Share

Most Corporations Don't Pay Income Taxes

by: Richard Rubin  |  Congressional Quarterly

photo
(Image: Jcusa.com)

    Most corporations, including the vast majority of foreign companies doing business in the United States, pay no income taxes, according to a Government Accountability Office report released Tuesday.

    During the eight-year period covered by the report, 72 percent of foreign-owned corporations went at least one year without owing taxes, and the same was true for 55 percent of domestic corporations.

    Small companies were much more likely to pay no taxes than larger companies. Still, more than 3,500 large domestic corporations - with more than $250 million in assets or $50 million in gross receipts - did not pay taxes in 2005.

    The report said about 80 percent of the companies studied paid no taxes because they didn't generate any profit after expenses. Money-losing companies can legitimately owe no tax, and others can use provisions of the tax code to lower or eliminate their liability.

    But the lawmakers who sought the data seized on the report as proof of corporate gamesmanship.

    "It's shameful that so many corporations make big profits and pay nothing to support our country," said Byron L. Dorgan , D-N.D., who requested the report along with Carl Levin , D-Mich. "The tax system that allows this wholesale tax avoidance is an embarrassment and unfair to hardworking Americans who pay their fair share of taxes. We need to plug these tax loopholes and put these corporations back on the tax rolls."

    The report covered the period from 1998 through 2005. During that time, corporate income taxes as a share of gross domestic product dipped, from 2.2 percent in 1998 to 1.2 percent in 2003, the lowest share since 1983. But receipts jumped after that, hitting 2.7 percent in 2006 and 2007, according to the Office of Management and Budget. That was the highest share since the late 1970s.

    The GAO report also found that foreign-owned corporations were somewhat more likely to report no income than domestic corporations. There are several possible reasons for that. Foreign corporations may be younger, and startups are more likely to have no net income after expenses. They may also be in industries with lower profit margins.

    Another possibility could be the use of transfer pricing, which companies use to account for transactions between subsidiaries in different countries. Creative, rule-stretching use of transfer pricing can allow companies to push their profits into lower-taxed jurisdictions. The report does not attempt to examine whether illegal transfer-pricing caused the difference between foreign and domestic companies.

    But companies looking for lower-taxed jurisdictions often take profits out of the United States. The country's 35 percent top rate on corporate income is among the highest in the industrialized world.

    Many tax experts and lawmakers from both parties, including Ways and Means Chairman Charles B. Rangel , D-N.Y., and presidential candidate Sen. John McCain , R-Ariz., have called for lowering the corporate tax rate. Lawmakers are likely to differ on what revenue-raising measures, if any, should be paired with a corporate rate cut.

    In addition, Levin, Finance Chairman Max Baucus , D-Mont., and other senators have been trying to close the "tax gap," the difference between taxes owed and taxes collected.

    In a statement, Baucus said, "I'm committed to finding ways to improve compliance and reduce taxpayer burden so that we begin to bridge the tax gap, which accounts for $345 billion in legally owed but uncollected federal revenues each year."

    He said the GAO report "shows yet again the need for full-fledged [tax] reform next year...."

    "We are constantly reviewing the tax code to find ways to crack down on those who are trying to avoid paying their fair share, without placing undue compliance or reporting burdens on honest taxpayers. As part of this on-going effort, we are reviewing the GAO report to see what it might suggest about where to target tax gap efforts," Baucus said.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Ask yourself: is it fair

Ask yourself: is it fair that I, a working class person, pay more in income taxes than most corporations? Ask yourself: How is it that in story after story we hear about 'cash-strapped cities' and 'cash strapped states' and not one word about why that is the case? For thirty years wealthy individuals and corporate entities have been excused from paying their fair share of taxes. That's why your school district had to cut art and social studies. Well, that and spending a few trillion trying to steal Iraq's oil.

Wow. Maybe average Americans

Wow. Maybe average Americans should follow their corporate leadership and stop paying taxes too! Better still, the income tax should be replaced with a national sales tax, so everyone pays regardless of income. Someone buys a $1 million yacht he pays the same sales tax (25%) as a guy buying a $100item, so everyone is taxed fairly. Exempt such things as food and medicines and we'd have a tax system in this country that everyone contributed to and that generated enough revenue for the government, provided they did their jobs and saw to it that the economy was in good shape. As it stands now, the tax system is simply another game for the clever to avoid and the average to carry a disproportionate burden.

Hideous.

Hideous.

Well that is really

Well that is really something. I have worked as a teacher all my life. My first job, fourty years ago the contract was for 6,000.00 per year of which I paid taxes. Now I am a sixty year old university professor, half time, work full time, make 20,000.00 per year with relatively no benefits like the other 72 per cent of non tenure track state employee's - and for the thirty five plus years I have worked, it has always been for some higher premise I held, like working for the common good, for society, for the children, for my nation, even tho' I was taxed for everything and lived a meager and unselfish life I believed I was doing good. This message that the GAO awards no contract bids to dubious private contractors who do not pay taxes but reap all the rewards and now this lack of corporations paying taxes leads me to believe that I must have been a complete fool all these years. I am ashamed of my nation and the people - at least I will go to my death tax poor but high on the do gooder's list of fooled patriots. Capitalism needs to be reformed.

