Share

The True Meaning of the Holiday Season

by: Greta Christina   |  Greta Christina's Blog

photo
Children dressed as Santa in Chandigarh, India. (Photo: Reuters)

    So what does Christmas really mean?

    Among all the traditions of the holiday season, one that's becoming increasingly familiar is the War on the Supposed War On Christmas. In this tradition -- one that dates back to the sweet olden days of overt anti-Semitism -- the Christian Right foams at the mouth about the fact that not everyone has the same meaning of Christmas that they do, and works themselves into a dither about things like store clerks politely recognizing that not everyone is a Christian by saying "Happy Holidays" instead of "Merry Christmas." Because in the mind of the Christian Right, it somehow disrespects their faith and impinges on their religious freedom to share a country with people who feel and act differently than they do.

    Okay. Insert rant here about how the Christian Right isn't actually interested in religious freedom and respect for their faith. They're trying to establish a theocracy. They don't care about religious and cultural plurality. They don't care about the fact that winter holidays mean different things to different people, and that different people celebrate different ones and in different ways. They don't care about the fact that not everyone in the country is Christian, and that lots of people who do call themselves Christian are actually pretty secular in both their everyday life and their celebration of the winter holidays.

    No, scratch that. They do care about it. They think it's bad.

    But that's not actually what I want to talk about today.

    In the face of Bill O'Reilly and company screaming hatefully about the true meaning of Christmas, I want to talk -- in true grade-school essay form -- about what Christmas means to me.

    Because I actually like Christmas.

    Christmas; Solstice; Hanukkah; Kwanzaa; Festivus; "the holidays"; whatever. I don't have a strong attachment to any particular name or date or occasion. Any mid-winter holiday around the end of December will do. Lately I've been calling it either "the holidays" or "Santamas" (in honor of what Bart Simpson has described as the true meaning of the holiday: the birth of Santa). I was brought up culturally Christian, though, with Christmas trees and Santa and all that, and I do tend to refer to it as Christmas at least some of the time.

    And I love it. I always have. I know it's fashionable to hate it, and I get why people get annoyed by it -- but I don't. I love it. It's one of my favorite times of the year.

    And here's what it means to me.

    I think that holidays tend to rise up naturally out of the rhythms and seasons of a particular geographical area. And in parts of the world where winter is a big nasty deal, I think it's almost inevitable that a winter holiday, at right around the darkest, shortest day of the year, is going to become the biggest holiday in the culture.

    It's been noted many times, for instance, that Hanukkah is far from the most important holiday in the Jewish religious calendar. What's less well known is that Christmas isn't the most important holiday in the Christian calendar, either. Christmas is pretty much a pagan midwinter holiday shoehorned into the Christian religious calendar for convenience. From a strictly religious standpoint, Easter is a much bigger ticket. (Getting born? Big whoop. Everybody gets born. Dying on the cross as a sacrifice for our sins, and getting resurrected three days later because he's God? Now that's what they're talking about.)

    And yet -- in parts of the world where winter is a big nasty deal -- Christmas has almost entirely eclipsed Easter, for all but the most devout. Christmas gets an entire month of frenzied eating and drinking and shopping and traveling and party-going and family drama. Easter gets -- maybe -- a nice dinner or brunch, plus for kids it acts as a sort of secondary candy- frenzy holiday to Halloween. If the holidays were really about Jesus, we'd be having a nice quiet dinner with friends and family in late December, maybe with a hunt for hidden chocolate Santas for the kiddies ... and a massive social and economic whirl in March or April. As it's commonly celebrated -- at least in the U.S. -- the meaning of Christmas is only partly about the Christian religion. And a pretty minimal part at that.

    So what is the meaning of Christmas? Solstice? Santamas? The holidays? Etc.?

    It's cold. It's dark. The days are short, and the nights are long. Life is harder than usual right now, and we're cooped up in close quarters more than any other time of the year.

    So let's celebrate.

