Truthout Original

US General Accuses Bush Administration of War Crimes

by: Matt Renner and Maya Schenwar, t r u t h o u t | Report

photo
Abu Ghraib 37 (2005), by artist Fernando Botero

    Maj. Gen. Antonio Taguba (now retired) served as the deputy commanding general for support for the Third Army for ten months in Kuwait during the early days of the Iraq occupation. In a statement released today, he bluntly accuses the Bush administration of war crimes and lays down a challenge for prosecution.

    In 2004, Taguba released a classified report detailing abuses committed at Abu Ghraib Prison. The "Taguba Report" (executive summary) urged Pentagon officials to follow up on its findings by enforcing adherence to the Geneva Conventions in interrogations.

    Taguba retired in January 2007, later alleging that Pentagon officials had ordered him to retire for being "overzealous" in his criticisms of the military.

    In light of ongoing Congressional investigations into so-called harsh interrogation techniques, and on the heels of Congressman Dennis Kucinich recently issuing articles of impeachment accusing President Bush of, among other offenses, authorizing torture, we present Taguba's latest statement for your consideration.

    The full Physicians for Human Rights report outlining the medical evidence of torture perpetrated by the United States can be read at their website.

 :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

    

Preface to Broken Laws, Broken Lives

    By Maj. Gen. Antonio Taguba, USA (Retired)

    Maj. Gen. Taguba led the US Army's official investigation into the Abu Ghraib prisoner abuse scandal and testified before Congress on his findings in May 2004.

    This report tells the largely untold human story of what happened to detainees in our custody when the Commander-in-Chief and those under him authorized a systematic regime of torture. This story is not only written in words: It is scrawled for the rest of these individuals' lives on their bodies and minds. Our national honor is stained by the indignity and inhumane treatment these men received from their captors.

    The profiles of these eleven former detainees, none of whom were ever charged with a crime or told why they were detained, are tragic and brutal rebuttals to those who claim that torture is ever justified. Through the experiences of these men in Iraq, Afghanistan and Guantanamo Bay, we can see the full scope of the damage this illegal and unsound policy has inflicted - both on America's institutions and our nation's founding values, which the military, intelligence services, and our justice system are duty-bound to defend.

    In order for these individuals to suffer the wanton cruelty to which they were subjected, a government policy was promulgated to the field whereby the Geneva Conventions and the Uniform Code of Military Justice were disregarded. The UN Convention Against Torture was indiscriminately ignored. And the healing professions, including physicians and psychologists, became complicit in the willful infliction of harm against those the Hippocratic Oath demands they protect.

    After years of disclosures by government investigations, media accounts, and reports from human rights organizations, there is no longer any doubt as to whether the current administration has committed war crimes. The only question that remains to be answered is whether those who ordered the use of torture will be held to account.

    The former detainees in this report - each of whom is fighting a lonely and difficult battle to rebuild his life - require reparations for what they endured, comprehensive psycho-social and medical assistance, and even an official apology from our government.

    But most of all, these men deserve justice as required under the tenets of international law and the United States Constitution.

    And so do the American people.

    ---------

    Also See: Human Rights Group Says It Has Proof of Detainee Abuse

»


Matt Renner is an editor and Washington reporter for Truthout.

Maya Schenwar is an editor and reporter for Truthout.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

Vox clamantis in deserto,

Vox clamantis in deserto, you are the voice of someone yelling the truth in the wasteland, the land of the USA!!! It´s a pity but I have felt the same many many times. I like to ask with the voice of Cicero calling for Catilina´s removal in the Roman Forum -namely Bush and his cohorts in this particular instance. But ... to what purpose? History will tell, because we have ears but do not want to listen! Will Obama listen? I doubt it the way he is turning out these days.

The whole system has be

The whole system has be co-opted and corrupted.They are not supposed to be our "leaders", and America is not supposed to be a "democracy". Until people grasp this, they will not comprehend the true con-job that has been perpetrated. They have been seduced by the promise that "govern-ment" will take care of them. And we are being taken care of... in the best interest of those in and behind the "govern-ment". "Govern" means control. "ment" is derived from "mente", which translates into "mind". It's a Monster now. And always has been, we've just been conned into forgetting.

