Share

Beyond the Conventions

by: Norman Solomon, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Marti Russel shines a mirrored wall on the floor of the Republican National Convention in St. Paul, Minnesota. (Photo: Charlie Neibergall / AP)

    With varying degrees of confidence or even complacency, many people have assumed the jig is almost up for the horrendous political era that began when George W. Bush became president. Always dubious, the assumption is now on very shaky ground.

    The Bush-Cheney regime may be on its last legs, but a new incarnation of right-wing populism is shadowing the near horizon.

    Much as modern capitalism is always driven to promote new products in the marketplace, the corporate-fundamentalist partnership must reinvent and remarket itself. We're now seeing the rollout of a hybrid product under the McCain-Palin brand.

    After watching Sarah Palin's acceptance speech and the laudatory responses from many TV journalists, I remembered wandering around the floor of the Democratic convention in Denver. At the base, the two major parties are even more different than the speeches are apt to indicate.

    Under the roof of the Democratic Party, notwithstanding its shades of corporatism and militarism and numerous other grave faults, there's a lot of longstanding and ongoing involvement from key progressive constituencies - including labor unions, African-Americans, gay rights activists, human rights defenders, environmentalists, fair-trade advocates, health-care-for-all organizers, feminists, and on and on.

    In contrast, the Republican Party is a political institution that views all such constituencies and activists (including the new target of GOP derision, "community organizers") as enemies to be smothered and crushed. The party's latest "populist" packaging is another wrinkle in a timeworn pattern; the most avid political servants of corporate elites are eager to keep generating the anti-elites rhetoric and imagery of down-home regular folks.

    At the 2008 Democratic National Convention, some of the speeches ran counter to basic progressive tenets of peace and social justice. But none came close to the zeal for social Darwinism, jingoism and militarism routinely spewing from the Republican convention's podium.

    In ways too numerous to count and in realms too profound to truly evoke, this decade has grimly underscored that - notwithstanding theoretical claims to the contrary - it matters greatly who is president. From the Supreme Court to thousands of subcabinet positions to executive orders to a vast array of foreign-policy decisions including the potential use of nuclear weapons, the president is able to wield state power with consequences huge enough to be unfathomable.

    A popular strand of analysis on the left has downplayed the importance of the president. The story goes that corporate forces rule, and the person in the Oval Office is little more than a figurehead for those rulers. There's some validity to that assessment, but in the face of experience it has tended to calcify into a form of denial.

    With right-wing Republicans running the White House for 20 of the last 28 years, maybe the downplaying of the importance of the presidency has become a kind of coping mechanism for some progressives. Accustomed to a status quo that grows increasingly dire, we've settled into an uncomfortable "comfort zone" as familiar as it is macabre. At the same time, the cascading effects of right-wing control over most of the federal government have been cumulative and devastating.

    Of course, progressives should always keep organizing, educating, protesting and agitating. But the potential for achieving progressive changes in government policies is severely limited while the right wing is entrenched in the White House. The changes we need can only be propelled from the grassroots, but the possibilities are badly circumscribed when the far right maintains a grip on state power.

    After the election in early November, it'll be President McCain or President Obama.

    We'll never pass this way again.

    --------

    Norman Solomon, a national co-chair of the Healthcare NOT Warfare campaign, is the author of "War Made Easy: How Presidents and Pundits Keep Spinning Us to Death." A documentary film of the same name, based on the book, has been released on home video. For information, go to: www.normansolomon.com.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

I could not agree more. The

I could not agree more. The Democratic Party isn't perfect and there definitely are factions that are not progressive at all, but there is a tremendous amount of progressivism in the party, especially under Obama. More importantly, Obama will be forced to cave under the pressure of the progressive movement that got him there. A President McCain will know full well that progressives did not vote for him and all the marches, rallies, protests and petitions in the world won't stop him from anything.

Right on, right on! So many

Right on, right on! So many progressives fall into that trap - "it doesn't matter." But as Solomon argues so well, it does. And yes, we have to keep working, no matter who's in office, for real change.

I Think Obama is a great

I Think Obama is a great orator and despise BUSHCO for the loss of civil liberties and the Global fraudulent War of Terror but there is little real difference from both Democrats and the Republicans when you look at their action (not their words). In fact since the Democrats took control of congress in 2006 they have been done very little to oppose FISA, inact impeachment and stop the occupation of both Iraq and Afghanistan. The Democrat and Republican Corporations are not interested in the American People and have shown this with clear action. Talk is cheap and this convention is all TALK. There will not be any action to follow. I have had enough I am voting Independent.

But Norman, the only reason

But Norman, the only reason the Republicans have maintained the White House is through the fixing of elections. We are no longer in a democracy, or in any remnant of one. We have an insurmountable problem with voting machines THAT WILL be hacked in Nov. This country is in the grip of fascist control by the party and the man who is in the Oval Office today, but also with the help of two-faced, grimy war-politicians, like Diane Feinstein. The major reason McCain even has a chance in this election is because we are still using electronic voting machines.

