News

Democrats Waver Over Offshore Drilling Ban

»

by: Paul Harris, The Observer UK

photo
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has signaled she is open to a vote on offshore drilling. (Photo: Los Angeles Times)

     Under fire from Republicans, top Democratic politicians in the United States are considering lifting a ban on new offshore oil drilling.

    The issue is now at the forefront of the presidential election, as Republican candidate John McCain has made allowing new drilling one of the centrepieces of his campaign, claiming that it will help drive down petrol prices.

    Democrats have hitherto said new drilling would do little to relieve consumer pain at the pump, accusing Republicans of misleading the public
and being a pawn of big oil companies. Yet signs are emerging that they are easing their opposition to the comprehensive ban.

    Last week House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said she would consider allowing a congressional vote on the issue if drilling was part of a wider energy plan that also focused on promoting alternative energy sources. Pelosi told a television interviewer that she would consider a vote, but 'it has to be part of something that says we want to bring immediate relief to the public, and not just a hoax'.

    More than 30 Democrats have signed up to sponsors legislation that could pave the way for fresh drilling off America's coasts. Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama has also moderated his stance, moving from staunch opposition to suggesting that new drilling could be part of a new energy strategy. That shift led to accusations from some of his supporters that he had flip-flopped.

    A group of politicians from both parties, dubbed the 'Gang of 10', has proposed a mixed strategy of new drilling and alternative energy, which could gather wide support.

    Yet plans for any fresh off-shore drilling have outraged environmentalists. They believe it will take years to develop any oil reserves and that the move represents nothing more than a bonanza for an oil industry that already gets huge tax breaks. They also believe it will eventually pave the way for drilling in ecologically sensitive areas, such as parts of Alaska.

    But the issue has become a problem for the Democrats after McCain enthusiastically embraced the idea. In the unusual setting of a massive biker rally in the small town of Sturis, South Dakota, the Republican recently told a cheering crowd: 'We're going to drill here and we're going to drill now!' It is a line that has since been repeated on the campaign trail and has struck a chord with those parts of the American public for whom high petrol prices are the key concern. It certainly threw Democrats off-balance, as they tried to push a more balanced energy policy with longer-term aims of reducing oil use.

    But energy policy has rapidly become the hot topic of the election, overtaking even Iraq or Georgia. In a country whose cultural and economic life is dominated by the car, there are no more passionate debates than over the doubling of petrol prices in the past couple of years.

    It has offered hard-nosed Republican campaigners an issue to rally around and a stick with which to beat an Obama campaign that has started to make rare missteps. In one recent incident Obama mentioned that, if Americans kept their tyres inflated correctly, it would save petrol consumption and reduce the need for drilling. The comment was factually true, but was seized on by Republicans, who carried out numerous stunts, such as delivering tyre gauges to reporters on the campaign trail. It became a powerful theme on conservative talk radio, where hosts lampooned Obama and accused him of putting tyre pressure at the forefront of his energy policy.

    In fact, the energy debate has enlivened a Republican party that has recently seemed moribund beside the huge and well-run Obama operation. It has allowed the party to attack the Democrats and set the agenda of the recent political debate, giving Republican activists a sense of hope.

    'This is a narrow race. Obama has a solid edge, but it is still close,' said Professor Shawn Bowler, a political scientist at the University of California at Riverside. The polls are bearing that out. As the party convention season looms, the RCP national average of polls has Obama ahead by just three points. In the battleground states the picture is mixed, with McCain ahead in Missouri, Virginia and Florida, and Obama leading in Ohio, Michigan and Colorado.

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

I am appalled and disgusted

I am appalled and disgusted at even a second's faltering on offshore drilling. What is with the Democrats - shame shame shame. This year I have 4 grandchildren coming into voting age. One is working diligently for Obama. We must consider them. Offshore is not even a viable alternative. I personally am investing in hemp and solar. Please stop selling out as we are talking of the future of the planet. Ms. Pelosi, whom I have long admired has lost votes of friends in San Francisco to Cindy Sheehan. What happened to you Nancy?

Oil pulls strings in DC, not

Oil pulls strings in DC, not us. Revolt.