    Let's sing. Let's decorate. Let's eat and drink. Let's light candles and put up electric lights. Let's have parties. Let's visit our families and our friends. Let's give each other presents. Let's spend time together that's specifically devoted to enjoying each other's company, and take part in activities -- like gift- giving and parties and big group dinners -- that strengthen social bonds.

    Let's remind ourselves that life is worth living, and that the cold and dark won't be here forever. Let's remind ourselves that we care about each other, and remind ourselves of why.

    That's what this holiday means to me.

    Happy holidays, everybody!

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

I am still having a hard

I am still having a hard time figuring out what Santa has to do with Christianity anyway. If anything, Christmas seems to be a deeply rooted pagan religious holiday glossed over by Christianity. Jesus was born in the spring, people, we know this, already...

Ummm, well, yeah, and

Ummm, well, yeah, and except. Gaza, Iraq, Afghanistan. Rendition, detention, torture. Bush, Blair, Howard, and Sharon the carrot. Livni, Bibi, Abbas the fraud. Nancy Pelosi, corruption, and torture AGAIN! The pretense of "hope", the vilification of "hope", and hope as the grand charade. Rahm Emanuel, Oliver Cromwell, and Spunky the Potomac leach. A F of Oh Well, gee we owe a lot of money. And Christmas is the season of death. Global warming as pandering hoax and the climate is really in comprehensive collapse. Wishing you well and bailouts are painful as hell and, would it be morally criminal to restore a 57 Chevy? You know, in today's post gasoline powered 9/11 early twenty first century conundrum of a 'war-of-terror' world.

Let the Xtians, Right or

Let the Xtians, Right or Left, try living up to their own BS, for a change.

The irony about those

The irony about those ranting that stores must have "Christmas Sales" not "Holiday Sales" is that they are actually insisting that Christ's name be used to hawk merchandise. Given Jesus' clear stand regarding the mixing of commerce and religious observation, this stand seems disrespectful, at best. Pious Christians SHOULD be demanding that the word "Christmas" NEVER be used in stores. Otherwise, how does "Christmas Sale" differ in substance from "Jesus sez: Check Out These Lo-Lo Prices?" Better religion through blasphemy--great thinking.

If I recall correctly, the

If I recall correctly, the evergreen tree is the symbol of the Norse God Baldur's death and rebirth. Santa was tacked on later - something about a guy who stuck small gifts into the shoes / socks hung out before the fire to dry until the commercial interests took the idea and ran with it. Happy NonDenominational Gift Day!

I like Christmas as well. It

I like Christmas as well. It does not make a whit of difference when Jesus was born during a calendar year, in my opinion. "Experts" seem to think that He was born in the spring but that is not relevant. And I think it is in important that we celebrate Jesus' birth. Without His birth there would be no resurrection. Therefore, His birth is just as important as His resurrection. However, I too believe that we go overboard...a lot. I would like to see Christmas a holiday similar to Thanksgiving ...people get together, eat, enjoy one another's company, hopefully, and go home. We set up impossible expectations for Christmas...for the celebration itself as well as for gift-giving. A token gift would be acceptable to represent the magi's gifts. I truly do not think that Jesus would be too thrilled with the way we have secularized and merchandised His coming to the earth. And I think He would be aghast at people's going into debt in order to do so. JOY CAME DOWN at Christmas. Let us celebrate His coming with Joy and prayer...and hang onto that Joy and the prayers the rest of the year. Carol

Lately I've been calling the

Lately I've been calling the holiday season "Christmess". Big irony to those christian-right-nut-jobs: Santa Claus is a "saint" meaning he is a holy figure from their own religion. They rebel against him because he's not the "reason for the season" but they're kidding themselves because he is Saint Nicholas and that makes him a religious figure.

