Opinion

China Has Already Lost the Olympic Games

»

by: Favilla's Chronicles, Les Échos

photo
Chinese athlete Liu Xiang at the Prefontaine Classic track and field meet in Eugene, Oregon, June 8, 2008. Favilla's Chronicles' authors maintain that - whatever happens during the Beijing Olympics - the Chinese regime has already lost in terms of the world's regard. (Photo: Don Ryan / AP Photo)

    The Olympic Games begin Friday. No one doubts that the opening ceremony will be perfectly organized, that the fireworks will be the most beautiful in the world since the French Revolution's bicentenary on July 14, 1989, that Beijing will display absolute technical mastery in the implementation of a world-famous event.

    But we knew all that in advance. When the IOC entrusted China with the organization of the 2008 Games, that country had already emerged from its two centuries' hibernation to enter into the cycle of the most mind-boggling economic and technological catch-up in the history of capitalism. Consequently, any risk that China would not be up to hosting the Olympic event was approximately zero.

    On the other hand, the Chinese regime had much to show in other domains. Well, now we've seen quite a bit. First of all, the television viewer has been able to observe himself what all visitors to the region have experienced: the very high pollution level of the Chinese capital - one indicator of the low priority the Chinese regime assigns ecological aspects of development. Aware of the bad image a thick haze floating over Beijing on the world's television screens could give, the authorities made the astounding decision to stop all factories' operation during the Olympic period. The result for air quality is mediocre; on the other hand, the regime has demonstrated urbi et orbi that a dictatorship may subject all economic actors to its most capricious ukases.

    Then, given the commitments made to the IOC, we could have hoped that China would manage the human rights question during this period with a little bit of subtlety. Instead, we've been treated to a festival of repression, from massive removal to the shadows of Tibetan - or just plain democratic - dissidents, to rejection of certain journalists' visas, by way of the variable geometry employed to block Internet sites and the transformation of Beijing into a city under a state of siege with tanks and missile batteries as though the Uighur militants had become an imminent danger within the last month ... up to and including the Monday attack attributed to those militants.

    Finally, "last but not least," China's ambassador to Paris took the liberty of adding arrogance to impropriety by threatening France with celestial thunderbolts should the president of the Republic dare to receive the Dalai Lama.

    Before this Olympic episode, China's image in the whole world was almost entirely colored by its exceptional economic success. In a few weeks, the country has committed all the mistakes on the political field that lead it to appear as a dictatorship first of all and as an economic giant only secondarily. The Games will surely be a magnificent spectacle; but for China, they are already lost.

    --------

    Translation: Truthout French language editor Leslie Thatcher.

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

The picture of Mao Tse Tung

The picture of Mao Tse Tung on chinese money should say it all: A ruthless dictatorship would kill 30 million of it's own citizens for political expediency.

In terms of technical and

In terms of technical and organizations drama, the opening ceremonies were a success. Understating this won't help those who wish to advocate for transparency in China. The U.S. could not have pulled off that kind of human cooperation, in my opinion. The Chinese people are largely well-fed, literate, and disciplines to a pretty remarkable degree. The leadership is corrupt. Where is this not true? Isn't it a question of having enough healthy individuals that the corrupt leadership can't control everything any more, the under-the-radar phenomenon by which good people here have to get any improvements in anything? Cheers.

There is a lesson here for

There is a lesson here for those governments with fascist tendencies on how to have millions of visitors, put on a spectacular show and yet still maintain control. When we complain about Chinese ecological degradation, we forget that China is now the world's factory. The dirty well paying jobs that used to be here are gone to China. WE are busily transferring our jobs and money to China. In return we get cheap goods, buying of US bonds and pollution.

China has enabled the

China has enabled the genocide in Sudan, supported the military dictatorship of Burma, and polluted our planet on a huge scale. Most people do not realize that the power for Chinese manufacture of cheap toys and cheap clothing comes from the burning of dirty coal. One product of the burning is a total of 700 tons of mercury, the toxic metal that goes around the world, into our air, water, land -- and the fish that we eat. American power plants are designed to stop the mercury -- but this costs more. China chose not to spend the money.

I have no doubt that the

I have no doubt that the Chinese government is very good at suppressing information from outside (and dissident information from within) China. I think a more important question is whether the people understand that they are being kept from outside information. In the US, the people do not think they are being kept from anything, and thus the wall against the outside doesn't have to be very complete. If the Chinese people know they are being deceived, no wall will be strong enough.

"The most amazing--and

"The most amazing--and ironic--characteristic of this government is its ability to suppress information from outside the country." This statement is also applicable to USA.

A reader of this article

A reader of this article should not presume the Chinese people themselves will learn about the government's bludering. The most amazing--and ironic--characeristic of this government is its ability to suppress information from outside the country. To more than a billion people, the Olympic Games in Beijing are a roaring success.