Share

Republican Campaign Against Likely Democratic Voters Begins

by: Steven Rosenfeld  |  AlterNet

photo
Danielle Wipperfurth, left, of Minneapolis, Minnesota, gets help from Mary Jo Clark, as she registers to vote. GOP officeholders and party officers are trying to discredit recent voter registration drives by Democrats. (Photo: Chuck Burton / AP)

    The GOP's latest accusations are long on rhetoric but short on facts.

    Across the country and on the Republican National Committee website, a handful of GOP office holders and party officers are trying to discredit recent voter registration drives and record-setting turnout by Democrats in 2008 primaries, saying efforts seen as benefiting Democrats are rife with "voter fraud."

    Consider the following examples:

    * The Louisiana Republican Party last month attacked Democrats for a "phony" registration drive because as many as 30 percent of applications were missing information - an industry norm - and called for an investigation. Louisiana Secretary of State Jay Dardenne, a Republican, launched that investigation; however, his office has since declined to comment.

    * This past Sunday, Alabama Attorney General Troy King, a Republican, appeared on Fox News to complain that voter "fraud and systemic corruption" were rampant in a handful of mostly Democratic-majority counties. He said absentee ballots were being sold for $40 or traded for driveway gravel, but he did not announce any prosecutions.

    * In Indiana, after that state's presidential primary, the East Chicago Republican Party chairman claimed that record turnout by Democratic voters included people from nearby Illinois, a charge that the local county election director rejected as unfounded.

    * Most notably, the Republican National Committee has a page on its website titled ""You Can't Make This Up!" It features an interactive map on which states are linked to a list of "voter fraud" stories. The reports are a grab bag of almost anything nefarious concerning the voting process or elections, including allegations that may never be prosecuted or tried in court.

    Since the 1960s, the Republican Party has raised "ballot security" issues in campaigns to justify a range of activities that critics have said lead to voter suppression. In recent years, fears of voter fraud - which as defined by the GOP refers to people impersonating other voters - have led state legislators to pass additional voting regulations, such as tougher voter ID laws and stiff penalties for errors by registration groups. Critics say the laws often are intended to shape the electorate to benefit GOP candidates.

    "As long as there are any expected close elections, and/or efforts on the ground to register and mobilize low-income voters, we should expect to see a propaganda campaign to blunt the effects," said Lorraine Minnite, a Barnard College political scientist who has written extensively on GOP claims of voter fraud since 2000.

    Particularly notable to Minnite is the RNC web page, because it echoes an approach used by a Republican front group in 2005 and 2006, the American Center for Voting Rights, which made exaggerated claims of Democrat-related voter fraud as part of its strategy to lobby states and Congress to pass tougher voter ID and voter registration laws. The group claimed to be nonpartisan but was created in 2004 by a former top election lawyer from the Bush-Cheney 2004 campaign, Mark "Thor" Hearne.

    "The roundup of claims is effective precisely because it's a mountain of words," Minnite explained in an e-mail. "When you try to read it, you quickly find lots of junk in the file. There are lots of stories about corrupt politicians, stories about people simply accused of things, stories of registration workers making up a couple of names, stories about people who are confused about the rules (including some election workers), multiple stories about the same ambiguous incident, 'concerns' about absentee ballots, etc."

    This approach was political propaganda, she said.

    "The style is what we saw in the report issued by the American Center for Voting Rights: Compile any news article you can find that mentions anything related to election crime, whether the report is definitive or not, factual or on the level of gossip, and call it 'You Can't Make This Up!' The ACVR called their report 'the most comprehensive and authoritative review of the facts surrounding allegations of vote fraud, intimidation and suppression made during the 2004 presidential election.' Don't bother to investigate the report, verify the facts, or consider alternative explanations. Just compile the reports and point to the pile."

    Minnite, who has found most GOP claims of "voter fraud" to be mistakes that did not include deliberately impersonating voters, predicted that an analysis of the incidents now on the RNC site would find "fewer people committing fraud than losing their right to vote for lack of proper documentation."

    This does not mean that there are not instances of people who intentionally impersonate voters. However, those instances are rare - single incidents in states with millions of voters - and almost always are caught by local election and law enforcement officials.

    Minnite also noted that some of the GOP's claims of voter fraud came from locales with histories of political corruption, which prompts some partisans to jump to conclusions.

    "For example, there is a long history of both racial political conflict, as well as intra-black political conflict in the Black Belt counties of west Alabama, which are now the focus of voter fraud investigations by Republican state officials," she said.

    In East Chicago, Ind., the state Supreme Court overturned the 2003 mayoral primary results after absentee ballots were found to have been altered, according to a report in the Post-Tribune newspaper.

    When asked who these oversized claims of voter fraud were targeting, Minnite said it was likely people who did not pay attention to facts in campaigns.