This is no surprise to me.

This is no surprise to me. Since corporations were given the same rights as a person (just google- corporations are people) it should follow that these extremely rich and powerful "people" would influence our laws and ideologies to the point that after destroying unions, the average middle class livable wage, and shipping the manufacturing base overseas they would place the burden of the infrastructure they MUST have to do business on the shoulders of the people their agenda has hurt the most and most will say "Well thats just the way it is" and go back to their corporate sponsored soma holiday.

We had to write a check for

We had to write a check for $7000 on top of our payroll taxes, just two of us, working as a nurse and special education teacher. We have "expenses" too. Corporations need to pay taxes. They enjoy rights of "individuals" but do not have the same responsibilities. I think Al Gore had the best idea: tax pollution, not income. We want people to work. We don't want pollution. We wouldn't have to pay taxes to take care of sick people or work with kids with disabilities, but we would have to pay taxes to drive our cars, have fires in our fireplaces, heat the spa. This makes sense. Corporations could not get out of pollution taxes. I think that would be a great plan that benefits working people.

.......and how many are

.......and how many are subsidized with tax money? Not like there's corp.welfare or anything...

Taxes are for "little

Taxes are for "little people," remember? Buffet pays less tax than his secretary. It was just yesterday when "offshore tax shelters" were all the hubbub. Notice this report came from the GAO and not from the IRS which, apparently, feels it's doing a heckava job, although it's likely there's no one there who even understands what the f**k transfer pricing is...

This is just how the fascist

This is just how the fascist corporatists, otherwise known as neo-con republicans (along with their democratic party patsies) want it! Corporations and the rich used to pay much more in taxes decades ago. Now they are back to where they were in the late 19th century and the 1920's: aristocrats who think they don't have to contribute to the American society via paying taxes. In fact, according to them, they deserve to not have to pay any taxes. It's time for people to go on a general strike. No one works until Congress and the Senate pass laws by veto proof margins to bring back progressive tax rates and plug all the loopholes to right this wrong! If there was a general strike, and no one went to work for a week, the powers that be would be brought to their knees!

No surprise here. Their

No surprise here. Their stooges, the Republicans, work tirelessly night and day to make and keep it that way. What surprises me is that the Democrats, so often attacked by the Republicrooks for insufficient patriotism, have never launched an attack on the patriotism of both corporations and individuals who make grandiose amounts of money, but feel no obligation whatsoever to support our country; in fact, who actively fight any effort to make them contribute their fair share to the upkeep, and therein, the defense of our nation, and take deep offense and umbrage at any suggestion that they might consider doing so. But of course, any such effort along these lines would be hampered by the fact that these people, like the party - no make that mafia - which represents them, have no shame. The well being of the country is always subordinated to their first and foremost priority: their own profit and their control of this country's wealth. If I recollect correctly during the 60's they had a word for these people, and the word, I believe, was PIGS.

I;d be really curious about

I;d be really curious about a correlation between the "no profit" corporations and the bonuses paid to their CEO and board members versus their tax liability. CEO pay and bonuses are a deduction from their taxes so it's a double whammy for the average American compared to the corporate "personage" we work for, buy from or just get shafted by.

All You Guys are Oh So

All You Guys are Oh So Right! (correct) I find it safe to say @ this point that "All You Contributors" are All too Real for Sure! Which only goes to show that the sheep head bigots are too busy Drooling over the Every Word of Lush Limberger, Bill O'Liarllie, Joe Lie-berman, & the rest, to become One with Reality & Read what Non Cronies (You) have to say about the True Issues @ hand! Otherwise they'd be Trashing & Bashing your "Every Word!" Are there That Many Rich NeoCONS? Or are there That Many Sheep Heads to go around?

Most corporations pay no

Most corporations pay no income taxes. The courts have decided -- incorrectly, in my view -- that entities are individuals in the eyes of the law, like you and me. I don't agree, but you and I pay taxes and sho should they!. This applies double or triple to foreign entities that seek the privledge of selling into the greatest, largest market in the world! All this stuff about shareholders being taxed on dividends is hokum because dividend payout is geneerally very, very small. That last is unnecessary because the officers and directors have taken over, the intersts of the sarehlder/owners of these enterprises doen't even have a seat on the train. A;; you guys save for large, institutional inevstors are, in a word. screwed.

I think McCain is running

I think McCain is running an ad right now where he complains about the high U.S. corporate tax rate (one of the highest in the world, he says). And Obama wants it even higher! How will U.S. corporations possibly manage??? Well, maybe the rate is high. But given all the tax loop holes, most corporations aren't paying taxes anyway.

