News

White House Missing as Many as 225 Days of E-Mail

»

by: Pete Yost, The Associated Press

photo
An internal White House draft document obtained by The Associated Press reveals that up to 225 days of e-mail messages dating back to 2003 are missing. (Photo: Paul Morse / White House)

    Washington - The White House is missing as many as 225 days of e-mail dating back to 2003 and there is little if any likelihood a recovery effort will be completed by the time the Bush administration leaves office, according to an internal White House draft document obtained by The Associated Press.

    The nine-page outline of the White House's e-mail problems invites companies to bid on a project to recover the missing electronic messages.

    The work would be carried out through April 19, 2009, according to the Office of Administration request for contractors' proposals, which was dated June 20.

    Last week, the White House declined to comment on the document.

    On Wednesday, the White House refused to talk about internal White House contracting procedures, but said the information is "outdated and seriously inaccurate." It would not elaborate. The White House also declined to say whether it has hired a contractor for the work yet.

    "With an eye on the clock, the White House continues to drag its feet and do everything possible to postpone public access to the records of this presidency," said Anne Weismann, chief counsel to Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, a private watchdog group.

    The draft document outlines a process in which private contractors would attempt to retrieve lost e-mail from 35,000 disaster recovery backup tapes dating back to October 2003, a period covering such events as growing violence in Iraq, the Abu Ghraib prison scandal and the criminal probe into the disclosure that Valerie Plame had worked for the CIA.

    The recovery project would not use backup tapes going back to March 2003, according to the draft document, even though an earlier White House assessment suggested e-mails were missing from that period as well.

    Industry experts point out that relying on the backup system to ensure accurate retention, preservation and retrieval of all e-mails is problematic because it does not take into account deleted e-mails.

    "A backup system isn't designed to be a 100 percent complete inventory of all e-mails," says William P. Lyons, chairman and chief executive of AXS-One, a provider of records compliance management solutions.

    "It's designed to make a copy of data at a specific point-in-time," said Lyons. "Data is backed up on a daily, weekly and monthly basis as part of a disaster recovery strategy, to ensure to protect the organization from data loss."

    The White House draft document says that the number of days of missing e-mail ranges from 25 to 225, a range that industry experts say would make it difficult to bid on a recovery project.

    "Generally, when the scope of the work is expected to fluctuate by a factor of nearly ten, I can only take you so seriously," said Steve Schooner, co-director of the Government Procurement program at George Washington University.

    "Contractors cannot accurately plan for or staff based on such an estimate," said Schooner.

    At a hearing on Capitol Hill in February, the White House told Congress it was trying to determine how many e-mails were missing. An earlier analysis from 2005 estimated the number of days of missing e-mails at 473 over a period of 20 months.

    While the higher number would appear to suggest the White House has found a large amount of previously missing e-mail, that may not necessarily be the case. Industry experts say it is unclear from the brief description in the draft document whether the missing-day measurements in that document and those in the earlier analysis can be compared.

    "We will continue to work with members of Congress and the National Archives and will communicate the results of our accounting effort at an appropriate time," White House spokeswoman Emily Lawrimore said.

    Rep. Henry Waxman, D-Calif., and chairman of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, has said the White House's failure to properly archive e-mails violated the Presidential Records Act. The top lawyer for the National Archives has expressed disappointment the White House did not have a formal records management system in place.

    On Wednesday, House Democratic Caucus chairman Rahm Emmanuel of Illinois criticized how the problem has been handled, saying, "The White House that wants to keep track of all your e-mail and phone records can't even keep track of their own."

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

I am speaking as an expert

I am speaking as an expert who has actually designed and implemented email systems (I am not talking about being the system admin of email software, I am saying that I have actually created the email software). First off their system sounds incredibly archaic. Anything that important should have redundant backup systems. Especially since they are claiming to provide for the "Continuation Of Government". Second off, malfunctions do happen, thus the need for backups. It is entirely believable that they lost a day or even two days worth of email due to a malfunction. But to lose hundreds of days of email is inconceivable. Where are all of the unemployed IS admins who's job was to ensure that this could never happen? Another problem with the claim is that the days of lost email are non-consecutive. In general, computer systems either work or they don't work. You are either losing multiple consecutive days of email or your aren't losing any at all. To claim that on this day and this day and this day we lost the email but on all of the other days it worked fine, is very hard to believe. Also there is something totally haywire about the contention that the act of deleting the email out of their personal mailbox was sufficient to get rid of the emails. An email system which meets the federally mandated laws for records retention is going to be making copies of those emails before they ever reach the users mailbox. Even if by some extraordinary circumstance, nothing nefarious happened and they really and truly did have that many malfunctions of the email system; then as I understand it, we are talking about a situation of gross negligence which is still actionable under the law. For instance if this had happened to a corporation under Sarbanes-Oxley people would be facing huge fines and the possibility of going to jail. To lose that much email is not a case of business as usual. As far as who should get the contract for "rescuing the email", well, it's obvious that the only company that could possibly be capable of doing it is Halliburton on a no-bid contract. ;-) Sounds like a repeat of the Nixon Tapes and the missing minutes "recorder malfunction" to me. The good news is that this is a pretty clear indication that they are running scared, this was an act of desperation. The Impeachment Proceedings are finally having an effect. The bad news is that they just might get away with it. Once the election is over people rapidly lose interest in pressing criminal charges. Mainly it becomes a posturing technique to influence voter perception. But if we can't even trust the voting machines then it's all for naught. By the way, that is a really nice photo you have there, good job putting this together.

