Share

Iowans to Congressmen: Stop Immigration Raids

by: Henry C. Jackson  |  The Associated Press

photo
A Department of Homeland Security bus leaves a meat-packing plant in Postville, Iowa after an immigration raid on May 12. It was the largest such raid in US history, resulting in the arrest of nearly 400 people. 45 workers are still being detained by Homeland Security. (Photo: Harry Baumert / Des Moines Register)

    Postville, Iowa - An immigration raid that arrested nearly 400 people in northeastern Iowa scarred a small town and tore families apart, residents said Saturday.

    Dozens begged a visiting congressional delegation to do everything in its power to stop federal immigration raids. The May raid in Postville at Agriprocessors, the nation's largest kosher meatpacking plant, by Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials was the largest of its kind in U.S. history.

    Reps. Luis Gutierrez, D-Ill., Albio Sires, D-N.J., and Joe Baca, D-Calif., members of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus, heard three hours of often emotional testimony. Women whose husbands are being detained talked about their longing to be reunited, underage workers detailed deplorable working conditions and city and religious officials lamented the impact on the community.

    The speakers alternated between sharp criticism of immigration officials and the Department of Homeland Security for launching what they called an inhumane raid, and at their former employer, Agriprocessors, which they said took advantage of workers and allowed unsafe conditions. Many said they were equally responsible for the situation.

    By the end, Gutierrez said he had heard enough.

    "This is wrong," he said. "We've taken men and women who want to work and made felons out of them."

    Gilda Yolanda Ordonez Lopez, 17, wept as she described working 12-hour shifts with no overtime pay.

    When Adolpho Wilson was an employee at the plant, he was cleaning an unplugged meat grinding machine when someone turned it on by mistake, he said.

    "I shouted, I screamed. I said, 'Help me, help me!'" Wilson said in Spanish. "When they heard me, they took apart the machine, but it had eaten my hand."

    Jerry Messer, a local union official with the United Food and Commercial Workers, said Agriprocessors should be punished.

    "The family that owns that place, they're the ones who should be prosecuted," he said. "They're the ones who should be deported, not the workers."

    Phone messages left with Immigration and Customs Enforcement and Agriprocessors by The Associated Press were not immediately returned.

    Postville Mayor Robert Penrod told the congressmen to take the message back to Washington that immigration raids do not work.

    "This raid did nothing for this community," he said. "It downgraded us substantially. It caused people to suffer, and it caused our reputation to suffer clear across the country."

    Sires, the New Jersey congressman, said he was convinced.

    "I don't see this type of thing working someplace else," he said. "We don't want it to ever happen again."

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Shame on America! Is this

Shame on America! Is this the best way we can feed all the people? I think the law should be if you get a legal job in the US, you should be legal and be able to apply for citizenship. Either that or make those companies pay fair wages so they will attract American workers. The illegal's only crime is he wants to feed his family.

Nothing sgainst people who

Nothing sgainst people who want to work hard to support their families -- but they are here illegally. We cry out to let these people stay -- people who have broken the law to come here -- but make it nearly impossible for the foreign-born spouses of Americans to get green cards and come here? Why should it be easier for an "illegal" from Mexico to attain the right to live in the USA than it is for a European with a Master's degree. Our entire immigration system must be overhauled -- the sooner the better.

I agree with the above

I agree with the above statement. The jobs that immigrants do are jobs, in many cases, that most Americans won't do, Get rid of any immigrant who commits a crime with a weapon, whether they have killed someone or not. But, anyone who has put his/her life on the life to come to this country, works hard, backbreaking labor for low wages and even pays taxes, should be allowed to remain in this country. There is a process in place to become a citizen; they too should be allowed to go through this process. Farm laborers and low wage workers are not a threat to this country. Terrorists can even be natural born citizen, even in government and other places of high office. Let homeland Security fight the enemies of America....not just label illegals as the enemy.

Dear visiting congressional

Dear visiting congressional delegation, what is being done to investigate illegal and deplorable working conditions perpetrated by Agriprocessors??? Make me want to puke...more of the same from the fat cat fascists running this country.

