Truthout Original

On Iraq: Wiping Out the Legend

by: Maya Schenwar, t r u t h o u t | Book Review

photo
More than five years into the Iraq war, it's time to figure out how to prevent future wars like it, according to the authors of "Lessons From Iraq." (Photo: Rick Loomis / The Los Angeles Times)

    A new book from Foreign Policy in Focus explains what made the Iraq war possible, and how we can stop the factors that precipitated it before they breed.

    "We can't move on. The damage done by this war has to be examined if it is to be repaired."- Miriam Pemberton, editor of "Lessons From Iraq: Avoiding the Next War"

    A silent mythos is enveloping the liberal consciousness in the waning days of the Bush presidency.

    It spins like this: When it comes to Iraq, Americans' one reassurance is that this war can't possibly be repeated, not now that we've watched its consequences play out and caught a glimpse of the deception that caused it. As a result of Iraq, the logic goes, we will likely elect a new leader who railed against the war from its inception. We'll then shift toward a foreign policy that disavows offensive interventionism. We will make new friendships and repair old ones. We will live in peace.

    However, in the forward to "Lessons From Iraq: Avoiding the Next War," a collection of essays from the progressive think tank Foreign Policy in Focus, editor Miriam Pemberton warns against such now-we-know-better thinking. She cautions against the oft-uttered mantra surrounding large-scale deeds of evildoing, "Never Again."

    "The lessons in this book will not be a guarantee against the next war, even supposing they all took hold," Pemberton writes. "There will be a next war."

    I winced as I read that line. I wanted to close the book. But because I also wanted to review it, and because the contributors to "Lessons From Iraq" are smart people, and because - despite all pacifist inclinations - I know that, throughout history, there has always, always been a next war, I kept reading.

    If you too are riding the "hope" wave into 2009, holding your breath for a war vaccine, you too should keep reading, and not because your bubble needs bursting. You should keep reading because "Lessons From Iraq" delineates a realistic path along which we can direct our hope. It also teaches us to recognize those other, pernicious species of bubble, to ensure that, when they evolve again, we can burst them before they get too big.

    The 16 bite-size essays that make up "Lessons From Iraq" are divided into three sections: Purposes, Ways and Means and Collateral Damage. Some of the freshest essays lie in the Purposes section. In Neta C. Crawford's "The Dangerous Leap: Preventive War," the author distinguishes between "preemptive" and "preventive" wars. A preemptive war is one that defends against an immediate, certain threat. (Picture Saddam with his finger poised over the nuclear button at the point the US stormed Baghdad.) A preventive war is initiated based on an amorphous, ambivalent, might-be threat. (Picture what really happened: an attack based on shaky intelligence and overconfident statements about a potential - not actual - risk.) An attack motivated by only the possibility of a threat turns war into a self-fulfilling prophecy, according to Crawford.

    Much of the rest of the book addresses these problems: the unwise reasons for and disastrous consequences of preventive war. In "American Imperialism," Chalmers Johnson looks at the transformation of US foreign policy into an agenda that is both imperialist (regarding the "East") and isolationist (regarding Europe). It's an archaic model, according to Chalmers - one used by provincial-thinking presidents of the late 19th and early 20th centuries, for whom far-off lands were "pure abstractions" waiting to be conquered.

    The imperialist isolationist project is a particularly dangerous one, Chalmers says. It assumes that the US bears the responsibility of making sure no threats emerge in the world, all the while avoiding cooperation with - let alone consensus from - its allies. He describes the Bush-Cheney-Rumsfeld-Rice ideal as "a world where the United States, unfettered by treaties, international law, or commitments to allies, could attack any country at will and where this demonstration of power and resolve would cause all other governments to fall in line behind it - or topple one another."

    Yet, perhaps more sinister than the bizarre imaginings of neocon utopians are the concrete goals driving the imperialist movement, according to the book's later essays.

    One of the more obvious of these - the quest for a "secure" oil supply - also fits neatly into Crawford's "preventive war" mold. But instead of preventing nuclear war, this motivation is about heading off oil shortages. In a mixture of imperial zeal and oil-seeking desperation, according to an essay by Michael T. Klare, the Bush administration has advanced a movement to forcefully stamp out any barriers to Gulf oil. That may sound like a grandiose plan, but when a groundwork has been laid that justifies preventive war, American entitlement and unilateral military action, the path to free and easy US oil access becomes alarmingly clear.