I marched in the protest

I marched in the protest just before the war began...you know, the one where over ten million people worldwide took part, and the Criminal-In-Chief referred to as no more than a "focus group". I joined other Americans afterwards in continuing protests in my town. I've also written my congressman and senators more times than I can count, and have expressed, each time more bluntly, my desire to see this President, and all of his co-conspirators, impeached and tried for war crimes, with the full weight of the law specifying the punishment for their endless crimes. Tell me what else I can do within the law?

I'd be in favor of

I'd be in favor of impeachment only if the maximum sentence was death by hanging.

WAKE UP

WAKE UP AMERICA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The secret of

The secret of liberty: “Those who won our independence knew that fear breeds repression and that courage is the secret of liberty.” ~U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis

I was in the United States

I was in the United States recently visiting family and friends (I have been living in Guatemala for the past 15 years) and I realized that just about everyone is in debt. Besides that the main concerns are getting the kids to soccer and baseball and watching sports on television and deciding what new movie to see on the weekend and planning the summer vacation and what about the Bills' second year running back and the hit and run car accident he had on May 31st. The truth is that no one has the time, nor the inclination to get riled up about our military torturing the Iraqi prisoners - that's "over there". And that is very sad, thank you Major General Taguba for reminding us that these actions come under the serious charge of "war crimes". I can only hope that some folks back home take this as seriously as I have.

Plato said a Democracy lasts

Plato said a Democracy lasts about 200 years until a group learns they can vote themselves privileges.

Until we the American people

Until we the American people go to the streets in major protests we are as guilty as Bush and Cheney. I was illegally in East Germany in 1988 and witnessed 1 million East Germans parading down the streets of East Berlin. They brought down the hated "wall", not Ronald Reagan, or even Gorbatchow. The East German people took their "inalienable rights" into their own hands. What in the hell is going on in America ? Why has the nation let itself be conned by these crooks. They are so bold faced in their crimes they don't even deny them. Instead they have built an until now impermeable "wall" bricked with "executive privilege". It is time to take our country back, and that should start with record demonstrations demanding the impeachment of Bush and Cheney. Only then will the backboneless Democratic Congress see that "we the people" will not accept anything less. Wake up Mrs. Pelosi !! Real democracy starts from the bottom, but it takes courage, a commodity I fear the spoiled American people is poorly lacking. They are more concerned with gas prices. People like General Taguba are setting the example with their courage. Let's tear down the "wall" dividing our trodden principles with the painful reality of our broken system. Only we the people can do that, insisting that all politicians do our will.

Give up. The destruction

Give up. The destruction is done. The notion that government derives its power from the people is a quaint anachronism. Turn on the TV, and enjoy a nice, government-sanctioned drug, a little alcohol sounds good right about now. On Monday, get your butt back to your wage-slave job so you can pay for the gasoline to get to your tomorrow. or vote for for people who stand for meaningful change (cough Ron Paul cough) before voting becomes completely meaningless too. Take yer pick.

To hell with impeachment; I

To hell with impeachment; I say we use "enhanced interrogation techniques" on the terrorists who did violence to our nation - the ones who usurped power, shredded the Constitution, lied, cheated and emptied the National Treasury; I say we use s little water-boarding on them and force them to admit their crimes; I say we bring no charges, but keep them imprisoned at Gitmo for the rest of their unnatural lives: I say no habeas corpus for Bush, Cheney Rumsfeld, Rove, Addington, Libbey, et al; I say they deserve the same sort of ignominious fate as Rudolph Hess at Spandau. You'd think after the last eight years,people would have enough of Fascist nonsense. But living here in the buckle of the Bible Belt, I can assure you there are plenty of good citizens of the Reich who have not learned their lesson. They will gladly cast their vote for more of the same rather than vote for a black man, They have learned nothing in the nearly a century and a half since Lincoln uttered these words: "Yet, if God wills that this war continue until all the wealth piled by the bondsman's two hundred and fifty years of unrequited toil shall be sunk, and until every drop of blood drawn with the lash shall be paid by another drawn with the sword, as was said three thousand years ago, so still it must be said "the judgments of the Lord are true and righteous altogether." It would seem America still has a long way to go and much to suffer before the debt is paid.

