Share

Four Senate Democrats Urge EPA Chief to Resign

by: Zachary Coile  |  The San Francisco Chronicle

photo
Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Stephen Johnson. (Photo: Getty Images)

    He's accused of misleading Congress.

    Washington - Four Senate Democrats called on EPA chief Stephen Johnson to resign Tuesday, alleging that he gave misleading testimony to Congress and repeatedly bowed to pressure from the White House to avoid regulating greenhouse gases.

    California Sen. Barbara Boxer, who chairs the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, and three other Democrats on the panel - Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island, Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota and Sen. Frank Lautenberg of New Jersey - also announced they are urging Attorney General Michael Mukasey to investigate whether Johnson made false statements to Congress. Mukasey's office said it was still reviewing the request late Tuesday.

    The pressure on Johnson is part of an escalating battle between Democrats in Congress and the White House over climate change policy. Democrats are seizing on new evidence that Johnson overrode the opinions of Environmental Protection Agency scientists and reversed two of his own decisions at the request of the White House.

    EPA spokesman Jonathan Shradar fired back at Boxer for what he called a political attack. "Administrator Johnson's record is one of aggressive, health protective environmental standards. Sen. Boxer's record is one of press conferences and political tirades," Shradar said.

    Democrats insist that Johnson misled Congress when he testified before Boxer's committee Jan. 24 about his decision to reject California's effort to set the nation's toughest limits on emissions from vehicles. The EPA chief testified that he listened to all sides before deciding that California had failed to make its case.

    "I made the decision. It was my decision. It was the right decision," Johnson said at the time.

    But last week, a top Johnson aide contradicted his testimony. Former EPA deputy associate administrator Jason Burnett, who resigned last month in frustration with the administration's climate-change stance, testified that Johnson had initially supported granting at least a partial waiver after concluding that California met the legal criteria.

    But Burnett said Johnson changed his stance when the White House made clear that President Bush opposed California setting its own fuel economy standards. "The administrator knew the president's preference for a single (national) standard," Burnett said.

    Klobuchar said the testimony showed that Johnson not only overruled his own staff but also misled the public about who really made the decision. "If we can't trust the top EPA official to tell the truth to the American people, then he must go," she said.

    The lawmakers also allege that Johnson yielded to White House influence in a recent EPA decision over whether climate change endangers human health. The decision was critical because if the agency had made such a finding, it would have been required to start regulating greenhouse gases.

    In December, EPA officials sent an e-mail to the White House stating that Johnson supported the EPA staff's view that global warming threatens human health. "In sum, the Administrator is proposing to find that elevated levels of [greenhouse gas] concentrations may reasonably be anticipated to endanger public welfare," the document read.

    The White House refused to open the e-mail and later asked EPA officials to retract it. When Johnson recently announced that EPA was starting a new rule-making process to determine whether climate change poses a health risk, he never mentioned this previous finding.

    Boxer said she was frustrated that EPA officials have stonewalled congressional inquiries into those recent decisions. Johnson refused to testify at a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing this week about EPA's dealings with Congress. Last week, the White House released the e-mail with EPA's draft of the endangerment finding but would not allow senators to make copies. Lawmakers were allowed to read it only while being watched by two White House lawyers.

    Boxer said the final straw was an e-mail sent to EPA staffers last month that directed them not to speak to the press, congressional investigators or to EPA's own inspector general, and to forward the inquiries to their superiors. Boxer said Johnson "has become a secretive and dangerous ally of polluters, and we cannot stand by and allow more damage to be done."

    But the White House is standing behind Johnson. White House spokesman Trey Bohn said Johnson's critics are attacking him because they disagree with the administration's policies on energy and climate change.

    "In every sense, administrator Johnson has cooperated fully with Congress, and the facts bear that out," Bohn said.

    E-mail Zachary Coile at zcoile@sfchronicle.com.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

This is very troubling to

This is very troubling to me. It is the heart of the problem with our current federal government. It's all done in secret, facts are ignored, the will of the government is based on the will of corporations. The refusal by this administration to work with congress at all, to attempt to force them into a rubber-stamp committee, is a complete mockery of our constitution. It's time to take back control of our government. It's time to stand up and be counted. Unless, of course, you don't mind living in squalor while a very small minority reap all the profits and benefits derived from OUR labor.

"Lawmakers were allowed to

"Lawmakers were allowed to read it only while being watched by two White House lawyers. I think that about sums it up, don't you? It's later than we think.

Barbara Boxer is one of the

Barbara Boxer is one of the most consistently patient and enlightened human voices on the planet. And the fine senator is accused in words like these? EPA spokesman Jonathan Shradar fired back at Boxer for what he called a political attack. "Administrator Johnson's record is one of aggressive, health protective environmental standards. Sen. Boxer's record is one of press conferences and political tirades," Shradar said. Political tirades? Barbara Boxer? This would be funny if time weren't so dear and the need for action so immediate and near.

Congress has a 9% job

Congress has a 9% job approval rating per the Rasmussen Report. There is a movement to vote all Congressional incumbents out of office. See: http://forum.stopthespray.org/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=1668

This is exactly the same

This is exactly the same thing tactic that the Bush admin has used since 2000. Appoint a loyalist and keep facts from coming out. Why? Because some big corporation, some where, benefits. And those benefiting are the same ones who keep the republicans in power. Too cozy. A criminal relationship. A corrupt administration with those in congress not helping much, although I see a few signs of that changing.... I hope. As long as this admin. gets thrown out. Too bad there are no voting laws that have insisted on paper ballots for every vote along with the trashing of electronic voting machines....plus at least a high incidence of surprise random audits.

All reptilian aliens that

All reptilian aliens that are destroying the planet should be executed and replaced with caring human beings.

Finally, Congress appears to

Finally, Congress appears to be showing a little bit of spine and standing up to the illegal and immoral acts of this Administration. Congress should DEMAND THE TRUTH, because that is their charter. The Congress and the Courts exist to hold the Administration in check. Carl Rove, Harriet Myers, John Bolton and all the others should be forced to testify -- for the benefit of all Americans. The President should be held accountable and his acts, and those of Cheney and the rest, should be investigated. Our Constitution specifically prohibits an Imperial Monarchy. There should be a hearing on the charges of Impeachment, as brought forth by Denis Kucinich. The Justice Department should act as if it were an honorable institution. The EPA should be about Environmental Protection. Two quotes from James Madison, our 4th President and a Founding Father: "The means of defense against foreign danger historically have become the instruments of tyranny at home." "The essence of Government is power; and power, lodged as it must be in human hands, will ever be liable to abuse." Only Congress can protect us from abuse of power; it has been much abused to the detriment of the earth.

I am once again proud to

I am once again proud to have voted for Barbara Boxer. Give 'em hell!!!!