Share

Never Forget

by: Marc Ash, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
An American soldier lies on an operating table. in Ramadi after being wounded in an IED blast. Iraq 2006. (Photo: Lucian Read / battlespaceonline.org)

    When they say to you that "mistakes were made," never believe that. Mistakes are always made, but mistakes did not lead us on the road to Baghdad. We were taken to Iraq by those who knew exactly, precisely what they were doing. Or believed so anyway.

    Do not be persuaded to believe that "bad intelligence" was the problem and war was the unfortunate result. No one who made this war believed themselves what they told the nation. They knew quite well and they went anyway. And they took us with them.

    When it is said that an "insurgent" has killed or been killed always ask who that was, and why. More often than not, it was someone who lived there, but would not live under foreign rule.

    Do not be seduced into thinking of torture as harsh interrogation. The hour is late and we must confront the torturers among us.

    If you are the slightest bit concerned that we have crushed freedom here and in other lands in the name of freedom, be more concerned. We have.

    Never forget or let your children forget that it was all a lie, told with purpose.

    Many of us believed that Vietnam was a catharsis, a moving beyond a point to which we could never return. It took only 28 years to get from Saigon to Baghdad. And we took the exact same road. Don't be too ashamed the trick we fell for was the same one Mark Twain warned of when he wrote, "Beware the leader who bangs the drums of war in order to whip the citizenry into a patriotic fervor ..." "All you have to do ...," said Hermann Goering "... is tell them that they are being attacked, and denounce the peacemakers for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger. It works the same in any country."

    It has worked in our country. Again.

    At the end of any battle, the last man holding a sword is the judge. But Nuremberg forgot Dresden. Will we forget Abu Ghraib? Will the world forget what we have done? In the year 2001, we believed that it did not matter who won the presidential election. What do we believe now?

    We have sacked Babylon. Only a fool would believe there will be no day of atonement.

    We stand at the precipice of a new age of political pragmatism. Realists, making realistic decisions. Let it be listed among those things that are real the danger of ignoring the enormous crimes of these last eight years. Lest we come to ask for whom the bell tolls.

  

»


You can send comments to Truthout Executive Director Marc Ash at: director@truthout.org.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

True, every word of it.

True, every word of it. Shameful, shameful, shameful. The Land of the Free and Home of the Brave has shown itself to be filled with Followers and Cowards. Me and almost everyone else. Shame.

i have always said mistake

i have always said mistake after mistake is not a mistake it is only suppose to look like a mistake. this was all well thought out. they needed to be justified so 9/11 was it. they all need to be held accountable. unfortunately i am afraid we will lead down the same path again. they were warned about 9/11 and did nothing.

Yes - the invasion of Iraq

Yes - the invasion of Iraq was no "mistake" it was well thought out. It proved to be the great mistake that gave rise to a new world scene - deleterious for the West - because Cheney, Rumsfeld and the neo-conservatives in the G W Bush Administration did not take into account the realities of the Middle East and in particular of the fissiparous nature of Iraq. Our consultancy did much work on this subject - the new world scene resulting from Iraq - which may be accessed at our site dipconsult.eu

"Freedom is never an

"Freedom is never an achieved state. Like electricity, we must keep generating it, or the lights go out. We now witness a fire sale of American liberty at the bargain basement price of the false promise of security. The America being designed this moment will not resemble the America we have been defending. The danger is not that Big Brother may storm the castle gates. The danger is that Americans will not realize he is already inside the castle walls." Samuel Adams Speech at the Philadelphia State House, August 1, 1776 "If you love [the promise of dispossessed] wealth better than liberty, the tranquillity of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, go home from us in peace. We ask not your counsels or arms. Crouch down and lick the hands which feed you. May your chains set lightly upon you, and may posterity forget that ye were our countrymen."

Obama faces a dilemma. I

Obama faces a dilemma. I agree that the perps should be held responsible, but he can't get into a blame game, or look petty and vengeful. That means that others--Congress, the courts, the DOJ--will have to pursue and prosecute, and they should. They also will have to demonstrate even-handedness, justice not vengeance. The best model would be South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission. Bush minions would have to confess to their crimes in order for some final accounting. I don't believe that throwing all these people in jail will solve things; allowing them to confess, set the record straight, perhaps pay damages to individuals harmed, or provide restitution to the extent possible should be available for any who cooperate. The perps wouldn't all be punished to our hearts content, but the record would be cleared, and precedents re-established so nothing like the Bush administration could EVER happen again.

