Opinion

Facebook DIGG

GM Must Remake the Mass Transit System It Murdered

by: Harvey Wasserman  |  Visit article original @ Common Dreams

photo
Light rail in Denver, Colorado. (Photo: Xanterra.com)

    Bail out General Motors? The people who murdered our mass transit system?

    First let them remake what they destroyed.

    GM responded to the 1970s gas crisis by handing over the American market to energy-efficient Toyota and Honda.

    GM met the rise of the hybrids with "light trucks."

    GM built a small electric car, leased a pilot fleet to consumers who loved it, and then forcibly confiscated and trashed them all.

    GM now wants to market a $40,000 electric Volt that looks like a cross between a Hummer and a Cadillac and will do nothing to meet the Solartopian needs of a green-powered Earth.

    For this alone, GM's managers should never be allowed to make another car, let alone take our tax money to stay in business.

    But there is also a trillion-dollar skeleton in GM's closet.

    This is the company that murdered our mass transit system.

    The assertion comes from Bradford Snell, a government researcher whose definitive report damning GM has been a vehicular lightening rod since its 1974 debut. Its attackers and defenders are legion. But some facts are irrefutable:

    In a 1922 memo that will live in infamy, GM President Alfred P. Sloan established a unit aimed at dumping electrified mass transit in favor of gas-burning cars, trucks and buses.

    Just one American family in 10 then owned an automobile. Instead, we loved our 44,000 miles of passenger rail routes managed by 1,200 companies employing 300,000 Americans who ran 15 billion annual trips generating an income of $1 billion. According to Snell, "virtually every city and town in America of more than 2,500 people had its own electric rail system."

    But GM lost $65 million in 1921. So Sloan enlisted Standard Oil (now Exxon), Philips Petroleum, glass and rubber companies and an army of financiers and politicians to kill mass transit.

    The campaigns varied, as did the economic and technical health of many of the systems themselves. Some now argue that buses would have transcended many of the rail lines anyway. More likely, they would have hybridized and complemented each other.

    But with a varied arsenal of political and financial subterfuges, GM helped gut the core of America's train and trolley systems. It was the murder of our rail systems that made our "love affair" with the car a tragedy of necessity.

    In 1949 a complex federal prosecution for related crimes resulted in an anti-trust fine against GM of a whopping $5000. For years thereafter GM continued to bury electric rail systems by "bustituting" gas-fired vehicles.

    Then came the interstates. After driving his Allied forces into Berlin on Hitler's Autobahn, Dwight Eisenhower brought home a passion for America's biggest public works project. Some 40,000 miles of vital eco-systems were eventually paved under.

    In habitat destruction, oil addiction, global warming, outright traffic deaths (some 40,000/year and more), ancillary ailments and wars for oil, the automobile embodies the worst ecological catastrophe in human history.

    Should current General Motors management be made to pay for the ancient sins of Alfred Sloan?

    Since the 1880s, American corporations have claimed human rights under the law. Tasking one now with human responsibilities could set a great precedent.

    GM has certainly proved itself unable to make cars that can compete while healing a global-warmed planet.

    So let's convert the company's infrastructure to churn out trolley cars, monorails, passenger trains, truly green buses.

    FDR forced Detroit to manufacture the tanks, planes and guns that won World War 2 (try buying a 1944 Chevrolet!). Now let a reinvented GM make the "weapons" to win the climate war and energy independence.

    It demands re-tooling and re-training. But GM's special role in history must now evolve into using its infrastructure to restore the mass transit system - and ecological balance - it has helped destroy.

    --------

    Harvey Wasserman is co-author, with Bob Fitrakis, of four books on election protection which are available at www.freepress.org, where this article first appeared. His Harvey Wasserman's History of the US is at www.harveywasserman.com along with Solartopia! Our Green-Powered Earth, A.D. 2030.

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Why should we just 'give'

Why should we just 'give' any of them money. How will that help? Why not send to every taxpayer a 'voucher' for $10,000 toward the purchase of a new car manufactured by one of the big three. The manufacturer can then redeem the voucher. That way the tax payers get some 'bang for their buck.' Just handing them money won't help the dealers and others who are not directly involved with manufacture. And, it certainly won't help them get back to manufacturing cars - which is their business. Create business by giving money to the people who can and will speand, given the opportunity!

Congratulation Mr Wasserman.

Congratulation Mr Wasserman. I have been waiting for someone to write about the points mentioned in the DVD, "Who Killed the Electric Car". Unfortunately, too many knowledgeable (?) Washington representatives, are believing that we need to give billions to the Detroit auto manufacturers. Yet this is the same Detroit who has brain washed the American public that Hummers, Lincoln Navigators and the alike are cool(?).

