News

Facebook DIGG

Reporters Say Networks Block War Reports

by: Brian Stelter  |  Visit article original @ The New York Times

photo
Journalists bringing the war home.
(Photo: Michael Kamber / The New York Times / Polaris)

    Getting a story on the evening news isn't easy for any correspondent. And for reporters in Iraq and Afghanistan, it is especially hard, according to Lara Logan, the chief foreign correspondent for CBS News. So she has devised a solution when she is talking to the network.

    "Generally what I say is, 'I'm holding the armor-piercing R.P.G.,'" she said last week in an appearance on "The Daily Show," referring to the initials for rocket-propelled grenade." 'It's aimed at the bureau chief, and if you don't put my story on the air, I'm going to pull the trigger.'"

    Ms. Logan let a sly just-kidding smile sneak through as she spoke, but her point was serious. Five years into the war in Iraq and nearly seven years into the war in Afghanistan, getting news of the conflicts onto television is harder than ever.

    "If I were to watch the news that you hear here in the United States, I would just blow my brains out because it would drive me nuts," Ms. Logan said.

    According to data compiled by Andrew Tyndall, a television consultant who monitors the three network evening newscasts, coverage of Iraq has been "massively scaled back this year." Almost halfway into 2008, the three newscasts have shown 181 weekday minutes of Iraq coverage, compared with 1,157 minutes for all of 2007. The "CBS Evening News" has devoted the fewest minutes to Iraq, 51, versus 55 minutes on ABC's "World News" and 74 minutes on "NBC Nightly News." (The average evening newscast is 22 minutes long.)

    CBS News no longer stations a single full-time correspondent in Iraq, where some 150,000 United States troops are deployed.

    Paul Friedman, a senior vice president at CBS News, said the news division does not get reports from Iraq on television "with enough frequency to justify keeping a very, very large bureau in Baghdad." He said CBS correspondents can "get in there very quickly when a story merits it."

    In a telephone interview last week, Ms. Logan said the CBS News bureau in Baghdad was "drastically downsized" in the spring. The network now keeps a producer in the country, making it less of a bureau and more of an office.

    Interviews with executives and correspondents at television news networks suggested that while the CBS cutbacks are the most extensive to date in Baghdad, many journalists shared varying levels of frustration about placing war stories onto newscasts. "I've never met a journalist who hasn't been frustrated about getting his or her stories on the air," said Terry McCarthy, an ABC News correspondent in Baghdad.

    By telephone from Baghdad, Mr. McCarthy said he was not as busy as he was a year ago. A decline in the relative amount of violence "is taking the urgency out" of some of the coverage, he said. Still, he gets on ABC's "World News" and other programs with stories, including one on Friday about American gains in northern Iraq.

    Anita McNaught, a correspondent for the Fox News Channel, agreed. "The violence itself is not the story anymore," she said. She counted eight reports she had filed since arriving in Baghdad six weeks ago, noting that cable news channels like Fox News and CNN have considerably more time to fill with news than the networks. CNN and Fox each have two fulltime correspondents in Iraq.

    Richard Engel, the chief foreign correspondent for NBC News, who splits his time between Iraq and other countries, said he found his producers "very receptive to stories about Iraq." He and other journalists noted that the heated presidential primary campaign put other news stories on the back burner earlier this year.

    Ms. Logan said she begged for months to be embedded with a group of Navy Seals, and when she came back with the story, a CBS producer said to her, "One guy in uniform looks like any other guy in a uniform." In the follow-up phone interview, Ms. Logan said the producer no longer worked at CBS. And in both interviews, she emphasized that many journalists at CBS News are pushing for war coverage, specifically citing Jeff Fager, the executive producer of "60 Minutes." CBS News won a Peabody Award last week for a "60 Minutes" report about a Marine charged in the killings at Haditha.

    On "The Daily Show," Ms. Logan echoed the comments of other journalists when she said that many Americans seem uninterested in the wars now. Mr. McCarthy said that when he is in the United States, bringing up Baghdad at a dinner party "is like a conversation killer."

    Coverage of the war in Afghanistan has increased slightly this year, with 46 minutes of total coverage year-to-date compared with 83 minutes for all of 2007. NBC has spent 25 minutes covering Afghanistan, partly because the anchor Brian Williams visited the country earlier in the month. Through Wednesday, when an ABC correspondent was in the middle of a prolonged visit to the country, ABC had spent 13 minutes covering Afghanistan. CBS has spent eight minutes covering Afghanistan so far this year.

    Both Ms. Logan and Mr. McCarthy noted that more coalition soldiers were killed in Afghanistan in May than in Iraq. No American television network has a full-time correspondent in Afghanistan, although CNN recently said it would open a bureau in Kabul.

