Share

Bob Herbert | Climbing Down the Ladder

by: Bob Herbert  |  The New York Times

photo
Older Americans have been hard hit by the mortgage crisis. When foreclosure strikes, many have no place to go and are left to live in their cars or on the street. (Photo: NMA)

    I asked Kim Richardson, who is 59 and lives in a modest ranch house in Rocky Mount, N.C., what she would do if a hearing next month goes against her and she loses her home to foreclosure.

    After a long pause, she said, in a voice faint from worry, “I don’t know. I’ll be out on the street, I guess. I don’t have anywhere to go.”

    Ms. Richardson, who lives on a pair of monthly disability checks, lies awake night after night, unable to fend off the frightening homeless scenarios that dominate her thoughts. “I never believed that anything like this could ever, ever happen to me,” she said.

    If you believe Ms. Richardson’s account, and I do, she was fast-talked into a mortgage that would have been impossible to pay off with her fixed income. Foreclosure would have seemed inevitable. But Ms. Richardson and her current lawyer, Carlene McNulty of Raleigh, N.C., said the figures that would have made it obvious to Ms. Richardson that she couldn’t afford the mortgage were deliberately concealed.

    While the news media have been focusing on the banks, brokerage houses and mega-millionaires being buffeted by the ill winds of the financial crisis, the millions of lower- and middle-income Americans sinking toward the protracted hell of destitution are getting very little attention.

    Older Americans are taking a particularly wicked hit. Analysts at AARP have found that “Americans age 50 and over represent about 28 percent of all delinquencies and foreclosures in the current crisis.”

    Losing a home to foreclosure is a disaster for anyone. It’s a catastrophe for older people. The AARP Public Policy Institute, in a recent report, poignantly explained: “For Americans age 50 and over, losing a house represents a loss from which there is limited time to recover, and for some, a recovery may be impossible given their age and limited incomes.”

    When Ms. Richardson bought her house in December 2005, she tried to make it clear that she could not afford monthly payments much higher than $500. Fine, she was told. She closed the deal with the understanding that she had a fixed-rate mortgage with monthly payments of $537. Prudent and skeptical, she tried to find out if there were any economic bombs hidden in the confusing mass of paperwork that she was confronted with.

    “I had all these stacks of papers at the closing,” she told me, “and they were just passing papers back and forth to me, back and forth, telling me to sign. And I kept saying, ‘Wait a minute. Wait a minute.’ ”

    She was assured that nothing untoward was going on.

    Ms. Richardson did not have a fixed-rate mortgage. Her monthly payment rose, and rose again, eventually passing $800, which she could not pay. There was also a balloon payment provision hidden in the welter of documents, along with other obligations that would not emerge until Ms. Richardson was waist-high in economic quicksand.

    Ms. McNulty, the lawyer, is trying to forestall the foreclosure, while at the same time trying to locate those who, in her view, defrauded her client. Her attempt to hold anyone accountable has been maddeningly difficult. As she explained, the original deal “was securitized into one of these now infamous trusts.”

    The distress calls from despondent men and women who believed until very recently that they were living the American dream are coming from all over the country. Tova Navarra of Atlantic Highlands, N.J., was waylaid by illness. “I will end up bankrupt, disabled and bereft of a career,” she told me. “I’m wondering if this will become a bankrupt society.”

    After a series of medical setbacks forced her to stop working, Ms. Navarra, 60, watched her standard of living deteriorate step by agonizing step to the point where she was forced to leave her condominium and move into a senior citizens’ residence that she currently cannot afford. The condo is in foreclosure, and she is staring at a future with no upside.

    “The first time you realize that you can’t pay the mortgage — that’s the beginning of a very keen panic,” said Ms. Navarra. “The medical bills pile up and that’s when people start deliberately skipping doses to try to make the medicine stretch out a little more.

    “You find yourself gradually climbing down the economic ladder, and you start thinking, ‘How am I going to survive, and where am I going to go?’ I said to myself, ‘Oh, my God. I’m going to end up sleeping in my car.’ ”

    Real people. Real suffering. We may be fascinated by Wall Street, and bogus yarns like Joe the Plumber’s. But the real story in this country right now is the increasingly dire plight of those heading toward the bottom of that ladder that Ms. Navarra was talking about.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Terrific article by Mr.

Terrific article by Mr. Herbert. There must be a special place in hell reserved for those who, deliberately, have cheated and defrauded senior citizens and the less fortunate among us in the wealthiest country on earth.

One cannot but wonder: Is

One cannot but wonder: Is there now in this country ECONOMIC GENOCIDE? By removing safety nets, poor and middle-class people are falling down to the ground, and the impact is killing, first their spirits and soon after, their bodies. Katrina eviscerated the poorer population of New Orleans, so many abandoned to die in the floods: 3 years later it is abundantly clear that this administration knows that by doing nothing, eventually the rest of the "problem" will actually die off. I call it genocide. Failing to protect citizens' health, as evey other industrialized nation has done, and many struggling nations are trying to do, even children (cutting SCHIP) I call genocide. Squeezing the elders via Medicare cuts and changes, attempting to "fix" social security-it ain't broken-cutting housing programs, etc. I do not term euthanasia. I call it genocide. Oh, this WAS a rich county once. Now it isn't the wealth has been funneled into the accounts of a very few (1%) of the population. 99% can share what is left.

