Share

What a Long, Strange Trip It's Been

by: Bill Ayers  |  In These Times

photo
Upon the end of a surreal campaign season, Bill Ayers speaks out. (Photo: Chris Walker / The Chicago Tribune)

    Bill Ayers looks back on a surreal campaign season.

    Whew! What was all that mess? I'm still in a daze, sorting it all out, decompressing.

    Pass the Vitamin C.

    For the past few years, I have gone about my business, hanging out with my kids and, now, my grandchildren, taking care of our elders (they moved in as the kids moved out), going to work, teaching and writing. And every day, I participate in the never-ending effort to build a powerful and irresistible movement for peace and social justice.

    In years past, I would now and then - often unpredictably - appear in the newspapers or on TV, sometimes with a reference to Fugitive Days, my 2001 memoir of the exhilarating and difficult years of resistance against the American war in Vietnam. It was a time when the world was in flames, revolution was in the air, and the serial assassinations of black leaders disrupted our utopian dreams.

    These media episodes of fleeting notoriety always led to some extravagant and fantastic assertions about what I did, what I might have said and what I probably believe now.

    It was always a bit surreal. Then came this political season.

    During the primary, the blogosphere was full of chatter about my relationship with President-elect Barack Obama. We had served together on the board of the Woods Foundation and knew one another as neighbors in Chicago's Hyde Park. In 1996, at a coffee gathering that my wife, Bernardine Dohrn, and I held for him, I made a $200 donation to his campaign for the Illinois State Senate.

    Obama's political rivals and enemies thought they saw an opportunity to deepen a dishonest perception that he is somehow un-American, alien, linked to radical ideas, a closet terrorist who sympathizes with extremism - and they pounced.

    Sen. Hillary Clinton's (D-N.Y.) campaign provided the script, which included guilt by association, demonization of people Obama knew (or might have known), creepy questions about his background and dark hints about hidden secrets yet to be uncovered.

    On March 13, Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), apparently in an attempt to reassure the base,- sat down for an interview with Sean Hannity of Fox News. McCain was not yet aware of the narrative Hannity had been spinning for months, and so Hannity filled him in: Ayers is an unrepentant "terrorist," he explained, "On 9/11, of all days, he had an article where he bragged about bombing our Pentagon, bombing the Capitol and bombing New York City police headquarters. ... He said, 'I regret not doing more.'"

    McCain couldn't believe it.

    Neither could I.

    On the campaign trail, McCain immediately got on message. I became a prop, a cartoon character created to be pummeled.

    When Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin got hold of it, the attack went viral. At a now-famous Oct. 4 rally, she said Obama was Ïpallin' around with terrorists.- (I pictured us sharing a milkshake with two straws.)

    The crowd began chanting, "Kill him!" "Kill him"- It was downhill from there.

    My voicemail filled up with hate messages. They were mostly from men, all venting and sweating and breathing heavily. A few threats: "Watch out!" and "You deserve to be shot." And some e-mails, like this one I got from satan@hell.com: "I'm coming to get you and when I do, I'll water-board you."

    The police lieutenant who came to copy down those threats deadpanned that he hoped the guy who was going to shoot me got there before the guy who was going to water-board me, since it would be most foul to be tortured and then shot. (We have been pals ever since he was first assigned to investigate threats made against me in 1987, after I was hired as an assistant professor at the University of Illinois at Chicago.)

    The good news was that every time McCain or Palin mentioned my name, they lost a point or two in the polls. The cartoon invented to hurt Obama was now poking holes in the rapidly sinking McCain-Palin ship.

    That '60s Show

    On Aug. 28, Stephen Colbert, the faux right-wing commentator from Comedy Central who channels Bill O'Reilly on steroids, observed:

    To this day, when our country holds a presidential election, we judge the candidates through the lens of the 1960s. ... We all know Obama is cozy with William Ayers a '60s radical who planted a bomb in the capital building and then later went on to even more heinous crimes by becoming a college professor. ... Let us keep fighting the culture wars of our grandparents. The '60s are a political gift that keeps on giving.

    It was inevitable. McCain would bet the house on a dishonest and largely discredited vision of the '60s, which was the defining decade for him. He built his political career on being a prisoner of war in Vietnam.

    The '60s - as myth and symbol - is much abused: the downfall of civilization in one account, a time of defeat and humiliation in a second, and a perfect moment of righteous opposition, peace and love in a third.

    The idea that the 2008 election may be the last time in American political life that the '60s plays any role whatsoever is a mixed blessing. On the one hand, let's get over the nostalgia and move on. On the other, the lessons we might have learned from the black freedom movement and from the resistance against the Vietnam War have never been learned. To achieve this would require that we face history fully and honestly, something this nation has never done.

    The war in Vietnam was an illegal invasion and occupation, much of it conducted as a war of terror against the civilian population. The U.S. military killed millions of Vietnamese in air raids - like the one conducted by McCain - and entire areas of the country were designated free-fire zones, where American pilots indiscriminately dropped surplus ordinance - an immoral enterprise by any measure.

    What Is Really Important

    McCain and Palin - or as our late friend Studs Terkel put it, "Joe McCarthy in drag" - would like to bury the '60s. The '60s, after all, was a time of rejecting obedience and conformity in favor of initiative and courage. The '60s pushed us to a deeper appreciation of the humanity of every human being. And that is the threat it poses to the right wing, hence the attacks and all the guilt by association.

    McCain and Palin demanded to "know the full extent" of the Obama-Ayers "relationship" so that they can know if Obama, as Palin put it, "is telling the truth to the American people or not."

    This is just plain stupid.

    Obama has continually been asked to defend something that ought to be at democracy's heart: the importance of talking to as many people as possible in this complicated and wildly diverse society, of listening with the possibility of learning something new, and of speaking with the possibility of persuading or influencing others.

    The McCain-Palin attacks not only involved guilt by association, they also assumed that one must apply a political litmus test to begin a conversation.

    On Oct. 4, Palin described her supporters as those who "see America as the greatest force for good in this world" and as a "beacon of light and hope for others who seek freedom and democracy." But Obama, she said, "Is not a man who sees America as you see it and how I see America." In other words, there are "real" Americans - and then there are the rest of us.

    In a robust and sophisticated democracy, political leaders - and all of us - ought to seek ways to talk with many people who hold dissenting, or even radical, ideas. Lacking that simple and yet essential capacity to question authority, we might still be burning witches and enslaving our fellow human beings today.

    Maybe we could welcome our current situation - torn by another illegal war, as it was in the '60s - as an opportunity to search for the new.

    Perhaps we might think of ourselves not as passive consumers of politics but as fully mobilized political actors. Perhaps we might think of our various efforts now, as we did then, as more than a single campaign, but rather as our movement-in-the-making.

    We might find hope in the growth of opposition to war and occupation worldwide. Or we might be inspired by the growing movements for reparations and prison abolition, or the rising immigrant rights movement and the stirrings of working people everywhere, or by gay and lesbian and transgender people courageously pressing for full recognition.

    Yet hope - my hope, our hope - resides in a simple self-evident truth: the future is unknown, and it is also entirely unknowable.

    History is always in the making. It's up to us. It is up to me and to you. Nothing is predetermined. That makes our moment on this earth both hopeful and all the more urgent - we must find ways to become real actors, to become authentic subjects in our own history.

