Share

I Speak Spanish: Sorry About That

by: Pilar Marrero  |  La Opinión (Los Angeles, United States)

photo
(Photo: jvoves /flickr)

The issue of language and cultural identity continues to cause a stir in some corners of this country.

In Dallas, the police chief announced that they were investigating 39 traffic violations issued to drivers for the sole reason that they did not speak English. The fine was 204 dollars. At least six cops were involved in this type of ticketing over the span of three years, so the problem cannot be attributed to the obsession of one eager officer.

There is no law that says that it is illegal not to speak English (though, of course, it is highly recommended to do so), so Dallas officials did the right thing in bringing this problem to light as soon as they were aware of it and launching an investigation to try to figure out why it happened.

In Taos, New Mexico, another curious incident of a similar nature took place. An entrepreneurial hotelier purchased a rundown little inn with the intention of renovating and reviving it, and in the process he made a series of changes in the hotel's personnel management policies. As a part of these changes, he ordered some of his employees to Anglicize their Hispanic-sounding names. And so Martín became Martin, Marcos turned into Mark etc.

According to the hotel's manager, Larry Whitten, the employees that deal with customers at the front desk and over the phones should have names that average folks can understand and pronounce.

Whitten told a local paper that his order to change the names had "nothing to do with racism, just a desire to satisfy my guests, because people calling from all over America don't know the Spanish accents or the Spanish culture or the Spanish anything."

I had a good laugh when I came across this ridiculous statement. In what world does Mr. Whitten live? The people of the United States, according to him, don't know that there is such a thing as Latino culture and that many Latinos live right here in this very country? Really? Who are these people that are so unaware?

I understand, of course, that it can be a bit inconvenient when someone has a thick accent and you can't understand their English. I've called customer service many times and been put through to a kid in India that I can barely understand. All the same, I try to pick up on what he's saying, and I ask him to repeat himself if there's something I don't catch, because someone named Siddhartha has a right to work just the same as everybody else.

But these communication issues aside, a person's name is, well, an extremely personal thing. If my name is Pilar, how should I disguise it to better accommodate these people to whom Mr. Whitten refers, to these people who live in a parallel universe where all names come from the British Isles? Maybe I should change it to something like Pailar? Would that help anybody out?

Nonsense. If I have to interact with clients or work as an effective journalist, I must try hard to speak the best English I can and make myself clearly understood, but I shouldn't have to change my name; my name is part of my culture and my very identity.

It's obvious that in both the case of the Dallas police ticket frenzy and the debacle with the Taos hotel manager that the controversies were fueled, if not by overt racism, then at least by misguided attitudes and actions. What is strange to me is that the two kerfuffles took place in the Southwest, in Texas and New Mexico, and not in more homogenous states like Kansas or Idaho.

At any rate, as far as we Hispanics, Latinos, Latin Americans and Chicanos go, all these and all other possible identities that can be derived from the people of the world who speak Spanish or are bilingual have always been a part of this country, and this is true now more so than ever.

--------

Translation: Ryan Croken. Ryan Croken is a freelance writer and editor based in Chicago. His essays and book reviews have appeared in The Philadelphia Inquirer, Z Magazine and ReligionDispatches.org. He can be reached at ryan.croken@gmail.com.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Why in US, if I am not

Why in US, if I am not British, I should be pushed to speak that language. I like the language, but I also like other languages. American is not synonimous with British.

Dear Anonymous on 11/3 at

Dear Anonymous on 11/3 at 18:19 - In answer to your question (why be forced to speak English in a country that is not England), because there are still - after 233 years - there are still people here who LIKE being lorded over by a KING (and fail to understand that others do not). English, no matter how mangled in their mouths, is all they have to remember how that feels.

While I assume the worst of

While I assume the worst of all police in matters pertaining to race--and that goes double for the Dallas police--it's possible the Dallas cops made an honest mistake. According to news stories, it is a requirement that the holder of a Texas COMMERCIAL license speak English, so they may have gotten the requirements mixed up. Plenty stupid of a cop to do that, but not nearly as stupid as actually writing and filing citations that include the cop's name, and which, if indeed done with ill intent, would violate federal civil rights laws.

