Share

The Financial Meltdown Continues

by: Dean Baker, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
A trader on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange after the closing bell on September 18, 2008. Dean Baker argues that our current financial crisis continues to be driven by the collapsing housing market and Alan Greenspan's previous denial of a "housing bubble." (Photo: Reuters)

    Virtually the only certainty in the current financial situation is there will be more problems ahead. Those who controlled the levers of economic and financial policy neglected their greatest responsibility, which was to ensure an orderly financial market and prevent exactly the sort of collapse that we are now seeing. This was a policy failure of massive proportions, not a natural disaster.

    The central problem remains the collapsing housing market. The Case-Shiller 20-City Index shows a nominal price decline of almost 20 percent over the last two years, an event that few in the financial sector apparently considered to be a serious possibility. This price decline has led to an unprecedented rate of defaults on mortgages and derivative instruments.

    These defaults, in turn, have raised questions about the solvency of a large number of financial institutions. This has led to an increase in the price of risk more generally and the crisis of confidence that is currently shaking financial markets worldwide.

    While there is no simple path out of this crisis, it was a crisis that could have been easily avoided. If the Federal Reserve Board had acted to stem the growth of the housing bubble before it grew to such dangerous proportions, the country would not currently be facing a recession and the prospect of a financial collapse.

    Alan Greenspan had the tools necessary to rein in the bubble had he been so inclined. First, he could have imposed tighter restrictions on mortgages, as the Fed has recently done. This would have prevented many of the worst mortgages that led to the subprime crisis and helped inflate housing prices.

    More importantly, he could have used his platform as Fed chairman to explicitly warn of the dangers of the housing bubble. In his Congressional testimonies and other public appearances, he could have carefully explained how house prices had diverged from a 100-year-long trend in the mid-90s.

    He could have pointed out that after just increasing at the same pace as overall inflation for a century, house prices suddenly jumped by more than 70 percent, after adjusting for inflation, in the decade from 1996 to 2006. He could have shown this increase was not supported by any changes in the fundamentals of supply and demand in the housing market, nor was it matched by any remotely comparable increase in rents.

    If Chairman Greenspan had pointedly made the case for the existence of a housing bubble and explicitly warned of the losses likely to be suffered by individual homeowners and the huge risks being taken by financial institutions that were heavily invested in mortgages and mortgage derivatives, it almost certainly would have been sufficient to take the air out of the bubble. As a last recourse, he could have raised rates with the explicit purpose of bringing down house prices.

    Instead, Greenspan repeatedly denied the existence of a housing bubble, dismissing the warnings of the small group of economists who tried to call attention to the potential dangers posed by a housing bubble. Greenspan's denials helped create a false confidence that allowed the bubble to continue to expand. It also helped to fuel the complacency in financial markets that led the country's largest financial institutions to ignore potential risks and to become very highly leveraged against their capital.

    There are no easy solutions to a financial crisis of the sort the economy currently faces. It is not possible to change history, and we must work with the crisis the collapse of the bubble has created. However, it is important to recognize this crisis was entirely foreseeable and preventable.

  

»


Dean Baker is the Co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research. CEPR's Jobs Byte is published each month upon release of the Bureau of Labor Statistics' employment report.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Or to take it back one step

Or to take it back one step further, all centrally planned economies fail.

The Federal Reserve acts out

The Federal Reserve acts out of greed, it's not out to help our country, it's out to destroy it. This is all planned to destroy the world's economy so "they" can push their one wold electronic currency system. Wake up, people!

Soon it won't matter. We'll

Soon it won't matter. We'll all be living under bridges like a bunch of sorrowful trolls in a fairy tale. Well, at least those of us who don't live in Minn., where the bridge has fallen down. We can only hope that the next administration is really interested in changing the country, and I don't see how? Forget the delusions of people who would vote for Palin or the youthful exuberance of Obama's supporters, Wall Street money still runs the USA and until they are brought under control change is just something you hand over to a troll under the bridge.