    We may not be able to will a movement into being, but neither can we sit idly for a movement to spring full-grown, as from the head of Zeus.

    We have to agitate for democracy and egalitarianism, press harder for human rights, learn to build a new society through our self-transformations and our limited everyday struggles.

    At the turn of the last century, Eugene Debs, the great Socialist Party leader from Terre Haute, Ind., told a group of workers in Chicago, "If I could lead you into the Promised Land, I would not do it, because someone else would come along and lead you out."

    In this time of new beginnings and rising expectations, it is even more urgent that we figure out how to become the people we have been waiting to be.

    ---------

    Bill Ayers is a Distinguished Professor of Education and Senior University Scholar at the University of Illinois at Chicago. He is the author of "Fugitive Days" (Beacon) and co-author, with Bernardine Dohrn, of "Race Course: Against White Supremacy" (Third World Press).

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Yes, Yes, Yes. Thank you

Yes, Yes, Yes. Thank you for your wonderful words.

He has always been an

He has always been an amazing human being; we had to keep quiet about it, but let's face the truth...he suffered losses too. He fought for all of society. Many millions worldwide felt as he did. If innocents died, they were his friends. McCain and other pilots b ombed innocent kids and women in Vietnam; killed them. Why is that ok? Right on, Bill, and thank you for your courage under fire

Thank you Mr. Ayers for

Thank you Mr. Ayers for providing a wise and succinct commentary of the 2008 election. These thoughts and emotions ran through all of us who voted for Obama. Worry not Mr. Ayers, most of us saw you not as a terrorist, but as an activist, someone who was willing to put their money where their mouth was. It must have been tough to have been made into a prop in order to scare the ignorant right. There was a time where I did not fear the right, where I thought that these were just people with a different view on how the world worked, and they would try their darnedest to make the world better...regardless if they were wrong or right. Now, I see a part on the right that is bent on creating fear in the populous that they purport to serve then attempting to exploit that fear in order to secure positions of power. This is where you, Mr. Ayers, came in. You were a puppet of fear, the Satan in the marionette's play, the terrorist, the anti-American, the unknown. You were used by the Republican party, a party I don't even recognize as being American anymore, to scare their sheepish followers into voting for the McCain/Palin ticket. I thank America for not falling completely for this ruse. I am also glad that the fear mongers on the left, namely Hillary and co., failed when they tried to use you to secure power through fear as well. It seems that smartness won this time around. Unfortunately, 56million of Americans fell for it. Maybe our educational system failed them? You, Mr. Ayers, would know. Being an expert in education and all. In sum, I truly appreciate you writing this piece. I appreciate the fact that you had to wait until after the election to write it because you were smart enough to know that anything you said would be used against Obama. And, though I don't agree with what you did in the past, I am proud to call you a fellow American. Take care and thank you Mr. Ayers.

Just great to get this story

Just great to get this story out. By the way, we may not be burning witches, but we are still throwing sick people into jail by the thousands. So maybe we've not come so far after all. California just voted to continue, a sign that visceral , not thoughtful opinion, still rules.

Thank you, Bill. Thank you

Thank you, Bill. Thank you for taking the time to set the record straight on what has become the "damning of all that is good" by those who consider themselves to be "The Right". I hope that this election, your eloquent detail here, and much more to come will push them back into the holes where they belong. They are neither Christian nor Right. They are morally bankrupt and I'm so sorry that they have put you through such a lingering hell. From one college instructor to you, Professor: Thank you.

I was hoping you would

I was hoping you would comment once the election was over. And thank you for your caring so much in the '60's!! And now, too. chuck

How bombing people and then

How bombing people and then getting shot down made people believe McCain is a hero is something I never have understood. I was a child during Vietnam but still remember the horror I felt at what my country was doing.

I must add a hearty thanks

I must add a hearty thanks also. The past months of absolutely crazy thinking and talking were difficult - much more difficult for you I'm sure. I applaud your courage then, and now. Now, on with the work of becoming the people we have been waiting to be. It's good to know you are out there. Thanks, again

It is very sad that you

It is very sad that you never thought of your impact on the U.S. men and women fighting in Vietnam. You greatly influenced the poor treatment they received upon returning to the this country. You negatively impacted many lives.

A great piece Mr. Ayer.

A great piece Mr. Ayer. The poisonous slander coming from the floundering, uninformed, and hate-filled McCain/Palin campaign was difficult to watch and harder to listen to. First McCain attempted to (once again)... re-invent himself..Then..he shamelessly engaged in a horrific attempt to denigrate Mr. Obama... just so he could finally have the one thing he has wanted for so very long..the Office of the President of the U.S. Obviously...he realized he could NEVER get there honestly..on his own merit..(at least agaisnt Obama..so clearly better candidate....who despite all the nonsense spouted by McCain..Palin and the poisonous 'talking heads' at Fox ...remained dignified..on track and level-headed. A leader. I was astonished by the hatred..lies..and bully tactics used by the McCain/Palin campaign..and was embarrased for McCain when he refused to even aknowledge Obama by name..refering to him as 'that one'. What an appalling display of pettiness and disrespect. As for Palin..good grief. McCain should retire. He is not to be trusted. As for Palin...North to Alaska...and stay there. Thanks for your article to set the record straight. .

Bill, you are a great

Bill, you are a great American and I want to thank you for all your service to this country. You're a bigger hero, to me anyway, than any fighter pilot could ever be, shot down or otherwise. You are on the right side of history, and I hope I'm not the first to think of your militant time as a form of alternative service...I would tend to think of Palin as more J Parnell Thomas in drag because she's going down on lots of ethics charges, not drinking herself to death and attacking heaven and earth, I mean the Army.

Those of us who marched and

Those of us who marched and were arrested in the 60s know some of what Bill Ayers must be feeling and thinking. Unfortunately, the Palin and McCain crowd don't respect dissent, even though they claim to love the "Maverick" label. Bless youm Bill and Bernardine!!

Right on.

Right on.

It must have been very

It must have been very difficult for you to sit by and listen to you, your honorable life, and Barack Obama's reputation be distorted al these months. Among the many beautiful things that have happened this week, is this, your patient and wise response. I support you and am proud to be a fellow 'terrorist' ... or whatever they want to call those of us who care about and work for justice. Thank you...

Thank you Mr. Ayers. Thank

Thank you Mr. Ayers. Thank you for your words, your courage, and your generosity.

AND...'!RiGHt!'... ONnnn...!

AND...'!RiGHt!'... ONnnn...!'TiME'!... '!?PRO?!'-FeSSSoRrrr... wphhgg };@~

We have a long way to go.

We have a long way to go. Whether "our" generation of rabble-rousers leaves a legacy of let's-get-it-on, or let's get to work and get it done, still remains to be seen. At this age, the hipsters are ripe for harvesting wisdom from lives that have gone around the bend and back again, several times. Will we rise to the occasion? "Come on people now, smile on your brother, everybody get together, try to love one another right now." Jesse Colin Young, o yea.

To Bill As an Australian,

To Bill As an Australian, also living and aware in nthe 60s, a fervent 'Thanks Mate!'

