Truthout Original

George Bush, at Sea in the Desert

by: Michael Winship, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
President George W. Bush addresses the World Economic Forum on the Middle East at the Sharm el-Sheikh International Congress Center, Egypt.
(Photo: AFP / Jim Watson)

    President Bush's recent speech before the Knesset, ostensibly to celebrate Israel's 60th birthday, was not only a display of political cynicism at its worst - using a diplomatic occasion to perpetrate an unseemly attack on Barack Obama - but a microcosm for the disregard with which the president holds the rest of the world. And vice versa.

    Events in the Middle East over the last two weeks are all the proof you need. Here's what the president said: "Jews and Americans have seen the consequences of disregarding the words of leaders who espouse hatred. And that is a mistake the world must not repeat in the 21st century.

    "Some seem to believe that we should negotiate with the terrorists and radicals, as if some ingenious argument will persuade them they have been wrong all along. We have heard this foolish delusion before. As Nazi tanks crossed into Poland in 1939, an American senator declared: 'Lord, if I could only have talked to Hitler, all this might have been avoided.' We have an obligation to call this what it is - the false comfort of appeasement, which has been repeatedly discredited by history."

    Although officially President Bush denied he was talking about Obama - and the Democrat's stated willingness to talk with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad - John Yang, at NBC News, reported, "Privately, White House officials said the shoe fits the Democratic frontrunner."

    American historian Brian P. Murphy told the Boston Globe, "I can't imagine there's a precedent for a sitting president to go before the legislative body of a foreign government and launch a political attack on a major-party nominee running to succeed him."

    It was a shabby performance in an improper, overseas forum. He didn't care. Of course, the reference to appeasement was an attempt to smear by making a comparison between Senator Obama and British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain's capitulation to Hitler at Munich in 1938.

    Last summer, Bush read the book "Troublesome Young Men," an account of how Winston Churchill and fellow Conservatives fought back against Chamberlain's submission to the Nazis. But ironically, as the book's author, Lynne Olson, pointed out in a Washington Post op-ed last summer, it's the appeaser and Bush who have more in common than the president may care to know. "Chamberlain came to office with almost no understanding of foreign affairs or experience in dealing with international leaders," she wrote. "... He surrounded himself with like-minded advisers and refused to heed anyone who told him otherwise."

    President Bush's own continuing heedlessness was again highlighted just a couple of days after the Knesset speech when he delivered a chastising lecture on democracy to Arab nations at the World Economic Forum in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt. "Obtuse" is how a Boston Globe editorial described it. "Bush seemed oblivious to the loss of respect for the United States that his Mideast misadventures have caused in the region."

    Newsweek's Christopher Dickey echoed the Globe's dismay: "Looking at Iraq, the peace process, Lebanon, the growing strength of Iran, the continued deterioration of Somalia, the potential disintegration of Sudan, not to mention the vast decline in the value of the dollar and the faltering global economy, the participants at the forum knew only too well they were halfway to hell on roads paved with George W. Bush's good intentions."

    So, as Bush thoughtlessly careens into the last months of his presidency, a good portion of the rest of the world has decided it can spin on quite well without him. Even Israel.

    Almost as if everyone waited until President Bush had left the region and the coast was clear, there was immediately a surprise announcement of Turkey brokering indirect talks between Israel and Syria over the Golan Heights. And now Qatar has brokered a political power-sharing deal between the Lebanese government and the Hezbollah Shiite militia that may keep the country from exploding in another war. The United States has opposed both efforts.

    Such defiance isn't just because George Bush is a lame duck. So bereft is his administration's Middle East policy of initiative or consistent purpose that the United States has lost what little credibility it had left.

    It's becoming clearer as Egyptian newspaper editor and human rights activist Hisham Qassem says, "America is neither loved nor feared." Instead, we're the lumbering, addled giant, aimlessly kicking desert sand, irritating the world instead of leading it.

»


Michael Winship is senior writer of the weekly public affairs program Bill Moyers Journal, which airs Friday nights on PBS. Check local airtimes or comment at The Moyers Blog at www.pbs.org/moyers.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

Churchhill and Roosevelt

Churchhill and Roosevelt negoiated with Hitler. The whole not talking thing is just plain stupid

Even more surprising about

Even more surprising about Bush's comment before the Knesset is that his own family made their money trading with the Nazis, before, during and after the war. The US had to finally pass the "no trading with enemies" and only then did the Bush family, when it was mandated did they quit. Could be that he's just the mouthpiece, but I think it's a deliberate obfuscation. He must know his own family history. I don't believe the man is that stupid. It's just him again pointing the finger when he should be looking in the mirror. Just like he portrays himself as a Texan when he's really from Maine. He never was nor ever has been a member of the middle class. The contempt he has for the truth is diabolical. AND, why isn't it out there in the MSM that his own family sits on a pile of cash which they made off of the killing of Jews?

