Share

What Next for Guantanamo Bay?

by: Philippe Sands  |  The Guardian UK

photo
A Guantanamo detainee looks through his hands from his cell at the Guantanamo Bay military detention facility. His fate and that of the 249 other detainees will soon be in the hands of President-elect Barack Obama. (Photo: Brennan Linsley / AP)

    President Bush leaves the Obama administration with some difficult decisions, including what to do with present and future detainees.

    President Bush leaves the Obama administration with some difficult decisions: looking back, how to address a legacy of abuse, illegality and global disrepute? Looking forward, what to do with present and future detainees? Obama needs to say five things on day one, to America and to his global audience.

    First, he should state that he will not use the phrase "war on terror", words that tend to legitimise the struggle of those who seek to harm us.

    Second, he should announce that the US will, as a matter of legal obligation, no longer use torture or cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment, as defined by international law.

    Third, he should declare the closure of Guantanamo, with all detainees gone and the interrogation facility permanently shuttered by July 1 2009. Of the 250 or so detainees who currently remain, the great majority are not thought to pose any real threat to the US or anyone else. They should be returned to their home countries, with effective guarantees against ill-treatment.

    Fourth, he must address what will happen to the 50 or so detainees who will remain in the US, some of whom are now subject to proceedings before military commissions under the Military Commissions Act 2006. He should announce the immediate suspension of all such proceedings and the repeal of that Act, a stain on America's reputation for justice and the honour of its military. Any detainee accused of committing crimes against the US should be tried before courts established in accordance with article III of the US constitution or, as provided for in the Uniform Code of Military Justice, by courts martial or military commission.

    Fifth, he should announce that the US will honour and underscore its historic commitment to international efforts against impunity, so that past detainee abuses will not be forgotten. His administration should establish a comprehensive investigation of alleged post-9/11 detainee abuse, to be undertaken by an independent, expert commission, with a mandate to establish the facts as to how the administration embraced cruelty, and to make recommendations by the end of 2009.

    With these five steps, Obama can go far in restoring the global reputation of the US and its ability to lead and to inspire.

    ---------

    Philippe Sands QC is professor of law at University College London, a barrister at Matrix Chambers and author of Lawless World (2005) and Torture Team (2008).

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

And how about ceasing the

And how about ceasing the long standing Foreign Policy of "Divide, Exploit and Occupying other countries"

One thing left out: The

One thing left out: The United States should return the entire territory of Guantanamo Bay to the nation of Cuba, after cleaning it up.

Normalization of trade and

Normalization of trade and travel with Cuba needs to happen as well. If we can travel to China, we certainly should be able to travel to Cuba. Eisenhower established a People to People program as a legacy to promote interchange among ordinary people that might put brakes on posturing and promotion of hostilities by governments. In 2001, I traveled to China with the program, where I observed that health practices from around the world were being implemented as well as renewed interest in traditional Chinese medicine. Hard work and entrepreneurial endeavor seemed to be everywhere in China. I am not denying the government was suppressing some subcultures, but even governments want to eat and entertain themselves. Trying to suppress everybody has got to get tiresome. It is my understanding that out of necessity Cuba's medical programs have many low-tech treatments that work very well. Pent-up demand for exchanging insights could benefit the people of the U.S. and Cuba. Americans already go to Cuba legally and not, depending on what strings they know how to pull. We need to end such nonsense. I hope Obama acts quickly on this.

Send this to President-Elect

Send this to President-Elect Obama. I wish someone could explain to me WHY these things were allowed to happen in the first place, and even worse- why was it allowed to go on and on? I agree to- no more Imperialism that made oil more valuable than human blood. I disagree to returning a chunk of land on Cuba, which is the only outpost we have to protect us from our communist neighbors, along with their newly reformed friendship with Russia. And exactly what (besides nothing) do the health care programs of China and Cuba have to do with the housing of proclaimed terrorists and torturing innocents in a camp called Gitmo?

I think that this matter is

I think that this matter is somewhat complicated by the fact that some countries will not take back the prisoners and they may be in danger if returned. What about the 7 years that these young men have lost of their lives, specially if they were not guilty of anything but being on the wrong place at the wrong time. This is not as simple as closing Guantanamo. The base will likely remain open and the jail needs to close. There should be restitution for false imprisonment if deserved to cleanse the US from the taint of a very vicious deed.