Yes, absolutely! GM, the

Yes, absolutely! GM, the tire and oil companies need to right the wrongs of the corporate personhood's karma... They do live forever so the least they can do is correct what has been shown to be an actual criminal conspiracy to destroy southern California's transit system. If we don't insist on this then we will continue to be slaves to the self-appointed and culturally legitimized petroleum gods/demons/warmongers

I COMPLETELY AGREE !

I COMPLETELY AGREE !

YES, DO IT!!!!!!!! Wow,

YES, DO IT!!!!!!!! Wow, what a great article. Just look at all these powerful, smart comments. Wow

In the early 1960' I ran

In the early 1960' I ran afoul Chrysler and Standard of California on the same mass transit issue. "Who Framed Roger Rabbit" also addressed destroying mass transit in southern California, as in replacing the old "red car" rights of way, and building freeways and cars instead, All the "big 3" and the AMERICAN oil companies are to blame for the stupid but profitable to them decisions.

I absolutely agree with

I absolutely agree with Harvey Wasserman. I would add that any bailout money for Ford and Chrysler include the same conditions. Automobile dependency and its related effects (suburban sprawl "growth," pollution, etc etc) are destroying what's left of our global environment.

Their was actually a

Their was actually a conspiracy. Tire companies also bought up light rail and trollies, then tore up the track. Now we are addicted to having our own transportation. I can't give mine up, but at least I average 40 mpg in my small engine toyota. I'll get a prius next. It's really tractor trailers and the military that use the most gas. The military uses more oil than the entire country of Sweden. Give that bailout money to companies that make windmill farms and rebuild the electric infrastructure. The big three have made themselves obsolete.

Sloan was pro-Hitler and GM

Sloan was pro-Hitler and GM made their vehicles under the "Opal" company name. Sloan worked against FDR. You know, I live in a little bitty hamlet and a trolley used to run right past my house. I think your idea is a fine one. Maybe get GM some good karma for once.

our congress is to blame as

our congress is to blame as well as the big three. our congress has been bought and paid for by them for decades. blame congress and ourselves. we are all to blame. like any recipe, start from scratch.

So true. The GM bus

So true. The GM bus conspiracy of the 1950's destroyed the very efficient trans-Bay "Key Route" that ran from the East Bay across the Bay Bridge (from 1937 to 1958) into San Francisco. In 1960 the system was “sold” to AC Transit that is a public agency that uses buses. But then in 1964 construction of the Bay Area Rapid Transit System was begun. Ten years and hundreds of millions of dollars later we again had a workable mass transit system from the East Bay into SF! (And BART tracks even run along part of the old Key Route’s right-of-way in Berkeley.) I grew up in Detroit. Early in his career (during WWII) my father was an engineer for GM. The corporate culture of GM has not changed much in 65+ years. GM is still a big, politically-connected, pig-headed bureaucracy that would cause too much damage if we let fail. So bail it out --- but this time make sure our government keeps a firm grip on GM's privates so it doesn't screw the public again. Jeff Adams Berkeley, CA

Mr. Wasserman speaks for

Mr. Wasserman speaks for millions of us. However, if we leave the big 3 out of it we still must build or re-build mass transit. In central Missouri, where I live in a town of twelve thousand, a rail line once connected several small communities to Columbia, the biggest town in the region, where the University of Missouri is located. All these little towns were once thriving, with banks, bakers, lawyers and even car dealers. With the dismantling of the rail system they have all withered into isolated communities of a few dozen homes. Restoring light rail would re-awaken these towns, restore real estate values and property taxes, and eliminate thousands of single-vehicle trips to work in Columbia every day, not to mention the highway carnage they create. Mr. Wasserman has put his finger on an idea whose time has come.

The other evening I was at a

The other evening I was at a friend of mine whom happens to own a 1969 Ford Mustang 428 Cobra Jet. He collects garage art to accent the walls. He purchased a 1955 Oldsmobile front grill emblem. In it was the 6 (six) Fleur DE Les in the OLDS emblem. GM began in France. Old elite money. This elite money has bankrupted the good ol' US of A. They (the elite) are back for THEIR property that they lost to the brash colonists before 1776. some call me frank

$50 billion in taxpayer

$50 billion in taxpayer money is going to pay back the campaign contributions made by the auto companies to Obama. Logic does not come into play anymore than with the trillion dollar payoff to the oil, gas, and munitions companies that funded the Bush campaigns. Just good business and bad government, nothing really new. Of course it would be better to not subsidize old technology and put the dollars into light rail and Amtrak (whose funding is 1/10 of what it was pre-Bush and 1/1000 of what it needs to be. But there are no strong train and light rail unions and companies like Boeing are too busy building billion dollar bombers to think about building high tech rail cars. As when BART was built in the SF Bay area most of the components would have to come from European manufacturers.