I'm voting for a third

I'm voting for a third party, I can't make the profound compromise in principles that it would take for me to vote for Barack. I will only vote for a true anti-war candidate.

Torture is treason. Bluntly

Torture is treason. Bluntly put, this is what we are trying to comprehend individually and as a nation. Torture overwhelms human standards expressing, in effect, every violation that can be perpetrated against a human being. It unmistakably violates at root all the Articles of the Bill of Rights and the very intention of the US Constitution because torture is the ultimate corruption of power. Members of the Bush Administration have violated the Geneva Conventions and the Convention Against Torture. They have also violated Federal law - an impeachable offense - because the Supremacy Clause of the Constitution makes the treaty domestic law too. Major General Taguba reminds us that the victims of torture do not recover but actually carry the scars of such treatment invisibly for the rest of their lives. Citizens must realize that the very existence of torture implies the breakdown of Law, Due Process, and accountability from those in power. Once incriminated in crimes of torture its proponents and apologists must work to erode the democratic laws in place that would hold them accountable. Americans who believe in the greatness and possibility of our Nation must fully realize that people who are imprisoned indefinitely without charges and tortured are not prisoners. They are slaves. This is what the Bush Administration and its collaborators have done and what they represent. They must be held accountable. Therefore, "War Crimes" is the term and impeachment is the remedy. Major General Taguba has acted in the greatest tradition of democratic patriotism, military honor and courage by speaking out "defending the Constitution against all enemies both foreign and domestic". Each of us must do so too.

Dear Eddie - I want to draw

Dear Eddie - I want to draw your attention to the first story here about a U.S. general accusing the Bush Administration of war crimes. Polly

A response to comments above

A response to comments above - The "American People" aren't letting them get away with anything, "they" have guns to our heads, just what are the "American People" supposed to do? Complain? We do plenty of that, they do not listen, Threaten them with impeachment? They dissemble and continue, Write a Congressperson? They are part of the problem. It's time the "American People" took a look at the source justification for all this sickness. What is needed is a longer historical perspective on what happens inside empires. America must take a step back and understand that jet fuel, aka Kerosene, even an ocean of it, is incapable of aerosolizing 110 floors of concrete or melting 4 inch steel girders. America Has Been Had. Wake up or suffer.

It is frightening that the

It is frightening that the American people have allowed Bush and his cronies to get away scot free after the crimes they have committed against the people of Afghanistan and Iraq. They are also dragging America deeper into debt with every day that passes, spending vast sums of money on arms, with which the generals seem unable to defeat the ragged civilian Iraqui and Afghan militia, who seem to be fighting for their own country. Where will it end? When will it end? Tom.

I fully agree with the

I fully agree with the General As a WW II veteran ASN # 12087329 I say that we Americans are the current "good Germans of the Third Reich" ! We are all guilty of doing little to stop these atrocities ! Thomas Jefferson had the answer ! Where is Bush's God in all this ?

Maj. Gen. Taguba - Thank you

Maj. Gen. Taguba - Thank you Sir. You are a man of honor and courage. You stand for the sort of America that many of us believed in. Why though is the Major General such a lone voice? Where are the men and women of courage and honor in the America's elected bodies and for that matter in the world at large? Why is the world media so silent on the Taguba statement - try Googling for it and you will find little or no mainstream media coverage! I cannot see any difference in substance between the crimes committed in Bosnia and those alleged to have been committed in Iraq. Bosnian leaders faced war crimes trials why should not the US leadership? It seems they never will, since the US sought to set itself beyond the reach of international law when it decided not to support the formation of the International Criminal Court in La Hague. It may take years or eternity for a criminal trial. In the mean time IMPEACH!

Why I would voite for

Why I would voite for impeachment of President Bush and Vice President Cheney The President and Vice President have acted with unprecedented abandon for the U. S. Constitution and the basic principles of International Law by provoking and executing an attack on the sovereign nation of Iraq without due cause. The resulting loss of lives, torture and maiming of innocent civilians constitute unjustifiable violation of the Geneva Convention and human rights. Using unsubstantiated premises of weapons of mass destruction, connection to known terrorists groups, and other unsubstantiated imminent dangers to the U. S. and/or U. S. interests,and ignoring all reports to the contrary, carried out a campaign of death and destruction throughout Iraq. If this does not constitute a basis for articles of impeachment, then we shall likely never find a more egregious reason for impeachment of any person under the U. S. Constitution, and we shall have failed in our responsibility, as a people, to uphold the virtues that our forefathers long ago established for our government.

