Truthout Original

Russian Jerks Meet Western Knee-Jerks

by: Steve Weissman, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili and US General John Craddock, head of the US European Command, after a press conference in Tbilisi, Georgia, on August 21. (Photo: Reuters)

    The Russians can be real jerks, but they are not the only ones dragging us into a cold war redo. Blockheads on all sides are bringing back the risk of all-out nuclear conflict, along with a new arms race and the thrusting of American power from the Russian borderlands to wherever we see a Russian proxy. Even if Barack Obama and Joe Biden manage to win the election in November, the financial cost of a rush to yesteryear could cripple any real chance for a better tomorrow.

    Strangely enough, the Russians appear to be complying with the six-point cease-fire agreement that French President Nicolas Sarkozy brokered, though no one would know it by listening to the heated rhetoric now coming from Washington and its NATO allies. The agreement, which the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs has posted on its web site, allows Russian troops to remain in the breakaway regions of South Ossetia and Abkhazia. It specifies no limits on the number of troops or types of weapons the Russians may have. And, pending the establishment of "international mechanisms," it specifically permits the Russians "to implement additional security measures," such as the checkpoints the Russians have set up on Georgia's main highway.

    Sarkozy now insists that Russia can implement these extra measures only in the immediate vicinity of the two provinces, while Western media have talked about a "security zone" on the Georgian side of the administrative borders of South Ossetia and Abkhazia. But none of this appears in the written agreement the Russians signed.

    Even more to the point, the Russians never agreed in the cease-fire to maintain Georgia's "territorial integrity." As Sarkozy well knows, they explicitly rejected any such provision and have openly declared they would now support South Ossetia and Abkhazia in seceding from Georgia, just as the United States and most of Europe supported Kosovo in breaking away from Serbia.

    None of this in any way justifies the way the Russians are lording it over Georgia, threatening Poland with nuclear annihilation, or threatening to rearm Cuba. They are, as I said, acting like jerks, and hurting their own cause, especially in Western Europe. But they are doing what they agreed to do, and in loudly proclaiming otherwise, NATO leaders seem determined to fire up a new cold war.

    Adding fuel to the fire, most in the West ignore the role of Georgia's President Mikheil Saakashvili in provoking the Russian attack and continue to lionize him as the great democratic martyr of our age. He's not, and never was. Washington covertly staged his "Rose Revolution," and his great appeal to Georgian voters was primarily his ultra-nationalistic promise to put down any independence or autonomy for the Ossetians and Abkhazians. The current crisis stems directly from Washington's attempt to use this Georgian fervor against the Russians, and keeping the hotheaded Saakashvili as our man against Moscow simply keeps the pot boiling.

    If democracy and self-determination are the goal, it would be smarter by far to call the Russians on their bluff as "liberators" and propose an internationally supervised referendum to ask the Ossetians and Abkhazians what they want. But, no. The Western Europeans continue to embrace Saakashvili, even as they put off making Georgia (or Ukraine) a full-fledged member of NATO. No one, either in Europe or the United States, wants to go to war to defend Georgia, not even John McCain, whose foreign policy adviser Randy Scheunemann was a paid lobbyist for the Georgians. But now that the cold war juices are flowing, very few - left or right - seem willing to step away from Saakashvili's grasp.

    This is a particular problem for the Democrats, who are beginning their convention in Denver this week. Barack Obama, the presumptive presidential nominee, has called for costly social programs, from universal health care to the creation of new energy sources. But his vice-presidential pick, Joe Biden, has just returned from visiting Georgia as a guest of Saakashvili, and is pushing a $1 billion aid package for the Georgians. And that's just the first billion. If the United States leads NATO into a new cold war, the costs could be staggering, which will leave very little for "change we can believe in."

    So far, I'm fairly pessimistic. Obama seems to have absorbed Biden's zeal for Saakashvili, and on the question of Georgia most of the Democratic Party now sounds like secondhand McSame. But there's always hope. If we can believe Mikhail Gorbachev, the Russians do not want a new cold war, and most Americans would clearly prefer health care to warfare. The question is whether American democracy and a new leader committed to change are strong enough for the popular will to prevail.