    How was that groundwork laid? In its "Ways and Means" section, "Lessons From Iraq" spells out the careful crafting of public and Congressional opinion - the creation of a "legend" - to meet the needs of the imperialist plan. In John Prados's excellent piece on the political manipulation of intelligence, he shows how the strategic silencing of some people and data and the emphasizing of others generated a body of "evidence" to back that legend. Norman Solomon's essay examining the media's relationship with the legend is especially revealing: Mainstream news sources, with their power to decide what is "objective truth," quickly banished antiwar sentiments to the sidelines as the war in Iraq mounted. Even now, he notes, their "objective" perspective on the war is vastly skewed. For example, mainstream reports on Iraqi casualties are practically nonexistent.

    How to remedy the vast damage wrought by the legend, as the Iraq war still rages? The book offers a few concrete steps. A piece by Ivan Eland suggests a straightforward yet weighty solution: reduce the US military presence worldwide. Former UN Chief Weapons Inspector Hans Blix urges an emphasis on rigorous weapons monitoring as an alternative to preventive military action. Phyllis Bennis, author of the recent book, "Challenging Empire," recommends a heightened regard for international popular opinion. A foreboding essay by Fred Barbash calls for a revival of checks and balances in the US government, lest we, like Rome, abandon our democracy for empire.

    Summed up, these essays share a clarion call: It's time to stop the legend in its tracks. For it is useless to call for policy change without recognizing the deep-seated psychological currents that keep the legend going. An uncanny ability to play on those currents allowed the administration and its cheerleaders to implement their destructive policies in the first place. Now, says "Lessons From Iraq," it's time for us, the American people, to take our emotions - and our policies - back.

    Somewhere between the generous "learning experience" model and the conversation-killing mantra of "Never Again," "Lessons From Iraq" attempts to rebuild from the language on up, refashioning our national discourse - and our dinner table discussions. It urges us to grit our teeth and plunge into the piles of official lies and rhetoric-coated secrets that cloak the horror of the past five and a half years of our country's life. Before the official story is ossified, before the mainstream media pave over public outrage with euphemisms and softened narratives, this book asks us to preempt revisionism, to think long and hard about the way we will remember Iraq.

»


Maya Schenwar is an editor and reporter for Truthout.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

What, I pray has

What, I pray has become of all the voters, backers, pushers of the current administration? Have they all disappeared into the fabric of past space time embarrassed to the point of deminishment? I think not. I have voted against this administration twice and warned against suport of this particular devastating tyranny. And believe me received nothing but hatred in return. Care to have a particularly dark ride on the reality train? Regardless of what you may think of George Bush, the fear is that the majority of the American public are at or about the same intellectual level and bear as narrow and disconnected a view of the world as Bush. Think ....... the McCain campaign has the audacity to push the theory that Obama hasn't fought a war and hasn't visited a war zone enough to be commander and chief. When in the last election a bonefide war hero was disparaged by this same crew of opinion twisters and their hero Bush had never left the United States before he became president, however his party may have arranged the debacle they called this Presidency.

I just read 14 comments on

I just read 14 comments on the article above. Comments from good Americans. Americans who love their country so much they can't see one thing right with it. Americans who see their Government as corrupt, the electorate as stupid (minus their good American selves) and history as some kind of teacher to be ignored. If these good Americans had had their way America would never have gotten involved in WWII cause after all why should violence be met with more violence. I thought in that case history taught "Fight or Die" Now today fight for oil? How preposterous! We have batteries. Of course we should impeach Bush after all he is much worse than Clinton. If only Bush had had an affair with a 21 year old and cheated on his wife. We can forgive that but forgive saving people from rape rooms...how dare he! Yes I enjoyed reading all about history, politics and morality from the good Americans who wrote all those lovely comments above but I thank God everyday that those good Americans constitute, still, a minority of opinion in this country. It will be those good Americans that stab the fatal blow when "Their Will Be Done" God help us and keep us from all those good Americans.

Thanks to the elder Briton

Thanks to the elder Briton for his perspective from across the pond. How I miss my grandfather. How valuable the experience of years in gaining perspective. In America the aged are shelved unceremoniously, when they should be sought out for their contribution to the national conversation and honored for their wisdom. Younger Americans need perspective in order for true change to occur. What monumental effort will be required to change what is so ingrained in our culture, our legacy?

Such wonderfully intelligent

Such wonderfully intelligent comments. What has struck me most is watching Congress supoena one top administrative official after another. In collusion, they have all said "I don't recall." Or worse yet, not shown up to the Congressional hearings at all. There is a court process taking place. We'll see how that goes. However, is this all the "checks and balances" of our Congress? If impeachment is the ultimate, then Congress must do it at the very least! Yes, Pelosi, at the expense of your democratic agenda which has been obstructed for the most part! Maybe its time we changed our laws to punish the President with more than impeachment.

