Share

Bush's Farewell Hallelujah Chorus

by: Michael Winship, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
President George W. Bush at the unveiling of his official portrait in Philadelphia. In his "legacy" tour before leaving office, Bush is giving interview upon interview of his administration's "major accomplishments." (Photo: Reuters)

    With all the interviews President Bush has been giving out lately, you'd think he has a new movie coming out for Christmas.

    ABC, NBC, National Review, Middle East Broadcasting, the Real Clear Politics Web site - even a talk with The Washington Post's NASCAR expert. For a fellow who's sometimes gone for months without a press conference, suddenly, the president's a regular chatterbox, spreading the word in these final days that his eight years in office really, really weren't all that bad. Honest.

    Regrets, he's had a few. But only a few. Or so he told ABC's Charlie Gibson: "I think I was unprepared for war ... In other words, I didn't anticipate war. Presidents - one of the things about the modern presidency is that the unexpected will happen."

    But of course he anticipated the war. He and Cheney and the neo-con biker gang had been gunning for an invasion of Iraq long before 9/11. Not that Gibson followed up and asked about that.

    This is a president, you'll recall, who once said he couldn't think of any mistakes he's made. Instead, he regrets what he sees as the blunders of the intelligence community, not himself. "The biggest regret of all the presidency has to have been the intelligence failure in Iraq," he said to Gibson. "A lot of people put their reputations on the line and said the weapons of mass destruction is [sic] a reason to remove Saddam Hussein. It wasn't just people in my administration; a lot of members in Congress, prior to my arrival in Washington, DC, during the debate on Iraq, a lot of leaders of nations around the world were all looking at the same intelligence. And, you know, that's not a do-over, but I wish the intelligence had been different, I guess."

    Truth is, as far as intelligence goes, the president heard what people thought he wanted to hear, shaped it to his purpose, turned his agents loose to scatter rumors and hearsay on the Sunday talk shows, and bullied a frightened Congress into compliance. He stirred up fears of smoking guns and mushroom clouds where there were none.

    Nor was he ready to take the rap for the financial meltdown, even though he said he was sorry people were losing their jobs and savings. As he explained to ABC's Gibson, "You know, I'm the president during this period of time, but I think when the history of this period is written, people will realize a lot of the decisions that were made on Wall Street took place over a decade or so, before I arrived in president, during I arrived in president."

    Odd syntax aside, point taken. Many of the seeds of economic woe were planted by lax oversight and deregulation during Bill Clinton's watch (and Ronald Reagan's and that of the president's father). But whatever happened to, "The buck stops here?"

    This legacy tour - few dare call it victory loop - is all part of a strategy, The Washington Post reported, devised two months ago at a meeting in the White House, when White House counselor Ed Gillespie "began meeting with agency heads as part of an effort aimed at compiling the major accomplishments of the Bush administration."

    The Los Angeles Times got hold of two pages of positive talking points that have been sent out to officials so they can be included in speeches and interviews. According to the Times, the memo states that the president "'kept the American people safe' after the September 11 terrorist attacks, lifted the economy after 2001 through tax cuts, curbed AIDS in Africa and maintained 'the honor and the dignity of his office.'"

    Would that the mainstream media would open up the questioning to the rest of us. For one, Mr. President, did you value abject loyalty over know-how and wisdom? Mother Jones magazine reports that recently Republican Sen. George Voinovich asked the Government Accountability Office (GAO) for questions to ask Barack Obama's political nominees. He got back more than he bargained for - a 150-page list of issues left undealt with during the Bush years.

    Among the revelations within the GAO's report, according to the magazine's Jonathan Stein: "The Department of Homeland Security and Department of Agriculture have no plan to work together in the event of a food-borne disease outbreak or terrorist attack. The Department of Defense's security clearance process takes so long it jeopardizes classified information. The EPA's chemical risk assessment program is improperly influenced by private industry ...

    "Problems like the politicization of the Justice Department are not mentioned. But this report serves as a peephole into the myriad internal problems of the executive branch, depicting a federal bureaucracy that is rife with mismanagement, inefficiency, and faulty communication practices - all of this combining to jeopardize both the nation's health and security."

    No one has asked George Bush about this. Instead, the reporters granted the president's valedictory interviews have asked perfunctory softball questions about Iraq and the economy, then segued to inquiries about domestic life in the White House and what he'll do in Texas after January 20.