»


A veteran of the Berkeley Free Speech Movement and the New Left monthly Ramparts, Steve Weissman lived for many years in London, working as a magazine writer and television producer. He now lives and works in France.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

Trying to be dispassionate,

Trying to be dispassionate, I have a hard time figuring out what's going on. Are the Ossetians really proRussian, are they mistreated by the Georgians? (Yes I'd say). Is Georgia being manipulated by the US (neocons) ? Probably. Should Russia respect Georgia's border? Yes. Is Russia protecting the Ossets? Probably. Is Russia doing ethnic cleansing, removing Georgians from Ossetia? Yes. Should the west be more understanding of Russia and be an ally against Islamic terrorism? YES. The situation is confusing, and nobody is really helping clear it up. To be practical and realistic we should not provoke the Russians with missile defense in Poland, but we should have them withdraw from Ossetia, replaced by (yet another) peacekeeping force. International Kosovo-like negotiations should then go on for a few years, until, probably, Ossetia (and Abkhasia?) get autonomy or independence. But the dems need to be elected, so I guess we need a clear attitude (even if that means gross oversimplification) which the repugs can't attack too much.

The author deserves credit

The author deserves credit for a) writing the truth about the limited terms of the ceasefire agreement, thus the reasonable compliance of the Russian side with what has been agreed, and b) finally indicating that the South Ossetians and Abkhazians ought to have a significant input in a future resolution of the conflict. Georgia, indeed no other entity, should dismiss the democratic rights of the majority in a region which wants self-determination; the questionable notion of "territorial integrity" hardly justifies anybody treading with army boots over the rights of the people of such territory.

Steve grew up in Berkeley in

Steve grew up in Berkeley in a well to do family, father a dentist, as i recall. Private school for all the kids. Now an author(ity). I don't think so. Just another "liberal" elitist. Push his israel buttom, and check the response.

Both the USA and Russia have

Both the USA and Russia have leaders as corrupt and as incompetent as those who led the world into the holocaust of World War I. That goes for the Obama creeps as much as for the Busheviki. Looks like the new century is beginning much as did the old. . . . August 1914 = August 2008. Chris Herz cdherz44@yahoo.com

I agree with "Joe S". What

I agree with "Joe S". What we need is REAL change, what we apparently will be getting is a change of faces on the corporate / military puppets. So, McCain's neo-con demon Scheunemann hasn't stirred up a war over NOTHING since Iraq, and now he's steering Grandpa "Straight Talk" into another exercise in fake democracy-and-freedom for money. -And Joe Biden is apparently signing on, and dragging Obama into the slime with him. Swell. However, to "Solkoniki Park", may I say, I know that our politicians are scaly bloody minions of Satan, who will do anything to steal anybody's natural resources, but apparently you haven't figured that out about Russia's politicians. Perhaps you forget that during the Soviet Union, many Russians were moved into entities like Georgia to colonize it, so they could outnumber the original inhabitants of the place. Those "breakaway regions" were originally Georgian territory, and yet you want to pretend that Vladimir Putin is an annointed Saint with no expansionist plans? Saint KGB, perhaps? I too despair of any solution to the problem of politics, but I think both sides are overdue for a Lenin, willing to thin out the ruling class.

The Soviets always liken

The Soviets always liken themselves to “chess players” in contrast to Americans whom they considered poker players, bluffing and unready for an extended confrontation. Well, Grand master Putkin has played one hell of a game. First he built a strong position- strengthening his wrecked economy. And then he bided his time while the world’s only “super power wasted itself pursuing a bellicose strategy that went no where and exposed its weaknesses. When the crisis or better crises arrived Putkin expertly moved his knight to the centre of the board and check. It’s not mate yet but the US is in a terrible position. Then, Putkin a chess master schooled in the old USSR’s toughest classroom, the KGB, simply punches the time clock and defers to NATO’s toothless ceasefire knowing there is little they can do. During the Viet-Nam war Country Joe and the Fish taunted LBJ in a song singing “send him back to Texas make him work on his ranch. It’s time for GWB to do that and could he do us all a favour and take his neo-con crew of checker players with him.

In the late Walt Kelly´s

In the late Walt Kelly´s now vanished comic strip “Pogo”, Georgia’s Okefenokee Swamp served as the stage for a cast of wonderful talking animals who employed a rich combination of wit, and word play to lampoon the most ridiculous aspects of American society. As I contemplate the chaos that Bush and Putkin have inflicted on the world, I find myself thinking of a particular “Pogo” moment in which “Miz Beaver, the toughest gal in the swamp” gives Mr, Mouse some sage advice. The unfortunate rodent had just been thrashed in a wrestling match with an undersized “earth worm child” who had ambitions of becoming a boa constrictor. “Mr. Mouse never fight fellas smaller than you.” She tells him.” If you wins you is a bully and if you loses you is a bum. Always fight bigger fellas, win or lose you is a hero.” Unfortunately, we seem to live in a jungle not a swamp.

Surely the West also advised

Surely the West also advised Saakashvili on hair and makeup-since we're talking about appeal.