These indictments (all

These indictments (all true!) are only the tip of the iceberg, the main mass of which is the treasonous betrayal of America after the 911 attacks on the part of the Bush Administration. The professional suicide commando attack on that date was a carefully coordinated military operation with plenty personnel supporting it. Some of the self confessed operatives were Omar al Bayoumi, Osama Basnan, and Haifa Bandar. There were, of course, many others; all of whom were allowed to leave the country unmolested. Most left quickly, but the above persons (search those names) left only when they felt like it. In the case of Bandar, who gave the terrorists $120,000.00 in financial support, she stayed in the US for years after the fact. Not only that, but as the wife of the Saudi ambassador, she was present at many a White House function during that time!

They Live, We sleep "They

They Live, We sleep "They use their tongues to deceive. The venom of snakes is under their lips. Their mouths are full of bitterness and curses and in their paths nothing but ruin and misery and the fear of God is not before their eyes! They have taken the hearts and minds of our leaders. They have recruited the rich and the powerful and they have blinded us to the truth. Our human spirit is corrupted! Why do we worship greed!? Because outside the limit of our sight, feeding off us; perched on top of us from birth to death are our owners, our owners, they have us, they control us, they are our masters! Wake up! They are all about you, all around you!" From the blind street preacher in "They Live" by John Carpenter

Dont impeach... Send ALL to

Dont impeach... Send ALL to The Hague. We will see if the press will cover that event. TS

Thank you General Taguba for

Thank you General Taguba for standing on principle. You are one voice that critically matters in what has happened these past 7 years. And there are other voices of integrity that have yet to speak out. Word to Speaker Nancy Pelosi.

My letter to Pelosi, copied

My letter to Pelosi, copied to Conyers, Kucinich, Clinton, Obama, Wexler and my local rep's: Antonio Taguba wrote yesterday “After years of disclosures by government investigations, media accounts, and reports from human rights organizations, there is no longer any doubt as to whether the current administration has committed war crimes. The only question that remains to be answered is whether those who ordered the use of torture will be held to account.” War crimes, Ms. Pelosi. And it appears to me that you are an accessory to these crimes by blocking the criminal investigation and impeachment of Bush and Cheney. Do the right thing, at long last, and let history judge that you FINALLY acted responsibly. You are making me ashamed to be a Democrat.

I also shall NOT vote for

I also shall NOT vote for any one who doesn't suppost Kucinich. This is past a joke - it is a national tragedy. I often wondered how hundreds of thusands of German citizens stood by while Hitler constructed his hekk on earth. Now I know.

Bush. Cheney, and Rumsfeld

Bush. Cheney, and Rumsfeld must be accountable. Either impeached now or brought totrial after the election. And McCain ("McBush") must not be allowed to run Bush's third term.

