Opinion

Facebook DIGG

Cause for Alarm

by: Bob Herbert  |  Visit article original @ The New York Times

photo
Soldiers' coffins being transported back to the US.
(Photo: Tami Silicio / The Seattle Times)

    Beaches, barbecues and flags as big as baseball fields. Fireworks as loud as thunder lighting the nighttime sky. Hot fun, as Sly & the Family Stone would say, in the summertime.

    Friday was the 232nd anniversary of the adoption of the Declaration of Independence. Celebrations were ubiquitous. HBO offered a marathon telecast of its John Adams series. Bands of wildly varying quality, from one coast to the other, let loose with "The Star-Spangled Banner," "America the Beautiful" and "The Stars and Stripes Forever."

    It was a July Fourth like many others. There was nothing overt to signal anything was wrong. The Red Sox had traveled from Boston to play a weekend series against the Yankees in the Bronx. In Washington, the National Independence Day Parade made its way along Constitution Avenue.

    And yet, there was an undercurrent of anxiety in the land. Vacations have been curtailed because of the price of fuel. Since the holiday fell on a Friday, the monthly unemployment numbers from the Bureau of Labor Statistics were released a day early, on Thursday. They weren't good. The Times summed things up with a Page 1 headline:

"Outlook Darker as Jobs Are Lost and Wages Stall."

    The high and the low were being buffeted. The bad news bears were loose on Wall Street, and the prospects for the summer employment of teenagers were abysmal. The national employment rate for teens in June was the lowest in 60 years.

    But the anxiety seems more intense than the usual concern for a cyclical economic downturn. Something fundamental seems to have gone haywire. David Boren, a former U.S. senator who is now president of the University of Oklahoma, has written a short book that he called, "A Letter to America."

    His sense of alarm in the opening paragraph could not have been clearer. "The country we love is in trouble," he said. "In truth, we are in grave danger of declining as a nation. If we do not act quickly, that decline will become dramatic."

    I couldn't agree more. The symbols of patriotism - bumper stickers and those flags the size of baseball fields - have taken the place of the hard work and sacrifice required to keep a great nation great.

    You know that matters have gotten out of hand when, as we learned this week, American instructors at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba, gave classes on torture techniques used by the Communists to extract false testimony from American prisoners during the Korean War.

    Talk about defining deviancy down! As Al Gore reminds us, this is the first time in American history that "the executive branch of the government has not only condoned but actively promoted the treatment of captives in wartime that clearly involves torture, thus overturning a prohibition established by Gen. George Washington during the Revolutionary War."

    There are signs galore of the nation's turn for the worse. We are fighting a debilitating war in Iraq without any idea of how to pay for it - or how to end it. No one has any real idea about how to cope with the devastating energy crisis, or how to turn the economy around.

    The airline industry is a first-class mess and the knees of the General Motors colossus have buckled. Locks are being changed on foreclosed homes across the country and working families lucky enough to meet their mortgages are watching the value of their homes decline.

    We can build spectacular new stadiums for football and baseball teams (the Yanks, the Mets, the Giants and the Jets are all getting ready to move into staggeringly expensive new homes) but we can't rebuild New Orleans or reconstruct the World Trade Center site destroyed almost seven years ago.

    This year's presidential election is the perfect opportunity to place the truth before the American public in the form of a realistic examination of the state of the nation, and an honest consideration of creative ideas for moving forward. Instead, we're getting hour after hour and day after day of trivia: Who's up? Who's down? Who's patriotic? Who's not?

    Mr. Boren believes that the combination of unrestrained partisanship and the corrosive influence of big money have all but paralyzed the political process. He worries about the neglect of the nation's infrastructure, about the growing divide between the very wealthy and everyone else, and about "the catastrophic drop in the way the rest of the world views us."

    The U.S., with its enormous economic and military power, is still better-positioned than any other country to set the standards for the 21st century. But that power and leadership potential were not granted by divine right and cannot be wasted indefinitely.