Christmas was the

Christmas was the bastardization of pagan spirituality. It was the attempt of the church to woo people into its sphere of influence. The pagan or wicca spiritualities were very strong among the peasants. So the 2prong attack included killing 2-3 million woman as witches and then coopting the pagan symbols in the church. The tree is only one of the symbols they grabbed. The season is the soltice. It is the observance of the shift in the earth's energies. I agree with the poster above that winter in the northern climates demands some kind of celebration to get us throught cold and dark season, the season of death and sleep. Spring is the season of renewal and birth and the chuch, again, used the Spring equinox celebrations and by claiming it for christ's resurrection.

http://video.google.com/video

http://video.google.com/videosearch?q=Zeitgeist&emb=0#q=Zeitgeist&emb=0&start=40

I once spoke with a young

I once spoke with a young Hollywood wanna-be screenwriter who was doing a story about Santa Claus as a demon. He told me that, in his research, the farther back in history he'd searched, the more sinister Santa had become...and when you're stuck in the gridlocked undergound parking structure of a giant mall on Christmas Eve, you can feel the evil vibes churning in your gut. Know that you are being sorely tested.

Every day is a good day to

Every day is a good day to open your heart to family, friends and strangers. At the darkest time of year-and the coldest where I live- why not have a universal tradition of gathering of love and generosity in our so difficult world. Saint Nicholas was a rich man who happily spent his life doing for others and consequently died w/nothing. My favorite material gifts are those I give-sometimes anonymously. The best gifts to receive are from anothers heart. I like Christmas, too. I like Thanksgiving, I like anything that I can say thank you for the opportunity to participate in the best of living.

"In parts of the world where

"In parts of the world where winter is a big nasty deal, Christmas has almost eclipsed Easter..." I'm sorry, but no. I think you'll find that the Russian Orthodox Church makes much more fuss over Easter, while barely noticing Christmas (children get presents on Jan. 6, the Feast of the Epiphany, also known as "Little Christmas"). That said, I think partying in the dark cold time is a swell idea, for any reason. Keep Saturn in Saturnalia!

the problem with the whole

the problem with the whole christmas thing is that in many stores the employees are not allowed to say "merry christmas" when someone says it to them. i thought this website was supposed to be for freedom rather than censorship. and this isn't even censorship in media, its censorship in everyday life. actual human being to human being censorship. be careful, the thought police are at hand, and they are in the guise of self righteous morons who pretend to be for freedom. and by the way, real christians, meaning not catholic, don't worship any saints, so saint nicholas is nothing to us but a pretend character taken from paganism

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_Nicholas

Yea, whatever. Jesus would

Yea, whatever. Jesus would be really puzzled by all the Christmas hoop-la. Call me a reformed evangelical and one who feels Christmas should be real to those who honestly see it as a real festival of Jesus' birth. But do I give a rip whether the check-out person at Wal-Mart says "Merry Christmas" versus "Happy Holidays"--oh please. Real faith doesn't measure itself by what mass consumer culture counts as authentic. If that was the case then I'd be checking on what Brittany Spears says about about theology. I'm glad you celebrate the holiday the way you do. Yea, there's a lot of spurious controversy as to how Christmas got its heritage. To those who follow Jesus and his way of life, it's all secondary. He's no less real to us if someone says Merry Christmas than if one says "Happy Hannukah". Enjoy the day off if your fortunate enough not to work on Christmas.

The writer states that

The writer states that "Getting born? Big whoop. Everybody gets born. " Only a confused or paper Christian, not a true believer, would say that. George Washington is the most important person in the history of USA and his birthday on February 18 is celebrated, by law it's a federal holiday. Because of George Washington 4th of July is the most important holiday in USA . For Christians of the world this is in minute comparison to Christmas when Jesus our Savior was born and Easter when he died for all of us on the Cross. If there is no Jesus (Christ), there is no Christmas and no Easter. Therefore, Christmas is a big deal for all Christians.

