Share

Obama's Path to Greatness: Health Care as Stimulus

by: Dean Baker, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
If Obama announced plans to jump-start national health care insurance, it could provide an immediate boost to the economy. (Photo: Keith Mellnick / Ryan Donnell)

    President Obama will have a historic opportunity to establish himself as a truly great president in his first days in office. He can take advantage of the current economic crisis to announce plans to jump start national health care insurance. Extending health care insurance can be an effective stimulus that will provide an immediate boost to the economy.

    More importantly, it will provide the same access to health care that people in other wealthy countries have long taken for granted. For this accomplishment, President Obama will rank alongside Presidents Roosevelt and Lincoln as one of the nation's truly great presidents.

    The backdrop is straightforward. Economists from across the political spectrum are now calling for a large stimulus package to limit the economy's decline and the rise in unemployment. The consensus is in the range of 2.0-2.5 percent of GDP, or $300 billion to $400 billion a year.

    This level of agreement among economists is encouraging, but the reality is that it is difficult to effectively spend $300 billion to $400 billion a year on short notice. There are some no-brainers that belong in any stimulus package: aid to state and local governments, extended unemployment benefits, and extra money for food stamps and home heating oil assistance. This is money that will be quickly spent, boosting the economy, while helping those hit hardest by the downturn.

    A stimulus should also include increases in infrastructure spending, which will come about by moving plans forward for projects already on the books. There should also be a substantial green component, involving retrofitting homes, businesses and other buildings, which will reduce our energy use.

    However, after we get through this list, the sum total for the stimulus package is probably still in the neighborhood of $150 billion a year, at best half of the targeted sum. This is the gap that will be filled by extending health care coverage.

    As a basic outline, the government can give a substantial tax credit (e.g. $3,000) to employers who cover workers for the first time in 2009 and 2010. It can also offer a tax credit covering most, or all, of any additional payments by employers who increase their coverage.

    This means that an employer who picked up the workers' share of insurance payments, or got a better plan, would have much of the cost reimbursed by the tax credit. Credits can also be given to individuals who are either self-employed, unemployed, or not otherwise covered through their employer.

    If 20 million workers get coverage through this tax credit, that would cost $60 billion. If another 60 million get an average of $1,000 in additional health care benefits, this would cost another $60 billion. If we also throw in funding to reduce the health care burden for Medicare beneficiaries, for example by $1,000 each, this will cost roughly $40 billion. The total cost would be $160 billion a year, a reasonable target for the stimulus package.

    At the same time that this health stimulus is enacted, we should open up the Medicare system, allowing all employers and individuals the option to buy into a Medicare-type plan. This is important, because a well-working public sector plan will be important to controlling costs over the long term.

    After 2010, the tax credits would be cut back, with the goal being a system of subsidies that pay the full cost for low-income people, but phase out at higher income levels. It will also be important to use the Medicare-type plan and other tools to squeeze waste out of the system, since controlling health care costs is essential to sustaining a healthy economy over the long term.

    Extending health care coverage in this way is effectively eating dessert before dinner, but this is exactly what we want to do to counter the recession. It is important that we spend money now to boost the economy. We will be getting double value if this stimulus can be spent usefully toward meeting a longstanding goal, such as providing national health care insurance, rather than just buying things at the mall.

    Fixing the health care system so that costs are effectively contained will be a long and difficult political battle. Powerful interest groups, like the insurance and pharmaceutical industries, will use all their power to obstruct this effort. The health care system's waste is their profit.

    However, we should be reassured by the fact that every other country has managed to more effectively contain costs. Average per-person health care costs in other wealthy countries are less than half as high as in the United States, and they all enjoy better health care outcomes.

    Over the long run the task of containing health care costs is clearly doable. The question for President Obama now is whether he is prepared to take the big leap toward being a truly great president. This opportunity may not come again.