There is a growing chorus of

There is a growing chorus of angry citizens urging the perpetrators of what amounts to a horrific war crime to be brought to justice. We are calling for the prosecution of the main promoters of this debacle, which has killed close to a million Iraquis and Americans. I urge all who care to read Vincent Buglosi's "The Prosecution of George W. Bush for Murder", which lays out the case by one of this country's most respected and able prosecutors. It is time to pay the piper.

WAYNE LAPIERRE; THANK YOU .

WAYNE LAPIERRE; THANK YOU . that is a great quote for our country to back to.

Never forget that America is

Never forget that America is NOT free. How are we free? America gets "two" choices in presidential leadership. Two and there realistically, wasn't so much difference between warmonger number one and warmonger number two. Let's think Rahm Emanuel as White House Chief of Staff. Clinton as Secretary of State? Congress dictates and the American people get to pay for it. Our president declares wars of naked aggression and genocide and the war grinds on and on. 9/11/01 was most likely an inside job and to this day there is no honest nor independent investigation. Treason is the rule of our land as is war profiteering. Can we all say Dianne Feinstein? America is NOT free and as the war grinds, so does what little of our "liberty" we had left. How does the NSA peeking at one's emails sit with you? America is NOT free, we are just over indulged and pampered to bankruptcy.

I agree with Mr. Ash's

I agree with Mr. Ash's sentiments--I have, in fact, often expressed them in only slightly different form over the years. The invasion of Iraq was not a mistake; it was coldly calculated, with every intention of remaining in the region for as long as possible. Unfortunately, as long as the belief that military service automatically equals heroism prevails in the United States, the Iraq mess will never be the subject of serious, widespread discussion. It will remain a fringe issue, because very few people (even among those who know in their hearts that the invasion and occupation of Iraq was and is fundamentally WRONG) are willing to violate one of our most cherished social mores.

There is no way that we can

There is no way that we can begin to reclaim our greatness as a nation until those that have trashed our worldwide integrity and leadership have been brought to justice. I agree with the previous poster, although I would love to see Bush & Cheney drawn & quartered for the crimes they have committed against our republic, the war is but one example of the treasonous activity they have inflicted upon us. There is really no way to make restitution to the families that have been damaged or destroyed, ..at the very minimum we need a public acknowledgement of what has become obvious-they lied to the world in order to carry out their own agendas. We should banish them all from our country.

Start with the 5 supreme

Start with the 5 supreme court justices that took 2000 election from the people when they appointed w as president. Include in that the absolute drive for the republicans to gain the white house while controlling both the senate and the house and stacking the supreme court with their puppets. Next, investigate the neocon's agenda of using a disaster(9/11) as an event to hoodwink the people for their/our support of attacking a sovereign nation that absolutely nothing to do with that disaster(9/11). And above all investigate every bit of that disaster(9/11) to bring the irresponsible and the criminal to justice. The 2 major towers may appear to be the main target but wtc 7 definitely had enough cause and motive for members of our own government to at the least allow that disaster(9/11) to happen and a very high probability of orchestrating the whole event. And to go back to the earlier beginnings, investigate all the neoconservative think tanks that for several decades have plotted a way to gain a control that would turn this country and the world upside to support the corporate elite's imperial empire, in other words the grandest plan of grand larceny ever perpetrated on the people of this country and the world. And somebody for goodness sake, expose milton friedman and his economic ideology for the fraud that it is and for the misery it has caused all around the world. All of this pertains to the true terrorists that have and still are attacking everybody everywhere they can under the cover of our military fighting a war against terror.

Nice article Marc! I'm

Nice article Marc! I'm worried by all this "we have to move forward" talk we're hearing now. I think the Obama Administration needs to understand that as difficult and painfull as it may be, there is NO MOVING FORWARD until the truth about 9-11 is exposed and Bush Administration's many crimes are acknowledged and accounted for.

