Opinion

General Taguba Knew Torture Scandal Went to the Top

»

by: Joseph L. Galloway, McClatchy Newspapers

photo
General Taguba knew that blame for the detainee torture scandal went as high as the secretary of defense, Donald Rumsfeld, and maybe as high as the president. (Photo: The Atlantic.com)

    Tony Taguba knew something about prisoners in wartime long before the Pentagon ordered him to investigate the torture and shameful mistreatment of Iraqi detainees revealed by those soldier photographs taken inside Abu Ghraib prison.

    You see, his father, Sgt. Tomas Taguba, was a soldier in the famed Philippine Scouts and was, briefly, a prisoner of the Japanese after Bataan fell in the opening days of our war in the Pacific. Sgt. Taguba escaped during the Death March and spent the next three years spying on the Japanese and relaying the information to US forces.

    After the war, the senior Taguba was allowed to enlist in the U.S. Army and served honorably and unsung until his retirement. His son was born in Manila in 1950 but grew up as American as apple pie, earned an ROTC commission at Idaho State University and was only the second Filipino-American to attain the rank of general in our Army.

    Maj. Gen. Anthony Taguba would undergo his own trial by fire when, in 2004, he was named by the Pentagon to conduct a carefully walled-in investigation of the abuses of prisoners at Abu Ghraib.

    By regulation - and no doubt by the design of those who appointed him - Taguba could not investigate any uniformed or civilian official whose rank was higher than his own two stars.

    Taguba and his investigators sifted and probed and assessed the blame as high as they were permitted to go. Taguba believed - no, he KNEW - that the responsibility for this outrage went much higher. He knew it reached to the office of then Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld and likely beyond to the lawyers who served President George W. Bush and perhaps even to the president himself.

    But the brass, military and civilian, wanted Taguba and those who ran 16 other Army investigations of the Abu Ghraib scandal only to get to the bottom of the situation, not to the top.

    A female Army Reserve military police brigadier general was reprimanded but criminal charges and courts martial were limited to five enlisted men and women, none ranking any higher than staff sergeant.

    For his honesty in both the investigation and in sworn testimony before congressional committees Tony Taguba became persona non grata in the halls of the Pentagon. The career of one of the Army's more talented and honorable officers ended with an untimely retirement.

    But Taguba wasn't done. The full truth had not been told.

    In a week when McClatchy published a five-part series by my colleague Tom Lasseter on the extra-legal American military detention center at Guantanamo and who's responsible for giving Americans a green light to mistreat, torture and detain both the guilty and the innocent prisoners in our custody, Maj. Gen. Taguba spoke out as well.

    In the preface to a damning report on the treatment of Guantanamo detainees by a group called Physicians for Human Rights - which had examined and interviewed 11 former Guantanamo detainees freed without charges - Taguba declared that there was no longer any doubt whatsoever that President George W. Bush and others in the White House had committed war crimes.

    "The only question that remains to be answered is whether those who ordered the use of torture will be held to account," Taguba wrote. "The commander in chief and those under him authorized a systematic regime of torture."

    Following the boss' orders, lawyers in the White House Counsel's office and in the badly named Department of Justice twisted and turned the words and the very meaning of those words in international treaties, in the Constitution, in the federal statutes and the military regulations so that interrogators in brightly lit prison rooms in Afghanistan, Iraq and Guantanamo as well as those secret CIA prisons hidden all around would be free to use the waterboard, electrical shocks, sexual humiliation, and all the other dirty little ways you can make a man scream and talk.

    To date, seven long years after we scooped up our first detainees in Afghanistan, not a single one of them has faced evidence, his accusers, or anything remotely resembling a legal court hearing on his guilt or innocence.

    Even a conservatively-tilted U.S. Supreme Court recently gagged on what the Bush Administration and its lawyers did their best to get them to swallow - the idea that some people in American custody are not entitled to the most basic of all protections, the writ of habeas corpus. The basic right to stand before a properly constituted court of law and make the government prove by the evidence that they have got the right man.

    I know. I know. A snowball has a better chance in Hell than we do at ever seeing the President and his cronies actually brought to justice for their high crimes and misdemeanors. We are going to see these walking examples of the lowest common denominator become the happy recipients of a blizzard of presidential pardons on Jan. 19, 2009, before the few who haven't already fled slip out of town ahead of the subpoenas.

    My thoughts keep returning to a little speech Gen. Taguba made to his team of investigators as they first began their work in 2004: "Bottom line: We will follow our conscience and do what is morally right."

    Would that our President and his unindicted co-conspirators had done the same.

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

Time to twist some ears on

Time to twist some ears on our "voted in" government. (Pick up that phone/drive to their office, yes -make yourself cranky) Our ancestors are rolling over in their graves. Our legislators can only do what we let them and WE ARE LETTING THEM ! A million + people have been murdered, maimed and tortured. America (you and me) can stop this runaway train! Start today Kucinich knows !

The concept of a second

The concept of a second generation hero being punished for heroic acts brings tears to my eyes. Will the nightmare end 1-21-09?

I find it so sad, but not

I find it so sad, but not surprising that I have not heard one word about this honorable heroic man, General Taguba, on our mainstream corporate (inherently conservative) media. I wish you and your loved ones a happy and healthy life.

our country has been more

our country has been more than tainted by this torture scandal...it has been shamed. the president IS guilty, and all his underlings including the "honorable "military which dishonored itself by its complicity which is illustrated in the dismissal of gen. Taguba. And so are WE guilty by our silence...Anyone who paid attention has known this reality and yet we went about our comfortable lives rather than protesting....and continue to be silent. So , "what kind of a people are we?? " he asked anonymously??? Do we continue our complicity? And what kind of a person am I? paul monahan

All military officers take

All military officers take an oath to protect and defend the Constitution--not the President and his hangers on. Imagine what the largely bloated, corrupt, self-serving, syncophantic, go along to get ahead military would be like were all, or even just many more, officers were as honorable, decent, and honest as Gen Taguba. I wonder how a person of honor managed to slip through the cracks to make it to the rank of Maj. Gen. in today's military. The Pentagon naturally corrected its mistake by seeing this admirable man to the door forthwith. Shame, shame, shame on them.

Seconded. Salute to

Seconded. Salute to Gen.Taguba. A man of honor and integrity.

I salute you Gen. Taguba,

I salute you Gen. Taguba, your honor and your integrity.