    Patriotism has its place. But waving a flag is never a good substitute for serious thought and rolling up one's sleeves.

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Yet another "we're goin

Yet another "we're goin down" op-ed without a single suggestion as to how We The People are to reverse course when, for the first time in our history, the two major political "parties," the mightiest military in the universe, the entire Judicial Branch, and Big Corp Everything have melded into a single unit. Even the "Founding Fathers" didn't see that one coming. BH is a fine writer, but this repetitive presentation of "the facts of the case" to the choir without the inclusion of actionable solutions is a waste of time and suggest that even he can't admit the truth: there is literally nothing WTP can do short of all out violent revolution.

I like the quote,

I like the quote, "Patriotism has its place. But waving a flag is never a good substitute for serious thought and rolling up one's sleeves." Unfortunately there are many in this country, witness the hoo hah about lapel pins (made in China by the way), for whom patriotism begins and ends with symbolism. Sacrifice is for suckers. This attitude began with the Reagan administration when he took down Carter's solar panels in the White House and it has grown ever since. It flowered when Bush told people to go shopping instead of going into wartime mode. Now it has replaced real patriotism on all the major news outlets and also on Fox TV. It has festered in the "support the troops" decals on vehicles (also made in China) while sticking it to the soldiers and marines who have been killed and injured.

Thank you for writing and

Thank you for writing and posting this eloquent reality check to the faux-patriotism of Karl Rove. Patriotism means constructively criticizing the current, tragic state of affairs - because we love America. Senator Boren's book clearly deserves a wider audience! We need to insist that patriotism means constructive criticism of misguided, delusional, and self-destructive policies. From invading Iraq on faulty intelligence and based on wrong assumptions to ignoring the threats to New Orleans and mismanaging the response to Katrina, the Bush administration has weakened our nation in deed and words. We must focus the debate on these harmful actions, even if done out sincere delusions, and emphasize that these policies have hurt America. We don't call Bush "anti-American" and we reject any attempt for Republicans to call our far wiser, more compassionate and enlightened policies "anti-American" too. Let's rediscover some enlightenment values during our July 4th celebrations! If we can avoid the cultural quicksand of faux-patriotism and insist on the need for sacrifice and hardwork, then we should win a huge landslide.

Not so sure, Frank1569.

Not so sure, Frank1569. While violent revolution is the extreme of the extreme, there are a rare few alternatives. Here's one for you, and it should appeal to a lot of the clueless in the US. Simply put -- do nothing. Kind of what we are doing anyway, only with a real purpose this time. By this I mean -- a national general strike. Everyone literally stays home until one condition is met: "they" all leave Washington. Nothing moves, gets bought or sold, receives services until every one of the current Administration and Congress resigns, and is replaced by state caucuses back home, where the pressure would be equally required. It would require great preparation, and a willingess to sacrifice and support one another, perhaps for a long time. But would an all-out "violent revolution" require any less?

I like the suggestion above

I like the suggestion above for a "do-nothing" revolution, in other words a national strike until the traitors in the administration are IMPEACHED NOW before the election so the harm they do may be somewhat minimized or at least shortened Stay home with the family. play sand lot baseball, start a neighborhood scrabble contest, visit local museums and rec centers, buy nothing, sell nothing, dig in your heels.

To Dave K: The Do-Nothing

To Dave K: The Do-Nothing Revolution - as opposed to the All Out Violent revolution. I believe that a national general strike as Dave suggests would be a very potent means to bring the US to a national sense of responsibility and sanity and I am currently practicing this revolution.