It's a big relief and

It's a big relief and reassuring to hear your end of the "Bill Ayers story". You are different in "real life" than how you were portrayed by the McCain campaign duh! I listened as I read your article and heard your reasoned, calm, clear-thinking discussion about all that occurred around your political concerns from the 1960's on, as well as your hopes for the future of us as Americans. Thank you!

Mr. Ayers, You were painted

Mr. Ayers, You were painted as a terrorist & used as a prop in an attempt to paint Obama as an angry black man. Some did it for personal political gain & others for ratings & revenue. I believe they all knew exactly what they were doing & the story was there for any of them to find the deeper truth if they wanted it. The fact that a prestigious McCain campaign donor had actually played a role in hiring you to sit on the board in question was never even discussed in the media. We've all made mistakes in life & you simply acted with conviction that none of my generation has had the balls to under our current administration. I don't know your full story but I'll seek more of it in order to more fully understand where it is you came from. Thank you for sharing your very insightful thoughts on the election & displaying your intelligence & clear logic. Peace.

To Professor Bill

To Professor Bill Ayers Dear Sir, You have done a masterful job debunking the slander that was heaped on you by that ill fated McCain/Palin campaign. To think that these people had the illusion that they would be qualified to be the leaders of this nation is nothing less than grotesque.

I was a bit disappointed to

I was a bit disappointed to find that there was no explanation or defense of what the Weather Underground was doing during the sixties in blowing up unoccupied buildings here in the US. While administration after administration, Democrat and Republican, carried out mass murder and terrorism with weapons of mass destruction in Southeast Asia, the WU sought to bring the effects of that genocidal war home to a largely ignorant and complacent American public, an effort that is reflected in the following quote by William Shirer "Until we go through it ourselves, until our people cower in the shelters of New York, Washington, Chicago, Los Angeles and elsewhere while the buildings collapse overhead and burst into flames, and dead bodies hurtle about and, when it is over for the day or the night, emerge in the rubble to find some of their dear ones mangled, their homes gone, their hospitals, churches, schools demolished - only after that gruesome experience will we realize what we are inflicting on the people of Indochina ..."

It's really sad, that the

It's really sad, that the right had to bring Bill into the election. They'll do anything just to hang onto their base. They're still dividers, because they just don't get it. Period. Let's hope someday this will change, there's always HOPE!

Well said Professor! So nice

Well said Professor! So nice to hear from you.

I opposed the Vietnam war. I

I opposed the Vietnam war. I also opposed the Weathermen for their tactics. I do not believe in violence. I do believe in Gandhi. I think the Weathermen made grave, callow, immature mistakes that set our movement to end the war, back, not forward. That said, I see many ways in which Bill Ayers has sought to redeem himself with good works, and I certainly do believe he is a valuable witness to history, for better or worse, and deserves to be engaged, not turned into a straw man. You had to expect that in the pursuit of power, Obama's opponents would leverage every perceived advantage. Luckily for us all, and for whatever reason, their anti-intellectual jingoism failed to rouse a majority of the rabble. But it is disturbing to me that they roused any at all. There are lessons to be learned from the 60s. I wonder if we will ever learn them.

Obama IS a terrorist, but

Obama IS a terrorist, but for the opposite reason McCain and Palin cite. NOT because he associated with the freedom fighter Ayers. Rather, because he voted to fund the War of Terror. He is one of hundreds of terrorists we have elected to rule us and to genocide people in the Middle East, among other parts of the globe (Africa). I wish Mr. Ayers had had the courage to say what he knows to be true about Obama in this article or one before it. P.S. Don't blame me for anyone the gov't kills in the Middle East. I voted Nader in 2004 and 2008.

I never did give any

I never did give any credence to the shit coming from the right. I never listen to THEM.

Pat B.'s comment stems from

Pat B.'s comment stems from the rhetoric that we have been hearing in the last 5 years about how if we agitate against war we are not supporting our troops. I thought this was laid to rest. How is it supporting the troops to wish the fighting never to end? How does Joe the soldier (can't resist that!) benefit, knowing that his younger sister and brother are also going to have to risk their lives if their values involve fighting the country's wars- just so the wars will never end? Do you think Joe doesn't want to come home? The fact that the ambiguity of some people to deal with the idea of soldiers doing something inherently wrong-- may, in some small number (it was pretty much a media myth) have maligned the returning Vietnam soldiers (and maybe some of them were actually responsible for the part of the bloody carnage that they did for fun?)-- does not make it wrong to want to end wars! This is the same philosophy that says we have to keep fighting in order to honor those who have died, such that more will die, such that we have to honor those by sending more to die, until, in order to make every soldier honorable, every man or woman in this country is dead-- and then I'm not sure how to honor them unless it is to kill the children. But we will, I hope, slowly begin to let go of the rhetoric from the last 8 ignorant, fear-mongering, and misinformed years, and perhaps free speech will once again mean you can speak out against your government rather than meaning you can't do that but you can use racial invective and you can force religion onto school children. Maybe common sense will come into vogue and it will be ok to think for oneself. I have a dream...

Institutionalized murder in

Institutionalized murder in support of an illegal war is the greatest evil. Serving your country takes many forms. You did the right thing then, and now. Your every bit as much a patriot as John McCain. And much more so than a Sarah Palin. Thank you.

"It is very sad that you

"It is very sad that you never thought of your impact on the U.S. men and women fighting in Vietnam. You greatly influenced the poor treatment they received upon returning to the this country." I do believe Mr. Ayers was thinking of the impact on the innocent people living in Vietnam...who received somewhat poorer treatment in their own country.

Hillary became morally

Hillary became morally repugnant when she tried to link you ("terrorist Bill") and Obama, but disavow, play down, ignore, or forget her own early 70s work in the SF Bay Area for the law firm that did such a great job for the Panthers and other leftists. To sell out her roots, scapegoat you, and give the McCain/Palin/McCarthy right such a weapon against Obama was unforgivable. Glad she lost; glad Barack is our president-elect.

Dear Bill: Congratulations

Dear Bill: Congratulations and a million thanks for your poise and thoughtfulness amidst yet another sustained GOP mudpie artillery barrage. Thanks also for pointing out Hillary Clinton's culpability in this farce. I was happy to vote for her for senator, but she tacked so hard right she completely lost her moral compass. You and Bernadine are truly inspiring to those of us who believe not in some crude cruel and greedy jingo fantasy of innate US superiority, but rather in the difficult and necessary ideal of social justice. Thanks as well to IN THESE TIMES and TRUTHOUT. Together we are building the collective struggle which is the only possible hope for humankind.

It is good to have moral

It is good to have moral leaders, even though it is hard on them, and sometimes they do not wish to lead, except that they are stuck with having character and morals. Thank you sir for your moral character and your willingness to take hits for it. Hilary

Mr. Ayers, As a Vietnam

Mr. Ayers, As a Vietnam veteran let me add my thanks for having the courage to see wrong as wrong and trying to agitate to right it. I was terrorized by my government and the support for the war by my fellow Americans throughout my high school years. As my family slipped into a ruinous split up, I had a choice to go to jail or Vietnam or give up my citizenship. I managed some college courses on my own, but then my gov again changed the rules for deferment - within months I was wearing green. I live in Asia now and returned to Vietnam last year to lay some ghosts to rest and offer prayers for the forgiveness of my countrymen. The country smelled differently. Fresh fruits and vegetables were everywhere. Korean and Japanese company presence was everywhere. Everyone was busy with life and not with fear and death. Now that our actions in Iraq have insured that religious fundies will be in control, I wonder how long the American conscience will allow the Iraqis - who also never threatened us - to live with the fear and death we have brought them too in the name of freedom and democracy? p.s. As Gore Vidal recently noted, the myth of the hero McCain is of McCain's own making. p.s.s He's right. I was there.

