News

Wall-E for President

»

by: Frank Rich, The New York Times

photo
Some conservatives have objected to Wall-E's message of love, loyalty, friendship and concern for the environment. (Photo: Reuters)

    So much for a July Fourth week spent in idyllic celebration of our country's birthday. This year's festivities were marked instead by a debate - childish, not constitutional - over who is and isn't patriotic. The fireworks were sparked by a verbally maladroit retired general, fueled by two increasingly fatuous presidential campaigns, and heated to a boil by a 24/7 news culture that inflates any passing tit for tat into a war of the worlds.

    Let oil soar above $140 a barrel. Let layoffs and foreclosures proliferate like California's fires. Let someone else worry about the stock market's steepest June drop since the Great Depression. In our political culture, only one question mattered: What was Wesley Clark saying about John McCain and how loudly would every politician and bloviator in the land react?

    Unable to take another minute of this din, I did what any sensible person might do and fled to the movies. More specifically, to an animated movie in the middle of a weekday afternoon. What escape could be more complete?

    Among its other attributes, this particular G-rated film, 'Wall-E,' is a rare economic bright spot. Its enormous box-office gross last weekend swelled a total Hollywood take that was up 20 percent from a year ago. (You know America's economy is cooked when everyone flocks to the movies.) The 'Wall-E' crowds were primed by the track record of its creator, Pixar Animation Studios, and the ecstatic reviews. But if anything, this movie may exceed its audience's expectations. It did mine.

    As it happened, 'Wall-E' opened the same summer weekend as the hot-button movie of the 2004 campaign year, Michael Moore's 'Fahrenheit 9/11.' Ah, the good old days. Oil was $38 a barrel, our fatalities in Iraq had not hit 900, and only 57 percent of Americans thought their country was on the wrong track. (Now more than 80 percent do.) 'Wall-E,' a fictional film playing to a far larger audience, may touch a more universal chord in this far gloomier time.

    Indeed, sitting among rapt children mostly under 12, I felt as if I'd stepped through a looking glass. This movie seemed more realistically in touch with what troubles America this year than either the substance or the players of the political food fight beyond the multiplex's walls.

    While the real-life grown-ups on TV were again rebooting Vietnam, the kids at 'Wall-E' were in deep contemplation of a world in peril - and of the future that is theirs to make what they will of it. Compare any 10 minutes of the movie with 10 minutes of any cable-news channel, and you'll soon be asking: Exactly who are the adults in our country and who are the cartoon characters?

    Almost any description of this beautiful film makes it sound juvenile or didactic, and it is neither. So I'll keep to the minimum. 'Wall-E' is a robot-meets-robot love story, as simple (and often as silent) as a Keaton or Chaplin fable, set largely in a smoldering and abandoned Earth, circa 2700, where the only remaining signs of life are a cockroach and a single green sprout.

    The robot of the title is a battered mobile trash compactor whose sole knowledge of human civilization and intimacy comes from the avalanche of detritus the former inhabitants left behind - a Rubik's Cube, an engagement ring and, most strangely, a single stuttering VCR tape of 'Hello, Dolly!,' a candied Hollywood musical from 1969. Wall-E keeps rewinding to the song that finds the young lovers pledging their devotion until 'time runs out.'

    Pixar is not Stanley Kubrick. Though 'Wall-E' is laced with visual and musical allusions to '2001: A Space Odyssey,' its vision of apocalypse now is not as dark as Kubrick's then. The new film speaks to the anxieties of 2008 as specifically as '2001' did to the more explosive tumult of its (election) year, 1968. That's more than upsetting enough.

    Humanity is not dead in 'Wall-E,' but it is in peril. The world's population cruises the heavens ceaselessly on a mammoth luxury spaceship that it boarded in the early 22nd century after the planet became uninhabitable. For government, there is a global corporation called Buy N Large, which keeps the public wired to umpteenth-generation iPods and addicted to a diet of supersized liquefied fast food and instantly obsolete products. The people are too bloated to walk - they float around on motorized Barcaloungers - but they are happy shoppers. A billboard on the moon heralds a Buy N Large outlet mall 'coming soon,' not far from that spot where back in the day of 'Hello, Dolly!' idealistic Americans once placed a flag.

    And yet these rabid consumers, like us, are haunted by what paradise might have been lost. How can they reclaim what matters? How can Earth be recolonized? These questions are rarely spoken in 'Wall-E,' but are omnipresent, like half-forgotten dreams. In this movie, a fleeting green memory of the extinct miracle of photosynthesis is as dazzling and elusive as the emerald city of Oz.

