Opinion

Alexandra Cawthorne | The Straight Facts on Women in Poverty

»

by: Alexandra Cawthorne, The Center for American Progress

photo
Women face a much greater risk of poverty, one reason being that they are paid less than men, even when they have the same qualifications and work the same hours. (Photo: Brett Rogers / Beat Canvas)

    Women in America are more likely to be poor than men. Over half of the 37 million Americans living in poverty today are women. And women in America are further behind than women in other countries - the gap in poverty rates between men and women is wider in America than anywhere else in the Western world. Consider the following facts:

    Poverty rates are higher for women than men. In 2007,13.8 percent of females were poor compared to 11.1 percent of men.

    Women are poorer than men in all racial and ethnic groups. Recent data shows that 26.5 percent of African American women are poor compared to 22.3 percent of African American men; 23.6 percent of Hispanic women are poor compared to 19.6 percent of Hispanic men; 10.7 percent of Asian women are poor compared to 9.7 percent of Asian men; and 11.6 percent of white women are poor compared to 9.4 percent of white men.

    Black and Latina women face particularly high rates of poverty. Over a quarter of black women and nearly a quarter of Latina women are poor. Black and Latina women are at least twice as likely as white women to be living in poverty.

    Only a quarter of all adult women (age 18 and older) with incomes below the poverty line are single mothers. Over half of all poor adult women - 54 percent - are single with no dependent children.

    Elderly women are far more likely to be poor than elderly men. Thirteen percent of women over 75 years old are poor compared to 6 percent of men.

    Poverty rates for males and females are the same throughout childhood, but increase for women during their childbearing years and again in old age. The poverty gap between women and men widens significantly between ages 18 and 24-20.6 percent of women are poor at that age, compared to 14.0 percent of men. The gap narrows, but never closes, throughout adult life, and it more than doubles during the elderly years.

    Why Are More Women Living in Poverty?

    Women face a much greater risk of poverty for a number of inter-related reasons, including:

    Women are paid less than men, even when they have the same qualifications and work the same hours. Women who work full time earn only 77 percent of what men make-a 22 percent gap in average annual wages. Discrimination, not lack of training or education, is largely the cause of the wage gap. Even with the same qualifications, women earn less than men. In 2007, full time, year round female workers aged 25 to 32 with a bachelor's degree were paid 14 percent less than men.

    Women are segregated into low paying occupations, and occupations dominated by women are low paid. Women are tracked into ìpink-collarî jobs such as teaching, child care, nursing, cleaning, and waitressing, which typically pay less than jobs in industries that are male-dominated. In 2007, nearly half - 43 percent - of the 29.6 million employed women in the United States were clustered in just 20 occupational categories, of which the average annual median earnings were $27,383.[1]

    Women spend more time providing unpaid caregiving than men. Women are more likely than men to care for children and elderly or disabled family members. One study found that 69 percent of unpaid caregivers to older adults in the home are women. Because combining unpaid caregiving with paid work can be challenging, women are more likely to work part time or take time out of the workforce to care for family. Twenty-three percent of mothers are out of the workforce compared to just 1 percent of fathers.

    Women are more likely to bear the costs of raising children. When parents are not living together, women are more likely to take on the economic costs of raising children. Eight in ten custodial parents are women, and custodial mothers are twice as likely to be poor as custodial fathers.

    Pregnancy affects womenís work and educational opportunities more than menís. The economic costs associated with pregnancy are more significant for women than for men. Unplanned and mistimed pregnancies in particular can result in the termination of education and keep women from getting and sustaining solid employment.

    Domestic and sexual violence can push women into a cycle of poverty. Experiencing domestic or sexual violence can lead to job loss, poor health, and homelessness. It is estimated that victims of intimate partner violence collectively lose almost 8 million days of paid work each year because of the violence perpetrated against them by current or former husbands, boyfriends, or dates. Half of the cities surveyed by the U.S. Conference of Mayors identified domestic violence as a primary cause of homelessness.

    What Can We Do?