What about the hundreds of

What about the hundreds of billions of dollars that have gone to tax breaks and other wealthfare for huge corporations with declining taxes for wealthy individuals over the last two decades? There's also the faulty assumption that profits "trickle down" while the income gap is the largest it has been since the 1920s. Few to no government regulations over Fannie and Freddie were also part of the problem. This is a complex issue the blame for which I don't think should be laid at Greenspan's feet.

Alan Greenspan has decades

Alan Greenspan has decades of bad decisions and policies behind him. Conservatives crying for free markets are either delusional or outright lying. As long as we prop up corporations, including large ag businesses, we will have corporate welfare. Ordinary citizens be damned.

history:this

history:this REAGAN-GREENSPAN-BUSH-[NO-USE R-WORD]-BUST.Greenspan was appointed by Reagan and he did the accomplished job of selling out the usa. yeppers, a real expert.

Anybody with an annual

Anybody with an annual income over $250,000 should have his/her assets (even those assets tucked away in secret overseas accounts) confiscated and recycled in order to "bail out" the market in the current crisis. That's what I would call a meaningful trickle-down effect.

Perhaps Greenspan preferred

Perhaps Greenspan preferred not to "let the air out of the bubble" because it had created substantial paper equity for homeowners who increasingly borrowed large amounts of it to sustain or expand their lifestyle. Since neither the 2001 nor 2003 Bush tax cuts had done anything to stimulate the economy, it fell to private homeowners to provide the Keynesian stimulus that expanded demand and pulled the economy out of stagnation. Killing off the goose that was laying the golden eggs just as his Republican president was struggling to get another "mandate" from the voters was unthinkable for the politically shrewd and sometimes passive-aggressive Fed chief. Yes, he should have acted by 1999, but once Bush got elected and the tech bubble burst on Wall Street, he did not have the political courage of Paul Volker to inflict any more wet blankets on the electorate.

Here we are at week's end

Here we are at week's end and the fraud of the American little guy is complete. The market wizards have decided they need to use our future incomes to bail-out gazillionaires. The logic behind the decision? if we don't bail out the gazillionaires, the whole thing will crash adn we'll starve to death. The outcome of the bold solution? They're gonna ratchet up our taxes so damned high and so damned fast to maintain "investor confidence" that all of this bad debt will magically become good debt through some slick new pricing scheme dreamed up by, you guessed it gazillionaires. I have been saying this since Bush got elected and I stopped getting raises and started getting fifteen pre-approved credit offers a week and offers for re-financing a mortgage I don't even have.... You can't borrow your way to prosperity. It's true for the individual, it's true for the corporation, and it's most certainly true for the government howse only product is tax-payers. None of the reporting this week has talked about the other meltdown. Consumer borrowing has been plummeting. In an economic climate where no one will lend to borrowers who aren't asking and 2 of 3 dollars in GDP is predicated on spending by consumers (tax-payers mostly), how the hell are they going to convince foreign investors that anyone is going to pay back loans they couldn't afford and should never have gotten. The seeds of the civil war we're thirty years in the making. We've been getting bamboozled by Crony Capitalists for 30 years. I bet we have bloodshed in the streets pretty soon. This has gone on so long it is getting tiring talking about it.

The "housing bubble" was in

The "housing bubble" was in a very different economic climate than we have now. In many ways the rising prices were justified. If nothing had been done, housing prices would have gradually leveled off, and then come down a little, without a crash. But the crackdown in illegal immigration completely undercut the housing market. Almost all illegal immigrants did not individually have the resources to buy a house. But, they pooled their money, and several immigrants would share the same house and the mortgage payments. The loan was unsound only on paper, as proved by the fact that they had no problem making the payments. The only problem was that the labelling of the immigrants as "illegal" undermined the reliability of the measures of their ability to pay. Then the crackdown on illegal immigrants occurred, they abandoned houses or were deported, house prices dropped, and the collapse of the housing market began. It is natural justice. The solution? Open the borders, and stop calling immigrants "illegal". Those regions which are friendly to illegal immigrants still have strong housing markets. "Cast your bread upon the waters, and it will come back to you!"