Wait a minute. It's great to

Wait a minute. It's great to have the work of the 60s and early 0s presented in a positive and genuine light from someone who was there, but the work of now needs to be kept in focus, too. Steven Colbert is hardly a "right wing commentator". A small point in a great piece, but--

Sounds like a great guy.

Sounds like a great guy. Most salient point in the piece: " this would require that we face history fully and honestly, something this nation has never done." Amen to that. In America, truth telling is exotic; it takes either super-human courage, or some sort of 'nothing left to lose' status. (Dan Rather told one true thing and immediately got fired; only then did he make truth telling a regular habit. ) BTW, while we are facing truths about America's past, how about looking at the past more recent than Viet Nam? For example, the U.S. army's use of white phosphorus on civilians in Falujah? ("We only used it for illumination," the army said, after months of denials. Oh. Then why did they use it in the daytime? In Italy they made a great documentary on the subject. Banned here, of course.) Another quick question for you: what do Ralph Nader, Ron Paul, Dennis Kucinich, Jessie Ventura, Paul Craig Roberts, Assistant Secretary of Treasury under Reagan (and father of Reagonomics), and Lt. Col. Karen Kwiatkowski all have in common? Find out in detail, if you have the balls, on the Patriots Question 9-11 website ... No president, not even Barack Obama, has the power to change our culture of amnesia and lies. That's not the way culture works. In this respect as well the concluding message of Mr. Ayer's excellent essay is right on the money: the responsibility is ours.

Is that a picture of you at

Is that a picture of you at the top of this article? I'm shocked! You don't look at all like the picture my mind has formed of you over the past few weeks. Where are your fangs? And horns? And the blood running down your chin from all the innocent babies you eat for breakfast? Other than that, I pretty much say, "Ditto" to the comments by Andrew.

I must commend Bill Ayers

I must commend Bill Ayers for remaining thoughtful and eloquent in 2008. His commentary has a wonderful mouth feel of the late 1960s, like a fine cabernet, created then and just now reaching its peak. It has a heady aroma of reason, humanity and justice, tempered by the experience of aging. Wisdom like yours we need now more than ever. The faux "patriotism" of Palin and her petticoat fascists is a slippery slope toward moral bankruptcy, unreasoned fear and gross ignorance. As a Vietnam-era veteran with a top secret clearance who sent classified Cambodia bombing coordinates around the world on what later became the internet, then demonstrated against the invasion of Cambodia in 1970 after my discharge. I salute you for setting the record straight.

RE: Mr./Ms. Benjamin's

RE: Mr./Ms. Benjamin's lament that Mr. Ayers "never thought of [his] impact on the U.S. men and women fighting in Vietnam." The whole impetus for Mr. Ayers’ activities was to prevent any other U.S. men and women having to fight in an illegal and immoral war. Right and wrong is easy to assign in retrospect, but in the moment, feeling otherwise powerless to stop a wholesale slaughter, desperate people will take desperate measures. Some people, in their fervor, have bombed abortion clinics and murdered abortion doctors, and I have not heard half the outcry over that as I have over Mr. Ayers’ decades-past activities in the last few weeks. I truly believe that Mr. Ayers and his friends acted out of moral outrage, and not for kicks or out of some grab for power. I wish I could say the same about our outgoing administration. Unfortunately, we still have not done enough to stop the kinds of atrocities our nation committed in our name in Viet Nam, because we have seen it happen again in the Middle East. And in the end, both tragedies can be traced to a need to have control over some distant patch of the planet. I don’t condone the bombing of public buildings or places, and I can’t imagine participating in such things. But I do understand the outrage and the helplessness that underlies such acts. I have written to the papers, I have called my representatives, I have sent donations, I have shaken my fist, and I have talked to friends and acquaintances of all political persuasions until I’m blue in the face, and I know I have not been alone in this frustration. And still, for so long, nothing changed. We can only hope that our President-Elect has gleaned some lessons from the era in which Mr. Ayers’ recently-examined activities took place, so that he can avoid repeating history - something our outgoing Commander in Chief apparently failed to learn.

With every slur, with every

With every slur, with every negative allegation brought forth by the right, I did 2 things: 1. I posted refutations, detailed and analytical, in a political forum on a photography site I'm on, a site that has worldwide members and a cross-section of U.S Citizens. 2. I had a Master Card Moment every time and made a donation to the Obama campaign. I agree with previous posters that Hillary modeled the strategy of the right by being the first to embark on the Ayers avenue, and did so knowing full well the only merit was in it's ability to exploit fear. Denigrating another for personal advantage says more about the person, than the target. Sadly, much of the prime time, "reality t.v." addicted public grabs such fodder with a fervor, and without their daily feeding of hate, without an enemy's face on which to vent, without being told what to think about and focus their attention on, they flounder in their own nihilistic despair. We have a chance, a slim chance now, of reigniting the Democratic flame and becoming a country of citizens agqain, as opposed to amarginalized and segregated pockets of fear.

Those who watch as treason

Those who watch as treason is committed and do nothing are themselves committing treason. Mr. Ayers and the WUO saw the injustices going on and stepped up to fight it. If only we all could have such courage!!!!

"The '60s pushed us to a

"The '60s pushed us to a deeper appreciation of the humanity of every human being." This bears repeating.

I wish Mr. Ayers would use

I wish Mr. Ayers would use the spotlight temporarily on him to highlight the remaining mysteries and questions regarding the Sept. 11th Terrorist attacks and the yet unresolved issue of the Anthrax attacks. We have a long way to go and the truth needs to get out on topics such as false flag terrorism and political assassinations of the 60's.

Although two wrongs do not

Although two wrongs do not make a right, and those I respected most in the '60s were non-violent protesters such as Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., it is true that the '60s were drafting young people to go and kill an enemy, not take territory, but count bodies of villagers in Vietnam. That war was undeclared, and not conducted with any decency: there were shrapnel bombs placed into children's toys, for example. Today the land-mines in Laos still kill farmers. Those of us with friends who were soldiers heard about many attrocities, much more than "Me Lai." But, again, I think that the non-violent protests got a lot more attention than the violent protests, which only added to the ignorant self-righteous right-wing horde's attitudes. Nobody learned lessons from Vietnam in the way that my parents recounted the lessons their generation learned from the Great Depression; only 6 years after Vietnam was over, America elected Ron Reagon, who dismantled regulations on banks, and stopped giving loans to farmers so that suddenly almost no blacks were able to own farms (because the local banks would not give them farm loans). America didn't get it. I am glad the Bill Ayres is now about kids and elders; education and history, the non-violent attitudes that do make a difference; Ayres has now learned the value of speech rather than violence. It is discussion that leads to change; Obama proves it. Obama talks and listens. And yes, talking to more people should be applauded; how in the world do the Republicans think that a non-Republican President would ever listen to them if they never even listened to anybody who lived down the street? Listening doesn't mean "palling around," a very strange term; McCain and Palin don't even know or understand what listening means. Bush plans to demolish the environment in the next couple of months. The economy is bust, and may prove very difficult to get back. But at least Obama is trying to get ideas from everybody. I'm sure he will listen much more than these Republicans will ever give him credit for.