The hotelier incident is

The hotelier incident is stupid. I can see anyone in a public service position being required to speak English, even to each other, but changing their names is offensive. However I speak Spanish and would not dream of speaking English in a Spanish-speaking country, even though that is my native tongue. Nor do I expect paperwork and anything else to be in English, even though English speakers have been part of the founding and developing of most Latin countries. I try to learn Spanish, and when with native Americans I feel that Spanish is a colonial language, and try to learn their language to communicate. Because I understand Spanish, I know that there is a lot of Spanish cultural nationalism that derogates English and does not want to co-exist, wants to promote Spanish as the primary language. There are also Spanish-speakers who do want to integrate. I like both cultures, but see America as an English-speaking country, and that carries with it a lot of it's cultural heritage. Mexico should go with Quechua and Nahuatl etc to really get into its cultural heritage, Spanish is as much a cultural imposition as English is historically in No. America.

I live in AZ. I'm outraged

I live in AZ. I'm outraged by Sheriff Joe, who gained his monstrous amount of power how??? Luckily, he will no longer be allowed to throw every Hispanic in jail for minor traffic violations. I suspect, however, that something more serious can always be drummed up. A fact that we must acknowledge is that violent crimes in AZ are skyrocketing, and the vast majority of the most shocking are committed by illegals. Some of those were dropped off over the border because they were the worst offenders in Mexico. I don't mind Spanish, I can understand the basics. I do sometimes wish that the person who deals with the public would speak better English; after all, it is still the primary language. Whomever works for him/her can speak what they wish. Seems to me it would be easier to speak it, though. And that generally accepted myth that American citizens wouldn't do the jobs that illegals do? Lie. I know many legals who make less for the same job (generally working for a boss of the other race). Discrimination is rife both ways. Remember the days when customer service personnel from India were always called 'Dan' or 'Donna'? I refuse to call them that. I ask for their own names and have them spelled and repeated until I get the pronunciation correct. Then I ask to speak to a supervisor and tell him (well, they have always been a 'him') how I feel about it.

As far as I am concerned,

As far as I am concerned, people are free to know as many different languages as they can cram into their little crania; however, in this country, which is based upon English, one of those languages should be English. Anonymous 1:51 is right: there are too many Spanish-speakers who don't want to learn English; they just want to transplant part of Mexico here. If the law allows driver's licenses to be given to non-English speakers, that law needs to be changed. If you don't know the language, how can you read all the traffic signs? If there is an accident, how can you even exchange information with an English-speaking driver? It is just absurd to live in a country without learning the language. It is really offensive to hear someone who has lived here for 20-30 years who either can't or won't speak English. If I had any reason to want to live in any Spanish-speaking country, my first action would be to polish up my high-school Spanish. As for the hotel owner, let's be clear: he owns the hotel, and as the owner, he has the right to insist that all his employees speak English, especially when they are around him. Changing their names was going overboard, but requiring English-only is well within his rights. He did nothing wrong, but the name-changing thing was pretty stupid.

How many americans live in

How many americans live in other countries and not know how to speak the language? I lived in Japan and China and do not speak Japanese and Chinese. I had a Japanese driver's license. I notice that Counselor Troi mentioned only Spanish speakers--what about speakers of other languages who are not fluent in English. Mexican Americans are a stigmatized group in the US, so it's a lot more fun to criticize their language. And what makes you think that "polishing up" on high school spanish is going to help you in a traffic accident in Mexico or Spain? Please, admit your racism and stop trying to hide it behind other issues.

I don't know how many (or if

I don't know how many (or if there *are* any) Hispanics in America who truly do not want to learn English - and nobody else knows, either. I hope the number is small and decreasing. Everyone living in the US should learn at least enough English to get by; but that doesn't mean that Americans shouldn't learn other languages, too. I myself know at least 4 languages besides English and therefore know how hard it is to learn another language as an adult, which makes my sympathetic to immigrants struggling to learn English. I think most immigrants want to learn English and certainly want their children to do so. Hardly any stringent measures are needed to bring this about.

Anonymous 19:30. If other

Anonymous 19:30. If other countries are unwise enough to allow foreigners who don't speak their language to operate motor vehicles on their streets and highways, that is their business. I don't care what language a person speaks, here they need to learn at least enough English to "get by" and follow traffic signs and directions. It is more noticeable with Mexicans because they are our largest group of immigrants, both legal and illegal. Race has nothing to do with it; it's all about the numbers.

Everyone who lives in a

Everyone who lives in a country should learn the language of that country. When a minority does not want to bother with learning the predominant language, this is a problem. The vast majority of German, Italian, Polish, French, and Dutch immigrants have all learned English and so can Hispanics. As for 19:30, you should have learned some Japanese and Mandarin.

I live in New Mexico and the

I live in New Mexico and the hotelier is ridiculous! Tourists who come to New Mexico admire the Spanish and Indian cultures. Our cities, streets, mountains, rivers, etc all have Spanish names. Some people come here because they like the feeling of being in our culture! Most hoteliers play this up.