    For one, the man Newsweek once said was too busy making history to read it, is going to write some - he told National Review's Byron York and Rich Lowry that his interview with them was "jumping jacks for my own book that I'm going to be writing."

    Will it answer any of the tough questions? Perhaps. But almost certainly not the biggest one, from which he will divert, splintering off into a thousand digressions and self-deprecating anecdotes: Why?

------------    

    Michael Winship is senior writer of the weekly public affairs program "Bill Moyers Journal," which airs Friday nights on PBS. Check local airtimes or comment at The Moyers Blog at www.pbs.org/moyers.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Some of the Fascist cabal

Some of the Fascist cabal has been going around on the TV lately, doing their part as Bush apologists: William Kristol and Karl Rove. Seeing Bush lamely telling the story of how it was none of his fault isn't worth ten seconds of my viewing time! Bush is obviously a sociopath who only cares about himself. He's done as much as he could, along with Cheney, to raid the Treasury for his corporatist friends, the haves and have mores. I hope Obama, Pelosi, and Reid do not stand in the way of Congressmen like Kucinich and Waxman in having the whole Bushista Regime investigated, indicted, and eventually prosecuted and found guilty for all their crimes against the taxpaying American public which they ripped off, and against humanity in spreading more war and hate. I want to see these thugs having to attempt to flee America in their corporate jets to Paraguay, but like O.J. Simpson, getting caught in the chase!

Please, please, please don't

Please, please, please don't let this idiot build a "presidential library". It would be an affront to real presidents.

"...before I arrived in

"...before I arrived in president, during I arrived in president." "...but I wish the intelligence had been different, I guess." Yeah, Georgie, we wish YOUR intelligence had been different.

The real work is being done

The real work is being done behind the scenes. For a good take on this, a recent New Yorker article has this excellent quote: "What distinguishes this Administration in its final daysβ€”as in its earlier onesβ€”is the purity of its cynicism. " http://www.newyorker.com/talk/comment/2008/11/24/081124taco_talk_kolbert If you haven't read it, it's well worth it! Using rules to gut all kinds of protections, selling off federal lands to drilling and mining interests, equating birth control to abortion and allowing professionals not to provide it, every minute does harm. Then there's placing political appointees in permanent jobs. While Bush plays nice for the public, he is involved in doing his best to destroy what remains of our country.

I couldn't agree more with

I couldn't agree more with both posts. Bush won't be able to establish a Presidential Library once he "retires". This would require that he knows about or reads books, which he has already told us he doesn't have the time to do. As for the cabal that is leaving office along with Mr Bush, they should all be brought up on criminal charges as War Criminals as per the Geneva Conventions. To bring the world to he brink of worldwide conflagration so that Bush and his "oil buddies" can profit from the chaos that ensued was/is a perfect example of ...high crimes or misdemeanors..." as stated in our Constitution for the Impeachment of the President. If we allow this group to escape without some form of retribution, what is to stop future Chief Executives from doing similar or, heaven help us, worse! It's time that someone pays for their attempts at "stealing" our nation and squandering all of our previous efforts at International goodwill banked throughout the 20th century.

I agree with the

I agree with the commentators! This is nothing more than an attempt at the last minute to save face (his "legacy") for history while acting as a smokescreen so he can continue destroying the country secretly up till the minute he leaves office. I pity Obama for the job he has ahead of him once he walks through those once hallowed doors and discovers the mess inside. Sacked, pillaged and plundered by the neo-con Goths and Visigoths who've inhabited the White House for 8 years. I will take once exception to the author's points. We mustn't buy into the ploy of dismissing Bush merely for incompetence and idiocy! That he is, and more, but that's his perfect mask and "cover". He's just the empty-headed puppet of the jackals really in charge (his Pop, Cheney, PNAC--"deep government"). He's really the MOST SUCCESSFUL President in history ... at doing what he set out to do all along. Be the front man to cover up while his handlers plunder, pillage, steal and destroy!

Mysterious, there should be

Mysterious, there should be a Bush Admnistration library so that people can study the calumnus works of this cratered president. Never should it be called the George W. Bush library. Why?, because the Baghdad Library was unprotected and left to burn as the invasion wound down. But the oil ministry was protected. This was a tragic loss, akin to the burning of the Library of Alexandria. a place wheremuch of what was recorded of early civilization was housed. What an act of hypocracy - a George W. Bush Library.