  

»


Dean Baker is the Co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research. CEPR's Jobs Byte is published each month upon release of the Bureau of Labor Statistics' employment report.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Now it is time to see if

Now it is time to see if Obama can truly deliver what he promised during election time. I must admit that I am rather disappointed by Obama's healthcare plan, but I am willing to hear him out if it can jump start the economy. The United States has the worst healthcare system in the industrialized world right now. It is high time for some improvement. Of course, everybody keeps on talking about the economy. The financial crisis today will be minor compared to what will happen 30 years from now if the eco-crisis is allowed to continue. I do hope that Obama can actually deliver to that as well.

hope Obama hires DeanBaker

hope Obama hires DeanBaker and like minded INTELLIGENT staff.

I'll be happy when I see

I'll be happy when I see something that looks like a more humble, less arrogant & militarily aggressive United States. You know, something that doesn't smack of WHINSEC, "Security & Prosperity Partnership" & the Merida Initiative... show me something that doesn't include international communications & financial transaction 'tapping' & biometric cataloguing ...then I might say, "Hey! that AT&T DNC'08 wasn't as suspicious as it looked!!"

I think you are jumping the

I think you are jumping the gun a bit here. Obama, who got my vote, has made a lot of promises. Now we can see if he really cares about the people of this country or if he has been blowing smoke up our butts during this whole campaign. I will reserve MY judgement until another day.

I'm sorry but diddling

I'm sorry but diddling ourselves over tax breaks et. al. for privately funded health care won't cut it. It's GOT to be single payer, tax funded, universal health care. Anything less is an insurance company lobbyist boondoggle. Surely, that much is clear. Why is it that Cuba has a better and significantly cheaper system? Or England, France or any of the ECU countries? GET REAL, DUDE. You're sounding like Hillary in '92 and notice how well that worked out. Enough of this elaborate "free market" charade. If it were a free market my blood pressure meds would cost 12% or less than what they do. I was told this by my doctor! -- NO NO AND NO - the insurance companies have no place at the table on this one. -- Of the bankruptcies filed in the last couple years, 50% were due to catastrophic medical costs. 75% of that 50% had insurance company-provided health care. -- HELLO?!?!?!?

For healthcare reform to be

For healthcare reform to be realistic, needs based and predicated on the proposition that what we have is NOT working, this trial balloon is a Led Zeppelin. Lots of chords, no chromatic harmony.

Top of the list should be

Top of the list should be efforts to reverse global warming and reduce need for fossil fuels. A mass transit initiate like the interstate highway projects of the 1950's, which accelerated the move out of the cities and our dependence on cars, will provide both immediate construction jobs and longer term operation jobs, reduce the cost of people to travel to work and to school, reduce use of fossil fuels including the largest source of our oil, the tar sands of Canada, reduce suburban sprawl and the paving over of our farm lands, and eliminate the need to subsidize the energy industry and the corn agri-business companies like ADM to the tune of hundreds of billions of dollars. Unlike health care, transportation affects every American every day.

News flash the country is

News flash the country is BROKE. Spending IS the problem, how can anyone even remotely think the way out of debt is to spend even more?

I am convinced that Obama is

I am convinced that Obama is the best person for the job at this time in American history. Instead of nay-saying him, and nit-picking..(leave that to the Republicans..including McCain and Palin)..people ought to be solidly behind this man and doing whatever is necessary to make the promises made become reality. Sadly..too many people are waiting to pull him from his 'pedestal'..instead of working to make the dreams of a better America and world a reality. Good grief...just imagine if the world had to endure another 4 years of Bush the 'decider'..or even one term of McCain and nudge-nudge-wink-wink Palin. These two 'candidates' did their best to discredit Obama ..a man of integrity and natural leadership abilites through viscious lies and innuendo. Thankfully..enough people saw through their ugly side-show and elected the right person for the job. How about cutting the man some slack..instead ofleaoing to attack...and.. lets all be thankful that he did defeat the McCain/Palin train to nowhere.