    The poverty gap between men and women is not inevitable. The gender wage gap has narrowed over the past 30 years as women have gained greater access to education, the labor market, and better paid jobs. Ending womenís poverty and providing better economic opportunities for all women will require specific policy actions to ensure that:

    * Women receive the pay they deserve and equal work conditions

    * Women have access to higher-paying jobs

    * Women in the workforce have affordable child and elder care, as well as access to quality flexible work and paid family leave

    * Women receive the support they need through expanded tax credits to help meet the costs of raising their families

    * Women receive the contraceptive services they need so that they can plan their families

    * Women receive the support and protection they need to leave violent situations while maintaining job and housing stability

    Conclusion

    The best policy solutions to address womenís poverty must combine a range of decent employment opportunities with a network of social services that support healthy families, such as quality health care, child care, and housing support. Policy objectives must also recognize the multiple barriers to economic security women face based on their race, ethnicity, immigration status, sexuality, physical ability, and health status. These approaches must promote the equal social and economic status of all women by expanding their opportunities to balance work and family life.

    Endnotes

    [1] Wider Opportunities for Women, unpublished analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics data for 2007.

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

Society must cater to women

Society must cater to women more. This is a patriarchal world still. If we valued and honored women they would not be living in poverty. I have a Master's degree and have applied for at least 1,000 jobs in the past two years. I have made poverty level wages all of my life and nothing else. This is not my fault. It is the fault of the outside system that has been failing economically. Also, the lack of progress being made in everyone's consciousness to see women in their grace, worthy and all levels of wonder - intellectually, spiritually and emotionally. I believe I and as well as many other women have the power to create their own lives. Therefore, they can live economically free and independent lives. But, much of the time society does not support or believe in a women's ideas. So in order for life to work better for us all we need to honor women. I would like to see this in my lifetime. When women are honored for their words, intellectual, spiritual and emotional gifts. And being a Native women is the most challenging in this land...

One example of women in

One example of women in poverty is nuns whose orders and the church itself have failed them in their senior years. A nun of our acquaintance was not granted permission to retire despite being well past retirement age. She left her order - although she must continue to work as a teacher to support herself.

It all comes down to what we

It all comes down to what we value in our culture and society. Obviously women are not valued in our country if the gap is wider here then anywhere else in the Western World as the article states. We really do not value our citizens in general since we also are so low on the index in providing universal health care to our citizens. America has little to be proud of when you look at this picture. The greatest contribution given to any country is raising up a child well. Women are our greatest asset and yet as a society we ignore this. When we look at what we really value and seek to change it then we will solve this problem.

Wages have to be raised in

Wages have to be raised in this country way above minimum wage. We have to have complete healthcare for all. Rent has to go down. Maybe that will be a result of the housing crisis. Capitalism has to succumb to "reality" especially in dealing with minorities who really suffer in the face of capitalism. The capitalists can have their cake and eat it too, but it's time to make a contribution to fairness. We need to take a look at the socialism/capitalism balence. Denmark appears to have worked this out. They do not mind paying higher taxes because they get so much for paying them.

Women MUST be enabled to

Women MUST be enabled to maintain themselves, and their families, with adequate income, enough to avoid the need for assistance. Nobody guarantees a woman a loving, decent, sane husband. Nobody guarantees a woman a caring, decent, sane boss. She must NEVER be reduced to the status of a man's underling or victim, or a sort of property, in either marriage or employment. Women divorce husbands who mistreat them (and sue bosses who mistreat them). They must be prepared and enabled to take care of themselves and their children, and ultimately their parents. If they had the same level of education, training, and employment opportunities as men enjoy, women would not need to go on public support. And they would not have to turn into "golddiggers" in order to survive. No-fault divorce is FREEDOM, redemption after a bad mistake, having been bamboozled in the first place by a guy with more gall than brains.

While I agree with the "what

While I agree with the "what can we do" points in general, I do not agree that tax credits can help poor women raise their children. Most of us on a low income don't pay much tax anyway. But that doesn't mean we're freeloaders. We still contribute much to society by raising our children. Elimination of welfare has its benefits, but there needs to be some way to help single moms out, and "tax credits" won't do it.

Married women are less

Married women are less likely to be poor, and more likely to share in the success of their husbands. It is my empirical opinion, that the so-called "no fault" divorce is the cause of poverty for women. The aspirations created by Hollywood about love and romance just don't jive with reality. Women believe the fiction and break their marriage commitment, many times ignoring its consequences on their own children. It is not men who divorce women, quite contrary, women divorce men, mostly to secure a meal ticket in the form of child support and alimony. Social engineering in the U.S. has failed women miserably and created this problem. Men do not trust women anymore as this experience of "being taken for a ride" is so pervasive - it happens to brothers, cousins, friends, coworkers. It took 50 years to get us to this point, and it will take at least that much to repair the social fabric and reverse the damage.