Palin is Cheney with

Palin is Cheney with lipstick. Why should America trust the same clowns who broke our country to fix it. time to throw the bums out period.

What Obama and the Democrats

What Obama and the Democrats don't understand is that presidential elections really are about personality, not issues. Television enables every viewer to think that he/she knows the candidate, and most people vote for the person they like the best. The Republicans are much better at the politics of personality, especially in the television age and that's why they usually win.

Solomon writes: "...the

Solomon writes: "...the Republican Party is a political institution that views all such constituencies and activists ... as enemies to be smothered and crushed." One could say that the Democrats' core constituencies see whites, and particularly white males, as a group to be "smothered and crushed." (If you reflect on the fact that many Democrats are white males … well, that’s a lesson in itself.) On the other hand, McCain’s Hispanic outreach director, Juan Hernandez, is a Mexican nationalist, and Jerry Perenchio, Finance Co-Chair of McCain 2008, bankrolled the campaign against California proposition 227, the anti-bilingual education initiative. So Solomon shouldn’t be too despondent should McCain pull this one off.

No independent is going to

No independent is going to win this November. We do not have a parliamentary system, it is at best a protest vote. The Weimer Republic was far preferable to the Nazis, there is a gulf of difference between the variety of the flawed and overly cautious Democrats and the full of it Republicans with their odd philosophy that teen pregnancy is ok if there is a support system for the baby. This inevitably would lead to funding support for young momsif they weren't just full of it. The media is the problem, the media is the message and all o' that, people, if they fall in love with clever marketing rather than facts and logic, the people are dumb enough...

Thanks for the warning

Thanks for the warning Norman, I think we're getting it. The difference between the two conventions is stark. Obama was right, 'bitter people turning to religion and guns" McCain's convention, The American Taliban. I think we'll win over them, they are few. Sarah Palin is a twinkle in Karl Rove's fascist eye: he heard 18,000,000 votes, and she's the cover for trying to steal a few million for McCain.I don't believe Republicans have won an election legally since Ronald Reagan. I think the american spirit is alive and well. We will win.

There is evidence that the

There is evidence that the Democratic Party as a whole is moving back to the left, though at painfully slow pace. It is up to us to keep it moving in that direction, and to pick up the pace.

I fully agree with your

I fully agree with your argument, but there is one huge factor against people voting for the Democratic ticket. It's headed by a woman and many have not come to grips with themselves about the capability of the female in politics. Regardless of party affiliation. It's a shame, but true.

If President Obama does not

If President Obama does not bring the war criminal treaty-breaking invading murderous spying Bush, Cheney cartel to justice; and I mean prison and restitution....to JUSTICE....then America is lost and gone forever. Where there is no justice there is no freedom.

If McCain wins, do you think

If McCain wins, do you think he will pardon the Bush Administration?

Dear, "I have had enough. I

Dear, "I have had enough. I am voting Independent." If our Democratic Senate and Congress had the numbers to override filibusters and vetoes, proper change would already be happening. Are you comfortable with the fact that your vote might help elect Senator McCain and place our country in the same untenable position? If you are concerned about your civil liberties, you should worry about who will get appointed to the Supreme Court during the next four years. Who would Sarah Palin appoint, if she were to become CINC?

I have been saying this year

I have been saying this year that I would vote for a length of coiled rope before I would sit by and see Republicans voted into another presidency. I'm desperately hope we can out-vote them, but I must at least try. Unfortunately, the vote in 2004 was every bit as important, but I fear too many had not been awakened to that at the time. I hope we are now. I hope we know that -- as imperfect as it is -- the Democratic Party is the Anti-Bush/Cheney therapy that we need. BUT, with Barack Obama in there, we progressives cannot disappear into our gardens and forests for the next four years. We have to stand firm for our principles, for fair trade, for social justice, for all the things that government should be (and against all those that government should NOT be), or we will have no one but ourselves to blame is President Obama does not respond to our agenda. Vote for Obama and Biden. And stay active the day after the vote, too.

Of course it is important

Of course it is important who is president. But the reason the left has downplayed the office is because from Gerald Ford forward no Republican president has been making the decisions. And this will continue with McCain. In fact that is the point. "Genius" Rove has struck agian, choosing a middle level oilgarch as McCain's running mate and then orchestrating a "rift" between McCain and Bush in order to bolster McCain's false image as a maverick, And true to form everybody bites.The big payoff comes if (when) McCain keels over and Palin takes over as a female Bush and the same folks who have been running the country (Cheney, Rumsfeld, Scalia, et.al.) keep running the country until they hand it over to their neocon acolytes. Does anyone think they are going to give up one iota of what they have gained in the past 30 years just because on e of their boys is forced to vacate the office? They're certainly not going to give it up to a somebody as unstable as John McCain.

