicly known. Yet, when presented with credible information that licensees within their jurisdiction may have committed gross breaches of ethics, state licensing boards have refused to take action. To date, not one health professional has been held accountable for their role in torture."

Dr. Stephen Soldz, a psychoanalyst, psychologist, public health researcher and faculty member at the Boston Graduate School of Psychoanalysis is among numerous professionals who have weighed in on the Bond suit.

He has written, "Former Army Col. Larry James, now Dean of the School of Professional Psychology at Wright State University in Ohio, was Chief Psychologist with the Joint Intelligence Group and a member of the Behavioral Science Consultation Team [BSCT] at Guantanamo from January till May, 2003. Official documents and press and detainee accounts raise serious questions as to whether Dr. James aided, participated in, or looked away from the numerous human rights abuses occurring at Guantanamo during that time."

He continues, "Psychologist Trudy Bond has filed ethics complaints against James with the American Psychological Association and the Louisiana Board of Psychology. Both have declined to investigate, as has every health professional association or state licensing board with which complaints of Guantanamo or other detainee abuse have been raised or filed. The ethics officials of the health professions appear to be taking a 'see no evil, hear no evil, investigate no evil' approach, making a mockery of the concept of professional ethics. While the American Psychological Association and other professional associations have issued pious statements against torture and detainee abuse, the clearly do not see pursuing accountability for those health professionals who aided Bush administration abuses as part of their responsibility."

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Standard Operating Procedure

Standard Operating Procedure for the profoundly corrupt state full of profoundly corrupt individuals.

Dr. James is the Mengele of

Dr. James is the Mengele of this century.

This kind of activity is an

This kind of activity is an insult to those psychologists who are working within ethical boundaries to heal wounded hearts and minds.When I think of the hours my own therapist dedicated to my well-being, I get very angry at this misuse of human understanding.

EVERY TIME A government

EVERY TIME A government BUREAU, BOARD, OR AGENCY is established to oversee a situation, it will do the exact OPPOSITE of what it's name indicates. All of these agencies are formed to keep cases OUT of court and to garuantee that no accountiblity of any kind can be placed.

Does anyone else smell a war

Does anyone else smell a war crimes tribunal in the near future? How is it that these people actually believe that they are above the law? This is a black mark on the profession of psychology. This is the guy who is teaching future psychologists of america.

The American Psychological

The American Psychological Association should remember the Nuremburg trials. Blind obedience to atrocity is never an excuse, and willful compliance deserves serious penalty. We should make it clear that we don't want people following in the footsteps of Mengele. Psychologists who feel patriotism justifies participation in torture should be removed from their profession. Those responsible for torture should be proscecuted.

As a retired psychologist, I

As a retired psychologist, I find this profoundly insulting personally, and degrading to my former profession. Members of the Louisiana Board, and the American Psychological Association, American Psychiatric Association, and American Medical Association all bear equal ethical culpability with those who perpetrated these perversions of our professions and now refuse to investigate and/or take a prinipled stand based on the Ethical Principles upon which all licensed professionals are required by law to practice.

If participating in torture

If participating in torture does not violate the professional ethics of a psychologist, we may well ask just what does? Just what ethical standards, if any, is a psychologist expected to meet? Considerable trust is placed, for the most part with good reason, in the judgment and ethics of uncounted thousands of professionals in this field. Can we extend such trust to practitioners who may never be held accountable for their conduct, no matter what that conduct might be?

There is no difference in

There is no difference in this circumstance than in the cases of Nazi doctors experimenting in concentration camps. If this is the response of professional boards and associations of psychologists, how can one bear to call himself or herself a psychologist and not personally fight to regain some human standing of the occupation by delicensing the unethical individuals and requiring a clear stand and actions on the ethics of the so-called profession.

The members of the State

The members of the State Board for licensing psychologists and disciplining them for violations are themselves in need of psychological help in a big way!! They have joined the ranks of the other criminally insane public officials that was formerly headed by Bush and Cheney and is now being led by Obama!! What a true disgrace to all that is good, descent, and noble in the human spirit. Shame on all these officials!!!

I am writing from Spokane,

I am writing from Spokane, Washington, home of CIA psychologists Bruce Jessen and James Mitchell as well as the Fairchild Air Force Base affiliated SERE school they used as a laboratory to reverse engineer pilot and soldier survival techniques to create more "effective" torture techniques for use by the U.S. military, intelligence agencies and private contractors in the "global war on terror". Now Michael Fassbender, a contract-employee of Spokane-based SERE Solutions has been arrested for the "especially violent" (quoting the judge) 10/20/09 rape of a woman at the SERE site just west of Spokane. As Ward Churchill and others have said, the chickens (and other types of made-in-the-USA fowl) have indeed come home to roost... and rape and infiltrate and spy and brutalize and terrorize here at home, just as they have done abroad. http://www.spokesman.com/stories/2009/oct/22/in-brief-woman-reports-rape-at-survival-center/

Death of Medicine in Nazi

Death of Medicine in Nazi Germany is a book about how prominent Jewish doctors collaborated with the Nazis. Someone can now begin writing a similar book about American doctors collaborating with American NeoNazis engaged in similar activities. The book can begin with Larry James.

