Share

Who Watches While the US Invades - Again

by: Marcia Mitchell, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
A child stands at the site of an October 31, 2008, US missile attack in Pakistan that killed 27. (Photo: Reuters)

    Has anyone in Washington noticed? The new US raids into Pakistan and Syria are, as was the invasion of Iraq, in blatant violation of international law. But who's keeping track of this sort of thing? Certainly not senior US officials, who apparently have weighed the negative consequences of illegal military operations against their perceived benefits and opted in favor of the latter.

    Washington officials apparently reason that relations with Syria, already damaged over the attacks, may well be mended with the arrival of a new occupant in the Oval Office, given that country's desire for an improved relationship with the United States. Possibly, but not certain. And what may work with Syria may not work with Pakistan; further, what may work with leaders of these countries may not work with their enraged citizens. There is no question that US raids launched from Iraqi soil only add to this latest downward spiral into Middle Eastern mud.

    It is fair to ask if anyone in Washington has noticed of late that Chapter VII of the UN Charter clearly establishes the rules for one country attacking another, rules to which this country is a signatory. International law provides three reasons for use of arms against an enemy - defense against imminent military attack, an overwhelming humanitarian catastrophe, or a UN Security Council resolution.

    (Regime change, now used as justification for having invaded Iraq, is specifically precluded as a reason for war. But again, no one seems to be noticing that toppling Saddam became a flawed justification once Weapons of Mass Destruction proved to be among the missing.)

    Perhaps concern over these new forays across foreign borders is unwarranted. Certainly, selective raids against Syria and Pakistan hardly amount to war. But they are acts of aggression, plain and simple. The fact that this sort of cross-border incident is commonplace around the world is no reason for the United States to continue this sort of operation.

    The announced objective for doing so is killing or capturing al-Qaida terrorists; the downside is the possibility of killing innocent civilians - children in schools, families celebrating a wedding, farmers working their fields. Add to the political calculus the certainty, not the possibility, of further infuriating and alienating other countries, both those considered friendly and those not so friendly. At this moment in history, it's hard to imagine a worsening of America's image abroad, but Washington seems determined to do so before the present administration leaves office.

    Our recent book, "The Spy Who Tried to Stop a War," the story of British secret service officer Katharine Gun's efforts to at least derail the Iraq war, offers two relevant quotes worth thinking about, given these new attacks on Middle Eastern countries.

    Richard Perle, sharing bellicose thoughts before the Iraq war, a war he saw as being insufficient to get the job done, said:

    "No stages. This is total war. We are fighting a variety of enemies. There are lots of them out there. All this talk about first we are going to do Afghanistan, then we will do Iraq ... this is entirely the wrong way to go about it. If we just let our vision of the world go forth, and we don't try to piece together clever diplomacy, but just wage a total war ... our children will sing great songs about us years from now."

    Most Americans must doubt that Perle's children's choir will perform as he predicted. Instead, they will consider his expectation consistent with a failed political culture, one that finds illegal "total war" preferable to "clever diplomacy."

    Another especially relevant quote coming from the Katharine Gun story is attributed to CIA Director Michael Hayden, who was at the NSA helm in 2003 when Gun revealed that agency's illegal spy operation against members of the UN Security Council. It also has to do with a political culture:

    "I'm not too uncomfortable with a society that makes its bogeymen secrecy and power ... making secrecy and power the bogeymen of political culture, that's not a bad society."

    But it is. At the moment, Hayden-esque bogeymen seem to be making decisions that are turning much of the world against the United States - decisions paid for in the currency of thousands upon thousands of lives lost and maimed, of millions displaced, of America's shattered image abroad, and of new raids of doubtful legality.

    There is no question that Perle's position on the Middle East was shared by a significant number of his pro-war colleagues, many still in high places in Washington. After more than five years of war, his words cast an ominous shadow over strategic planning sessions in Washington. And they bring to mind dangerous bogeypersons bent on total war, perhaps not just raids on Syria and Pakistan.

    Is anyone noticing?

  

»


Marcia Mitchell is co-author with Thomas Mitchell of "The Spy Who Tried to Stop a War: Katharine Gun and the Secret Plot to Sanction the Iraq War" and "The Spy Who Seduced America: Lies and Betrayal in the Heat of the Cold War."