Dean Baker is off the beam

Dean Baker is off the beam on this one and his plan is pure diddling. We must indeed have a universal, single pay health care system. This cannot be put into place overnight, but should be phased in like social security. The profit motive must be removed from the pharmaceutical industry so that patients and doctors are not subjected to their manipulation. Preventative m should be should be at the top of a doctor's clinical procedures. It's a big order.

From over 10 years of

From over 10 years of studying the US health care crisis, it is clear that keeping insurance companies in the system of "insuring' health care is costing 25-30% of every health care dollar. The only way the proposal Dean describes in this article will be sustainable is to limit the insurance company profit or eliminate insurance all together. Every other industrialized country has found a way to provide health care for all citizens- some countries via insurance companies and others without. For more data on this view the 4/15/08 PBS Frontline segment "Sick Around the World" at www.pbs.org and read T.R. Reid's book "We're number 37!" I want my tax dollars spent on effective, including preventative, medical care rather than CEO bonuses and shareholder dividends. Let the insurance companies (AARP included) insure things like cars, buildings, and such- things which are discretionary- not services needed to maintain life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

Providing single payer

Providing single payer health insurance would REALLY help the economy. Couple that with infrastructure and green energy initiatives for the future and it's a GO. The thing is I pay OVER $1000 A MONTH for health insurance. Nobody will "SELL" me a cheaper policy because I am older and ill. If I had the liquidity of my $1000 a month I could buy things and help the economy. Or I could pay off my mortgage in 10 years; something I wanted to do for the last 8 years and couldn't because of the insurance cost. My message is this: TAX CREDITS ARE BOGUS TO WORKING PEOPLE. WE NEED SERVICES FOR HEALTH CARE UP FRONT FOR FREE. We need the cost off our backs. Either that or triple our income so we can afford treatment. We can't live in an economy where the high prices are artificially sustained by off shore manipulation of exotic assets. Period. No tax credits please. I already don't pay them because of the high cost of my health care. I need relief. CASH relief.

Barack Obama’s vote to

Barack Obama’s vote to renew the Patriot Act, his votes to continue to fund the Iraq war, his backing of the FISA Reform Act, his craven courting of the Israeli lobby, his support of the death penalty, his refusal to champion universal, single-payer not-for-profit health care for all Americans, his call to increase troop levels and expand the war in Afghanistan, his failure to call for a reduction in the bloated and wasteful defense spending and his lobbying for the huge taxpayer swindle known as the bailout are repugnant to most of us on the left. well he will be better than mccain palin! at least that is what I and the rest of the world hopes for! (btw can anyone point out why bombing a big city filled with civilians makes a good war hero as in the case of mccain?)

Job #1 for Obama: Hire

Job #1 for Obama: Hire Baker as your economy person! One of the few economists who saw the Crisis coming! Say no to the Clinton Wall Streeters who were at least half responsible for the Crisis. Say no to Rubin, Summers... Also say no to the University of Chicago Milton Friedmanites... Might as well say no to the neo-cons as well--Dennis Ross, et. al

The "health care" industry

The "health care" industry can not thrive in a healthy society. If we can't reform their entrenched power, we Can reform ourselves. As a nation, we eat too much low quality food and we don't get enough exercise. Alcohol and tobacco are still profitable enterprises. We have been stressed out over the past 8 years and our immune systems are depleted. Taking better care of ourselves now will save medical costs down the road.

((TYPO corrected in last

((TYPO corrected in last sentence s/he/Summers/ )): Wait a minute folks, has not our new prez already committed himself to an incrementalist approach which will leave a lot of people without health care insurance? There's a lot of talk about how he will start his term not appearing like he is conducting the 3rd Clinton term. Well how will he? The HMO's and for profit hospitals already have their tongues hanging out and with people like Larry Summers to "help" him Obama may sell us further down the river than did Summers the Harvard janitors.

A intelligent and informed

A intelligent and informed friend who nevertheless has fairly right wing politics admits, albeit reluctantly, that single payer medical insurance and a backbone of federally run hospitals and clinics is "the only way to go." But he is a physician, so what the hell does he know?