News

Ex-Press Aide Writes That Bush Misled US on Iraq

»

by: Michael D. Shear, The Washington Post

photo
Former White House press secretary Scott McClellan speaking to the media on board Air Force One in 2006. In his new memoir, McClellan has charged that President George W. Bush was not "open and forthright on Iraq" and relied on "propaganda" to sell the war. (Photo: AFP/File/Tim Sloan)

    Former White House press secretary Scott McClellan writes in a new memoir that the Iraq war was sold to the American people with a sophisticated "political propaganda campaign" led by President Bush and aimed at "manipulating sources of public opinion" and "downplaying the major reason for going to war."

    McClellan includes the charges in a 341-page book, "What Happened: Inside the Bush White House and Washington's Culture of Deception," that delivers a harsh look at the White House and the man he served for close to a decade.
He describes Bush as demonstrating a "lack of inquisitiveness," says the White House operated in "permanent campaign" mode, and admits to having been deceived by some in the president's inner circle about the leak of a CIA operative's name.

    The book, coming from a man who was a tight-lipped defender of administration aides and policy, is certain to give fuel to critics of the administration, and McClellan has harsh words for many of his past colleagues. He accuses former White House adviser Karl Rove of misleading him about his role in the CIA case. He describes Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice as being deft at deflecting blame, and he calls Vice President Cheney "the magic man" who steered policy behind the scenes while leaving no fingerprints.

    McClellan stops short of saying that Bush purposely lied about his reasons for invading Iraq, writing that he and his subordinates were not "employing out-and-out deception" to make their case for war in 2002.

    But in a chapter titled "Selling the War," he alleges that the administration repeatedly shaded the truth and that Bush "managed the crisis in a way that almost guaranteed that the use of force would become the only feasible option."

    "Over that summer of 2002," he writes, "top Bush aides had outlined a strategy for carefully orchestrating the coming campaign to aggressively sell the war.... In the permanent campaign era, it was all about manipulating sources of public opinion to the president's advantage."

    McClellan, once a staunch defender of the war from the podium, comes to a stark conclusion, writing, "What I do know is that war should only be waged when necessary, and the Iraq war was not necessary."

    McClellan resigned from the White House on April 19, 2006, after nearly three years as Bush's press secretary. The departure was part of a shake-up engineered by new Chief of Staff Joshua B. Bolten that also resulted in Rove surrendering his policy-management duties.

    A White House spokeswoman declined to comment on the book, some contents of which were first disclosed by Politico.com. The Washington Post acquired a copy of the book yesterday, in advance of its official release Monday.

    Responding to a request for comment, McClellan wrote in an e-mail: "Like many Americans, I am concerned about the poisonous atmosphere in Washington. I wanted to take readers inside the White House and provide them an open and honest look at how things went off course and what can be learned from it. Hopefully in some small way it will contribute to changing Washington for the better and move us beyond the hyper-partisan environment that has permeated Washington over the past 15 years."

    The criticism of Bush in the book is striking, given that it comes from a man who followed him to Washington from Texas.

    Bush is depicted as an out-of-touch leader, operating in a political bubble, who has stubbornly refused to admit mistakes. McClellan defends the president's intellect - "Bush is plenty smart enough to be president," he writes - but casts him as unwilling or unable to be reflective about his job.

    "A more self-confident executive would be willing to acknowledge failure, to trust people's ability to forgive those who seek redemption for mistakes and show a readiness to change," he writes.

    In another section, McClellan describes Bush as able to convince himself of his own spin and relates a phone call he overheard Bush having during the 2000 campaign, in which he said he could not remember whether he had used cocaine. "I remember thinking to myself, 'How can that be?'" he writes.

    The former aide describes Bush as a willing participant in treating his presidency as a permanent political campaign, run in large part by his top political adviser, Rove.

    "The president had promised himself that he would accomplish what his father had failed to do by winning a second term in office," he writes. "And that meant operating continually in campaign mode: never explaining, never apologizing, never retreating. Unfortunately, that strategy also had less justifiable repercussions: never reflecting, never reconsidering, never compromising. Especially not where Iraq was concerned."

    McClellan has some kind words for Bush, calling him "a man of personal charm, wit and enormous political skill." He writes that the president "did not consciously set out to engage in these destructive practices. But like others before him, he chose to play the Washington game the way he found it, rather than changing the culture as he vowed to do at the outset of his campaign for the presidency."

    McClellan charges that the campaign-style focus affected Bush's entire presidency. The ill-fated Air Force One flyover of New Orleans, after Hurricane Katrina struck the city, was conceived of by Rove, who was "thinking about the political perceptions" but ended up making Bush look "out of touch," he writes.