What a disgrace, and this

What a disgrace, and this man is now the Chair of a Psycho Dept. at a teaching institution?! But then, the original land-grant university, MSU, was subverted by the CIA during the Vietnam war, with professors providing all sorts of aid to the Diem Regime: including weapons. University of Minnesota has it's share of "intelligence" related problems as well, with links to biotech realted programs and businesses that were criminal from inception to implosion. Sociopathy seems to run rampant in CIA/intelligence circles. Sociopathy is heavily influenced by environmental factors. Perhaps if we get rid of these so-called intelligence agencies we won't have so many human problems.

Those of us who labor in the

Those of us who labor in the vinyards of psychological healing find it inconceivable that one of our kind would stoop to facillitating torture. But then it occurs to me that not everyone drawn to the psychotheraputic arts are really talented at it... and those who aren't have to find some way to make a living nonetheless. And they often do so by teaching or administrating... or working for the scumbags that "manage" care for insurance companies. But torture is a quantum level beyond mere incompetence, in the direction of evil, and such people should be rooted out, exposed and expelled from the profession. This is the psychologists' moral equivalent to the priests who sexually abuse the innocent children in their care. Shame.

The allegations could be

The allegations could be entirely accurate but...gee, wouldn't it be nice, not to mention ethical, to at least try to find out what Dr. James has to say?

Is there not cause to think

Is there not cause to think that our enemies are unable to distinguish our government from the monster they believe they fight?

What's preventing the

What's preventing the Medical Profession from reviewing the journalism and commentary of Dr. Charles Krauthammer of the Washington Post? Maybe he has committed no crime, maybe he hasn't violated any medical standards, but should such a QUACK be giving advice on the editorial pages of a major national newspaper -- from the nation's capitol? Am I missing something? If Dr. Krauthammer were dispensing the same advice to individuals instead of the nation, would any other Doctors refer patients to him? Would any Doctors out there entrust a loved one to Krauthammer's CARE? And also, hasn't his work at the Post and elsewhere gone a long way to permit, enable, and excuse Dr. Larry C. James's barbaric -- junk -- medical practice -- both in his mind, but also in the psyche of the country as a whole ? Is this the public's fault? Isn't the public conditioned to believe experts and trust professionals? "Public Perception Management," is what the polical psy-ops crowd used to call this. ( Just WiKipedia Dr. Charles Krauthammer. He has a political science background and did psychiatric research for the Carter Administration.) Why doesn't the Medical Prosfession weigh in on this? Is there enough Prozac or Oxycondone in the world to relieve the suffering that Krauthammer's thinking has caused?

Dr. James must have been

Dr. James must have been under the influence of the criminal psychos that were in the White House at the time. Cheney and Rumsfeld were his best advisors and James is a monstrous piece of nothing good.

George Orwell`s prophetic

George Orwell`s prophetic vision revisited in the home of the brave and the land of the free.

02:03 From Spokane, this is

02:03 From Spokane, this is very important to note. I hope the constituents of the 30 Republicans who voted against Sen. Al Franken's amendment to hold military contract employees accountable for crimes such as these are made aware of The Sere Solutions case. Come on "Media" do your job; start telling the people what these Senators are doing for their people - on their behalf! Washington is a lawless town.

Did this psychologist train

Did this psychologist train or teach at LSU? Hope not.....

I'm a military psychiatrist

I'm a military psychiatrist who just returned from Afghanistan. While I had no role in detainee operations, I can say that comparing Dr James to a Mengele is a bit of a stretch. It is emotionally-laden and sounds compelling but, as an analogy, holds up poorly under scrutiny. It is disturbing to envision medical providers of any kind passively condoning and/or actively participating in what is deemed "torture". For those that oppose the war, the answer is likely simple: Get out of the Middle East and all these issues are eliminated. That plan, though reasonable on many levels, also belies an overly simplistic understanding of the complicated web that has been woven by US occupation. For those who appreciate why this conflict continues (even if you do not condone it), the presence of medical and mental health providers ultimately can function to provide a tempering oversite to the process of soldiers interacting with prisoners. The article above certainly suggests Dr James had a more ominous role in his previous deployment positions. Truthfully, other than vague accusations in the article above I am not certain what specific actions or omission or comission he is actually accused of perpetrating... perhaps I would find more info in the briefs filed in court against him... has anyone read these? In addition, the info above citing the recent alleged rape of a woman by a SERE training contract company employee is perplexing. The commenter above seems to be attempting to draw a link between that recent alleged act and the participation of medical providers in war-related torture. Perhaps someone can help me understand how these two phenomena are, or even could be, related?