Let's get real. The american

Let's get real. The american electorate does not care about real issues, they care more about cheap gas, cheap hamburgers and cheap shots. Who cares that Obama is the best hope for real change. Nobody is listening. The way to win an election is to wave the flag, appeal to people's lowest intincts, keep them ignorant and scare them into believing anything that corporate america wants them to believe. Looking at the state of nation and the world and what the Republicans have done, it is incredible that anyone would still vote against their own best interests and put them back in power. I think it is time for a reality check. "There is no way that this winter is ever going to end as long as this groundhog keeps seeing his shadow."---Phil Connors.

Joel Rosenblum has it

Joel Rosenblum has it totally right! The democRATS do not deserve our vote. If you vote the lesser of two evils, you still get evil; if you "hold your nose" it still stinks. VOTE THIRD PARTY!

Actually We the people,

Actually We the people, DON'T deserve any better! Sure Nancy and other democratic politicians are spineless. What else is new? To their credit, these democrats are still not saying they WANT offshore drilling, they still say its a bad idea and will do nothing for oil prices.But if 85% of We the people don't care or are fool enough to fall for ANY stupid line the republican trot out after ALL they've put us through these last 7 years, then why in the world would Nancy and her democrats martyr themselves for a mere principle (and lose out on all those contributions Hess is holding out)? And gay marriage will trump dolphins as a campaign issue any day. If this is the best that evolution has managed to produce after billions of years, then the world doesn't deserve any better either.

What are we thinking! Has

What are we thinking! Has anyone seen the Hardy film about dolphins and how the oceans are becoming big sewage dumps! Are we going to kill off all the wonderful wildlife and wilderness with our panic over gasoline? No one paying any attention to our global warming? Anyone care about the polar bears and caribou when they want to drill in Alaska, too? Don't we care whether our children will be able to breathe, have clean water. I am so outraged at this greedy grab when the time and money could be spent on alternative energy? If you believe in God, do you think He put all these beautiful creatures on earth (including us 2-leggeds) to see them suffocate, starve, poison our lungs, etc etc. WAKE UP, AMERICA

Nancy needs to learn a few

Nancy needs to learn a few facts from her Santa Barbara neighbors, who could tell her plenty about the misery of oil rigs in the ocean that slop gooey filth on the beach. It looks as though she just held a finger up and thought the wind was blowing her way from the vast inland public, which seems to have been totally bamboozled by the Republican oil-pushers and other assorted phonies. She needs to grow a brain as well as a spine. So do other Democrats making the wrong noises on this subject, including Barak. Bi-partisanship is wonderful -- until you wake up and find that you're in bed with crooks, liars, and other assorted felons, to whom you gave up all control.

The Republicans are

The Republicans are demogagues. Standing the outer hallway of the House chamber raiing against Nancy Pelosi for adjourning congress before allowing off-shower drilling, portraying such a move as the answer to the oil shortage and gas prices, is specious. Where were they with a solution to this mounting problem when they were in power and could convene the congress? Why did they wait till Democrats got a narrow majority to cry fowl. I cry fowl at them. Republicans, in congress and the administration brought us the highest gas prices in history, brought us a perpetual war, with torture, preemptive war, and the biggest deficit in history. Now off-shore drilling is the solution to all this?/

This is the predicted

This is the predicted consequence of our political and media systems staying quiet about Peak Oil. The US "peaked" in oil extraction in 1970, just as M. King Hubbert predicted in 1956. The world is at peak, now. Most of the "offshore" areas in the US that actually have oil are already being drilled - off the coast of Texas and Louisiana. Most of the areas NOT being drilled don't have oil, or have very little oil (barely enough to justify the enormous expense). The Saudis are increasing "offshore" drilling in the Gulf - a clear sign that the easier to get oil that is on shore is winding down. It is sad that most of the "progressives" and liberal Democrats and even most of the "alternative media" have done little or no education about the geological realities of oil supplies. Now we see the consequences. Politicians like to tell the voters there will be "more." Peak Oil means that the future will be "less." It's a bummer, so it was ignored. Now, it's harder to ignore, but the D's have decided they would rather have the R's frame the issue rather than talk about Peak Oil and the limits to endless growth on a finite planet.

This latest travesty of

This latest travesty of Democrats folding to the big oil industry and the Bush administration regarding drilling will really hurt the Democratic party. This disunity in the Democratic when it comes to issues will give the presidency to John McCain and his cronies in Nov. Is there any hope for a real change? From what so many of us are witnessing it will take a miracle to get a Democratic President that has the spine to stand up and represent the people instead of greedy corporate interests.