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Yet another reason why Obama

Yet another reason why Obama MUST be elected. The USA is on the verge of being attacked by a world grown inpatient with Mr. Bush's mindless aggression. America is better than G. W. Bush and what he is trying to make us out to be.

Let's hope Obama is and he

Let's hope Obama is and he chooses to reverse this approach and punish the criminals in charge.

It's not that anyone isn't

It's not that anyone isn't noticing, but it's like noticing that the Mafia is running all the pizza parlors and pawn shops and paying off the cops, or noticing that armed drug gangs have taken over a bunch of empty houses on the block. Many notice, but prefer to keep their mouths shut - cause the other choice is death.

Lots of us are indeed

Lots of us are indeed noticing, as we have noticed the failing fabric of reason tearing again and and again; as we have noticed U.S. military bases developed worldwide; former allies, good or bad, literally hung out to dry and their bordering neighbors attacked without provocation; noticing Mr. Bush's and his business partners'use of telling words like "Crusade" and "You're either with us or against us" and "God". We are indeed noticing. We are noticing the deterioration of the quality of life everywhere (while) there is military aggression; we are noticing the whole world is connected and we are noticing that on the opposite side of the world where the hurt is being delivered our lives are diminished - because we know that we may very well be the next target of empire's ever hungrier eye - and regardless of where the eye is trained we are paying the bill; supportive, complicit and involved because we have not tamed this dark aspect of the collective soul.

While it is convenient to

While it is convenient to blame the upcoming American election for the complete lack of attention being paid to international matters by Americans..the reality is..that is absolute nonsense. Americans have shown in the last too many years to count.. that they could care less what happens to 'those people..the Muslim brown ones'... over there. The only middle eastern country that has the attention of the American people at all times..is.. of course.. Israel. Any of those 'other' countries...well... Frankly..Americans do NOT care about what happens to Pakistan..Syria..Iraq..Occupied Palestine..no matter who is occupying the oval office.

I wrote Speaker Pelosi

I wrote Speaker Pelosi concerning this very matter. Especially since it is clear that Congress should consider the implications of attacking in averse to the international laws and treaties. I encourage every reader to write both Speaker Pelosi, Senate Majority leader Reid, as well as their own state represenatives and senators.

It sure is nice to see

It sure is nice to see someone refer to the Bush administration's actions as "invasions," rather than the MSMs "cross border raids." These are not just violations of international law, they are war crimes.

The bush people are trying

The bush people are trying to provoke an attack by rogue pakistani isi people with some sort of nuke or something...to leave as much wreckage of legacy as possible for obama..... The right had such a gleeful opportunistic time after 9/11 they want more and to continue war profiteering in high gear...pushing all other social concerns to the curb. When actual currency becomes worthless ...then violence, weaponry and military power becomes the default currency and the right wing loves that idea whether it be martial law or military might and coercion focussed outward

Thanks for noticing! I've

Thanks for noticing! I've been wondering the same thing - is anybody noticing?!? Fortunately, a few of us are, which hopefully means a few more are now noticing! But what to do about it? How to stop it? One thing we can do is vote in a new administration and Hope for Change!!

What Richard Perle stated is

What Richard Perle stated is very similar to what a famous despot said in a speech about 64 years ago - "Wollt Ihr den totallen Krieg?". Adolf would have been very comfortable with the NeoCON insanity that has been inflicted upon the USA and the rest of the world. Like frank1569 stated, many of us know it and see it, but what happens to those who might actually try to do something about it? We surely need Obama to win the presidential election, but we also need him to survive long enough to correct this problem that is destroying America.

I'm voting for Obama, WITH

I'm voting for Obama, WITH the following RESERVATIONS! No to giving Colin Powell any position whatsoever! Leave Hugo Chavez alone. No pre-emptive war even if Rahm Emanuel wants it!

One wonders how the election

One wonders how the election could be so close, and how so many Americans do not understand or don't care what this administration has done to our image in the world. The Republicans apparently will use any sleazy tactic to capture the vote of the mass of unthinking sheep in this country. We have a long way to go to recover, even with an Obama in office.