     One of the great things about art, including popular art, is that it can hit audiences at a profound level beyond words. That includes children. The kids at 'Wall-E' were never restless, despite the movie's often melancholy mood and few belly laughs. They seemed to instinctually understand what 'Wall-E' was saying; they didn't pepper their chaperones with questions along the way. At the end they clapped their small hands. What they applauded was not some banal cartoonish triumph of good over evil but a gentle, if unmistakable, summons to remake the world before time runs out.

    You have to wonder what these same kids make of the political show their parents watch on TV at home. The fierce urgency of now that drives 'Wall-E' and its yearning for change is absent in both the Barack Obama and McCain campaigns these days.

    For me, Mr. Obama showed signs of jumping the shark two weeks back, when he appeared at a podium affixed with his own pompous faux-presidential seal. It could have been a Pixar sight gag. In fact, it is a gag in 'Wall-E,' where, in a flashback, we see that the original do-nothing chief executive of Buy N Large (prone to pronouncements like 'stay the course') boasted his own ersatz presidential podium.

    For all the hyperventilation on the left about Mr. Obama's rush to the center - some warranted, some not - what's more alarming is how small-bore and defensive his campaign has become. Whether he's reaffirming his long-held belief in faith-based programs or fudging his core convictions about government snooping, he is drifting away from the leadership he promised and into the focus-group-tested calculation patented by Mark Penn in his disastrous campaign for Hillary Clinton. Mr. Obama's Wednesday address calling for renewed public service is unassailable in principle but inadequate to the daunting size of the serious American crisis at hand. The speech could have been - and has been - delivered by any candidate of either party in any election year since 1960.

    What Mr. Obama has going for him during this tailspin is that his opponent seems mortifyingly out-to-lunch. Mr. McCain is a man who aspires to lead the largest economy in the world and yet recently admitted that he doesn't know how to use a computer, the one modern tool shared by everyone from the post-industrial American work force to Middle Eastern terrorists to Pixar animators. Getting shot down over Vietnam may not be a qualification for president in 2008, but surely a rudimentary facility with a laptop is. What Mr. McCain has going for him is a press corps that often ignores or covers up such embarrassments.

    The Republican's digital ignorance is not a function of his age but of his intellectual inflexibility and his isolation from his country's reality. To prove the point last week, he took a superfluous, if picturesque, tour of Colombia and Mexico, with occasional timeouts for him and his surrogates to respond like crybabies to General Clark's supposed slur on his patriotism.

    For connoisseurs of McCainian cluelessness, the high point was his Wednesday morning appearance on ABC's 'Good Morning America.' The anchor, Robin Roberts, asked the only important question: Why in heaven's name was Mr. McCain in Latin America when 'the U.S. economy is really at the forefront of voters' minds'?

     'I know Americans are hurting very badly right now,' he explained, channeling the first George Bush's 'Message: I care.' As he spoke, those hurting Americans could feast on the gorgeous flora and fauna of the Cartagena, Colombia, tourist vista serving as his backdrop. 'It's really lovely here,' Mr. McCain said. Since he can't drop us an e-mail, a video postcard will have to do.

     Mr. McCain should be required to see 'Wall-E' to learn just how far adrift he is from an America whose economic fears cannot be remedied by his flip-flop embrace of the Bush tax cuts (for the wealthy) and his sham gas-tax holiday (for everyone else). Mr. Obama should see it to be reminded of just how bold his vision of change had been before he settled into a front-runner's complacency. Americans should see it to appreciate just how much things are out of joint on an Independence Day when a cartoon robot evokes America's patriotic ideals with more conviction than either of the men who would be president.

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

Please don't bash all

Please don't bash all republicans for the ones who hated the movie. I'm a republican and loved it to death, not to mention don't see the issue in wanting to be good stewards to the planet. A lot of us also liked it. I have also heard some democrats annoyed with this movie, or turning it into political propaganda when it isn't. The movie is about love first, not the environment.

Thank you Frank Rich for the

Thank you Frank Rich for the great commentary along with a glowing review. The message is right on, and hopeful. Folks really don't want to live on a permanent cruise ship, and though indulging can be a kick sporadically, humans want to have more meaning. The film lets us know that our greed will overtake the earth before we can recognize our spiritual destiny, caring for our world. Thank you WALL-E for your guidance.