Exactly my thinking. What's

Exactly my thinking. What's wrong with this country? The President goes on TV in 1961 and exposes a deadly cancer creeping through the halls of government - the military industrial influence corrupting our lawmakers so badly they'd sign off on war for a slice of the profiteering. Just a few years later, we're up to our amputated arms in death and destruction in Vietnam in a conflict squeezed out of an artificially manufactured fear of Communism and a faked first-strike incident. After years of failure, futile killing and dying, a new sensibility rises from the youth culture, shaming the duped public into a new awakening, giving Congress the push it needs to investigate a rotten-to-the core White House. The Vietnam War ends. Fast Forward to Iraq, where we send in thousands of ground troops in search of imagined WMD. The same country was fooled again but today stops short of investigating the mountains of evidence showing the current White House to be thoroughly corrupt. It points to feeble-mindedness and gullible distractibility, combined with selfishness and a basic lack of patriotism. America is getting what it deserves - a Congress so blatantly unethical, they barely care to hide it. Our children will suffer because of the inaction of the post-9/11 Americans who let the government rape our economy. Think about it every time you gas up, or plan for your children's future.

Did I miss something, or did

Did I miss something, or did Maya neglect to mention which legend needs to be wiped out? i.e. Invincibility of US military, Saddam the evil tyrant, Iraqi WMD, ties to Al Qaeda, etc

Forrest Gump observed that

Forrest Gump observed that "Stupid is as stupid does." If "normal" people are lining up behind McCain and they actually vote him into office, then they continue to sleepwalk though history and have only themselves to blame for the misery they experience with a government intent on eliminating social security, maintaining a broken and inhumane health care system, and "drilling its way out of the oil crisis." These same people also hold the illusion that Iraq is a war. It is, more accurately, an illegal occupation. Perpetuating the fallacy of what is happening in Iraq as a war only makes it easier for the administration and its party faithful to speak the nonsense regarding "victory and an honorable return by the troops." While these may be noble and inspirational images for many, they simply portray an illusion, not even closely resembling reality. We can do our part to shatter the fairytale of the current administration by avoiding terminology that perpetuates this illusion. We should simply and consistently refer to what is happening as the illegal occupation of Iraq by U.S. Forces.

It is later than you think.

It is later than you think.

A Common Body of Consensus

A Common Body of Consensus In Knowing Precisely the Point 14:58:-) (first comment posted) If we are not to continue with what has been continually repeating in an increasingly vicious and self consuming circle, we must break to smithereens both the circle itself and the engine that generates, regenerates and empowers it! This will not be accomplished by continuing to enable it through a sighing consignment of it to "the nature of man" which carries an uderwritten assumption of being powerless to change what this assigns to "nature" as having wrought.......... In our "reading of history" can we not begin to grow up enough to LEARN from it rather than consigning ourselves to continuously repeating it?? Must humanity continue in the playpen of provided boundaries, dependently spoon-fed by others for what it swallows and passes for thought? How DOES a baby learn not to go over the edge, to feed itself, to be potty trained? Certainly not by being kept ever seemingly protected from experiencing itself! The humanity of this nation, with humanity of the world looking on and learning too, MUST learn from these currently forgone times the errors of its ways. This must needs come through the process of facing together and as seen among one another, the bare truth as piece by piece it is brought out to stand revealed. There must humanity, seeing truth together and reflected among each other, then Know, and also KNOW that they Know the Truth that sets us Free. We can only come to such openly known, cognitive, Freedom Serving terms with Truth by immediately Standing UP to enforce our abundant majority demand for impeachment. Through the impeachment process the Truth will Stand Revealed before us, and with the whole world watching in consequence, we must all learn, and together this time, from history as its revealed. History then would be written as the Truth in human consensus revealed it to be. Humanity nationwide and worldwide would then, as needed, toghether and at once, learn from history being written as revealed.

From England, an old man

From England, an old man comments: A most interesting article and very perceptive. I endorse all the sentiments and the points made in it, bar one; namely that America is "losing" its democracy and "becoming" an imperial power. It seems to me that America is and has been an Empire since some time before the First World War. The imperialist aims and methods have just become more evident, the disparity between the actual and professed aims more strident and the tendency towards an imperial, even a hereditary structure of rule in the constitution, ever stronger. The sad thing is that America's victims, (chiefly the British Empire and after that Europe) are dupes in the process of self destruction, both by default and by the compulsion endemic in the capitalist system. The counterpart of the above is that America will ultimately suffer the same fate as her erstwhile victims...unless???