Well said, Mark. Amen. Let

Well said, Mark. Amen. Let us hope that we can at least undo some of the damage we have done. And let us hope that Barack Obama keeps his pledge from his victory speech: "I will always be honest with you".

FREE? The Bush/Cheney

FREE? The Bush/Cheney administration have done the most terrible disservice to not only to the American people, many of whom are misguided, uneducated folks buying into false patriotism, but also destroyed the lives of hundreds of thousands of innocent Iraqi and Afghani civilians. The damage done to their countries in the form of weapons containing depleted uranium will linger on for many generations while the war profiteers are cashing-in handsomely. When you see the photos of children being birthed today in Iraq totally deformed and almost looking like monsters you wonder at what price this pre-arranged war came to humanity. And yet there are people who will defend this system and the mess it has left the country/world in irrespective of what the consequences will be. It would not surprise me at all if 9/11 had been an inside-job destined to trigger what has been happening since and what, if at all, will take generations to rectify. Taking all of the ill-gotten gains of those who have profited from this scheme such as Haliburton et al may well help get the country out of the fiscal misery it is in as will the restitution and pay-back by those who contributed to the financial melt-down. Will it happen? I doubt it - the American resolve is just not there and flags keep being waved as a sign of loyalty to a system that will self-destruct just like communism did and for the very same reasons. Bush/Cheney ought to face the World Court in the Hague to be brought to justice - the people who died or are affected for the rest of their lives should not have suffered in vain.

I second Douglas C. Smyth's

I second Douglas C. Smyth's proposal that those responsible pay for their crimes. And I up the ante: I want each person to make it his or her responsibility to demand that our will be done. I want the perps to be put in figurative public stocks, made to confess their crimes, repay costs that the public has had to bear, pay restitution to Iraqis and Afghans damaged by their wars, deconstruct the thousands of military bases built to protect their energy investments (the Pentagon admits to just over 700 military installations, but it leaves out thousands), etc. The South African model is a useful one, as is the Chilean model that sought to rebuild a democracy destroyed by the CIA and its henchman, Pinochet. The Chilean people's long-term resistance, smartly conceived and executed, is a good model for US citizens to follow in forcing our authorities -- courts, agencies and elected officials -- to do what we demand. In Chile the Catholic church worked with businessmen to bring down Pinochet and restore democracy. Might we dream of our institutions being so dedicated to democracy?

Thank you Mr. Ash. Some of

Thank you Mr. Ash. Some of us, the relatively enlightened few, will not forget. As for the rest of America, they don't have a clue how far "down the rabbit hole" we are. Of course, this was no mistake. The members of PNAC proposed a war in the Middle East to take control of oil (and our "Empire's" future) more than a decade ago, and indicated that in order to get the American people to go along with this war a "new Pearl Harbor" would be required. The events of 9/11 were the new Pearl Harbor. Any reasonable person who asks the right questions and does his/her homework cannot reach any other conclusion than that it was an inside job. I agree with the comments that holding Bush & Co. accountable for their many treasonous crimes against us and humanity will be necessary to "unify" the nation, but I don't see unity as being a realistic goal at this point. There are at least two Americas, and we seem to be farther apart than at any time since the civil war. The battle continues!

Truthout - Please remove

Truthout - Please remove this distasteful and disrespectful photo from your site. This is a brave young man who was in the wrong place for the wrong reason. Or, maybe you could send a copy to his mother if bad taste is the order of the day.