This company should be shut

This company should be shut down and investigated! Obviously these corporate fat cats are taking advantage of immigrant labor because they can work them to death, pay them extremely low wages, and dare them to report this injustice. They've got it all worked out and our government assists by being the enforcers. Blaming the victim for the ills of our economic system. Raise wages and enforce worker safety rules.

The comment that starts with

The comment that starts with Shame on America is right on. In addition, it is our policies and the policies of the World Bank, etc., that force people to do desperate things to put food on the table. If your kids were starving, wouldn't you say, *Legal Schmeagle - I'm going to get a job!* I think that a lot of the people who come here wish they could stay home, if only they could get a job that would sustain them.

There seems to be a vicious

There seems to be a vicious callousness which is increasingly being institutionalized. Political pap just thinly veils a burgeoning trafficking in misery for money. Beyond indifferent and voracious corporations and speculators and a military gorged on the nation's wealth, there is a vibrant market in victimizing people under the guise of security, expediency, and political ideology. Bureaucracies that manage lives are lucrative ventures, especially with an unending pool of "aliens to manage".

It's the same old story over

It's the same old story over and over. 'Poor illegals; all they want to do is work an feed their families" etc. True the businesses that hire them are equally guilty, but both are breaking the law! Deport the illegal worker, and throw the business owers in jail.

Why should the American tax payer have to subsidize Mexican workers? That's the job of the Mexican goverment, but they're corrupt. On a trip to Mexico in '07, a guide told our group, "Mexico gets their income from OIL, Tourism, and the MONEY sent home from the Mexicans working in the US. I worked 47 yrs. in a US factory, so I know about "hard work".

at the "Université de Droit

at the "Université de Droit et de Sciences Economiques -Assas" - Law and Economics college - we were taught in the 60's about the probable repercussions of Western policies in regard to investment in creating long term industries (and therefore jobs) in the 'Third World', notably Africa for Europe and South & Central-Americas for the U.S. I'm sure other students were taught the same thing at the same time.Nothing was done or very little and certainly not in any democratic way. Now forty years later the Western countries are faced with what they knew all along would happen : a steady growing surge of hungry people, 'have-nots', trying in any way possible to put food on their family's table. What surprises me (though I guess it shouldn't...) is the similarity in the responses by the different govts. in dealing with the "unwanted illegal aliens" all throughout the occidental realm. Over here in France the favorite method employed by the authorities is to snatch children in the middle of the classroom (yes, with uniformed cops barging in and physically removing the kids of illegal aliens as one way of rooting out their parents). And as in the States most "illegals" hold down hard jobs, pay taxes and generally contribute to their respective societies. So it seems that it is not just the entire western immigration system that should get a thorough overhaul but the political perspective and actions of the 'haves' govts. toward investment in the 'developing' countries. This mess is not something that just happened in the last decade ; it has been brewing for quite some time and we have no excuse for our passivity when we could have done so much to avoid getting to where we're at. In agreement with some of the comments here I would enlmarge it and say " Shame on the Western Governments and on the people electing them!"

The question is: are the

The question is: are the people crying to these congressmen illegal themselves? It's a shame when families are impacted but it wouldn't happen if they were here legally. The U.S. cannot support tens of millions of aliens taking our jobs because the corporations can pay them so much less and get away with it. Sorry, but send them home and make our government more responsible to actual American citizens.

We are exporting wealthy

We are exporting wealthy Americans to Mexico as well. My neighbor integrated with a family in Mexico and is moving there to retire. I would not put it past a corporation to make a deal with the feds to do this so as to go out of business in a way that will make it easier to not have to pay retirement benefits to former workers and so on. The story we see here today is probably a tip of the iceberg. A tenacious investigative reporter could probably plumb this one for some time. There's more than a whiff of intrigue here.

Amusing The message that

Amusing The message that starts "Dear visiting congressional" is amusing. I'm sure the owners of this Kosher buisinees will be amazed to discover they are fascists.