...it strikes me as

...it strikes me as poignantly, tragically, presumptuous, that we, here, in our relative safety, get to stand witness to the daily loss of life in other countries where war is waged by us, and we talk of truth as if it were ours alone to reveal... How dare we presume to preside over any truth that sheds any light on an injustice, when bombs fall and destroy lives everywhere but here. If the reality of truth as seen through the eyes of an Iraqi woman had to burden our poor sorry psyche's here in America, we would surely expire from the overwhelming assault on our too long sheltered senses... Comfortably numb hypocrites are we indeed who shout and are heard, but do nothing more. For Mr. Ayres to do what he did means that he must have somehow been moved enough by what he saw to not just simply stand by and protest, but to become an advocate for people he did not even know. To practicing Christians, read this as " he who would lay down his life for his fellow man." Indeed Mr. Ayers risked much for doing what he did. And some might say that those who protested back then did so under the shadow of their own impending draft day, but I think that line of thinking is flawed...a "cop out" if you will. That's like saying that one has a somewhat cowardly agenda behind all of the protest, but can one truly be labelled thusly who somehow finds the courage to act on their convictions by risking all that they held dear, as did Mr. Ayers...? If being an American, or Patriot, or an activist means having Bill Ayer's DNA flowing through my veins, I'll own that heritage any day!

Thank you, Bill. I was

Thank you, Bill. I was wondering why or when this whole notion would be put to bed. It is the one thing that ruined my feelings about the Clintons and I was appalled that Obama didn't set the record straight and leave it there. Maybe I'm just politically naive and simple-minded. Thanks again.

Extreme times in some cases

Extreme times in some cases calls for extreme measures. Like the gentleman who commented about Gandhi, I too abhor violence. But I also realize when government does not listen to its own people, people are then forced to take drastic measures they might never have taken otherwise. This nation was founded on revolution and when the rights that the forefathers beset upon us are threatened by tyranny, one comes to a wall of choice: either rebel or do nothing. If the forefathers did nothing, this great and of ours would not exist. I rest my case and commend Bill Ayers for his candor.

There is a dark but

There is a dark but satisfying irony in the fact that the neoconservatives regime was, in effect, toppled the Weathermen. That means that the Weathermen's bad actions back in the 1960s are now technically good, by virtue of setting the stage for Obama, who seems to have settled next to JFK in the task of capturing the national imagination. He may very well have lost the election had not McCain & the GOP decided to use Williams Ayers as the face of Terror. It's karma, neh?

3 cheers for you, Bill

3 cheers for you, Bill Ayers, and for all of us who helped make history on Election Day. and we'll give our President-elect the best we have to give to get us back to being The United States of America, back on the road that leads to a "perfect union".

In response to your post,

In response to your post, thank you. Other issues that we are not able to discuss - similar to the shame of the post Nazi Germans - institutionalized and organized assaults upon our citizens of color by law enforcement leaders, covert wars initiated for profit, and sold to the populace with lies, economic depredation as an instrument of social policy, consciously and willfully destroying the social contract through looting the treasury to create crises to stifle change. Ah yes, the Nixon, Reagan, BushI and Bust II regimes of assault, attack, lethal toxic corrupt and dangerous disregard for treaty, rule of law, or human rights. Ayers is not the terrorist. He is a freedom fighter.

"On the other, the lessons

"On the other, the lessons we might have learned from the black freedom movement and from the resistance against the Vietnam War have never been learned. To achieve this would require that we face history fully and honestly, something this nation has never done." Bill Ayers, thank you for eloquently illuminating the forces at work in the present and past political seasons. Born in 1964, I have lived most of my life in the shadow of right wing dictums. One of my deep hopes with this election is that we will move to a new set of values as a country, including a more honest self-evaluation of the lessons offered from the 1960s. We can become a great country once again if we are truly able to move beyond the divisive and destructive politics of the right in what I hope is a new chapter of American self-awareness, one I have never seen in my lifetime.

The questions precluded by

The questions precluded by anointing John McCain a national hero in the recent presidential campaign: Why was an aircraft carrier stationed off the coast of Vietnam on the day of John McCain's bombing run over Hanoi? What was the goal of the campaign? Were these goals accomplished? What were the costs in terms of human lives and ecological damage? Many thanks to Bill Ayers for reminding us of simple truths and the means by which they are obfuscated.

I have to laugh out loud

I have to laugh out loud when the MSM try to portray the Weather Underground as a 'lefty fringe group' or terrorists -- although I was still in high school the SDS, the WU, Black Panthers, Angela Davis, Abbie Hofman, Tom Hayden, Jerry Rubin etc were all heroes of mine. Thank you Mr Ayers for fighting the good fight and caring enough to take action against the ruling elite!

From a former Southeastern

From a former Southeastern Y.I.P. Minister of Information: Good work. Three YIPs plus for you. "YIP, YIP, YIP...."

I was hoping Mr. Ayers would

I was hoping Mr. Ayers would go into more specifics about what he did in the 60s and why - from what I know he joined a protest group trying to rise against the Nixon administration for a corrupt war and criminal acts. I heard Ayers was exonerated because he was illegally surveilled under orders from 'Deep Throat' himself and Nixon, Liddy and the other criminals were ousted and prosecuted in shame while Ayers went on to be an educator and continued fighting for social justice and improvement of our country. Why not get into the gory details? We shouldn't fear talking about the 60s because of the different cultural contexts today, the full truth must be spelled out. Someone should call Hannity on this - Nixon was more un-American then Ayers in my book.

I hope that we can now move

I hope that we can now move on from the lies and distortions and the absolute corruption of real American Value by the Right. This is an excellent piece, one about what real Americans are and should be. How we let the Right define these things has been depressing -- the media should have "outed" the real Bill Ayers long ago. Thanks for this, Bill.

Thank you for exercising

Thank you for exercising your first amendment here Bill. My husband and I volunteered for Obama in the NC primary and it was an amazing journey working with old, young, black and white, all with different backgrounds, who cared not about his race but his intelligence and ability to lead. We watched Hillary Clinton and said then that the Pandora's box of lies and dirt by association she created would be used by the Republicans against Obama. As I have said before - it will be hard to put the hate genie that McCain, Palin and their enabling media whores unleashed back into the bottle. I endured that hate from the mouths of so-called "born again Christians" while working at the polls in western NC last Tuesday. Who would Jesus bomb?

Great piece, and thank you

Great piece, and thank you Mr. Ayers. I'm not surprised by the hate mail you've received, and hopefully these were just ill-informed ignoramuses who will not act out their hatred and venom. Regarding Palin, she's now cryig over how the media is treating her. she owes you a big apology, and one to Mr. Obama for LYING about your relationship to each other! If she doesn't apologize, one wonders what kind of values she teaches her children. McCain owes you an apology too. I doubt anyone is sending them death threats !

When I first began reading

When I first began reading this article, I thought it was from the NY Times. I was heartened to think that millions of other thoughtful people around the world would also be reading and learning what I learned this morning about our past. I wish this article and the follow-up comments could be read by everyone that witnessed the lies from the past 54 years of my life. Thanks to Mr. Ayers for writing what you did and thanks to all of the eloquent people that took the time to clearly represent your opinions.