Bush/Cheney's intent is now

Bush/Cheney's intent is now blatantly evident. Day by day the overall agenda of the Bush/Cheney administration pictures out with clarity. Beginning in 1992, at the end of the G.H.W. Bush administration, Dick Cheney, then Secretary of Defense, drafted the Defense Planning Guidance Plan (DPG)which, over time through to 1997, and with the a large cadre of prominent members of that administration--names we all know in the present--(William Kristol, Paul Wolfowitz, Lewis Libby, Jeb Bush, Zalmay Khalilzad, Donald, Fred and Robert Kagan, Mark Lagon, Gary Schmitt, Abram Shulsky and many more, a raft of military officers, and Northrop Grumman Corp and other industrialists,) became the committee creating the Project for the New American Century (PNAC). It was/ is blueprint for what has become the George W. Bush administration. By September of 2000, it became the reformulated RAD (Rebuilding America's Defenses guidance document for the incoming administration, a declaration of world military supremacy and control, beginning in Iraq--"change of regime." But, it said, it would be difficult to implement with the public, it "would take another Pearl Harbor. . ." Read on. . .a must---to understand. Fast forward to 2008, by way of 9/11, a tragedy never forensically investigated--a crime scene closed to exposure ( even the two chairs of the 9/11 Commission are calling for a new investigation because of information and material that was withheld from the committee.) . And then there was the manufactured and deceptive intelligence propaganda selling WMD terror( we have just learned about by the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence Report and also McClellan's book disclosure) and the 'shock and awe" firebombing to plunge us into an 'planned' unnecessary and immoral war. Never mind the hundreds of violations and actions that undermine the Constitution, emasculate the balance of powers foundation of constitutional government, the hundreds of signing agreements and Executive Orders that egregiously reveals Bush's contempt of the Law and his declaration of his"decider" imperial power, the usurpation of power and presidential privilege, a regime memorialized by its penchant for secrecy, and the largest debt in history--sinking the economy and the value of the dollar. Just go to the current revelations that show the extraordinary permanent building projects all over Iraq, the largest most luxurious embassy in the world at a cost (not yet finished) of over a $billion, 30 bases and pushing for 58 permanent bases in Iraq alone, pushing the a Maliki government for an agreement that grants immunity INDEFINITELY to not only military personnel, but private mercenary and other contractors of whatever nature, grants U.S. control of air space up to 30,000 ft--in other words---all the essentials for a permanent occupation.Bush, at its inception said it would last for generations---how did he know? McCain inadvertently said 100 years. (IT IS THE PLAN) The Iraqi ministers are complaining to the U.S. Congress, "It would impair Iraq sovereignty," said Ali al Adeeb.They don't want the occupation to continue. And where is 'what's his name. . . oh yes, Osama. . .Bush says now, 'oh, he's not important." He never was. He was a U.S. asset remember--fighting with the CIA and Afghanistan against Russia. Here is the visual---the evidence in black and white--the plan. The War was not about Saddam, or terrorism, or democracy (their sovereignty) it was about expansion of hegemonic control--a permanent foothold in the Middle East---you got it---to protect our interests---black gold--rivers of it running through pipes across the rugged mtns from the Caspian Sea. And the cost--the published amount---$12 billion a month. Upwards of over $2 trillion in the short term---what is long term? And according to the GAO military accounting when first we began supplying money--there was over one $trillion 'unaccounted for in the Defense Budget. How can you lose a $trillion? Our national debt is now stretching $10 trillion with the economy in peril. The cost in human life---let me count the hundreds of thousands, including over 4000 of our soldiers killed,unnumbered wounded, 25% of our troops returning home with serious mental wounds medicine will not cure, shocking hundreds of soldier- suicides a year, and the maiming continues, estimated 4 million Iraqi exiled---to raise questions of United State's integrity into the future. Connect the dots, it makes quite a picture of intent, most of which are impeachable offenses. The witnesses are gathering with speed. Add your own to the long list and lets get on with the business of cleansing this government---NOW. Our Washington representatives need to be held accountable for their lack of accountability in doing their job. What vested interest keeps them from keeping their Oaths of Office? And where is this REAL issue of Impeachment and integrity of government talked about in the current campaign? Have you read that McCain is a 'signatory' on the PNAC project--which truly makes him a Bush clone; a third term--indeed, but devastatingly so. I don't know where Obama sits, as a Senator--will he Impeach? Anyone asking THE question? How about rescuing one or two of the other candidates---who WILL talk about the real issues. The Republic hangs by a thread, we are in a Constitutional Crisis ---no one seems to hear the alarms clanging. Wake UP America--this is a perfect storm raging!!! The many Rivers are rising?

Thank you, General Taguba.

Thank you, General Taguba. I do wish your statement had been published long ago. Regarding impeachment, has everyone considered the fact that Nancy Pelosi would become president if we ridded ourselves of Bush and Cheney via impeachment? Undoubtedly she would be a good choice for the office, but wouldn't that make the whole procedure impossible?

Impeach the Pair!

Impeach the Pair!

"This Constitution, and the

"This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land" "The judicial Power shall extend to all Cases, in Law and Equity, arising under this Constitution, the Laws of the United States, and Treaties made, or which shall be made, under their Authority;--to all Cases affecting Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls;--to all Cases of admiralty and maritime Jurisdiction;--to Controversies to which the United States shall be a Party;……., and foreign States, Citizens or Subjects"

Enough of our citizens have

Enough of our citizens have to unite in this cause to hook the media in and the exposure will lure our elected officials to snag the guilty as a way to cleanse their guilt and complicity... This the th real world citizens.