This article stinks of anti

This article stinks of anti Russian bias. The author understands nothing of history and tries to justify, albeit from an a la mode, progressive slant, the Nato expansion since Perestroika. 99% of americans will support the anti Russian agenda of either McCain or Obama. Americans are naive in thinking that there is that much difference between a Republican and Democratic White House when it comes to the nitty gritty of relations with Russia. Russians have the positive attribute of being able to endure with great patience seemingly unbearable hardships beyond what any other nation could muster ... until it reaches a certain point. Then all hell breaks loose. The West has acted criminally towards Russia since Perestroika in many different ways to numerous to list hear. Russia was almost destroyed by the late 90's and then it came back. The injustices of the time since Perestroika are now readily able to be seen, whereas before they were conveniently disguised under all kinds of Western programs to "help" Russia convert to a market based economy as a democracy. The West together with israel have been exposed for who they are. In a way it's sad that the West let a real opportunity go by and instead succumbed to the tried and tested policy of rape, pillaging and plundering of the Russian industrial base. Game's up now guys. You had your chance and you blew it.

Sorry Ray, JFK was in all

Sorry Ray, JFK was in all truth a charmer, as was his fashion trend setting wife, but JFK apart from that was a reckless cold war warrior who brought us to the brink of a nuclear war. This hero worshiping of JFK reeks of a desperation that actually prevents real change in the ol' USA, . JFK didn't stand up to Corporate America, he was corporate America, always more comfortable with the conservatives than the liberals in government. If you want a hero better FDR who strangely seems to have been edited out of the campaign rhetoric.

US/Israel are going after

US/Israel are going after the Caspian Sea oil (valued at $16 trillion).

Like most Americans, Mr.

Like most Americans, Mr. Weissman appears to know nothing about the efforts by Israel to gain control of Russia's resources (oil, gas, etc.) when the old Soviet Union was abandoned. Putin and his group have been trying to keep Russia for the Russians, in spite of all the hateful rhetoric the USA and Israel have poured out over the years. Weissman also fails to report the alarming number of American and Israeli "advisers" and other shadowy characters who have been working on the Georgians. It's the pipeline, people--that oil and gas that runs through Georgia that the USA and Israel feel should be theirs...and I suspect the Russians feel the same. Many ethnic Russians live in Georgia, by the way. Naturally they appealed to Russia for help. When USA states tried to secede from the Union, Lincoln waged a war against them to bring them to their knees. When Russia tries to keep Georgia in the Russian sphere, we cry "foul." What hypocrisy.

Time is on on Russia's side:

Time is on on Russia's side: the longer they endure the West encroachment into their backyard, the sooner they find out they won't even have a bed to sleep ! Either take on the West now and its leadership will still have a chance to survive after a global thermonuclear blast, or doing nothing and their leadership will eventually receive Saddam's fate. Whoever launch a first strike now would be able to wipe out 90% of the other party's nuclear arsenal, and as such, would survive a 10% nuclear retaliation. The choice is clear !

Weissman's article has it on

Weissman's article has it on point, but this points out the problem of inside the Beltway logic and the logic of the rest of us. Embargo on Cuba- we say NO, they say YES and so it stands. Government Sponsored Healthcare for all We say YES, they say... NO or "not now." The government gets caught up in this stupid logic of "influence" and so our soldiers are sent to kill civilians and then to die in foreign lands that pose no threat to us. We are lost and ignored. Millions marched against Iraq and were ignored. We need more than Obama and Biden especially given that Biden's primary qualification is that he was an anti-Soviet hawk for most of his career. We need wholesale change but I despair of how this might be possible. Kucinich, Paul, all those no matter their ideology who oppose war and foreign interference are completely ignored at best or derided as lunatics at worst.

I shudder at the thought of

I shudder at the thought of McCain in the Oval Office, with Joe Lieberman as vice-president and/or his top advisor--maybe not so much where Russia is concerned, but certainly where Arabs are involved as a potential threat against Israel. Specifically, at the moment, Iran.

I agree with Weissman. I can

I agree with Weissman. I can understand that the Bushites and the neo-conservatives, with their twisted views of international relations, will rush headlong back into cold war, machismo rhetoric, and take pride in prodding the Russian "bear" with a sharp stick. McCain has nothing to offer but a "me too" ideology. But to have supposedly progressive, rational people like Biden and Obama jump on the same wagon, joining all pre-mentioned FOOLS, is surely dismaying.

Since 1980, we have had 20

Since 1980, we have had 20 of 28 years of GOP Whitehouses + the other 8 years were Bilary (same as GOP). We need a swing to the American people rather than Corporate America in our White House leadership. JFK stood up to the rich people's puppets + see what he got in LBJ's home state; please GOD protect + elect OBAMA-Biden rather than McBush44-Romney.