Bill Ayers and more

Bill Ayers and more importantly Bernadine Dohrn, his wife, the real leader, led many good people astray during the 60s. Basically they had the mentality of an elite, like many terrorists before and since, and a contempt for the "broad masses" of Americans. Ayers got off because his wealthy dad got him a phalanx of pricey lawyers. Others were not so lucky. Several Weatherpeople rotted in jail for most of their lives and at least one is still there. Dohrn and Ayers also discredited the rest of SDS with their arrogant and destructive terrorist tactics. Carl Oglesby's recent memoir paints an especially realistic of the despicable and arrogant Dohrn and what she was up to. Ayers should be in jail himself.

A part of this new day is

A part of this new day is that we now might consider the "Government" to be ...us! We night not be perfect in our execution, but it's a start. I remember looking up the word AUTHORITY in the dictionary, and its meaning, lost in politics, is : a person or entity who has expertise in something. I can now hope that this expertise concept spills into the next administration, so that WE might make more informed decisions about OUR collective future.

MCain may have wanted to

MCain may have wanted to extoll his prisoner of War status by using and Ayer's association and condemnatory, but Palin was totally out of touch. I felt as soon as she condemned Obama for association with a terrorist, meaning someone who had fought against the Viet Nam war that she had opened up a huge emotional sore for many us us who actively opposed that war for years. Shame on her. She drove all those people to Obama for certain by that attack. She must have had no idea how divisive the Viet Nam war was, how long it went on, how hard it was to stop, how many people were killed and so on. Of course palin said that the US fighting in Iraq was God's will. ?????

It's great that we all have

It's great that we all have a calm rational forum such as this, where Ayers can get a few words in without being shouted down by a spittle-spewing mob incited by unprincipled individuals. Thank you, Bill, for this informative and thought-provoking article. I remember the '60s well, as I was a small-town newspaper editor by then. The country has never experienced again quite such divisive times down at the grassroots level--although the viciousness of this year's Republican campaigning was beginning to bring us close.

Professor Ayers, thank you

Professor Ayers, thank you for your words. I was eagerly waiting to hear from you, and I knew it would happen after the election. Your work in the world of education has been a gift. We need your voice and your ideas more than ever in this corporatized, standardized, illogical, often inhumane world of education. Thanks for the work you have done and are doing.

All well said and well

All well said and well taken. An even bigger issue for all of us is how it is possible for such ignorance to take hold. One or two make an untrue out of context claim (B.A is a terrorist) and immediately it becomes a virtual truth that can fire up rabid emotions, lynch mob anger and media wallpapering. If this can happen still- after the lessons of, what...McCarthy, Johnson, Nixon, Cheney, Rove and all that. What do we need to have in place to protect ourselves from the terrible consequences when the folly gets out of control bigtime?

We have met the boogey

We have met the boogey man--and he is an intelligent, aticulate, thoughtful, decent man with deep concern for his fellow humans. In fact he is rather like the man he was used to scare us away from. No wonder McPalin and their rabid dogs hate him so.

What a relief to read the

What a relief to read the true story of Bill Ayers. Thank you so much for telling your story so very well. I am now awakening each morning with hope in my heart. This is so different for me: I now recognize what role my thoughts have played in the past eight negative years. Now, in my better moments, I stop those thoughts and shift my attention to the good all around. I stop telling and delighting in negative stories about what is going on. This had become such a way of life for most of us. For the first time since 1793, we have a chance to model what it is like to be a nation of peace.

Nice to hear from the

Nice to hear from the 'terrorist' himself. In 1968 I was 5 years old, and from a little kids eyes the adult world made little sense. My cousin Joe was a Marine in Vietnam, and we watched the body bags on TV and prayed Joey would come home. Eventually He did, brought a drug habit and turned my siblings on to dope and LSD. We were working class and college was a chance that few in our neighborhood had. We had plenty of hate; when it was directed toward blacks the newspapers called it Racism. We didn't care. It's funny since I don't live with or hang out with hate - I find I don't have much anymore. Fast forward to 2008 and the election. The fact that Obama is black had very little with me not voting for him. It was all about - are you ready? ABORTION. Ya, abortion. If everybody in 1968 was so concerned about the people in the black body bags then how come in 2008 people don't care about the little people in the black body bags inside the abortion clinics?

Thank you, Mr. Ayers. It

Thank you, Mr. Ayers. It was so sad to see such a sociopathic disregard for truth in the McCain campaign. How does one respond to idiocracy? You did so superbly.

so mr. ayers, as a democrat

so mr. ayers, as a democrat and lover of all things cerebral, intellectual, humorous, political and historical, you just seem so likeable (republicans shudder!) so i must ask you, FOR THE RECORD, just how much (or little) of what "but i am a war hero!" McCain and "Caribou Barbie" Palin says about you is true? i just have to know. thanks, lisa, democrat raised in a hicktown in texas, hence my identity as a blueberry in a sea of strawberry. i'm curious as to what if any validity anything they said correlates to fact. you know, FACT, that thing that republicans, gosh darnit, you betcha, just don't like much.

"Perhaps we might think of

"Perhaps we might think of ourselves not as passive consumers of politics but as fully mobilized political actors." Hear Hear to that!!

I agree with the "anonymous"

I agree with the "anonymous" comments posted Sat, 11/08/2008 - 04:38.."Sounds like a great guy"... There will no peace or reconciliation without truth. If the Obama administration subverts the efforts of citizens who want to hold to account those who have drained our resources and taken this country into illegal wars...we will know where he really stands... Google: Goldman Sachs and 9/11. I am not sure if the truth will ever be revealed as long as the foxes continue to control the hen house..no matter what party is in power.

Professor Ayers, I would

Professor Ayers, I would like to also add my thanks to the many on this forum for your courage then and now in taking the stand that few others would and saying "This is wrong." I was dismayed to note that your side of the story did not come out before Election Day, but I understand why it may have been a conscious choice to delay your words until after the firestorm had passed, if indeed it was a choice. But even in a campaign there are limits to how far truth can be distorted - have you considered legal recourse for the slander of your name and character in the public eye?

I was there in the 1960's. I

I was there in the 1960's. I spent part of my time on the Columbia campus watching and listening to the SDS. And, part of my time was spent teaching in Harlem and listening to the teens whose brothers, cousins, fathers, etc were fighting in Vietnam. You need to understand both sides to really understand what was taking place at that time. IO also participated in the Civil rights movement and worked directly with martin Luther King Jr. IMHO, peaceful protest works a lot better in the long run than bombs. Witness the Martin Luther approach that eventually led to the election of President-elect Barack Obama. King believed in integration and Obama is a successful product of that belief.

"it will be hard to put the

"it will be hard to put the hate genie that McCain, Palin and their enabling media whores unleashed back into the bottle. I endured that hate from the mouths of so-called "born again Christians" while working at the polls in western NC last Tuesday. Who would Jesus bomb?" The American Taliban will make sure that everything we've fought for, including what Mr. Ayers fought for, will be reversed by these home-grown terrorists that believe that God talks to them, and and that God commands them to destroy everyone else that doesn't believe in what they do. After all, they see themselves as fulfilling God's prophesies of Armageddon and the Apocalypse. "Onward Christian soldiers, marching as to war, with the cross of Jesus, going on before !" Ayers fought to stop a war. The right-wing is fighting to start a world war. So who's the real terrorists here?