Over 1,000,000 dead in Iraq

Over 1,000,000 dead in Iraq because we were lied to by Bush. Fully, 50% of its population were children under the age of thirteen at the time of our invasion. Over 4,000 American soldiers have been killed—but the ratio of those killed to those maimed for life is ten to one. The Nuremberg Tribunals an international court headed by the U. S. after WWII judged “invasion” to be “the supreme international war crime.” This was presented to be an international standard of law and conscience for all time. It was rightly championed by us until the invasion of Iraq. The actions that have engendered and supported the war are criminal and impeachable. Many other war crimes have been perpetrated by the Bush government, including torture. Torture overwhelms human standards expressing, in effect, every violation that can be perpetrated against a human. It is the ultimate corruption of power. Its victims do not recover but carry the scars of such treatment invisibly for the rest of their lives - if they can bear surviving it at all. Implied in such government behavior is the breakdown of law, Due Process, and accountability from those in power. People who are imprisoned indefinitely without charges or legal recourse and tortured are not prisoners. They are slaves. This is what the Bush Administration and its collaborators have done and what they represent. A huge array of legislative action, “illegal legislation” in effect, has been enacted to essentially undo federal democratic statutes in order to promulgate the war by compromising of the Bill of Rights and the Balance of Powers mandated in the U.S. Constitution. This is because the people in government who have pushed the war have broken a vast array of federal and international laws to conduct it and because of this, they are legally liable unless they distort the terms and reverse the standards they have violated. This erosion of law still threatens Americans even in their own home. Please consider this...from the point of view of lives lost, lives ruined and the pains everyone associated with it must bear. Consider respect for life, and respect for our soldiers - who are supposed to “defend the Constitution against all enemies both foreign and domestic”. Our Representatives in Congress have certainly NOT done this. Therefore, consider respect for democratic law, civil order, natural order or even Nature itself; the war is wrong from every viewpoint and every element that supports it is wrong. So please stand up and speak out for peace, the U.S. Constitution and rule of law.

The one shame that really

The one shame that really should stand out is that it has taken so long for many people to finally and openly say that 911 was not an act of Terrorism by none other than perpetrators within our own country. Now that the real culprits day of reckoning is beginning to appear evident, hurried along by the defeat of their man at the polls, Obama will most likely be another target by the Far Right NeoCons and all of their Zionist egger-oners. I think he is smart enough to know very well what he is up against. If he doesn't, then he would have to be a part of the Plan. I pray that I am wrong and he is exactly what he portrays himself to be...a decent man that only has the American people and the rest of the world at heart. He was in the Senate long enough to know where all the bodies are buried. Now let us hope he will use that knowledge for the best benefit of us all.

Never Forget...9/11 Was

Never Forget...9/11 Was Treason And it has been covered up by both major political parties in a sickening display of "business as usual." "The Administration's decision to classify this information prevents the American people from having access to information about the involvement of certain foreign governments in the terrorist attacks of September 2001." -US Senate, October 28, 2003 http://www.fas.org/irp/congress/2003_cr/s102803.html That's treason, folks in black and white. The question then is: Why won't anyone do anything about it? Why isn't there anything said here about open treason related to the September 11th attacks? Why aren't you outraged? Where's your red white and blue faux patriotism in the face of real domestic enemies, covering up the actions of real foreign enemies? Are you going to complain to Obama about this? I sure can't do it alone. John Doraemi publishes Crimes of the State Blog http://crimesofthestate.blogspot.com/

I'm afraid that part of the

I'm afraid that part of the problem is that Bush, and many other of his kind, are 'believers', and he truly thinks that he was doing "God's bidding"... and that if we end up annihilated it is just proof that this is the time of the "Rapture". It is an unfortunate situation, and one that is very difficult to counter...

We the people have let Bush

We the people have let Bush and Cheney do their dirty work for eight years. The Nuremberg trial showed the way on how to deal with that. Starten unnecessary wars just to prove "I am a war president" is a major crime. The banrupting of the country for personal glory is another one. We will never live this down.

Bush is a puppet of, and the

Bush is a puppet of, and the "holy rollers" and "right-to-lifers" are tools of the NeoCONs. The NeoCONs do not share convictions with those groups - their only aim is to create a global fascist/corporatist totalitarian state. All of these so called "mistakes" are all part of their plan, which includes using the threat of a real or engineered external enemy (hence 9/11 and the GWOT, and more recently the provocation of Russia), as well as creating instruments such as The Patriot Act and the DHS to repress and control the American people through fear and intimidation. Just because Obama was elected and the Democrats kept their majorities in both houses of Congress does not mean that the NeoCON threat to America has gone away. Reid and Pelosi are still in their positions, Clinton has been selected as Secretary of State, and Lieberman still has chairmanship of the Homeland Security committee. Looking at these developments, it seems likely that we will have a political landscape going forward from which many more "mistakes" will be made. We Americans continue to have grounds to fear for our country as defined by our Constitution. If there was ever a time for vigilance, it is now, even (or especially) with Obama having been elected President. The NeoCONs are still among us, and are still very powerful. They need to be removed or our country will be destroyed.