Mommy why does the market

Mommy why does the market crash? Because the greedy pigs have stolen every penny and have run out of money to steal. Mommy, why doesn't the president help? He is printing them more money to steal just as fast as he can darling. The govs non-stop looting of the US treasury for these thieves will destroy the dollar. The base value of a functional, no frills housing unit on a postage stamp sized lot is about $20,000. About the same as a working couple's annual income. Until prices fall to this level NO recovery is possible.

Social Security will be the

Social Security will be the first hit for the market moneybags. Betcha?

Thank you Dean Baker for

Thank you Dean Baker for partially exposing the underbelly of the beast. Your statement " This was a policy failure of massive proportions, not a natural disaster." sums up the difference between good governance and and unregulated mayhem. This massive "lack of judgment" was preventable. However, the con artists and scheisters who created this titanic screw job on the American people were raking in millions in bonuses and the companies and conglomerates were raking in billions in profits before it turned sour. All aided by lobbyists and the Republican party, some of them still working for John McCain. They thought the good times would never end, at least for them, and they were right about that. They took all our money and deposited it in secret Swiss bank accounts. The people who created the problem are immune from punishment and will be walking away with millions in executive pay "packages". All the risk and losses (and there will be losses) will be assumed by the US taxpayer. The US taxpayer should be paying more attention to who is sailing this ship. Or they can elect the same "skull and bones" pirates who are holding America hostage. Who will go to jail for this?

With the very good

With the very good possibility of a half trillion dollars of corporate welfare on the table, it behooves me how people can complain about the costs of any of our social programs. The Fed's bailout is nothing more than giving money to people who gambled with their money, or others', and lost.

This mess really does need

This mess really does need to be laid at Greenspan's feet. Some of us in the real estate industry have watched with unease for years now, knowing a downturn was overdue based on historical 7-10 year cycles that all of us in the industry know about. We watched what levels of honesty there are in the industry be decimated by continued artificially low interest rates. In the rush to make money, an honest appraiser who did not approve a purchase price would find less and less work, because no lender was going to use such an appraiser. Mortgage brokering--an unregulated industry primarily because the banking lobby fought every regulatory and licensing effort, at least here in Colorado--was rampant. Honest and knowledgeable lenders trying to keep income to debt ratios in check were outbid by many other brokers offering attractive (and speculative) products. Real estate purchasing for the last decade has been largely determined by the greatest possible debt risk possible, not the safest risk for both client and lender. This crisis is not just about speculation in the B- and C-paper loans. There is a speculative level at all housing brackets. I have seen house loans made on the basis of a stock portfolio, which I guess is a tangible asset in an up market. But no matter whose feet you sit at for economic theory--Friedman, Galbraith--we ALL know what goes up goes down eventually. The layman on any street knows it. Greenspan should go down in history as the worst Fed Chair ever because he had the hubris to think he was above the most basic understanding of economic theory. At the very least, Greenspan should be a curse word for working people. As in, "This greenspanning economy means my kid is probably not going to have enough greenspanning money to get through college. Greenspan this administration!"

REAGAN/GREENSPAN SELLOUT of

REAGAN/GREENSPAN SELLOUT of our country's assets and abilities is not over. the sovereign wealth funds are increasingly controlling our country with no point of return. bush 'we will fight them over there, so we do not have to fight them over here' misses the fact they have been fighting us over here for a long time, with the complicity of our 'blind' government--and have consistently been legally and financially winning. there are americans who are economic traitors. the protective[!?!?] tariffs and laws have been broken and we are 'dying of a thousand cuts'. experience with the consumer low end of swf real estate entity taught me this.

Atlas Shrugged.

Atlas Shrugged.

There are several

There are several multi-billionaires in our country. Take one billion dollars from each one of their bank accounts and solve the financial mess.

land grab. look and listen

land grab. look and listen to the recreation of feudalism. if you think it's not possible, check your denial, and look again.