Bob is a great REPORTER and

Bob is a great REPORTER and he gets it all correct. To bad he's one of the few. We have a mass of media filled with REPEATERS. What we need is more FACT CHECKERS and context, so we can at least have an honest debate. For all that's worth. By the time the Federal Reserve and their henchmen who sit on the boards of the multi nationals along with their cronnies in goverment we will all wind up, well you figure it out if you can. They got us all so dumbed down with BS and petty crap, like Obama said we're left trying to hold on to the two things we think are divinely ours. Guns and God. And while we do were getting our pockets picked. We are toast. We've been warned numerous times,including by two great Presidents, Eisenhower and Kennedy, but we just didn't listen.

Change begins by first

Change begins by first acknowledging the problem. The issues are bigger than any one of us individually, but by finding creative ways to pool our energies, and by embarrassing those in power to do the right thing, we can chip away at the rot that has eaten America from the inside. America wasn't conquered, it simply rotted from within to the point of increasing collapse. Politicians and Big Money - take note. Here are loosly 10 concrete steps to restore America: 1)Immediately restore the Bill of Rights and the US Constitution. Make violating or failing to defend the US Constitution a high crime 2) Impeach Bush & Cheney immediately and place Bush's Supreme Court appointees on notice. Those suspected guilty of High Crimes should not be allowed to appoint anyone to our Legal System. Even if they are the President of the United States. 3) Delete the portions of the Patriot Act that promote fascism. Even if that means all of it, and ban torture 4) Criminalize lobbying and lobbyists, move them out of DC permanently. 5) Penalize financial black holes in the Pentagon Budget and force them to balance their books under the Congressional light of day. 6)Bring Anti-trust action against Big Money mergers, to re-diversify the banks, big media, telecommunications, and restore the Fairness Doctrine, 7) Restore "energy" to the list of regulatory responsibilities of the CFTC. 8) Create tax incentives and other motivations for products, services and works which place human priorities above profit. 9) Implement Universal health care, while banning profit motive from healthcare. 10) Make war profiteering a Federal offence with stiff penalties. No one should profit from killing and maiming others. Create a department of Government Integrity and Oversight Anyone else have a top 10 steps to restore our country?

THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION 2.0

THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION 2.0 The American Revolution 2.0 is a revolution in our thinking and has no leaders, no headquarters and no groups involved what so ever (we provide no targets to be discredited or warmed). The Revolution is made up of individual U.S. citizens who believe our country is in trouble and who only want to restore the United States of America back to the country it was intended to be. A country that we can be proud of and trust. These new (2.0) revolutionaries all agree to the following: #1 that we need to immediately go back to our Constitution and the Rule of Law (Real Law as outlined in the Constitution, not lobbied Profit law, Spy law or Torture law). #2 that we need to immediately create a separation of Corporation (Money) and State. Further, we will no longer tolerate citizens who attempt to one day profit from their government service in any direct or indirect way. Our government is no longer for sale! #3 that we need to immediately transition the Defense (& war), Energy (& water), Health, Insurance and News Media industries into the non-profit sector of our economy. We do this because we believe a profit motive in these industries causes great conflicts of interest and is not the proper or best way to handle those needs. We further note that these industries have basically now become our government (our rulers) and we know they will fight tooth and nail to avoid the changes that are necessary for the future our country and the world. Acting as individuals, we will each do our part to convince others of the importance of our mission and slowly but surely amass ourselves. We don't think this will be easy, but we'll prevail in the end because we know that more than anything else...they fear our agreement (on anything). We together, have the true power and they know it. So why don't we roll up our sleeves now and get the "cool revolution" going!

I think that one of the best

I think that one of the best things we can do is to study an ethic called "servant-leadership". this phrase was coined by Robert Greenleaf, and there are many in the field of management theory who practice and promote it. We need leaders whose main goal is to serve their "followers". And the best way to grow them is to do it from the ground up. This means teaching our own children about the need to serve the greater good, and we need to begin in our home towns to elect servant leaders. Begin at home, then spread to state capitals, then, finally, to the federal government. It will indeed be a long and slow process, but it offers us the hope that we can change the nature of our politics, and of our country.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.