Don't be so quick to blame

Don't be so quick to blame the dummy, look first to the ventriloquists (Cheney, Rove, et al) that have been pulling the strings, or had their hands up that ass, as it were. The real trick would be to push through the legislative process the means to rescind any prior agreements that would permit another country to not allow extradition of people subject to trial in this country or world wide for war crimes. And at home, to make any and all government employees liable for damages for conspiring to defeat the constitution of the United States of America, removing any protections granted to them by those same people that would be found guilty of such crimes. That's a start....... http://boskolives.wordpress.com

I fear for Obama. I

I fear for Obama. I believe the best hope is to have Hillary on the ticket with him. Bad enough to have the Republicans use race as their true issue, having the Dems on that wagon too, makes it a horrid double barrel he will be looking down. When will we in the USA begin to see we are not the "golden chosen" that we portray. Too many issues... too many Americans with the bags firmly glued over their heads.

Nice piece. I'm trying to

Nice piece. I'm trying to summon some type of joy that the creep is actually leaving. All I come up with is the depressing knowledge that so many Americans still admire him and will defend him. Recently I encountered a woman in a restaurant who's a singer in a band that plays for functions supporting the troops; her son is just back from Iraq. Her organization is called "The Only Thing Yellow is the Ribbons." She raved on about what a wonderful job the troops are doing and how much support they need. Having just been introduced to her by a friend, I couldn't tell her what a disgusting situation we find ourselves in that we have to even consider "supporting the troops." I just walked away. It is probably more true in my part of the country (Texas) but there is still support for Bush and the war and a pernicious sense of "patriotism" irrespective of what the politics are that got us into Iraq. These clueless souls tell everyone they're "not political" and don't want to discuss the issues but just want to support the troops. They think it's some big fucking high school football game and we need to root for the home team. There is no hope, no hope. These folks run this country. They run banks, businesses, they buy politicians and they control us. They are the "deciders." They are completely clueless about world events, history and the cause of conflict. They are the ones I fear will start hoarding gas and cause the most trouble when the situation gets really dicey. They're heavily armed and don't care who gets hurt as long as they can keep driving their pickups and SUVs and feeding their fat faces. Sorry to be so pessimistic, I've seen this mentality all my life. I've lived with it, I've worked for these folks. They're not going to be enlightened as we all thought we were after Watergate and the fall of Saigon. They will use every lie and slanderous scheme to stop Obama. I fear for him every time I see him, remembering too well the year 1968. My only hope is the internet and the revolution in communication that exposes nonsense. Let's just hope it exposes more nonsense than it propagates. J

Impeach? IMPEACH! Oh, no,

Impeach? IMPEACH! Oh, no, that would just distract from all the important initiatives we Dems can push through since we control Congress. Such as? Ah, well, hmm, ... Would I be wrong in supposing that indicting the Busheviks for war crimes, subversion of the Constitution, and treason would be a distraction as well? Thought so.

how much longer are we g0ing

how much longer are we g0ing to suffer this vile, incompetent oaf? impeach now

I sent this to the

I sent this to the "so-called" White House today: Hey Bush - Face that you are a mass murderer of the poor Iraqi people & others. We all know that you & your crew are heartless liars. Crude & debased humans. The law of karma allows you to redeem yourself through facing the same pain that you caused others. Imagine the pain of the millions of Iraqi's you caused & imagine you yourself going through that same pain. That is the beauty of the evolution of the soul that you will undoubtedly experience. All the torture, the bombings, the death & destruction will be yours. Of course you wrongly think that there is only one life & that you will somehow escape the responsibility of the pain you & yours caused. But doesn't it seem more fair that we must feel the pain for all the pain you caused others as conversely the love & pleasure. But you chose death, hate & pain. Good luck with that! In actuality you are a perfect soul going through the free will life experiences on this beautiful earth. You have chosen unwisely this life but still can learn from your really bad mistakes.

A brilliant piece of work

A brilliant piece of work Michael Winship. Thank you for your perspective.

It must be true that some

It must be true that some Texans wear ten gallon hats on two ounce heads. Oh Lord, when is he going to leave?

"There is a strange

"There is a strange interdependence between thoughtlessness and evil." Hannah Arendt

Add a comment:

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
The following question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Please enter the two words seen below. If you cannot read them you may use the button with circling arrows to get a new one.