To know our “national

To know our “national honor is stained by the indignity and inhumane treatment these men received from [this administration].” To understand that any act against the dignity of a single human being is indeed an act of indignity perpetrated against all humanity. To have men of honor provide testimony unequivocally establishing the record of such acts, and to do nothing! Is to become not only complicit in the crime, but to inherit the mantle of shame and partake of its immorality. Where are the few good men who remember their oath to defend our constitution against all enemies foreign and domestic?

There are many men and

There are many men and women of honor in the military who feel the same way as General Taguba. We must give thanks to him for speaking out in his own name, and in theirs. It is not too much to hope that one day our military leaders will proclaim that torture is incompatible not only with the rule of law and with democracy, but with the highest traditions of military service. Impossible? No: This is exactly what has happened in Chile, although it took some fifteen years after the end of the Pinochet dictatorship. And it appears to be happening in Argentina, another country with a history of "dirty war." The justification of torture as a means to get information is a lie, but that doesn't mean torture is ineffective. The real purpose of torture is terror. It's aim is to break the will not only of the individual who is tortured, but of everyone who fears that they may suffer the same fate. But torture does not only break people's will: It also produces resistance and hatred and moral revulsion. In the long run we can hope that the moral side wins. Torture also deforms the torturers. Most of the GIs who were put in this position were not sadists or bad people, but they had to become warped in order to carry it out. The process of recovery for a society that has practiced and suffered systematic torture as a policy can take decades. Reports like Gen Taguba's should be followed by Truth Commissions, to make everything public. If we're lucky, prosecution may follow. D.

Where are the voices of our

Where are the voices of our elected officials that we duly elected to represent us. They know that Bush and Cheney are going to bomb Iran and/or let Israel do it and then jump in and slaughter thousands of innocent lives again. I know I'm going to vote out my reps if they don't back Kucinich articles of impeachment. For one, it is there job to uphold the constitution and they are not doing it. So they are just as responsible as the other bastards, especially Pelosi.

I agree with Mr. Spero an

I agree with Mr. Spero an Anon. I must add, however, that there is a deep tendency in the U.S. that has been here for a good long time, only now it is festering. Some call it the "chicken hawk" phenomenon, but it is really a cowardice running from top to bottom in our culture. Our representatives and too many of us are power whores in tough-guy clothing: sissy-bullies. We do not hesitate to kick the defenseless in the teeth when they are down. We kid ourselves that there is something courageous about siding with an illegitimate bully and we flatter ourselves that these monsters, supported by an army of lawyers, need our defense. Bravo Gen. Taguba (ret.), Bravo Dennis Kucinich, and Bravo all real people of real integrity!!

As one who is still proud to

As one who is still proud to be called an American citizen, I appeal to all decent, God fear people in this great country and all members of the Congress and the Senate of the United States Government – to look long and hard at what has become the legacy fear and war crimes brought upon us and the shame that we now must endure because of what this present administration has done in our name. If these crimes of rape and torture and murder are allowed to go unpunished, we will destroy all respect and dignity that this once great nation has held in the eyes of the world. We also will destroy the very meaning of the American Constitution that our Fathers and Forefathers fought and died for. Those who are to blame for the policies that have made these crimes possible must simply be held accountable for their actions. That is what impeachment is all about. And if further charges can be made to acknowledge the wrongs that have been committed, then let it be done. To do nothing in this regard makes us, as ordinary citizen, guilty of complicity in these crimes that have taken place.

This is just the latest

This is just the latest disclosure in a pattern of war crimes, including torture, that leads straight to the door of the Oval Office. It's like a criminal case where the evidence exists from many irrefutable sources, and it's all in plain sight. Now what's needed is a Congress with the spine to uphold the Constitution and impeach or criminally prosecute those who so damaged our country. Belva Ann

And if they can't be

And if they can't be impeached before they are out of office, bring criminal charges against themwhen they are out of office. If George Bush retires without facing charges for his crimes, it will prove that this country has two sets of standards of conduct -- one for the wealthy and one for the rest of us.

