Share

The Coming McCain Military Draft

by: Juan Cole  |  Informed Comment

photo
US Marines graduate boot camp. (Photo: File)

    There has been almost no discussion in the press about the broader implications of John McCain's military policies.

    McCain wants to keep a large military contingent in Iraq for some years to come.

    He agrees that more US troops should be sent to Afghanistan. (Obama wants more troops for Afghanistan but will draw down the ones in Iraq so that is a wash).

    McCain has joked about bombing Iran, accuses Iran of sending insurgents into Iraq, and pledges to stop Iran's nuclear research program. McCain has said, "There is only one thing worse than a military solution, and that, my friends, is a nuclear-armed Iran."

    McCain has all but pledged a war on Iran. (In contrast, Obama says he will conduct direct tough diplomacy with Tehran).

    McCain is also a hawk on Georgia in the Caucasus and if he is to remain credible he'd have to increase US troop presence in the Greater Middle East.

    Although US military re-enlistments in the ten combat divisions have not fallen in the way some observers had feared, that statistic only speaks to the ability of the US military to maintain the status quo. Even that ability is in long-term question, as African-American enlistments, traditionally a significant proportion, slip.

    But McCain is not about the military status quo. He is ambitious for further conflicts. The current US military is too small to handle yet another front, and to maintain, as McCain insists they must, the current ones.

    My friends, there is only one way for McCain to make good on his hawkish foreign policy and his virtual pledge of more wars.

    McCain will need to institute a draft for young American men (and, given the times, maybe for women as well).

    If you are in your late teens and early twenties, or if you are a parent of a person that age, and you have strong views on a renewed draft, it should come into your decision about whether to vote on Tuesday and for whom.

    --------

    Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Hi, y'all, Thanks for

Hi, y'all, Thanks for correcting the original picture. One small point, though, the fine-looking lads in the new picture are Marines, not Soldiers. That may seem like a very small point to you, but, believe me, it's not a small point with them. Soldiers are found in the Army, not in the Marine Corps. As to your article, I had exactly the same thoughts when Bush invaded Iraq. It was obvious that the Draft had to be put back into effect, if we were going to have viable armed forces. Bushco didn't do it, though, and our boys and girls are paying for that now. We're way overdue for playing the "Blame Game", don't you think? Regards, shyde

I'm hoping and praying that

I'm hoping and praying that tomorrow people will vote so that McBush doesn't have a prayer in hell to implement all the wars. Young people should pay special heed to the danger of a McPalin Presidency.

I actually think the Right

I actually think the Right is afraid of the draft- at least of any kind of real, across the board draft with no basically no exceptions. Why? because if a truly broad and representative slice of americans is required to fight their wars, by and large people won't stand for it and they will stop them. The reason the Right can get away with Iraq etc. for years on end is precisely that most americans are not directly impacted by the war, like fighting in it, only those who 'volunteer'.

Take a deep breath, JC. As

Take a deep breath, JC. As you know, the President cannot restart the draft without the consent of Congress. And the military hates forced conscription - it's way easier and better to hire experienced "private security contractors" who, though their loyalties may not be to God and country, are trained veterans who WANT to fight. And, given the choice, most Americans would rather pay someone else then send their own kids off to hell...

Semper Fi - Shyde. I too am

Semper Fi - Shyde. I too am tired of hearing Marines referred to as "soldiers". God bless the Army, but Marines are Marines, not soldiers. As long as any president can hire civilians to do what are historically military jobs, they can say "Look, I've reduced the number of the military in Iraq." When you add back in the traditional military jobs you've doubled the force there. This is the politicizing of the military. Bad dog, bad dog.