News

Report Faults Gonzales on Data

»

by: The Associated Press

photo
Former Attorney General Alberto Gonzales allowed secret information to be mishandled. (Photo: Reuters)

    Washington - While serving as attorney general, Alberto Gonzales mishandled top secret documents, risking the release of classified information about two of the Bush administration's most sensitive counterterrorism efforts - a surveillance program and detainee interrogations.

    Mishandling classified materials violates Justice Department regulations and removing them from special secure facilities without proper authorization is a crime. But a report issued Tuesday by the Justice Department's inspector general says the agency decided not to press charges against Gonzales, who resigned under fire last year.

    Lawyers for Gonzales acknowledge he did not store or protect the top secret documents - a set of handwritten notes about the surveillance program and 17 other papers - as he should have. But they say he did not intentionally mean to risk letting unauthorized people see them, and say there's no evidence that occurred.

    The report by Justice Department Inspector General Glenn A. Fine is the latest taking Gonzales to task for mismanagement at the department during his 31 months as attorney general. The criticism could foreshadow the results of an ongoing investigation by Fine's office about Gonzales' role in the 2006 firings of nine U.S. attorneys. That inquiry is expected to be finished within months.

    "Like all other department employees, Gonzales was responsible for safeguarding classified materials, familiarizing himself with the facilities available to him ... for storing these materials and observing the rules and procedures for the proper handling of classified materials," Fine's report stated. "Our investigation found that Gonzales did not fulfill these obligations and instead mishandled highly classified documents about the NSA surveillance program and a detainee interrogation program."

    "NSA" stands for National Security Agency, which ran a controversial surveillance program that let investigators eavesdrop on terror suspects and people believed to be their associates.

    At issue is how, and where, Gonzales stored the documents, which are classified as sensitive compartmentalized information, or SCI.

    SCI materials are among the highest and most sensitive levels of classified top secret documents and usually relate to national security cases. They are supposed to be stored only in special safes or facilities that can be accessed only by certain people with SCI security clearances.

    At the Justice Department, however, Gonzales kept the documents in a safe in a fifth-floor office in the attorney general's suite - which is not considered an SCI facility. In August 2007, investigators found, the safe was searched by two employees who did not have SCI clearances but who looked through it "document by document" for papers requested through the Freedom of Information Act.

    Additionally, the report found, Gonzales also took some SCI documents - specifically, the notes about the surveillance program - to his house in suburban Virginia as he was moving from his secure counsel's office at the White House in early 2005 to the Justice Department.

    Although he initially said he believed he kept the documents in a safe at his home, Gonzales later told investigators that he did not know the combination of the safe. He said he may have kept the papers in his briefcase and did not always lock it.

    In a response to the report, Gonzales' lawyers indicated the former attorney general was merely forgetful or unaware of the proper way to handle the top secret papers.

    "Judge Gonzales regrets this lapse," concluded the lawyers' response, which was written by Gonzales attorney George Terwilliger.

    However, Tuesday's report showed Gonzales was briefed on how to properly handle SCI material both while at the White House and at the Justice Department.

    As a result of the security breach, Gonzales could lose any remaining security clearances he may still have. Fine's investigators alerted the NSA and the Justice Department's internal security officials to alert them that the top secret information may have been compromised.

    Fine also referred the case to prosecutors at the Justice Department's National Security Division to see if charges should be brought against Gonzales. It is a misdemeanor for U.S. government employees to knowingly remove classified documents from authorized areas without proper permission.

    But the department decided against prosecuting Gonzales after an internal review that began earlier this year, said Justice Department spokesman Dean Boyd.

    "After conducting a thorough review of the matter and consulting with senior career officials inside and outside of the division, the NSD ultimately determined that prosecution should be declined," Boyd said in a statement.

    On the Net:

    The Justice Department report can be found at www.usdoj.gov/oig/special/s0809/final.pdf.


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

Just another example of an

Just another example of an incompetent politico (in this case, Bush's personal lawyer) being placed in a position where they have no clue and just don't care. Look at Mukasey and what he has done to continue the first turkey's transformation of his agency into the IN-Justice Department. Look at the whistleblower's Chief Officer not prosecuting complaints and the resulting whistleblower's suit against HIM from his own department. -- Bush Administration is a new oxymoron, other than Cheney's complete secret control of his office. It all ends soon, we can restore liberties and Bill of Rights amendments and put this country back into a moral position in the world.

listen folks, it's obvious

listen folks, it's obvious what our choices for action are and they start this November....so, make the best choice available at the polls and then press for the new leadership to uphold the law and the constitution and bring these criminals to justice once and for all!!! Of course to vote for McSame is to insure the continued crimes against humanity through the escalation of the war and the complete obscuration of justice and the final erosion of our constitution.

What's important is that he

What's important is that he cracked down on the SuicideGirls website for being too risque. C'mon guys; at least he had his priorities right.

These Bush administration

These Bush administration guys never get prosecuted. It's all an insider game. If you or I committed this type of crime, they'd prosecute. Or if you are caught growing one marijuana plant in a non-medical cannabis state, it's a felony punishable by 5 years in prison. But to violate the law repeatedly as Gonzalez, Bush, Cheney. Rove and others have done, to authorize torture, to out Valerie Plame, to violate the constitution, that's not prosecutable. This country is run by an oligarchy. Watch the movie www.zeitgeistmovie.com to see it explained.

I just love the way this

I just love the way this keeps getting better, first Cheney takes classified information home, now Gonzales, and of course the Justice Department refuses to press the issue. What Gonzales did was illegal, a felony, the statutes are in the books. And of course, equal Justice for all. What a joke. Use to be, the administration tried to hide these things, now the don't care who knows. We use to have a Constitution, didn't we?

The United States has more

The United States has more people incarcerated than any advanced country in the world. Mr. Gozales has violated the law for which ordinary citizens woud be prosecuted. This is the method that is used by dictatorships, not by Democracies. This is how people loose faith in their government.

SURELY THIS IS A VIOLATION

SURELY THIS IS A VIOLATION OF HIS ETHICAL OBLIGATIONS AS AN ATTORNEY? WHEN IS CREW FILING A COMPLAINT WITH THE STATE BAR OF TEXAS? NOBODY IN THIS ADMINISTRATION WILL BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR INNUMERABLE CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY, THE CONSTITUTION, OR COMMON DECENCY. WHEN WILL THE REVOLUTION BEGIN AND THE GUILTY BLINDFOLDED TO ACCEPT THEIR FATE?