Television news can no

Television news can no longer compete with fiction or comedy central. I noticed there were more real stories about the crucial issues on the Daily Show and Stephen Colbert than anywhere else on television including PBS. I think it might be better if Americans did get their news from these two shows if they are unable to understand the internet. I will definitely go see this movie, as I need to know I am not alone.

It makes me sick that you

It makes me sick that you guys swoon over WallE the same way a younger generation swooned over ET, BUT you forget altogether during this election year a much more important film: SICKO by Michael Moore.

To the person who stated

To the person who stated "But dude, go get some sun, take a walk take some herbs or get on some anti-depressants." Our country is crumbling, and your suggestion? Take drugs. Is it really any wonder our country is crumbling when the only answer is to take drugs?

No individual is responsible

No individual is responsible for what ever our opinion is of the status quo, and no individual can change society. I do not vote for or against individuals. A ruling class controls this and every government that ever existed, with the exception of those like the former Soviet Union, which was controlled by a bureaucratic caste that took control in the mid 1920s, and ruled similar to the parasitic controllers of the Teamsters or United Auto Workers: they operate in their own interests and in support of the corporations that the rank and file workers are exploited by. Hitler and Mussolini had the support of capitalists who used their fascist movements to smash the working class organizations and militancy that threatened capitalist rule. I recommend entering the following in your search engines: The Bush Crime Family; Smedley Butler and the The Fascist Plot to overthrow the Roosevelt Administration; Trotsky's writings on Fascism; and Gerorge Seldes writings on Fascism. The dominant wealthly rulers win every election: local and national. From G. Washington to G. Bush, it has not mattered what party or individual wins elections. The entire structure for ruling class control was developed in the conspiratorial secret gathering in the spring of 1787, in Philadelphia that is called the Constitutional Convention. Females, poor propertyless whites, Native Americans, Blacks: slave or free, were not invited, and they had armed guards at the door. That gathering laid the foundation for the "Sucker Trap" that the so-called educational system, and mass media, has indoctrinated the gullilble masses to accept as "Holy Writ". Think about the words to the 'Pledge of Allegiance", "America the Beautiful", and "My Country Tis of Thee", and seriously consider the validity of every word in relationship to factual history, and contemporary society. Do not be afraid to "THINK" I am optimistic that 5-20% of the readers of this message will begin to "Think" and get out of the Bubble Brain Mental Midget state that the overwhelming majority of Americans in varying degrees suffer from: particularly those who have degrees in different types of indoctrination from the so-called institutions of higher education. Yours for "Mental Liberation" Kwame

Thank God for Frank Rich.

Thank God for Frank Rich. He has asked what all thinking Americans have been asking:. What are we leaving for our children?

For those of you who truly

For those of you who truly cannot afford the show price, understood. But, if it's at all fiscally responsible for you, please consider seeing it in theatres. I was surprised to find that two major theatres here in L.A., Arclight Cinemas and The Grove, were not showing Wall-E. While I don't know why this is, I do know that the more support such super-smart, super-clean, super-meaningful movies get, the more such movies WE will get. And, it's about time, because in recent years....well, you know. A+ for Wall-E; not a dull or overdone moment. As for the presidential contenders, why is expectation/hope still held out that any man can really effect meaningful change? I recommend reading Confessions of an Economic Hitman to tinally disabuse the naive of their hopes that a politician or some act of government will someday surprise and delight us, or unselfishly aid us. Never. If it happens at all, it's short-lived and usually hiding a selfish motive. This book is an eye-opener and like no thriller you've ever read, since it's all horrifically true.

I liked the Movie and got

I liked the Movie and got several of its CLEARLY HYPERBOLIZED artistic portrayals of mankind which they did most deftly for both comic and tragic effect. But dude, go get some sun, take a walk take some herbs or get on some anti-depressants. I know these are uncertain times and I agree Wall-E was a lovely movie with many morals in its tale. But I also have to say your interpretation of the movie and perceptions of the children clearly shows you have forgotten the innocence and the energy of youth that is exactly what makes them "Our Hope" for the future. what I worry about is when we have this great digital age and all we do is fill it with negativity or views of the world weary. I often feel world weary at times as well my friend but I try to not confuse my feelings with my rational thought or my perceptions. And remember you are not writing to a friend you are publishing. So if we are going to start to make a better world lets start right here with trying to not wallow in species self pity and loathing. tempting as it might sometimes be. I know I am sure somepeople will think I am full of it, and that is fine but I just had to give you some feedback on your narrative. I definitely not only got a feel for the movie but the mood you that you brought with you when you saw it. I personally think the Children because they are young and have not yet had enough unsupervised time to make big life mistakes yet, and because they inhabit young constantly growing bodies that feel strong, will see this as a call to action and so take heart and do not order up a billion lounging chairs just yet.