    "Probably the same people who think Obama is a Muslim," she said. "What I mean is that "voter fraud" is a form of racial coding for 'we must stop at least some black people (also known as Democrats in polite company) from voting or we are going to lose this election.' Commentators on the growing power of the internet to facilitate the spread of propaganda also like to talk about 'viral' messages. I would say this is one."

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Republicans are criminal

Republicans are criminal sociopaths. They use force (money) and media (fraud) to prevail. They should have been outlawed as a subversive organization during the 1800's

This is one of the issues

This is one of the issues that literally makes my blood boil when I read about them and I feel is the single greatest threat to Obama's electoral prospects and any potential we have for any real future reforms. The absolutely vile, corrupt disenfranchisement of only democratic constituents perpetrated by this administration is nauseating, and I simply cannot comprehend the endemic neglect of elected democrats to gain any traction on this issue at all. From fervent practices of GOP organized voter 'caging' and prosecutions by the politicized DOJ of democrats only, and the intentional lack of transparency of Diebold and electronic voting machines, and how many are even available for use in minority districts; the taciturnity of democratic elected officials on this has been mind boggling. What could they possibly have to gain from neglecting to turn this issue into a cause celebre to push back against these nefarious practices? That their existence at all first gained notoriety from a foreign press and continuing activism into investigations has been led only by grass roots efforts and academics is dumbfounding. The minimal to nonexistent efforts of American MSM or politicians on the left to bring continued awareness to these travesties, as if by ignoring them they will go away, and then to read now about how these practices are starting up again business as usual in this election cycle makes me furious to the point of fucking apoplexy. And I'm not sure what more I can possibly do. Yes, I have written my senator and representatives multiple times regarding this most imperative of issues, and get replies and updates of only this and that bit of legislation that my dem politician X has been in full support of and been incapable of getting passed in congress. So if we have on our hands another contested election this cycle with a dubious McCain win, anything short of mass rioting is unfathomable. But the blame still starts with our elected officials and their enablers in the main stream press.

When we get some comments

When we get some comments from the vote suppressors and those that find some reason for supressing some citizens right to vote I will start commenting. In the meantime, it's bedtime. See you all in 5the AM. Bye,bye.

" GOP accusations long

" GOP accusations long on rhetoric but short on facts" - - and Republican Party operatives are also even longer on sleazy tactics, and rough physical handling of oppponents when they decide that the situation warrants an actual physical attack. Remember the invasion of the Florida polling place by the Repulican Party goon squad in 2000. The Republican Party has abandoned all sense of decency or civilized behavior in its desire to win and control - - at any cost. It has become party of criminals willing to destroy itself rather than accept defeat.

Where is the proof.

Where is the proof. Besides, they might recall their own Republican voter fraud for past elections!

I'm not surprised that the

I'm not surprised that the GOP is making such claims. Aren't they the party who disenfranchised many Democratic voters in 2000 and 2004 in order to "steal" each election? These claims are just another case of "sour grapes"in the win-at-any cost mentality of the GOP. It's lucky for the Democrats that so many voters are turning out to vote this election. No matter what the GOP claims, they won't be able to disenfranchise every Democratic voter.

even if and I am only says

even if and I am only says even if, there is some fraud in the vote, I strongly suspect it goes both ways. Greg Palast has evidence that it goes all the way to Cheney on the Republican side, trying to disenfranchise members of the military voting absentee in Florida. I doubt that a few challenges to votes will change the hopefully overwhelming revultion of GW and company, including GW mimic McCain.

I guess the Republicans are

I guess the Republicans are so afraid of losing that they will use any and all means to win. And I think they are correct in their thinking. If they didn't cheat they would lose. Very few of us would vote for them if we knew the truth about them and what they stand for.

What on earth are the

What on earth are the democrats waiting for? They've capitulated to illegal domestic spying, they've taken impeachment off the table while they continue to support the illegal war in Iraq. And while they play patty cake with the republicans, the republicans are playing their usual dirty hardball. Now is the time to nail their coffins closed. Impeach Bush and Cheney. Haul Karl Roves ass to court and investigate these republican officials who are undermining the election system.

Takes one to know one. Once

Takes one to know one. Once again the Repugs blame the Dems for their own crimes and mistakes. They get more proactive about it all the time. Let's just hope it doesn't turn into martial law when the numbers don't go their way.