Particularly poignant in

Particularly poignant in this article is the suggestion that those who have not paid particular attention to the events of the past 7 years will also not be aware that history will have been rewritten by those desiring a more "balanced" account. This phenomenom, coupled with the fear-based idea in our culture that we have to wage wars "over there" so we don't have to fight them "here at home", and the obscene level of monetary support enjoyed by our military, will guarantee that wars will continue to be promoted, and fought in the name of "security". The internet and other real-time modes of communication will help to dispel the myths and legends, such as the photos from Abu Ghraib did, but no doubt these technologies will also be turned against us by those who would conquer the planet for themselves. The American people need to understand the corrosive effect of corporate power, and then act to pass laws that reign in that power through regulation. "Deregulation" has a positive spin in it's appeal to independence and freedom, but it may be the most damaging concept at work in our country today. The propaganda of the government has a direct connection to that of commercial interests that seek to create in the public mind a desirable "atmosphere" for their products. The collaboration of the two has brought us to the brink of empire, and the view should be enough for us to step back and take stock of our relationship to the planet and her people, and realize a house divided against itself cannot stand. This is but one facet of the holistic necessity of sustainability; as the Sierra Club's recent program describes it: from lightbulbs to leadership.

I lived through the Vietnam

I lived through the Vietnam War as a draft age young man. I remember thinking that the one good result of that war was that an interventionist war of choice would never happen again, at least not in my lifetime. I was sadly mistaken. Today's situation is much worse. The current administration has shown a much greater ability to control the media and the "truth" than Nixon ever did. Some were even proud to be on Nixon's enemies list - see cartoonist Art Buchwald. Nixon came close to being removed from office by impeachment. His pardon set the precedent that crimes by a sitting president will not be punished. Bush's trashing of the constitution is far more serious and dangerous to our society than Nixon's ever were, yet the threat of impeachment is nil. Today's Pentagon shows a much greater ability to control bad news coming from a was zone than Secdef McNamera and General Westmoreland ever dreamed of. Future presidents will have the ability to monitor all communications within and without the U.S., arrest anyone including U.S. citizens and declare them unlawful enemy combatants, jail them without the right of habeas corpus, and even render them to foreign countries for torture if necessary. Bush has shown that these actions can be taken with impunity. It is naive to think no future president will use these powers. During the next war the president can declare a national emergency and cancel elections. There will be no opposition.

Oh how far to the bad we

Oh how far to the bad we have come. "The Dangerous Leap: Preventive War" isn't just a dangerous leap; it's a war crime for which people were hung 60 years ago. That there is even a debate about this is most depressing. Even more depressing is that there are Think Tanks who even engage in the debate rather than pointing this truth out in stark terms.

It is said that we are

It is said that we are reincarnated until at long last we learn the lesson that reality is but a persistent illusion and that violence begets only violence. It is said that this is true for all save the samurai, who must pay the price for becoming a samurai, and that price is to be eternally reborn as a samurai. It is said that the price others pay for allowing themselves to be ruled by samurai (or those who imagine themselves samurai) is to be eternally at war.

A major lesson of political

A major lesson of political history is that we will be misled and will not learn from experience. Prosecutor Jackson opened the Nuremberg trials with the statement the purpose was not to achieve justice but to lay down a record of what happened so that future generations would know not to make the same mistakes. In the past few years I have written several letters to newspapers simply noting the findings at Nuremberg.. None were published. Some generated editorial responses that in no circumstances would they ever print a letter comparing Bush to Hitler. None of my letters mentioned Bush., only the findings on the course of the corrupting influences of power in the Third Reich.

What we do not need is a

What we do not need is a know-nothing cowboy president who likes to play at war. We need someone who can think, who does policy analysis and who listens to advisors but has a balanced view of both the US and the Global situation. This last president has been an arrogant fool. He likes to talk tough and dress up in his military garb and rough up the little guys. Hopefully, our next president can act presidential and live up to the laws of the land and the Constitution, not just the likes of big business.

It's naive to think that

It's naive to think that history will change. Boys/men (and now some women) will always want to go out and kill someone when they feel threatened, and sometimes when they don't. A reading of history finds few times when conquering was not the most respected modus operandi of the entitled. There are more weapons and more effective weapons. And now we have more and more violent media, etc. etc. Violence is no longer the new porn, it is the established porn. Sorry if this sounds depressing, but it's the darned truth. While we talk with the choir, "normal" people are lining up behind McCain, who would "rather win a war than win an election". Somehow the danger we are all in needs to get past the censorship of politically correct equal time.

Add a comment:

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
The following question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Please enter the two words seen below. If you cannot read them you may use the button with circling arrows to get a new one.