The movie is not so much a

The movie is not so much a clarion call for change, but a prediction. There is no hope. We're doomed.

Although I respect the

Although I respect the reasons of those who choose not to see this movie in a theater, it's unfortunate. We (my wife and I) just saw Wall-E at a "twilight" showing, ($5!!!) in a theater fitted with a DLP digital projector. If you've never seen a movie like this, I now appreciate how people felt when they saw the first "talkie". To see a purely digital movie, through a digital projector, on a brand new screen, in a reclining stadium style seat for cheap, it's just so nice. I get the perfect movie experience and feel like I'm sticking it to the man. I also understand that I have the benefit of living on the fringes of L.A. so such places are numerous, so I'm sorry if such an opportunity is not easily available to you. The movie is superb on so many levels, it's a work of genius that will be dissected for years to come. For the critics who write it off as "dark" or "not a kids movie", you either didn't watch the whole film, or you don't get and never will. So just stick your head back in the sand you fricken morons!

Download the movie off the

Download the movie off the internet, and watch it today, free. Hollywood doesn't really care, they are more interested in spreading propaganda, anyways. Save your money, it isn't a crime........ Starve the mammon beast

You're right. Obama, as are

You're right. Obama, as are all the so called leaders of the Democratic Party, are fatuous and far, far from ideal. On the other hand, McCain is increasingly scary. Apparently, being a Republic turns your mind to mush even if age doesn't.

Just watched this movie.

Just watched this movie. Really awesome movie in so many ways. It's good to know that there are some parts of Hollywood that are not totally dead and commercialized to death to what's happening in the world now, especially in the U.S.A. What the hell is a "consumer" anyways??? What the hell are GMOs and MSGs doing to the waistline of America???

Nice review. I too will wait

Nice review. I too will wait to see it when it comes out on DVD . It makes me wonder why we are not outraged , why are we so complient ? Why are we not wondering what we are leaving for our children and for their children , etc. ? It's time we get rid of the gang in Washington , it's time to take back America . The revolution will NOT be televisied .

One of McCain's favorite

One of McCain's favorite movies - "The Manchurian Candidate," which he says, "was very plausible at the time -- perhaps more than now." Hmmm, spoken by a man labeled "Songbird" by fellow POWs for the singing he did to the "enemy" in Vietnam, a man who admits to not knowing much about economic matters, to not knowing how to use a computer, and who sings songs about bombing millions of innocents. Hmmm...

Thank you, Truthout. There

Thank you, Truthout. There is an escalation of words. Pundits and reporters are first using a 'move to center' descriptions of Obama. I heard "lurch"to center last night from newscaster who actually wore an Obama button previously. Now I am also hearing the beginning of "going right wing". It is only July 6th. Soon the only difference will be that McCain has more hair.

To Many big words for me !

To Many big words for me !

Try "Winter In America" by

Try "Winter In America" by Gil Scott-Heron. Nearly all the music of the 60's and 70's echoes the ugly future we are NOW living in.

Thank you Frank Rich. It is

Thank you Frank Rich. It is all about the superficiality of the American (non) intellect. I just waited in line at the local Rite Aid (local only in that it is located here -- the profits go elsewhere -- weren't there one-upon-a-time local drug stores?), and was astonished that the most "series magazine on the news-stand was the Time Mag which extolled the virtues of the great "soft-ball" pitcher, Tim Russert. I had to think -- no wonder fifty million Americans were stupid enough to vote for George Bush -- TWICE. Thanks to Frank Rich for a momentary lift above that level of stupidity.

"women and children shall

"women and children shall lead the world"- pete seeger 2007

Great review. Obama has

Great review. Obama has kids..has he not seen this movie?

Glad you liked the movie.

Glad you liked the movie. I'll wait till it comes out on DVD. The wonderful global economy has my son & me living on our meager savings and his 1 or 2 days a week at a Dollar General store & my social security. While McPain was in Columbia singing the praises of the "global economy," the USA lost another 62,000 jobs, bringing the lost jobs for 2008 alone to almost half a million. He's got his: got rid of older, crippled wife #1 for much younger, MUCH richer wife #2. Obama--he's trying, but with the problems we've got--no president can solve them.

'Some warranted, some

'Some warranted, some not." heh.