It's the pot calling the

It's the pot calling the kettle black, as usual. What does it take to get us to launch an all-out attack on the Republicans? There are more of us, there are more Democrats in Congress, and still we let Bush & company get away with criminal behavior. Europeans stage riots when their governments sell them out. We've got to learn to do the same, or this country will become more of a corporate fascist dictatorship than it already is.

the nerve..... the election

the nerve..... the election thieves and diebold purveyors have the gall to say ANYTHING about electionfraud??!!!! Just a little reminder here, the N.H. primaries should show who rigs what.....and HOW

This pattern and practice of

This pattern and practice of deception is the story of the gang of violent extremists who came to power under the Eisenhower-Nixon regime, taking office in 1953 and immediately overthrowing the democratically elected government of Iran. In 1954 they armed Ho Chi Minh to defeat the French, then conspired to start the American war in Southeast Asia which used the American teenage boy to take the drug trade from French organized crime and give it to American organized crime. In 1954 they overthrew the government of Guatemala, setting up casinos in league with organized crime and what the book "Bitter Fruit" called, cryptically, "other recent arrivals,' likely German Nazis, Italian fascists, and Japanese Black Eagles, their allies against America's greatest generation in World War II. The dictatorships they set up stayed for decades, looking more like Nazi Germany than democratic America. In 1955 they overthrew Panama, assassinating President Remon. In 1956 they overthrew Costa Rica. For years in the 1950's they conspired to murder half a million Indonesians, supporting that dictatorship. These were some of their fascist doings. Who knows what else they did. But they came to power in 1953 with this fascist agenda in hand. And they continue to work on the agenda to the present day. They came back to power after assassinating John F. Kennedy, Martin Luther King Jr., and Robert F. Kennedy, and practiced their spying, propaganda, fraud and murder in the Nixon regime. They came back in the Reagan regime, the Bush regimes, I and II, the same men and women, working on the fascist agenda to destroy representative Constitutional democracy in the United States, while touting democratic reform, even writing a Constitution, as a motive for invading Iraq. Their voting machines are in polling places all over the country, totally unsecure, unreliable for the people, pledged by the machine-makers to deliver the Presidency, Congressional seats, Governorships, down to the local level, to their fascist collaborators or willing dupes. It is not 'Republicans' but the gang of violent extremists who took over the party that threaten the United States and, using its power, all humanity. Republicans helped elect the Democratic majority which took back the Congress but which has failed to stand against the fascists. Impeachment is not an option but a Constitutional responsibility. Only by standing apart from the fascists, bringing them to justice, can the American people save their country and reestablish our reputation as a nation of laws, the force of law, not the law of force. To take impeachment off the table is to collaborate with this domestic enemy which has committed treason against the people of the United States. We are far over the edge, pushed down the slippery slope to totalitarian fascist government. Now is the time for all good men and women to come to the aid of their country, to defend it from the fascist agenda.

It's so good to hear a

It's so good to hear a uniform response of outrage, after being dismissed as a "conspiracy theorist" for the last few years. Hard for the Repubicans to explain away that "minus 16,000 votes for Al Gore" in 2000 Florida. Of course, I get the same response when I point out that LOTS of building demolition experts tell us that 9-11 was a masterful example of controlled demolition, not "building collapse due to fire". It's really not a very hard scenario to comprehend. NeoCON ideologs let 9-11 happen, so they could have the war they'd wanted since the mid-90s. Informed capitalists helped the buildings fall down and made out very well on the insurance, rather than having to pay a fortune to tear them down due to asbestos. The corporate media fed the fear, because it sells a lot of their product, and people bought it. -And yes, we had two rigged Presidential elections. If you actually question, and look, you will see "the banality of evil" on full display. As before, they are counting on our credulity regarding their versions of the facts. Come on, people. Stop waiting on any of them, industry and mass media included. This coming election is not about change. Nothing will change, except for the worse. This election is about the dying gasp of the old order. It's about corporations that can't survive without going cannibalistic on each other, battling for dominance by toadying proxy. It's about lies and more abuse of the Constitution. OF COURSE there will be voter fraud, duly reported and distorted. But it doesn't ever address the REAL voter fraud, that happens when the DNC and RNC decide who we will be allowed to vote for. Why fight so hard for the right to vote on somebody that has already been chosen by one wing or the other of the Property and Money Party? We learned a valuable lesson here in Michigan this primary season. Do you see it? The real choices have already been weeded out, and here we are with our masters' choice, between a damaged white sock-puppet, and a really nice black one. Both CHRISTIANS, both pro-war, neither of them willing to utter the words IMPEACHMENT, or REPEAL THE (NOT-)PATRIOT ACT. Wow. What a choice. I'm done trying to help preserve a failing system. I'd rather put my effort into leaving those dinosaurs at the "top of the food chain" with nothing left to eat. The future is arriving, it's viral and spreading, and it's not stopping for roadblocks. The fact that you're reading this, on reader-supported news, makes my point. Now go forth and mutate. Don't be the last one out of this fake-election, fake-economy, fake-enemy, fake-issue slime pool.

Why McSame will win. The

Why McSame will win. The mainstream media on television is frontloaded for illiterate people to vote for McSame McPain and voting is rigged by republicans whereever they can. The youth vote could overwhelm their cheating, but the youth are big on talk and short on action (like voting).