Share

Human Rights Are Crumbling

by: StĂ©phane Bussard  |  Le Temps

photo
France and Great Britain are undermining Sudanese President Omar el-Bashir's indictment by the ICC. Stephane Bussard argues, "human rights are not just some appendage to good conscience. Respect for them is essential for durable post-conflict reconstruction." (Photo: Sayyid Azim / AP).

    The 1990s marked a significant advance in international justice. The May 1999 indictment of Serbian leader Milosevic was emblematic of the progress achieved in the fight against impunity. The attempt now afoot by certain Security Council members, including France and Great Britain, to torpedo an International Criminal Court trial even before it's launched could very well squander the benefits of the "moral decade."

    By expressing his resolve to indict Sudanese Head of State Omar el-Bashir for genocide and crimes against humanity, the ICC president committed a quasi-foundational act. By threatening to straightaway undermine it, the great powers show that they're ready to instrumentalize the Criminal Court to promote their own political agenda. Peace in Darfur cannot all the same be had for no matter what price. The message conveyed is devastating. It casts doubt on these same powers' commitment to international justice. It weakens the International Criminal Court's future credibility and posits the question of its independence with respect to a Security Council deemed to be "without morals." This treacherous blow - should it be borne out - proves that the era of euphoric multilateralism is over. Confronted with the multipolar world's new threats, we witness the great return of national sovereignties, hostile to outside views. This reversal in trend has negative repercussions on the United Nations. With the weak leadership of its Secretary General Ban Ki-moon, human rights will see their status as the UN's third pillar crumble and the Security Council satisfy itself with turning a deaf ear. It's worrying. For whether the destroyers of the cause like it or not, human rights are not just some appendage to good conscience. Respect for them is essential for durable post-conflict reconstruction.

    --------

    Translation: Truthout French language editor Leslie Thatcher.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

As long as the powers of the

As long as the powers of the "enlightened" west refuse to consider their own record for torture & war crimes - Basra, Guantanamo Bay, Abu Ghraib and all the thousands slaughtered as "collateral" damage ... and this just over the last five years, any such forum operates in a moral vacuum ... and as I write this the Americans are all engaged in their annual cry-in for September the 11th - conveniently forgetting that on the same day Pinochet with the backing of the CIA overturned a democratically elected government in Chile and installed a bloody dictatorship of murderers and torturers. Of course the President of the Sudan should be brought to justice... and so should Bush & Cheney

The author presents "human

The author presents "human rights" as if their violation were only happening outside of the developed, western world. He doesn't mention the US invasion and occupation of Iraq and Afghanistan, or the US detention and torture of thousands of innocent victims in its so-called war on terror. Milosevic and El-Bashir only tried to defend their countries against criminal western aggression, and for this the West says they must be arrested and tried! Meanwhile the real criminals in the White House and Downing Street go free.

We are entering very dark

We are entering very dark times if this U.S. administration is not brought to justice by the international community.