I have so looked forward to

I have so looked forward to this article because I knew that it could only possibly be written after the victorious election of Mr.Barack Obama fro president. Throughout the campaign I was embarrassed that so much unfairness of judgement was being directed at you and Mr. Obama. Recently I've really come to realized how very brave and heroic the activists from the 60's really were. Thank you Mr. Ayers, sorry for all the slime. Peace.

Stephen, in response to your

Stephen, in response to your comments about abortion clinics, I'd like to point out that no one is for abortion and the killing of babies, The crux of the Democratic argument is that we support individual freedoms and personal choices, The fact is that the abortion rate falls during times of Democratic governance. It is so simply because the democrats support economic equality and present us with a growing economy by supporting jobs and an adequate income for the impoverishes which removes the economic necessity of having an abortion when the jobs are unavailable to suport aditional births. The Republican Mantra of a Democratic Pro Abortion stand is a myth which must be confronted whenever it is presented. We all want to remove the necessity for a woman to choose to have an abortion. We as Democrats just have a different approach to reaching that goal. Again, Democrats support individual freedoms and the right to make personal choices, and to save the lives of women and prevent a return to back alley illegal abortion clinics. The fact is that abortions will always be with us as a necessity. Some abortions are for teen girls that refuse to deal with the "Holier Than Thou" attitudes held by the religious right. It is human to err and to sin, not one of us is free from sin, and those saying they have no sin are denying the death and resurrection of Christ according to scriptures and will have Jesus tell them that he knew them not on the day of Judgment. Judge not that thou be not be judged by the same measure you judge others. Repent this thy wickedness Stephen, and go sin no more.

As a Veteran for Obama I was

As a Veteran for Obama I was so glad to read this. You played your part against the Vietnam war, and many vets and Vietnamese appreciate that. Almost all the vets I know are dead set against the wars concocted by Cheney and Rumsfeld, especially the people disabled by the war. I also hope that Rahmbo, the new chief of staff, will be able to move a two state solution ahead in Israel. I know there is a long list of problems to solve and corruption to reverse, but that would change the world if it happened. Count me in for coalition building. That is what I believe in. Thanks.

McCain showed his blind

McCain showed his blind quest for power by selecting a VP running mate he had barely vetted. As it turned out he chose an ignorant, devisive woman who is an embarassment to intelligent women of all socio-economic and racial backgrounds. Together they tried to demonize a decent, well respected professor and author that has dedicated many years working for educational reform. His views are usually thought provoking and insightful, unlike Palin’s rants and meaningless right wing rhetoric.We are proud to personally know Bill and have the upmost regard and respect for him and Bernadine. They are outstanding parents and are well respected in their community. They are champions of educational causes and social justice and have worked tirelessly to help defend human rights. We’re sure that in his heart Obama shares these sentiments.

This is really the rest of

This is really the rest of the story

Thank you for writing this

Thank you for writing this article. It was something I'd hoped you'd do after the election -- knowing that anything you put out BEFORE the election would be abused and derided -- and you have not disappointed. It is all the more satisfying to read this after the election results since the McCain/Palin rabid dog strategy did not work as intended. It is heartening to hope that social justice just might spread and those of us who want to actually improve this country have a voice that is finally listened to by a president and administration working for all of us. I know I want to do everything I can to facilitate that and I suspect there are many others who feel the same.

"Bomb bomb bomb, bomb bomb

"Bomb bomb bomb, bomb bomb Iran." -- John McCain.

Thank you for this,

Thank you for this, something I can pass to my Grandchildren to give them a perspective for true patriotism and activism in their country.

Why isn't Bill Ayers suing

Why isn't Bill Ayers suing the asses off the Republican party?

Barack Obama is not a

Barack Obama is not a terrorist. He IS a revolutionary in the best sense of the word. William Ayers was never a terrorist. He was, however, a vandal with positive revolutionary intentions that just didn't pan out. If he'd commited the same actions for a republican cause he'd be branded a harmless prankster. Scary Palin, on the other hand, IS a terrorist with as many violent intentions as any other terrorist. Just because she hasn't done the dirty work herself does not mean that her vile intentions were not terrorist in nature when she knowingly used slanderous language as an attempt to incite violence against her oponent for her own political gain. "McCarthy in drag" is the perfect description.

Dr. Ayers, You seem

Dr. Ayers, You seem astounded that the 60s still play a role in national politics. I remind you that The civil war still plays a major role. Notice that the states John McCain and Sarah Palin won are predominantly former members of the confederacy. The 60s were a civil war of sorts, with the government (national Guard) killing protesting students. Obama's opponents allowed the end to justify the means in their eyes, which often causes more problems than it addresses. IN the end, they lost and that is what matters.

My dream: Mr. Ayers uses

My dream: Mr. Ayers uses his notoriety to denounce violence. Violence beget violence and hate begets hate. I understand the rage that led you to be a terrorist, but I believe you were sadly mistaken in your actions. As a VietNam war protestor, conscientious objector, and Peace Corp volunteer - and today a Vipassana meditator - I am convinced that violence will never create peace. I'm sad to say that some of the most violent and hate-filled people I have met in my life have been "anti-war protestors".

Thank you for helping to set

Thank you for helping to set the record straight. I don't agree with your past methods, but I deplore the attacks you suffered during this campaign season

I was a member of SDS in the

I was a member of SDS in the late 60's/early 70's. I never agreed with some of the violence though I did think the bombing, rebuilding and bombing of the statue in Chicago was quite farcical. And I certainly not apologetic about the causes I supported. I am now an unapologetic Christian who looks back on some of the causes of the 60's/70's with euphoric recall and sadness. There is a famous saying that goes, "Insanity is trying the same thing and expecting different results. We need to change the rhetoric and look at the realities. Many of the programs we all fought for have not worked. There certainly was nothing wrong, and people should actually be commended, for fighting those "wars". However hanging onto dreams that were never fulfilled is living in the past and ignoring reality. Yes, we should not give up the reason for a lot of those causes but we need new approaches. This comment section is too short to get into them all. Hanging onto the old ideas is not any better than all the arrows you are throwing at the Republicans (who deserve many of them). There is another line that goes, "If I am not the problem there is no solution!" Socialism, like supply side economics, is a great concept. But there is a major problem. There are human beings involved. Finally to give any kind of credibility to people who murder other people for their own purpose is insanity. There are Sunnis killing Shiites in Iraq for no purpose other than their doctrines are a bit different. That has absolutely nothing to do with the US (This is not a pro or anti war analysis). There are terrorists out there killing many other nationalities as well. This has nothing to do with US policy. The Israelis get blamed for the problems in Israel. But they didn't start three wars. They do not target innocent civilians. They are not the ones teaching their children to hate another nationality (ala the KKK). The Israelis have not left the negotiating table multiple times (By the way I negotiate as part of my career and if I could get 90% of what I ask for I would think I have died and gone to heaven.) Finally the Israelis are not the ones threatening to exterminate an entire group of people. Sorry for my rant but this is the idealist, non-realistic thinking I am talking about. It is not based on facts but some Utopian idea we have of the world. Bill Ayers, I wish you well and thank you for your contributions.. Sincerely, Bill gaffney

Just wanting to add my

Just wanting to add my thanks, Mr. Ayers. Who could have imagined, during the years we were involved in the peace movement during the Vietnam war, that the horrors of the past 8 years, (most of which continue unabated today) could have ever occurred? As the saying goes, "War is Terrorism".