I very much appreciated the

I very much appreciated the way this issue was discussed by Bill Moyers and one of his guests on the Journal last night (Friday 12 December). The idea is simple: the law has been broken, decimated, by Bush and any number of his top officials. Congress has reneged on its own constitutional responsibility, that of impeachment; by Bush's own public admissions, he has acted in contradiction of clearly-stated laws, the FISA act, for example, and thus despite the secrecy with which he has surrounded much of the doings of his administration, little digging would need to be done to bring charges of impeachment. Remember that Clinton's impeachment was because he lied to Congress, not because of what he lied about; the message was that breaking the law has serious consequences, for **anyone**. Moyer's guest was eloquent about the most critical issue in all of this, which is that, if no accountability is sought for the people whose leadership positions make them accountable by definition, then the idea of being a nation of laws, and not of men, is done for. Robert Mugabe, anyone?

The United States is

The United States is currently 53 trillion dollars in debt. thanks to the Bush Administration's corrupt leadership for the past eight years. Go to brasschecktv.com and click on the video The Future of the US economy to see a great video on pre-2008 election US economic data. Decide for youself, will the United States clean up its debt. deficit or will our children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren be paying the debt off for us, resulting in low standards of living for themselves and their families, (if they can afford families), for future generations.

Americans voted for G.W.Bush

Americans voted for G.W.Bush in 2004 after 4 years of fairly obvious lies from a bumbling stumbling possible sociopath !!! Americans should be ashamed of the Holocaust brought to Iraq over 25 years of subsequent US Administrations. The war on Islam is a war on 23% of the World's population -- probably started with the "creation" of Israel in 1948 and could end in WWIII with Iran & then Pakistan. Americans just don't know -- are not told -- are not interested -- they rely on supposedly patriotic leaders who are "controlled" by AIPAC and other lobbies. The Americans ,the British & the Australians get/got their blatant war propaganda from the Rupert Murdoch media empire & the rest is history !!!! All the American sorrow for their over 4,000 dead but nary a mention of the country they destroyed ,the over 1.2 Million Iraqi dead the over 4 Million displaced Iraqis ,the Depleted Uranium & Cluster bombs -- all this mayhem & killing all based on lies & deception. Americans are so dumb !!!! The hatred left towards the USA for all this will foster the terror -- will foster the "War" !!! Perhaps it will "protect Israel" but Israel has been the only Nuclear Super Power in the Middle East for years & that may be the cause of all this mayhem anyway !!!!

The interview with Charles

The interview with Charles Gibson was appalling on all counts. But I can't help citing the American electorate for putting these monsters into office. Twice. If the elections were "stolen," where were the pitchforks and the torches? Why didn't we fight in order to keep this administration from turning us into the reviled nation that we have become? For all the blame that I lay at the feet of George W. Bush, I lay it in equal amounts at the feet of the nation that elected him and that let him get away with what he did. I believe that the rest of the world may feel the same. We didn't do anything about it, and we might have. Look at us now, and wonder what we might have become had we challenged our Great Mistake .

The lack of pitchforks was

The lack of pitchforks was because the general public had no idea that the Bush Admin would be nearly as disastrous as it proved to be. Most people were living high on the times of an easy economy and they all thought that good times were ahead no matter who "won" the election of 2000. The 2004 election was also a sham, but there were no pitchforks because of 9/11 and the fact that the conventional wisdom believed that W had actually won his first election since he ran for governor. The majority of the people had never heard of Diebold and whatnot and they believed that their election system was still functioning. Something funny about Diebold, try hacking their machine to fix an election ~ its easy, untraceable, and you won't get punished anyway, provided you are fixing it FOR the republicans; try hacking one of their (Diebold's) ATM machines ~ probably completely impossible, you'll get caught and shot by a security guard or the police and you will go to prison whether you're a republican or not. It isn't that Diebold is incompetent, it's that they purposely designed an easily hackable voting machine so that they could fix elections.

As for George Bush, good

As for George Bush, good riddance of bad rubbish. But as for too many Americans--they would vote for the Devil if he were of their party or they are so ignorant of history and what's going on in the world, they don't have sense enough to vote for a decent human being--provided the political machine would let a decent human being run for president in the first place. We'll be paying for this 8-year mistake for generations to come.