Impeachment is certainly

Impeachment is certainly justified. But it's not going to happen, and indeed it may be better so. Were Bush and Cheney to be impeached, that's as far as it would go- they'd lose their jobs and nothing more, which is way too lenient. What needs to happen is for them to be tried by an international war-crimes tribunal- after they have left office- and imprisoned like any other murdering thugs.

How do you impeach a

How do you impeach a President that was never elected? Bush, Cheney,and all complacent members of Congress should be arrested and charged with Treason. Perhaps an international war crimes tribunal should take the matter under consideration as was done with the Nazis and the Bosnians

it is clear to anyone with a

it is clear to anyone with a brain and a willingness to accept the truth that the bush administration has broken law after law after law. the united states government has lost all legitimacy. the executive branch did so by it's actions. the legislative branch did so by not holding the executive branch accountable for it's illegal actions. the judicial branch did so by appointing a president. the following familiar words come to mind: "That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security."

Nancy what's stopping you?

Nancy what's stopping you? You are not behaving in a manner worthy of the title Speaker of the House. The title was given to you by the people who voted in 2006 and by the USConstitution by not acting getting Congers to bring the Impeachments out of committee you betray both the voters and the law of our land. You behave as if the media and the war profiteers are in charge. Please use your power. Your place in history is waiting. God Bless you and thank you in advance.

I'm so tired of hearing

I'm so tired of hearing about impeaching the president. Big deal. They'll still be able to enjoy their sorry lives sitting on a bunch of blood money. Bush and all his cronies/accomplices need to spend the rest of their lives in a maximum security prison. Unless you need to impeach before you can imprison, then fine impeach the bastards.

Impeachment is the way to

Impeachment is the way to make this failed administration accountable. I believe it is vitally important for us to preserve our reputation in the world and to send a signal to other politicians that this conduct will not be tolerated by the citizens of the United States.

I agree wholeheartedly

I agree wholeheartedly that Bush and Cheney should be impeached and tried for war crimes. I had an opportunity to see the movie"Taxi To the Darkside". I recommend it to everyone to learn of the atrocities perpetrated by our government in the name of "security". This war will continue as long as Washington is given the green light by not punishing the real criminals . I also think it unethical that many congressmen and women and others who hold high office are allowed to profit from the war through investments in military contractors.

America is a filthy

America is a filthy deadbeat. It failed to pay promised reparations to North Vietnam. America is nothing but a bunch of crooks, suckers, and lazy cowards. "Land of the Slaves. Home to the Cowards" It thought it could enjoy a simple lynching and it got a war instead.

thank you for your

thank you for your courage. Impeach George Bush and Dick Cheney. How dare they have committed these atrocities in our country's good name and gotten away with it. Do they think a flag pin in their lapels will do it?

Express yourself to someone

Express yourself to someone that can DO SOMETHING about impeaching Bush, Rep. John Conyers. Call his office and tell him that he MUST uphold his oath to protect the Constitution and follow the path towards impeachment. Pelosi, Dean, and Conyers do not have the authority to say that "impeachment is off the table." It is never, ever, EVER off the table. Here's Conyers' contact info. Call his office. Write him a letter and send it in the mail. Tell him in clear terms what you want. Address and phone number... Congressman John Conyers 2426 Rayburn Building Washington, DC 20515 202-225-5126

If the leaders of this

If the leaders of this administration are not brought to account we Americans will suffer. Not only throughout the rest of the world but also internally will our reputation be tarnished. We will never know peace until justice has been heard.

We must go beyond

We must go beyond impeachment to prosecution and conviction. In some countries these crimes would merit public execution. I agree that members of Congress and the Senate are remaining silent because they perceive that they too can be condemned as complicit, much as the high Nazi leadership went along for the ride; to enrich themselves, and grab as much power as they could. It's simply inexcusable.I commend the courageous Kucinich and Conyers (and Cynthia McKinney, who was forced out.). Too bad there aren't more like them. The problem is, that as soon as Bush leaves office, and becomes liable to prosecution, he's going to make a run for the big rancho he bought last year in Paraguay. We have to get him before he gets away.