Shame indeed. Imagine if

Shame indeed. Imagine if the atrocites committed by the US under the Bush adminisration had been committed by some other country... Thanks to news sources like Truthout..we are able to get a much clearer and more honest picture of what is really going on under the auspices of 'freedom and liberation'. Heaven knows we rarely..if ever... get the truth from the news conglomerates reporting the 'news' The crimes against humanity committed by the US under this administration are breathtaking in their scope. Bush, Cheney and the rest of the perpetrators ought to be treated according to the same laws that govern other nations. The fact that they are not being held accountable for the slaughter of hundreds of thousands of innocent people..and the destruction of a sovereign nation.. speaks to the inequality and hypocrisy evident when dealing with a superpower nation unwilling to see the truth of what is being done in their name. Shame indeed!

Someone suggested the

Someone suggested the picture for this article be removed, I don't agree. If Americans had seen pictures like this in their daily paper or TV news, maybe more would have questioned things a bit. Remember, flag draped caskets were not allowed to be photographed early on in the OCCUPATION of Iraq. There is so much to repair before things can be turned around. In this regard we need not to allow media conglomerate/monopolies. Why have we forsaken The Sherman Act, aka antitrust law. I don't trust the media anymore, does anyone?

Do you ever notice the

Do you ever notice the perversion of some people in that they see an American solider injured by an IRAQI IED and they Blame BUSH. They see Iraqi citizens injured by an American bomb and the BLAME BUSH once again. I can only image that if the US does indeed stay in Iraq until 2011 as the recent agreement states any American or Iraqi casualties rendered from Jan 20, 2009 until the pull out date in 2011 will be BUSH'S FAULT as well. Simply freeking Amazing!!

As a Europeanborn during

As a Europeanborn during WWII I am heartened by all these great comments. I really had got the impression that Americans must be the most gullible people on earth with the least conscience and intelligence possible to retain the right to call oneself a human being. When my American relatives come to Europe they pose as Canadians so as not to get the full brunt of European derision. Sorry, if this sounds very harsh, but here in Europe everyone in the least bit interested beleived long ago that 9/11 was a put-up job to get at the Iraqi oil. The admin knew it was going to happen and dynamited the twin towers in advance, rather too low for the collapse at the base at the same instant the towers were hit high up, to be feasable. After all, oil was GWB's business and it was his sole aim to enrich himself, to hell with the people killed on the way. Thank God for Obama (even though I don't believe in God), he has my fullest compassion for the job he took on and I admire his courge no end. I pray for his success daily, hourly. I don't condemn and I also pray for ALL Americans, may there be many more with the same convictions voiced here and with the courage to express them and live them out.

Never forget that 9/11 was

Never forget that 9/11 was orchestrated and carried out by a shadowy cabal of neocon criminals. Worse, it has been covered up by a consortium of both political parties and the media.Until America faces this truth and brings the real perpetrators to justice, we don't have much hope of throwing off the fascist rulers.

Thank you, Marc, for the

Thank you, Marc, for the hard lessons; keep telling it. Keep showing it. It will not end otherwise.

Cheney and Gonzalez is

Cheney and Gonzalez is indicted in a Texas Court of Law, for abuse of prisoners Arraignment set for Cheney, Gonzales in Texas - Yahoo! News: http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20081120/ap_on_re_us/cheney_indicted

The Iraq invasion only seems

The Iraq invasion only seems a mistake because of the loss of American lives (the Iraqis, of course, being non-American and therefore expendable) and the exorbitant cost to the tax-payer (unimportant, of course, to the powers that be). In truth, for those who stood to gain from it - as is also the case with Afghanistan, Pakistan and one day Iran, it has been a thundering success! The Middle East remains disunited and riven by religious and tribal loyalties, which has always been the plan. The soft underbelly of Pakistan, the route to controlling China and encircling and eventually emasculating Russia lies exposed to the Imperial Legions America has thrown into Afghanistan. Iran is now encircled. The masses see only suffering and bankruptcy, while the elites, for whom such trifles have no meaning, are making a fortune. Wake up! This has and never will be about you.