    He says the White House's reaction to Katrina was more than just a public relations disaster, calling it "a failure of imagination and initiative" and the result of an administration that "let events control us." He adds: "It was a costly blunder."

    McClellan admits to letting himself be deceived about the unmasking of CIA operative Valerie Plame Wilson, which resulted in his relentless pounding by the White House press corps over the activities of Rove and of Cheney aide I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby in the matter.

    "I could feel something fall out of me into the abyss as each reporter took a turn whacking me," he writes of the withering criticism he received as the story played out. "It was my reputation crumbling away, bit by bit." He also suggests that Rove and Libby may have worked behind closed doors to coordinate their stories about the Plame leak. Late last year, McClellan's publisher released an excerpt of the book that suggested Bush had knowledge of the leak, something that won McClellan no friends in the administration.

    As McClellan departed the White House, he said: "Change can be helpful, and this is a good time and good position to help bring about change. I am ready to move on."

    He choked up as he told Bush on the South Lawn, "I have given it my all, sir, and I have given you my all."

    Bush responded at the time: "He handled his assignments with class, integrity. He really represents the best of his family, our state and our country. It's going to be hard to replace Scott."

    --------

    Staff writer Michael Abramowitz contributed to this report.

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

Scott McClellan Does A Hans

Scott McClellan Does A Hans Fritzsche Hans Fritzsche, Chief of the Nazi Propaganda Ministry's Radio Division. Nuremberg War Crimes Trial, 1946 "Between these criminals and myself there is only one connection: they merely misused me in a different way than they misused those who became their physical victims." "In really serious questions of policy and the conduct of war I did not commit a single falsification and did not consciously tell a single lie." "But decisive for such a news machine is not the detail but the final fundamental basis on which propaganda is built. Decisive is the belief in the incorruptibility of the leaders of the State, on which every journalist must rely, and this basis is shaken by what has become known today of mass murders, of senseless atrocities and by the doubt in the honesty of Hitler's protestations for peace." "I am convinced that Hitler and at least some of his colleagues had deliberately lied to the people, in some important instances, right from the beginning of their political career, and, something that is not so important to history, I personally consider that, on these points, I have been deceived." "The main guilt of people such as Fritzsche is that they did know the actual state of affairs, but despite this, proceeding according to the criminal intentions of the Hitler Government, intentionally fed the people with lies or, to use an everyday expression, 'threw dust in their eyes.'" ~ Ferdinand Schoerner

Can't wait for Rove's

Can't wait for Rove's tell-all book. On second thought, yes, I can.

Texas is not Hillbilly

Texas is not Hillbilly country. Hillbilly and White Trash are two different breeds.

So tell me something I

So tell me something I didn't already know.

Senators and Congressmen

Senators and Congressmen that sat on their respective fat asses while watching the Bush administration destroy what was once the most respected country on the planet - should be impeached along with the perp-in-chief and his criminal cartel of Rove, Cheney, Rummie, Rice, Wolfie, Perle et al. Then and only then will real justice be served.

This sinking ship must be

This sinking ship must be running out of rats!!!

hopefully others will come

hopefully others will come forward now. i'm tired of being ashamed of being an american, of living in a country where insanity reigns and i'm mad as hell. have been for many years. bush may be smart, but he's still a vile incompetent oaf.

Another lying cult member

Another lying cult member confesses, gets rich, and yet remains un-indicted for the aiding and abetting of the high crimes and misdemeanors that resulted in the deaths and maiming of millions of innocents and tens of thousands of US military personnel. Everybody now: We're Number One! We're Number One!.

"I was just doing my job,

"I was just doing my job, following orders." Said the builders of the crematoria at Aushwitz. Said the guards at the concentration camps. Said those who gave them their orders. The War Crimes trials started at the top and worked down. With the most severe penalties for those at the top. We look back with a grim satisfaction that the penalties were just. Although the penalties in no sense were equal to the enormity of the crime. "I was just doing my job, following orders." Said the builders of Guantanamo prison. Said the guards at Abu Ghraib. Said those who gave the guards the orders. Said the Blackwater mercenaries. . . Said Scott McClellan Said... When those in the future look back on these dark days and dark deeds. What will they say? Shame on you Nancy Pelosi, Shame on us for our complicity.