    "It's terrible," Ms. Logan said in the telephone interview. She called it a financial decision. "We can't afford to maintain operations in Iraq and Afghanistan at the same time," she said. "It's so expensive and the security risks are so great that it's prohibitive."

    Mr. Friedman said coverage of Iraq is enormously expensive, mostly due to the security risks. He said meetings with other television networks about sharing the costs of coverage have faltered for logistical reasons.

    Journalists at all three American television networks with evening newscasts expressed worries that their news organizations would withdraw from the Iraqi capital after the November presidential election. They spoke only on the condition of anonymity in order to avoid offending their employers.

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

The sanitization of the war

The sanitization of the war in Iraq is almost complete. There is a war there, but it doesnt effect us much. A million civilians are dead, but no one can prove it here, so who cares? There is a lot of violence in Iraq, but it is not reported thanks to our outstanding media. It is a dead issue. They are ready for Iran now, Syria next. Who cares if it turns into one giant Palestine? Nobody I guess, except for you and me and all those who have to live there.

Whatever flavour of Kool-aid

Whatever flavour of Kool-aid they are drinking in DC, the MSM obviously partakes as well. Can you ask for a clearer example of the vital importance of supporting Truthout.org! I live at/near the poverty level, and I STILL manage to give my little $5 every couple of months. Come on, any of you who have not yet contributed. This service is for WE the People, that means WE gotta support it!. If the Truth matters at all to you, this is the place to put your money. Carry the battle to the enemy!

The reason I am

The reason I am "disinterested" in articles or segments about the occupation of Iraq and Afghanistan is that I don't trust the coverage. We have been fed so much propaganda over the years that it will take a major overhaul at the FCC (with a new party and president) for me to trust the corporate news again.

I watch Democracy Now on

I watch Democracy Now on FSTV and LinkTV. Journal and MOSAIC on Link, as well as several international shows on both networks. Some can be found on-line, and I totally recommend Mosaic at Linktv.org/Mosaic

The disinterest is because

The disinterest is because the warriors and casualties are essentially "mercenaries".... and most citizens know NO ONE who is actually in Iraq...and in harms way. None of their sons and daughters, grandchilren, husbands/wives, brothers/sisters have died , been maimed, and wrecked by #43's excellent adventure.The primary impact on ordinary Americans has been financial. If there was a DRAFT , there would be no americans in Iraq. And so so the networks play to the audience of spectators and have zero sense of responsibilty to report the story of the loss of the American soul .... just like the good germans. If we are uinformed and ignorant , hwo can there be any guilt, for us or for them.

Lara is a good

Lara is a good person...brave, and proven "in the field"...her industry, the mainstream media, however, is treasonous, ergo terrible disinterest in what they have to say about the occupations...didn't she hear that "the surge is working"? I heard it over and over on CBS. In that we activists set out to recapture the "free press", starting 8 years ago more-or-less, it's so good to see journalists finally recognizing the damage that the complete failure of their industry has done, in regards to allowing the neocons and Congress to execute their agenda of unAmerican ways, aggressive and illegal warfare against innocent nations, and the attack on civil liberties at home. I hope to see Lara marching and speaking out as a civilian-citizen AND as a real journalist, out in the streets with us in the near future, as we act against the loss of our Constitutional rights, and the destructive wars that her bosses, and their ratings/money-driven ways, have allowed to happen. REAL Journalism is lost in the nation, and the "free press" shamed. Lara, you were AWESOME on "The Daily Show". Please don't stop standing tall. Peace to you from a volunteer infantry veteran in south Louisiana, and "Welcome Home".

Main reason is that there

Main reason is that there really isn't that much to report. Bad guys (i.e. Al-Queada)are on the run, and the locals have seen who the winner is - the Iraqi government and it's US supporters. The "if it bleeds, it leads" MSM really don't have a lot of bleeding to report - therefore all the reporting of progress is boring. Ergo - no stories. Nothing drops faster off the MSM than success stories (and I'm not talking about the typically reported rags to riches human interest story), particularly the long grinding drive to accomplishment. In my own experience, we got a great report in 2003 about a school we refurbished and got running. 2 months later, after we got about 300 schools in my province refurbished, up and running; we called the MSM for a follow up report. Response from 5 contacts was the same: "We already did that story".

The story doesn't go nearly

The story doesn't go nearly far enough. What are the names of individuals, producers etc. who are responsible for this black-balling of the truth? And why is that the policy of the networks? I want to see their pictures and hear them say that they feel people are more interested in Paris Hilton than Bush/GOP incredible crime wave of mass murder, torture, theft etc. Rightfully their FCC licenses should be in peril. koolmuse anonymousource.com

I started out in Vietnam-era

I started out in Vietnam-era journalism school with the aim of becoming a foreign correspondent. A different direction called me, but I still have a vision of what good journalism is and CBS's coverage of Iraq as described by Lara Logan ain't it. And it's a crime. A war crime.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.