Why haven't psychologist’s

Why haven't psychologist’s in America voiced outrage? Torture rendered by a healer? It is their duty and obligation to stop this insane treatment. Psychologist of America why?

I just got off the phone

I just got off the phone with my brother and sister-in-law. They are horrified. At the end of this semester, they are pulling their two kids (one a psychology major) out of Wright State University, even if it costs them twice as much to send them to another university. They won't have a 21st Century Mengele teaching their kids, and neither should any of the other parents who have children enrolled there. Hats off to Trudy James, a woman and psychologist with the professional integrity (hey,now, there's a concept!) to fight what is clearly an unpopular battle!

"While the American

"While the American Psychological Association and other professional associations have issued pious statements against torture and detainee abuse, the[y] clearly do not see pursuing accountability for those health professionals who aided Bush administration abuses as part of their responsibility." - - The local psychologists working for Kaiser were like that too. My rights were not protected, they put me at risk. I think it was torture. Everybody wants to duck taking any responsibility.

I suggest that at some level

I suggest that at some level everyone who is a U.S. citizen shares some degree of culpability for the crimes against humanity committed by our government. I believe that healing and reconciliation of these atrocities can come about only after full and public acknowledgment of the truth. I propose, therefore, that we all formally offer our most sincere and heartfelt apologies to the victims of torture and inhumane treatment inflicted by our government, and petition our elected officials to establish forthwith a "Commission for Truth & Reconciliation" to be charged with the proper authority to fully investigate these crimes and to issue a public report of their findings. We need to call upon all those responsible for these crimes to acknowledge their guilt and publicly seek forgiveness, just as we do.

To the anonymous person who

To the anonymous person who wrote on Sat, 10/31/2009 at 15:21 starting, "I'm a military psychologist who just returned from Afghanistan" -- The SERE site associated with Spokane's Fairchild AFB trains soldiers, spies, contractors, foreign military and agents, etc. It used to be assumed that they were teaching resistance to torture techniques so that downed U.S. pilots would not break under duress. But we now know from Slate, New Yorker Magazine, Spokesman-Review and other exposes that two of your psychologist colleagues Mitchell and Jessen from their offices at 108 N. Washington in Spokane helped turn that SERE site into a laboratory for creating torture techniques which could not be resisted. It was in that same context that prisons at Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo became hell holes for barbaric acts of torture, sexual abuse, rape and sodomy, humiliation, degradation, and homicide. Blame it if you like on the defects of the U.S. personnel who carried out those acts. However, it is clear from U.S. Gen. Antonio Taguba's report and others who have looked at this that it also had to do with a context, a mind set, and a command environment which allowed the vilest nature of men (and women like Linddy England) under U.S. command to engage in criminal and barbaric acts. Spokane -- your perplexed questioning aside -- is intimately and permanently linked to that context, mindset, and command environment. Michael Fassbender, a 12- year U.S. Army military policeman who served in Iraq from Nov 2005 to Nov 2006 and a current SERE Solutions contract employee accused of the recent "extremely violent" rape at the SERE site, is as closely connected to Private Linddy England, Spc Charles Graner and other involved in torture and homicides in U.S. controlled facilities like Abu Ghraib as one could imagine. You state that you can not imagine medical or psychologist personnel condoning torture but not only have they done just that, they have been involved in designing and implementing it, as in the case of Mitchell and Jessen and others. It is precisely the failure of those required by their positions and professional codes of ethics to speak up and to refuse to collaborate which allows those at the bottom of the command and responsibility chains (both legal and ethical) to believe that barbaric abuses are permissible. For more on the Fassbender rape, http://www.airforcetimes.com/news/2009/10/airforce_fairchild_rape_103109w/

Sweeping it under the rug is

Sweeping it under the rug is the natural and easy response of any bureaucracy to any hint of scandal. There's a great line in the episode "Remember" in the World at War BBC series about there being a fine line between the reasonably just and the mere functionary. Sounds like the Louisiana board is opting for the latter.

Response to Kent

Response to Kent Walton--good idea but the people of this country don't have any elected officials. That's the problem. Until Americans take back their country and rule it themselves, they will continue to drown in the vomit of evil men until all are destroyed. Believe it.