This is what

This is what conservative/Republican rule has given us, the little people bare the burden while the rich get off scott free. Our very Republican newspaper had the audacity to write a column asserting how the rich are still getting soaked. Their lame rationale was that the total taxes they pay as a percentage of the federal revenue is higher than what those at the bottom pay. Someone was kind enough to write in and explain the error in their logic (and stupidity I might add). As a percentage of income, the rich ARE paying less. It's just that they are disgustingly more wealthy, so that percentage adds up to a significant chunk of change, reflecting the huge income disparity that has developed in this country, thanks to the Republicans.

Ya keep all this outrage up.

Ya keep all this outrage up. I general stike is a good idea, though to do it while we have Bush, may be fool harded. There is a Cooperative called Mondragon in Spain which may someday spread out the wealth through a living 21st century wage. Its the closest thing we will ever get to John Lennon's Imagine song where we all share the wealth of this beautiful planet.

The real shame is that our

The real shame is that our tax code is such a tangled mess with so many loopholes. I love how congressmen get upset at the results of their own incompetence. -- Nietzsche is Dead

Were it not for the GAO,

Were it not for the GAO, there would never have been any resistance to the Bush/Cheney agenda. Kudos to them for knowing their job and doing it.

The glaring question and

The glaring question and answer: Will any of the little people read this article? No, they still hear the line, "Tax cuts for the small business man." None of them that voted for George Bush will believe this. As do most of the population believe them about the "non-existent" Death Tax. I've found that most Americans believe everyone is subject to the inheritance tax, not knowing the facts that only persons who inherit over $1 million are the most subjected to the tax. Furthermore, they don't understand where their tax dollars go. Certainly there are abuses, but most of their taxes are used competently and sent back to the states as grants and incentives. The next time someone tells me he is over taxed, I tell him not to call the fire department when his house catches fire, not to call the police if they get mugged, not to turn on their tap to get water, to send their kids to private school (if they can afford it), complain about religious freedom and prayer in schools (if we didn't have this right not to pray would they be forced to pray to a god they do not know or have the government make them worship in only one way), but most of all get the heck of of the roads that federal money funds and stop flying out of the airports that taxes support. Let them pull themselves up by their bootstraps if they can bend over from all of the money in their pockets.

So what's the problem? Now

So what's the problem? Now if my ox gets gored, so should the neighbor's? Less tax is a good thing. Who in their mind would want to pay tax so that the money will be wasted in Irak or Afghanistan, or in military aid to Israel, Egypt, Pakistan, etc. O even worse, supporting a police-prison state at home? Do you have any idea how much money a copper makes compared to the value it adds society (nil)? So, if the regular employees would stop paying income tax, what would happen? Would the IRS be capable of dealing with the enforced collection? I think not.

I think we should all apply

I think we should all apply for corporate status as soon as possible! Imagine, we could deduct the cost of rent, the cost of school, the cost of food & entertainment, travel costs, just about everything we spend money on we could deduct and so long as we don't save any money we can claim to have not made a profit and therefore we owe no taxes. And if we want to save some money, we can just designate ourselves the CEO of our own personal corporations and give that CEO a salary, which could probably be taxed. But hey, wouldn't you rather only pay taxes on what you save instead of every penny you make? I'm just kidding about this, of course. I'm very much in favor of paying taxes. I agree very much with Jiggish from 8/15. I like infrastructure. I like that there is a local University to go to and I didn't have to be a born aristocrat to access it. And, hey, Number 9, rad that you've heard of Mondragon!!!! Seriously, everybody search Mondragon! I studied it in a developmental economics class last year, and it is an awesome system. It's kind of like capitalism except that its driven by the workers instead of the slave-drivers. Pretty cool stuff.

The statistical games being

The statistical games being played by this article are unbelievable. There isn't even a statistic that supports the title of the article. Instead we have things like "more than 3,500 large domestic corporations - with more than $250 million in assets or $50 million in gross receipts - did not pay taxes in 2005". No mention of how many large companies there are in total. Rubin is trying to spoon feed us only the information he wants us to have. Such manipulations are simply dishonest. The only real conclusion I can draw from this article is that "sometimes corporations don't make a profit, and when that happens they don't pay taxes." Course I already knew that.

No corporations pay taxes.

No corporations pay taxes. All costs to corporations, including taxes, are passed down to consumers through product pricing. This shell game is nothing more than politicians trying to make you feel better about taking your money from you.

The only thing stopping you

The only thing stopping you from rebelling is your own fear, programmed into you over decades by the I.R.S. who want the "easy money"--the rabbits. The lions have never been afraid because they make the rules in the back rooms of D.C. A File Tax Return revolt would get the attention of the haves and start to reclaim some power for "We The Proletariat". http://www.e-file-tax-returns.org/