It would have been

It would have been refreshing to have seen more evident remorse for Mr. McClellan's role in foisting this ill-begotten war on the American public. Even better, to have demonstrated some signs of actual integrity AT THE TIME, by resigning in protest, while it might still have done some good. Instead, this book seems nothing more than a belated concern for what's left of Mr. McClellan's reputation: too little, too late. Mr. McClellan was either a buffoon, or Liar in Chief; either way, the enormous suffering inflicted by this criminal Administration through this war, and other impeachable offences--with Mr. McClellan's help--will be on his conscience for the duration. For his "fifteen minutes of fame," he was clearly willing to sell out his country, and it will take more than this book to erase that stain.

Well! A lot of us already

Well! A lot of us already knew that Scott was selling us out for the Administration... Now he tries to make amends. It was painful to watch Scott in those times lie and defend the Administration. ....... Another 'Nail' in the coffin.

So...when do we have the

So...when do we have the guts to send the Bush administration to jail. For those of us who have been saying this "stuff" for years, none of this book comes as a surprise. We have a criminal administration that the US Congress should ensure get put out of office and into jails. If the US doesn't do it; the World courts will! Nan

McClellan's characterization

McClellan's characterization of Bush is in line with those of others who have worked within the inner circle. As political scientist David Gergen once observed Bush never had anyone on his team with license (or integrity!) to ask hard questions as 'advocatus diaboli' - unlike most presidents before him who have all known this to be an excellent way to avoid predictable mistakes. As for the propaganda machine - old news. Cheney had used the Office of Special Services to receive and cherry pick intelligence before the CIA with their better qualified staff could disqualify is as unsuitable to make Americans support the Iraq war. Reportedly the OSS was mostly staffed with inexperienced youngsters who could cover up their lack of skill by being loyal or find another job.

I had to laugh when I read

I had to laugh when I read "...which resulted in his relentless pounding by the White House press corps..." Is this how the Post sees the White House press corps? That hysterical! For the last 7 years, I've seen a White House press corps that let this administration lie with impunity, the Post being one of the worst offenders. How self-delusional and self-congratulatory of the Post. And how pathetic an attempt at rewriting recent history.

Impeach Pelosi for not

Impeach Pelosi for not impeaching Bush!

Everybody that knew anything

Everybody that knew anything about politics and this administration already knew what McClellan has written in this book, and for them to make out like this is news, makes my ass want to crochet

Finally, there is at least

Finally, there is at least one individual who is enough of an American patriot to bring some truth to "we the people". Mr. McClellan was front and center during the terrible deceptions put out by the current administration and has confirmed what many thoughtful Americans have long suspected. The frenzy to "war" was carefully planned even before 9/11 and that event only allowed the our invasion of Iraq to be done under the cloak of revenge. Facts were created or manipulated to fulfill the grand plan with little regard for the hundreds of thousands of American military personnel and their families and millions of confused American citizens and people around the world. The shameful actions of the Bush administration will leave a dark stain on the United States of America for decades to come. Do we, as a nation, have the courage and the humility to reverse this path to destruction? The next months should provide an answer to that question.

A great article exposing the

A great article exposing the lies and innuendos of a morally corrupt band of villains.

Can we get all these former

Can we get all these former White House operatives that have since turned on the Bush regime together and finally start impeachment proceedings? How much proof do we need? DAMN!

What a filthy piece of human

What a filthy piece of human garbage this man is! Trying to cash in for more money after KNOWINGLY feeding the American public lie after lie all these past years. He's nothing but Hillbilly White Trash and should be put in jail - along with all the other thieves and liars that ran our country into the ground during the Bush administration.

The White House used

The White House used Goebbels-like Propaganda to ram the Iraq War down our throats, which was a mistake. That means that the deaths, suicides, and maiming of our troops is a travesty of unheard of proportions. And, the dismantlement of Iraq, and the fraud and the waste there, and the countless lives destroyed in Iraq, were all a mistake. Valerie Plame, and Rove. Will there be a renewed investigation, with McClellan called to testify before a Grand Jury? If McCain is elected, will he Pardon Bush, though they will insist he did nothing wrong? Kind of like passing a law giving Telecoms Immunity for bad acts they and the White House insist they did not commit.

Get him under oath, get his

Get him under oath, get his testimony on record, then get the truth out of him. The practice of treason, then publishing so you escape punishment, has turned our country into a joke. This lying sack of cowardice deserves the maximum penalty, as do the bulk of those who worked for Bush. Get him in front of Congress now.

Just another one of W's own,

Just another one of W's own, confirming what many of us already knew.

Add a comment:

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
The following question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Please enter the two words seen below. If you cannot read them you may use the button with circling arrows to get a new one.