Disused railway land ran

Disused railway land ran just where Seattle needed to put lite rail. The land was available to King County which made it into a walk-bike trail instead. I would like to exchange my Honda for an alternative that I can take my service dog on and get 60 miles to my horse, (urban sprawl has removed any horse space far far away and unnecessarily made keeping and riding horses illegal in the city). I rode for many years on a major highway, Rainier Ave., downtown. Horses are as good an alternative as bikes, and safer. The one mile monorail constructed for the 60's world fair used inferior technology that was expensive and substandard then. Seattlelites have consistently voted for lite rail only to be obliged to pay each year to vote to reaffirm our choice. Yes, the auto makers and ancillary corporations will have to be forced-at every step: with a whip and chair, after bludgeoning them into submission. A woman can dream?

Better to have GM

Better to have GM manufacture light rail & mass trans systems than pay Siemens to do it for us. Better than have GM make more cars that are going to be relatively useless once the 9% oil depletion kicks in and starts producing regional shortages, turning private transportation into monuments to stupidity. We've got to find a way to ease ourselves through the transition to the post-petroleum age. What better way to do it than funding an Apollo Program of mass transit and a renaissance of both light and heavy rail?

I am 62 and German. In1975

I am 62 and German. In1975 I visited the US for the first time. I remember I was impressed by the country's multi-lane highways. I was impressed by the fact that everyone was driving a car. Years later, after multiple trips to the U.S., I began to understand the dire cost, environmental, health and otherwise, of this road and car excess to the country Luckily Germany never had a chance to do the same as the country is small and land is much more expensive than in the States. Out of the necessity to save land and avoid horrible congestions on its roads (which sometimes happen nevertheless) Germany invested in public transit. Visit Munich, my home town, and experience a fully integrated public transportation system. You never miss your care and it takes much less time to go downtown from the suburbs. Trains and busses arrive and leave on the minute and every stop has a transit map. In terms of transit convenience the U.S. is years behind. I never could understand that Americans don't grasp the long-term cost of individualized transport . I agree Americans should force the Big Three to build trains and green busses instead of automobile dinosaurs.

LET THEM SCRAP THE HUMMERS

LET THEM SCRAP THE HUMMERS LET THEM DITCH THE CADILLACS AND THE LITE TRUCKS SELL THE TIN OR RECYCLE IT INTO MASS TRANSIT (electrical)... NO BAILOUT...AND NO MONEY FOR DEVELOPPING MORE FUEL EFFICIENT MOTORS which they might request... THEY COULD HAVE DONE THAT ON THEIR OWN 35 OR 40 YEARS AGO , instead of letting the rest of the world do it. ....ALSO, TAKE A LOOK AT THEIR SYMBIOTIC COUSINS... OIL AND RUBBER..THEY ARE PART OF THE PROBLEM BIG TIME...THEY HAVE BEEN FEEDING ON EACH OTHER SINCE DAY ONE CONSPIRACY, AND COMMON FRONTING? not much!! pam

Good Luck on this ever

Good Luck on this ever happening. Too many corporate lobbyist and people in various positions that stand to gain from a bailout. Its amazing how perfect the bush administration has been with its propaganda in raping our country. Make money in iraq and war, make money for more of the buddy system in the financial bailout without enough oversight, and now..... the car industry.... the other good ol boy network...

Let GM bring back the EV1

Let GM bring back the EV1 (the electric car they had a while back, but use more recent battery technology so as to extend the range. GM destroyed every copy of the EV1, save those they disabled and allowed to be put in museums. Now force GM to bring those back for people living in large metropolitan areas like N.Y.C. and L.A.!

There is much that MUST be

There is much that MUST be done to rebuild the power grid, put in T. Boone Pickens' wind farm, and rebuild mass transit. I could care less if I have to give up my car. I've always lived modestly, within my means and with a desire to make the smallest impact I can. I've driven fuel efficient cars since 1974 and sadly watched the US auto industry endlessly moan about the competition taking over the marketplace, but willing to allow the unions to ensure the workers huge wages, which they will continue to earn until the day they wake up and the gates to the plant are padlocked. Will they still think their negotiators clever then? Please... we MUST all pull together to get it right this time, or we'll be adding ourselves to the endangered species list much sooner than you think.

NATIONAL THE AUTO INDUSTRY

NATIONAL THE AUTO INDUSTRY AND TURN IT TO MAKING, PUBLIC TRANSIT VEHICLES SYSTEMS. FDR DID IT IN WORLD WAR II TO MAKE TANKS AND WAR PRODUCTS.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.