Can't they ask the Israeli's

Can't they ask the Israeli's for a copy?

Hey George, If you don't

Hey George, If you don't have anything to hide, what are you afraid of?

Databases like Talon and

Databases like Talon and Echelon should make this a moot point. If they've done what they were intended to do, all e-mails in this country are in their databases, including the "lost" White House e-mails. And who is it that pays the price for this violation of the Presidential Records Act, which I assume is a felony? In this day and age, it is not credible that this was a mistake, or even Bush-class incompetence. No one is this incompetent, even the Bushites. No, this was a crime, and it should be prosecuted. And, since it is unlikely to have happened without a conspiracy, this steaming ball could roll uphill to the Oval Office. In the end, all of the violations of the Constitution and the law in general, are the responsibility of the man at the top, and he should be the final party to answer for these outrages.

How can something so obvious

How can something so obvious go unpunished? There should be a law making the public record of high government officials like the president on down, erase proof, and if it does go missing that in itself would be a crime. We all know it is a crime and they are getting away with it.

Why do you Americans permit

Why do you Americans permit your country to be run by criminals?

The White House "lost" the

The White House "lost" the emails for very good reasons, no doubt. I'm sure Karl Rove's fingerprints are all over the keyboards where the communications were deleted. Why? Those communications represent physical evidence of criminal wrongdoing at the White House. At the very least, there would be found much to incriminate the highest levels in the Valerie Plame affair, and act of high treason against the Nation. Oops, must have pushed the wrong buttons somehow. Duh ...

Once again , king George has

Once again , king George has shown us peons that HE and his thugs can do want ever they want . I can't wait to see his ass out of office . The last 8 years has been a dissaster .

Precisely WHAT is the White

Precisely WHAT is the White House hiding? If we only knew... This appalling administration just keeps going and going--the "ever-ready bunny" of corruption and deceit. And so, we find the emails--then what? Will Congress exercise responsibility, genuinely protect our Constitution and take this criminal bunch to task for their crimes and misdemeanors? Forget "impeachment"--I want to see IMPRISONMENT.

Again, they want to keep

Again, they want to keep track of everything you do and say on line, but they can't seem to keep their information available for the public to view. Isn't this the height of arrogance? I would love to believe that Congress will do something substantive about this. But, as we have seen so many times in the recent past--nothing will happen and Congress will wring its hands impudently.... What more can one say?

Why pay someone to find what

Why pay someone to find what you no doubt paid good money to someone else to remove?

We ordinary people do not

We ordinary people do not know whether these White House characters "discovering" that hundrerd of days' e-mails are "missing' have committed illegal acts, but when the same people have corrupted our state and federal legal systems, and packed the Supreme Court with their flunkies, then NOTHING they do is illegal when attempts are made to bring them to justice. For example, as their DOJ flunky Mukasey pronounced a short time ago, "not all crimes are illegal". That's the Cheney/Bush/Al Capone method for running the country - - into the ground. The e-mail trick is quite simple. Once you have corrupted the justice system to insure your immunity, you hire computer geeks to delete all the incriminating e-mails you wish, then corrupt the hard drives or destroy them. Easy. If you can manage to have several friendly computer companies manufacture fake voting machinesand control the software, organize your state flunkies in Ohio , Florida, and Georgia to disenfranchise voters by the tens of thousands, and steal the elections, messing with a few computers in your own offices is a cinch.

Maybe they should hire

Maybe they should hire Monica Goodling or Albertp Gonzales to find the missing emails. If not, don't you think there are other loyal Bushies out there who can manage to not find the emails? If they were serious about finding the missing emails, they should hire one of the computer experts who has shown how the voting machines can be hacked. These people know computers inside and out. If the emails can be found, they would find them. But, then again, do we really want to find the emails?

Yeah, filter the emails

Yeah, filter the emails American citizens write and retain that information for a decade. Share it with 18,000 agencies. But don't bother having the White House follow the laws that already exist for retaining government records because those laws can be changed and immunity can be retrospective.