A special place in hell for

A special place in hell for those who defrauded the poor -- perhaps -- but why not a regular place in a regular jail? People serve years for much lesser crimes. By leaving the subprime clan alone, we condone their crime. Their bank accoounts should be confiscated and money used to lessen the burden on their victims. The clan itself should be locked up!

A banker told me that many

A banker told me that many of these subprime loans were transacted in such a way that the paperwork is no longer available to the company that winds up suing people. Therefore, it cannot be a holder in due course. Already there have been some rulings against lenders, but we never hear about these.

Combine this heartbreaking

Combine this heartbreaking account with the news that Wall Street is giving out 70 billion in discretionary bonuses and I just have to wonder how some people sleep at night. But as Linda Chavez enthusiastically said last night to Bill Moyers, "in capitalism there are winners and there are losers". So goes the game, I guess they tell themselves when their consciences start to nauseate them.

For years, the Religious

For years, the Religious Fundamentalists and Right Wingers have carried on about sexual "sins" and sneered at the sins of our economic system. They call themselves Christian but their economic policies belie that. Jesus Christ, as shown in the Gospels, sided with the poor against the rich -- but American Fundamentalists have taken the Protestant Ethic to the extreme and turned money into the American universal whitewash. The only thing to feel guilty about is not being rich. The poor are vilified, both openly, as in the present GOP talking points about "people taking on mortgages they can't afford" being responsible for the current economic meltdown, and snidely, by claiming that anyone who wants to be rich in this country can do so and if one is not rich, it is because one doesn't deserve it! Now the Wall Street Bankers are getting ready to walk off with 10% of the committed federal bailout packages to be given in their end-of-year bonuses! The hotshot mortgage brokers who sold and then bundled these mortgages and the eager investment bankers who sold them to investors without revealing their inherent risk, walk away scot-free. McCain says straightening out our inequitable tax system is "class warfare." If it is, it is a war McCain and his fellow conservatives helped start by embracing 19th century social and political myths and foisting them on the electorate. It is depressing. I hope we can all hold on. But most of all, I hope there is some justice for the crooks who precipitated this.

While my heart bleeds for

While my heart bleeds for these folks, most are getting exactly what they asked for. For over 40 years the ignorance of the American people has allowed the greatest transfer of wealth out of the hands of the payroll class into the hands of the asset class in the history of man. It began with Regan’s trickle down economics and is now ending with the collapse of the US housing bubble. Like Bob once said on Bill Moyer "the class war is over and we lost". So when you go to cast your ballot this year and you vote against your own self interest because your candidate tells you the other guy will take away your guns or not let you kid say a prayer in his classroom, or he’s not like us, know that you are as much to blame for allowing this to have happened as the scumbag who took your money. Unfortunately you are probably still to ignorant to get it. Want a clue; go to Utube and check out George Carlins skit on “Who Owns America”. And when you finally figure out what he’s saying check out the movie called the Money Masters. Now go say a prayer your going to need it.

Sorry but this is just too

Sorry but this is just too full of holes to believe,why would a woman age 59 on disability with enough mental prowess to know her fiscal limitations before hand even consider trying to buy a home that late in life AND not go through the same government agencies from which she receives disability!? Besides the lawyer says ARM and Balloon payments were deliberately concealed and regardless of whether she can afford them or not fraud nullifies the contract even if the crooked asses that drew it up included a non-disclosure clause or not AND any financial entity that bought this mortgage knew that so every time that original contract was resold without question this lady was handed the full cost of the property plus penalties and interest all that lawyer has to do is take the original contract into any criminal court and demand remedy

I think it's a sham this

I think it's a sham this happen all-at-once! Tell me those in the know—the masters of the universe didn't see this coming! Was a bill passed a couple years ago that made bankruptcy much harder to do if at all? So wasn't the majority of this country's top leadership complacent even then—as they are now? When ANY bill is "rushed," it's a hoodwink. This whole crisis crap did NOT just happen. It's been seen coming for a long time. And if that is the case, was it planned? a quiet conspiracy? If so, what is the objective? Who's to benefit? If not, then there are many top leaders who failed to warn and protect their constituents from a foreboding danger.

What about the real estate

What about the real estate agents? As BH says, we're hearing lots about the banks, brokerage houses and mega-millionaires who are so afflicted with Greed-aholism that stealing enough for 10 lifetimes still isn't enough, but we hear nothing about the front-line money-monger soldiers responsible for finding the "marks" for the rest of the predator class to feed on. And, a note to those who believe the "people" are getting what they asked for and/or deserve: would you say the same thing to the 30,000 who died because they believed Vioxx was helping them? Should they have conducted their own medical research, too?

These are the same people

These are the same people who voted against their economic interests over and over - what did they expect? The fact is, this country should overwhemlingly be voting for Obama but look at the polls. They're still getting over on other issues like "anti-socialism"....but we have it for the rich so apparently that's okay. They will die in their cars supporting this dreck and guns and religion......but bankrupted by their "leaders" and inane economic policies.

Not enough attention is

Not enough attention is given to the elderly and the poor who are suffering in America. Ride into Los Angeles on the light rail and see all the shanty towns under the bridges. Visit Washington and see people eating out of garbage cans. The homeless are growing at an astounding rate. I'm ashamed of my country.

This gets to the nub of the

This gets to the nub of the scam pulled on middle class americans by the crooks in the congress and on wall street.