This is why we cannot allow

This is why we cannot allow McCain to take the office and continue the disastrous Bush policies. I just returned from an international conference in Spain, with people from all over the world, including a few from Russia, China, and Iran. They like Americans but are rightfully concerned about our administration's policies and actions. McCain will continue the bullying, hawkish policies of Bush. He thinks this is the responsible way to deal with the world. Obama at least shows a willingness to talk to people and negotiate. There is too much at stake. We are rapidly losing the respect and cooperation of the rest of the world.

if you place hope in the

if you place hope in the hands of Barack Obama then you will be disappointed. the hope and the power to turn things around in our once great nation is in our own hands. doesn't it disturb anyone that this fiscal year we are spending 700 billion on "defense?" the last estimate i heard for next year it will top 1 trillion. if the people don't take back their government and it most surely is ours, then the politicians, including the neocons, will continue to be our rulers. we the people have allowed the politicians to get away with all that they have and it is up to us to stop them. there are groups organized already and it's a simple matter of joining and participating. in sept 07 when 65% of the american people were against the iraq war i marched on DC to protest. i'm almost ashamed to report that fewer than 10,000 were in attendence. if 1/3 of the us population showed up then would we still be in the mire of iraq? i don't think so. we've all got to stand up together, march together and say no to the madness that has become our gov't.

Yes, I've been noticing,

Yes, I've been noticing, especially because I have a friend living in Pakistan and a friend who came from Syria, so the people living in those countries are very real to me. From where I now live in China, I am utterly dismayed by the manner in which the U.S. continues to attack people in more and more countries, apparently without end. I know how tough it is when you lose your job or don't have enough money to pay the bills, especially when your country is spending money as though there's no tomorrow on invasions, attacking other countries at will. It's like living as a child, trying to lead a good life and do well in school, in the same house with a deranged alcoholic father whose rages continually topple your world. Yet you are dependent on him. The naivete of American people is appalling, though, who still think that the U.S. is a working democracy and that anything can be done through Congress or presidential elections to stop these thugs running the country. At what point do people realize that there's been a fascist takeover? How many unjust wars and war crimes does the U.S. have to start before people begin to catch on?

I've noticed.

I've noticed. Unfortunately, I don't think Pelosi or Reid have the spine to do anything. Bush will pardon himself and all his partners in crime, and we will be stuck with a big mess, bigger by the day. Maybe they don't need an October surprise... maybe they'll just rig the election. Palin was talkin' all about voter fraud, is she going to cry fraud if they lose? What if they win?

Illegal acts of military

Illegal acts of military aggression are as American as apple pie and Wall Street meltdowns. The history of the last 50 years bears witness. The trick that seems to work for the current thugs in power is to start a war, let it devolve into chaos, then start another one so the public can never rally as a bloc against any one war. It's working quite well when you stop to look at it. Best wishes on November 4th, although it astounds me that an electorate of 150 million is content with just two choices of 'government.'

All I can say is that I will

All I can say is that I will watch gleefully if the karma rains down upon these criminals and destroys their lives and families. Popcorn, anyone?

The only time Americans have

The only time Americans have risen up en-mass and pounded their representatives during the last eight years was when they realized their tax dollars were about to bailout Wall Street and that their pensions were worth nothing after the market crash. I know a sizable number of Americans (including those posting here and elsewhere) are against preemptive war and the criminality of the Bush Regime; but the fact is the majority don't give a sh*t unless it hurts their pocketbooks.

Remember Cambodia? Bombings

Remember Cambodia? Bombings that were"never" happening? And look where that got us and what followed...When I pause to think about our present (last 8 yrs.) foreign policies I just can't get around the fact that here are supposedly some of the best minds our nation has to offer and they display such ignorance that I wonder if they ever took ONE course in history or modernaffairs.... I mean we HIRED THEM to conduct buisness on our behalf and they have shown repeatedly how clueless they are about the consequences of their decisions to the field where they are applied... The odds of Mr Obama getting us out of this mess seem almost unsurmountable. He's going to need all the help he can get! But at least he can bring to justice on charges of treason a pretty big gang of crypto-fascists posing as "patriots"....he can even use their Patriot Act II against them!