I am the "anonymous" who

I am the "anonymous" who posted earlier (18:56). The argument there was that accountability for the vast array of crimes committed by this administration is not only justified but necessary, lest we sacrifice the notion of equality under the law that is foundational to all else that a democracy is and represents. This is NOT a partisan argument, and all care must be taken to clarify and reiterate that fact. Several posters to this thread have mentioned the American public's stupidity/ignorance as the reason Bush served not one but TWO terms, and I agree. But it doesn't take a lot of looking and listening to recognize that there were a lot of people making similar arguments from very early in the administration -- before 9/11 -- about secrecy, about the denial of public access to information we, the taxpayers, had asked to have done via our elected officials, etc. Remember the concern over Cheney's energy panel? A lot of us have been listening -- and talking -- since early on; a lot of us were out demonstrating against the Iraq invasion during the several months of the buildup, while we were being told that war was a last resort. A lot of us. But one thing we need to know is that partisanship, of the ideological stripe that it has become, is its own sort of blindness, a self-sought ignorance. The problem isn't whether the Democrats or the Republicans have done the greater damage; the problem is that in either case we the people have not been minding our employees. Just because some in the last gang got away, and some in the gang before that (Iran-Contra has a special place in my heart), doesn't mean that we should leave the door open for the ones we can catch, starting now. Dr. F.

People living outside the

People living outside the heart of the North American empire, often forgive the North American people because they believe we are basically good, but are too deluded by our government to realize what it is doing in the rest of the world. Although it's true that we're largely deluded, it's no excuse. In reality, we in North America are too lazy and comfortable to inform ourselves of your plight. We'd rather sit fat and happy in our bloated SUVs, BBQing our factory-fed pigs, and watching a bunch of whinny millionaires play ball on our wall-to-wall flat screens. If we were really a good people, it would show more often.

How do you build a

How do you build a presidential library for a president who can barely read? Maybe a racetrack in his honor might be appropriate... somewhere far away from here.

Don't listen to him or look

Don't listen to him or look at pictures of him.

Mr. Obama, our

Mr. Obama, our President-elect, has done more for our nation in these few weeks since his election than current President did during his eight years in office. Bush destroyed our country and I hope that if the courts do not have the chance to have a say on his misdeed, that history will judge him.

INTELLIGENCE DOES NOT

INTELLIGENCE DOES NOT FAI[LURE]. PresBush is trying to redefine 'bad or faulty intelligence' does not exist: it is not ANY kind of 'intelligence' but misinformation, so as to relieve himself of his responsibility.Plame/Wilson information was 'good intelligence' and you saw what happened to it and them!

Actually, Bush was not

Actually, Bush was not correctly elected. In 2000, Al Gore won Florida. If the US Supreme Court had not stopped the recount in FL, we would have had President Al Gore. (Sigh.) In 2004, Kenneth Blackwell stole Ohio for Bush. He put plenty of voting machines in Republican precincts, but few voting machines is Democratic-leaning precincts. He prohibited the public from witnessing the recount of the vote. Put it all together and John Kerry should have won Ohio and the presidency.

The crimes that George Bush

The crimes that George Bush and his cronies have committed would fill a book. But has Congress acted to take back any of the dictatorial powers they've given to the President? No. Has Congress taken the initiative to expel this tyrant from office? No, because, as in the case of Bill Clinton (who stayed in office because Democrats in Congress allowed it) the Republicans in Congress wouldn't vote to toss George Bush and Dick Cheney out on their ears. There has been an impeachment cry for the past 4 years, but obviously Congress isn't listening and just plain doesn't care. Nobody is going to be able to fix the mess this regime is leaving behind.

Has the world not had enough

Has the world not had enough of this murderous and destructive administration?? The last thing anyone needs is a presidential library to 'commemorate' the deeds of the most corrupt and dangerous presidency in American history. Bush and his gang ought to be cooling their heels in jail while awaiting trial for their horrific crimes against humanity. The fact that they are not serves to illistrate to the rest of the world the absolute hypocrisy of the international courts and the U.S. when it comes to charging and prosecuting American leaders so obviously guilty of breaking international law.

we will all celebrate the

we will all celebrate the exit of this completely evil administration.

and yet, we're going to

and yet, we're going to take care of this VILE, INCOMPETENT OAF, who destroyed his own country, for the rest of his life, when he should be in prison for the rest of his life.