I was totally opposed to the

I was totally opposed to the Vietnam War, but just as opposed to violent protest, which always adds to the hatred in this world. The Weather Underground may have fancied themselves freedom fighters, but I found their activities appalling. Bill Ayers has written an interesting article here, and being a believer in redemption, I was pleased to read that he is using his talents to do things far better than bomb-building. One question, though, Bill: Just exactly what DID you say on 9/11/2001, if you didn't refer to bombing the Pentagon and the Capitol and regretting that you "hadn't done more"?? Here's your chance to set the record straight.

That info's out there,

That info's out there, people. Here's what Bill Ayers said, acc. to Wikipedia; check it out: Much of the controversy about Ayers during the decade since 2000 stems from an interview he gave to The New York Times on the occasion of the memoir's publication.[25] The reporter quoted him as saying "I don't regret setting bombs" and "I feel we didn't do enough", and, when asked if he would "do it all again," as saying "I don't want to discount the possibility."[20] Ayers has not denied the quotes, but he protested the interviewer's characterizations in a Letter to the Editor published September 15, 2001: "This is not a question of being misunderstood or 'taken out of context', but of deliberate distortion."[26] In a November 2008 interview with The New Yorker, Ayers said that he had not meant to imply that he wished he and the Weathermen had committed further acts of violence. Instead, he said, β€œI wish I had done more, but it doesn’t mean I wish we’d bombed more shit.” Ayers said that he had never been responsible for violence against other people and was acting to end a war in Vietnam in which β€œthousands of people were being killed every week.” He also stated, "While we did claim several extreme acts, they were acts of extreme radicalism against property,” and β€œWe killed no one and hurt no one. Three of our people killed themselves.”[27]

I just wish that some of

I just wish that some of those posting, throwing stones,etc knew Bill Ayers as he is. Having spent moments with him, on my own and with children in the classroom, I can tell you that a more genuine soul does not exist. All the writing and talking and whirling around him seems very strange to me, based upon those moments I was priveleged to have. There isnt' even anything that he himself can write that would capture who he is. As Atticus Finch, the giant created by Harper Lee, told Scout, walk in a man's shoes if you want to know him. We need to all bear this in mind as we now have a leader who is our only chance at real movement toward the ideals the country aspires to, but remain out of our reach. I hope you read this, Bill, much love from Louisville, Kentucky!

Great article! Why was it

Great article! Why was it not made public BEFORE the ELECTION?

Thank you for reminding us

Thank you for reminding us to be vigilant. I just returned from Belize where our election was adopted as their own. What happiness we shared on November 5 learning about the results. The past 8 years have been difficult. We faced inaction and neglect on behalf of Katrina victims while we even had offers of help from Cuba while our president may have been clearing brush. I will never forget my Belize driver's comments while driving to the Belize airport. Hartfield stated that he became totally disappointed in the US government during the aftermath of the Katrina hurricane. He could never understand why a government would spend billions of dollars in war and totally neglect the victims of a hurricane. We have much to atone for what has taken place in the past 8 years. We have only just begun by electing a president who offers us hope. We are a good and generous country. Let us never entrust it to people who tarnish our good name while attempting to destroy those who speak the truth.

Let's hope that Obama is a

Let's hope that Obama is a terrorist like Ayers not McCain.

Not sure how we got here,

Not sure how we got here, but I'll pick this one up... "The Israelis get blamed for the problems in Israel. But they didn't start three wars. They do not target innocent civilians. They are not the ones teaching their children to hate another nationality (ala the KKK). The Israelis have not left the negotiating table multiple times (By the way I negotiate as part of my career and if I could get 90% of what I ask for I would think I have died and gone to heaven.) Finally the Israelis are not the ones threatening to exterminate an entire group of people." First of all, Your history appears to begin in 1967. Are you aware of how Israel came to be? Are you hip to building condos in the occupied territories? Are you understanding the immense struggles of a people living in basically tent cities? They're pissed and have been shit on over and over and over. And who wouldn't be? Can you imagine how much safer and happier the world would be if Isreal retreated to it's pre-'67 borders, declared a truce, shared Jerusalem, helped them become a Nation as they had done, and used it's vast wealth in good faith to help bring up the Palestinians' standard of living (heck they'd have new consumers for their stuff). Then the US could stop subsidizing their Military; Iran, Syria, Egypt et.al. would have less to bitch about, and we could all just get on with it? *poof* dream bubble bursts...

Bill -- on behalf of all

Bill -- on behalf of all Americans, and especially those who were hanging around during 'Nam and wishing that we were not involved in that foolishness, I would urge you to SUE all of those who were involved in the libel and slander of your good name. I'm a former college professor, and pretty liberal, but I never considered myself a Terrorist. And I really would be interested in seeing if these Public Officials are really able to defame Americans so recklessly. You would certainly get access to some of the finest legal minds in the world on this one. And it would maybe lay some shame on what those politico's might consider the low point in their politicking. You are Not a Willie Horton and it is inexcusable that they have acted this way.

1. Educators and parents

1. Educators and parents know that you are a dedicated teacher. 2. Progressives of all kinds, including the commentators here AND the Obamas (I trust) know that you are and have been a smart and hardworking progressive for many, many years. 3. Sarah Palin and her audience "know" that you are an unrepentant badguy and enemy. In addition, the McPailin campaign believed (foolishly, in the event) that you would make a terrific bogeyman. As did Hillary. So now, my brother, my question/opinion for the "movement that is always busy being born when its not busy dying.": Our traditional role has been to speak truth to power and anyone else who will listen. And to try to "make" truth- based realities (good schools, mobilized voters, collectives, etc, etc,). When that is compared to the pain and misery especially our country has created or helped along, many crazy and stupid things seem called for. You did some of those, and in a different mode so did I and many other folks. Some of us were able to recover from our fanaticism (as you know, others died or were destroyed -- perhaps with their own cooperation). So now -- among "us" -- you are a source of strength and encouragement -- and ideas. But what are your ideas for reaching Barack and the rest of tose who elected him? I.e. those who either believe the myths of American exceptionalism or believe that "realism" means not challenging it. The times, I expect, will be a'changin' even more in the next decade than they were in the Sixties. The election campaign could have -- but did not -- help prepare Americans for that. I will publish this letter at davichon.wordpress.com

I speak for myself as one,

I speak for myself as one, and I believe we are all a recovering violent people. We have in the last 40 years come to the mind-numbing realization that violence is a useless strategy for resolving conflict in a media-shrunken world, that communication IS. Mr. Ayers has evolved, we all have evolved (well, with a few exceptions), and we are just beginning to grasp the true meaning of non-violence. To "face history fully and honestly," as he says, to have a truth and reconciliation event, to support the horrifying grief that must necessarily ensue, is our next step toward recovery from violence as a conflict-resolution strategy. Have we ever made amends for Hiroshima and Nagasaki? The true amends is to shoot all the nuclear weapons into the sun.