So many illusions. Obama

So many illusions. Obama will not change the essential parameters which define Bush's war policies, or the obscene 'bailout' of Wall Street at the taxpayers expense. I can't imagine voting for either McCain or Obama.

We know that Bush will issue

We know that Bush will issue a slew of pardons shortly before leaving office. Will those pardons be for specific offenses, or will they be "blanket" or anticipatory in nature? And, will it be possible to issue pardons for treason?

Some people are noticing and

Some people are noticing and have noticed. Like LOKI, I and many of my geezer friends joined demonstrations against the war in Iraq, including the largest ever worldwide demonstration. But Shrub & Co didn't notice. I spend a good deal of time in East and South Asia, like ARIEL KY; most of that time recently has been in Malaysia, a country whose population is about 60% Muslim. Most people I have met in Malaysia and Asia generally have noticed--and deplore--the warmongering behavior of the US during the last eight years (and more); most in SE Asia have not forgotten the havoc the US wreaked on them during the 60s and 70s. However, most Asians make a careful distinction between the people and the government of the US. Most people see Americans people as friendly, kind, and generous if a bit boisterous and very provincial; they see recent our governments as arrogantly and pointlessly belligerent. Many are aware that the US is, or claims to be a democracy, so they quite reasonably have a hard time seeing why such decent people would accept such indecent governments. Asians are generally thought of as patient people, but I wonder how long those folks will continue to perceive the American people as distinct from our governments. BTW, the number of people I met in Malaysia during the past year who would prefer McCain to Obama as our next President is equal the number of fingers on a fish.

The United States grows more

The United States grows more disgusting by the day.

Pelosi and Reid MUST wake up

Pelosi and Reid MUST wake up - or be replaced. The traitors' last-minute pardons must be overturned. And the war mongering, including that perpetrated by the hordes of mercenaries on the US-taxpayer-supported payrolls, must be disbanded. Madness may reign now, but beginning in January it must stop. Or else the people must begin marching, and marching, and marching, until our leaders wake up and stand up and do what they swore to do. Preserve, protect and defend the Constitution

We think it's an outrage,

We think it's an outrage, shameful and a shame that we live in a country that is an international outlaw, one which in fact has no respect at all for the laws that govern it. What kind of example is that to set? It's a good thing we choose our modes of behavior from the bottom up. I think that the International Court should bring charges, and try these crooks in absentia if necessary. If they can catch the Americans responsible for any of these crimes, they should. What is the criminal American State going to do about it, bomb the Hague? It makes me sick that the hypocrites who scream loudest about "our nation of laws," and how "law and order must be maintained" think that laws apply only to others, and banish the thought that they themselves (or it itself) is subject to any, even laws they have specifically agreed to. The other nations of the world would be justified to punish the US with sanctions, until the perpetrators, the President, his Cabinet, the heads of the CIA, the NSA, etc. who directed and performed these crimes, are turned over for prosecution. In fact, we find it so embarrassing, so humiliating, to be associated with these thugs, that we encourage that prosecutions go forward, and look forward to the day when these men, and a woman or two, are finally, and actually, brought to justice. To bring Barack Obama into this, I think he will be much more willing to obey international law than ANY past president. He believes in doing what is right, and I think he will. One can also hope, though it's probably against hope, that he'll see that past crimes are answered for, also. Let us all hope (and pray, if you are of that mind) that Obama IS elected President a couple of days from now. ONLY then will there even be hope that the US will finally become a good citizen of the world. Under McCain, NOTHING would change.

The analogy posted near the

The analogy posted near the bottom of the page describing the apparent takeover by the Mafia, or a group of thugs, and thinking some legal wrangling, protesting, etc. is going to make us safe seems to be an accurate description of our current state. When it comes to egregious crimes perpetrated by the most powerful throughout the world, what are we to do about safety and empowerment? If resource wars and our dependent personality disorders are based on our unconscious, consumer behavior, wouldn't it be effective to ban money and heal the people who use their power at other's expense? The people with the most hate tend to be the people with the most fear and they are voting for the fear/hate ticket, McCain/Palin. How about if we treat each other as if the person you're talking with is going to some day have a lot of power over others, no matter how much you hate that person? We're all responsible.