We celebrate Christmas and

We celebrate Christmas and Hanukkah in my family and I was taught from childhood to recognize and respect the practices of others. It is not difficult for me to do as an adult, and I now endeavor to teach the same as a parent. So while it's fun to exchange Merry Christmases with others, within a certain context, I still do not understand why anyone would have so much trouble saying Happy Holidays, instead, and especially with strangers whose backgrounds they are not familiar with. We now have Christmas, Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, with both religious and cultural/secular celebrations, people who are agnostic or atheists, humanists, wiccans, and Muslim Americans on pilgrimage to Mecca right now. And that's not even all. Plus, increasingly, families are multi-faith, multi-ethnic, multi-beliefs and practices. Yet when I was a child, and the world was not nearly as culturally complex, it was common to hear people say, "Merry Christmas AND Happy Hanukkah" or "season's greetings" or "happy holidays" or the generic "peace one earth" wishes, without a second thought about the giving consideration. So now, many many years later, when I hear "Merry Christmas" with all this silly debate -- it just sounds inconsiderate and immature. And like a giant unrealistic step backwards for our society. So, happy holidays, people, whatever your pleasure. and a little something I hope all can enjoy -- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Us-TVg40ExM

"So while it's fun to

"So while it's fun to exchange Merry Christmases with others, within a certain context, I still do not understand why anyone would have so much trouble saying Happy Holidays, instead, and especially with strangers whose backgrounds they are not familiar with." That is, it seems -- with all the religion competition -- more a deliberate slight, instead of a warm greeting of the heart. As it should, instead, at this of year. Peace.

Christmas story mocks

Christmas story mocks Roman military. 1. Luke's account is a Christian declaration of treason. A Roman coin, underneath the image of Caesar, said, "Savior of the World." For Christians to claim this title for Christ meant they denied it of Caesar and committed treason, punishable by death. 2. Due to the tax decree, Mary and Joseph became homeless refugees (think Iraqis or Afghanis). 3. An angel said, "I proclaim to you good news. " Roman evangelions routinely brought good news of a military victory. Luke is mocking Rome 4. And suddenly there was a host of angels." "Host" was a Roman military term for a formal military guard that might accompany an emperor. Again, Luke is mocking Rome. 5. Instead of court officials and the socially powerful hearing the good news, it is shepherds (think undocumented migrant farmers.) 6. Before Jesus is born, Mary says, "He has thrown down rulers from their thrones but lifted up the lowly. The hungry he has filled with good things, but the rich he has sent away empty." Imagine if our culture understood the greeting of "Merry Christmas" to mean, "I condemn our reliance on military might and domination of others."

"How does 'Christmas Sale'

"How does 'Christmas Sale' differ from 'Jesus sez: check out these lo-lo prices'." BWAHAHAHA! I almost fell on the cat laughing. That should be a sig file. The winter solstice holiday has been celebrated with fire and food ever since humans got around to figuring out that summer and winter alternated, and that it would get warm again when the sun started moving back up the sky. Even if there ever were such a person as Jesus, which has never been proven, there certainly is no date attached, and the festival of "Christ's mass," which wasn't even established until centuries later, had no set date. Easter, by the way, is also a Pagan holiday co-opted by the priests in their bid for secular power. Eostre, the goddess of life and fertility, was celebrated by planting crops (and a few other things), which is why "Easter" is also associated with eggs and rabbits. The myth of resurrection was tacked on to the first appearance of new crops. The winter solstice became a shopping holiday with the advent of end-of-the-year sales figures. Look for the first week of April to be declared a tax write-off holiday.

Back in better economic

Back in better economic times, we used to have a huge party on the Solstice. No gifts, a potluck, no expectations, and a clear understanding that this was a heathen holiday, and about getting together with friends to celebrate making it halfway through the winter without dying. We always made it clear: "It's dark. It's cold. We're all still alive. Come party 'til dawn." Damn, I miss it, and hope to re-start the event if we ever get a better living space. That Solstice party was my favorite memory of "Christmas"-time, ever. BTW, to the Christian, or should I say CHRISTIAN? -writer that referred to Catholics as not being true Christians, I have an observation to make. Most all of the Catholics that I have ever met have figured out that Biblical thing about "Judge not lest ye be judged." -But apparently, you can see into their souls better than your God can, so why wait for Him to judge them? I commend you on your new super-powers.