Impeachment, Iraq war, civil

Impeachment, Iraq war, civil liberties, socialized bank losses, and now drilling. Abject surrender by the Dem leaders, Obama included. Dems stand for nothing but the easiest reelection possible. And the Rabid Right just plunders and loots the country and the average people, attacks the Constitution, makes illegal war,and so on, and the Dems roll over for them. The whole political scene/ process is a farce.

I figured it would

I figured it would eventually come to this, considering that both the Democrats and the Republicans are securely in the pockets of the oil companies. And it will continue to be this way until the American people get good and angry enough to force a bill that demands public financing of elections. Until that happens, it will be business as usual.

I wonder how it is going

I wonder how it is going cleaning up that gigantic oil spill on the Mississippi river. They screwed the Alaskans on the Exxon Valdez mess, is that cleaned up yet? There is an oil spill in Brooklyn that they have been trying to clean up for over 50 years now, and they say it might take another 50. So we drill more, put more hydrocarbons in the atmosphere, and the hurricanes get worse, knocking down the new oil platforms they just put up. I cannot believe the dems are buying into the "hoax". I hope they scrap all of it once they are elected. It will probably take more than an all democratic government to put the oil companies in their place. I truly believe the oil companies are doing way more damage than the terrorists, if in fact the terrorists aren't working for the oil companies.

Leaving climate issues

Leaving climate issues aside,let’s suppose for the moment that oil can be safely extracted from environmentally sensitive areas, and that we resolve to pump them dry as quickly as possible. What then? Should we drill now, worry later (presuming we really have that choice) or decide to plan for a not so distant future?

Suggests there are two

Suggests there are two parties: Republocrats and Dempublicans.

Then the Dems wonder why

Then the Dems wonder why they lose. It's because they let the Republicans define every issue. If the Dems were right (and they were) that offshore drilling wouldn't help gas prices, they should have maintained their position and explained it. Backtracking just makes them look like they never really understood the issue and now they are coming late to the game that the Republicans already lead on. To win, you have to lead, not follow those who lead. Just more proof that the Dems don't deserve our votes. Vote Nader or McKinney.

What happened to Nancy

What happened to Nancy Pelosi's backbone? I was all for her, but I'm disenchanted now. We the people, deserve better!

Ye gods, what else is new.

Ye gods, what else is new. No wonder so many people are turned off on both parties. I don't know which is worse, the evil doer or the enabler.

The current democRAT

The current democRAT leadership is totally bankrupt and needs to be replaced with leaders that will fight for principle, not roll over at he first whiff of gunpowder. If they do not stand up for their constituants, then third party candidates will take away enough votes to hand them their third defeat in a row and America will endure 4 more of McBush. It is hard to imagine that the DNC is that stupid, but it appears that they are. The convention should be interesting. The cops may have to set up holding cages inside the Pepsi Center to incarcerate irate progressives!

Offshore drilling. Sounds

Offshore drilling. Sounds good. However, there's that little element called "greed" that so often intrudes. Corporations have to buy leases to drill offshore. They can sell these leases to the highest bidders. Most of the offshore drilling will turn into just another get rich scheme of speculation, and most of these offshore drilling leases will never be drilled--just sold and re-sold. So I don't think it's going to solve anything except make the rich oil corporations a lot richer and the poor American people even poorer. What we need to do to solve the oil crisis is to get off oil. Period. That's not going to be easy, but Americans are resourceful when necessary. The Green Channel on Dish Network TV is a great channel to learn about alternative energy. So is Mother Earth News magazine and Backwoods Home magazine. I'm saving up for a solar oven. Actor Ed Begley, Jr. cooks a lot in a solar oven. It's not much, but it's a start. You just set it up outside, give it a lot of time, and cook. Free--no electricity, no gas, just free old sunshine. After that--who knows? My brother is working on constructing a home methane tank. If he doesn't blow himself up in the process, he wants to make methane gas to cook with. I'm still out on that one...

Too bad about Ms. Pelosi,

Too bad about Ms. Pelosi, selling out her constituency since day one and all. Gee, impeachment off the table and now drilling everywhere on the table? Cindy Sheehan gets my vote, anyday...