Dear "cheap talker", You've

Dear "cheap talker", You've been far more polite than many of the Democratic faithful about telling independents that it will all be their fault if the Chipmunks get into power. Honestly, I've taken quite enough abuse from Dems on this subject of not voting for their guy, this cycle. So, it was refreshing to not have to turn into a humorless, angry, attack mutant, like I usually do. So, since you've proven that you're still listening, scroll down the thread and read David's post. He's spot on! I voted Nader in 2000, and Kerry in 2004, under the mistaken impression that it mattered. Very late in 2004, I started finding out how very much evidence there was to suggest that the elections have been rigged, heavily enough to get the Shrub into office, BOTH TIMES. It's all there in the archives at blackboxvoting.org So, if anybody else out there is nursing the mistaken impression that getting a few more of us Third-Party people on board is all you need, I suggest that you start at blackboxvoting.org, follow their links, search the net, and do your homework, then maybe we can all focus on what really needs to happen to get "progressives", or liberals, or for that matter anybody to the left of Hermann Goering, elected to the White House. -But seriously, this crap with electronic voting abuses is real, it is documented, it is provable, and the mechanisms to "hack the vote" have been proven and recorded in front of official witnesses. The only reason that nobody talks about it is that the mass media and the voting machine companies are all owned by wealthy, arch-conservatives, with phalanxes of lawyers around them. -That, and also because many people find detailed computer-geek issues to be a real sleeping pill. But We, The People cannot afford to sleep through this. Educate yourselves, pitch in, and maybe we can start "spreading Democracy" to America. Oh, and if you love the Old Republic as much as I do, prepare to be outraged. This is a point of grand political strategy that nobody can afford to overlook, that could render all your hard work for your candidate, useless. It did, in the last two elections. Check it out first, and THEN form your own opinions, that's all I ask.

The words of aggression,

The words of aggression, condescension and derision coming out of the Republican convention most certainly do not entice a non-party voter like myself. But, a tired old litany coming from the left of "Hey, vote for us cuz we're not as bad as the other guy" is simply not going to cut it either. Senator Obama is going to have to do a lot better if he wants to convince me to give up my precious vote. The Democratic Party is not the only other alternative and I will be spending my vote wherever I chose to. Nobody is stealing that vote, I am investing it. When politicians start to acknowledge that fact, then we will be making Progress.

McCain doesn`t stand a

McCain doesn`t stand a snowball`s chance in hell of ever being ELECTED by voters no more than Palin does by the 20% devout theo-con sect only through deception and fraud do they attain these positions. We are living the fruits of those labors that mo/ironically even themselves acknowledge as beyond fatally flawed it is just wrong and mark my words should they steal the office again you will see citizen`s( McCain described them during his autonomous monotone acceptance drone "ground noise and static") shedding blood on America`s streets over shelter, food and water!

The two most important

The two most important issues for the survival of mankind are global environmental degradation (atmospheric carbon buildup causing climate change, and chemical air, water, food, ocean, and soil pollution), and the other is global militarism. There is at least some faint hope that with enough grass roots acitvism and struggle Obama would begin to respond and move in the right direction. There would be no hope if the McCain/Palin extremists get into office.

SOLOMON is PART of the

SOLOMON is PART of the PROBLEM: Solomon says: "Under the roof of the Democratic Party, notwithstanding its shades of corporatism and militarism and numerous other grave faults, there's a lot of longstanding and ongoing involvement from key progressive constituencies " Normon Solomon defends Democratic Party as "different", dismisses corporatism & militarism and...other grave faults. Those groups may still identify with the Democratic Party, but they are NOT being serviced, supported nor defended by that Party. To their lasting detriment, they cannot conceive of anyplace else to go, and so watch helplessly as fascism rouses and organizes itself in America with no resistance in sight. It is a sham. Far from being represented by the Democratic Party, they are held hostage by it. By being silent or complicit, Democrats have effectively endorsed and legitimized those NeoCon policies. WHERE is the loud noise on Torture, on billions going to private war contrators, on conducting an illegal war, on spying on citizens? Hmmm...? Where in Denver did anyone go on attack about the abuses of our Constitution, several stolen elections, the repression of registered voters? Which speaker defended the rights of the journalists and protesters to report or speak their minds without being brutalized? Where is the believeablity? The Democratic Party, in abandoning oraganized labor and workers in general, as well as women by giving up on ERA, has LED us to this place, where a Sarah Palin can stand up and say such outrageous things. The Democrats gave up on the poeple in favor or corporate funding decades ago. For YEARS they could hasve been attacking thie illegal (I remind you) Administration on it Number One Issue: SECURITY! How EASY it would be to PROVE that they have repetedly HURT our national SECURITY, knowingly and through blunders. They try to get everything by force, and this Congress has let them. They should have been impeached years ago. Unfortunately everyone has to sleep in the bed made by this enabling, treasonous Democratic Party. Republicans go after what they want, creating thes God-awful mess, yet, the Democrats silence those who are outraged by that. Silence or ignore the anti-war movement, the impeachment movement, the single-payerhealth care movement, the women's movement, and so on. As long as Americans keep buying into Solomon's myth, we cannot begin to defend ourselves from this horror show, or even to conscieve of ourselves as actors in the process. Let us stop going down this avenue of false promises. It is a dead end. It is time to step up to responsibility, no matter the odds, and step out of the box to a political organization that supports us, defends us and truly stands for our values. Inspired1